News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by atemerev on Friday May 12, 2017 @03:15PM (#14326986)
Guaranteed minimum income is: sustainable, sufficient for basic life necessities, can be implemented for the current population levels. Choose two.

It is as inevitable as CAP theorem.

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by fahadkhan on Friday May 12, 2017 @03:34PM (#14327159)
The current population is growing. Evidently there is enough resources to population at this level (food, water, space, air, energy, etc). If production of resources is automated why can't resources distributed to sustain current population?
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by orthecreedence on Friday May 12, 2017 @08:07PM (#14328899)
Exactly. We have the resources. It's just a matter of redistributing them in a way that a) keeps people alive and b) doesn't grind the economy to a halt.

People in the US need to let go of a lot of the ideas we cling to (taxing the rich slows the economy, UBI is communism, wealth redistribution == USSR) if we're going to live through the coming automation boom.

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by atemerev on Saturday May 13, 2017 @04:49AM (#14330057)
The bulk of costs of living in modern societies: rent/mortgage, healthcare and education. Can't be really automated in the near future, expected to cost even more as everything else becomes more automated.
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by fahadkhan on Saturday May 13, 2017 @07:16AM (#14330385)
I believe education is currently undergoing a similar transition that music and film and been through. At the end of Education will be cheaper. It already is a lot cheaper in some cases.

Health care is tougher, due to stricter regulations (rightly so) and reluctance from doctors but I think the transformation there is about to begin. Look at what is happening with (open source) prosthetics.

Prime reason for rent and mortgage that I can see is wealth generation and in a society where wealth is less important perhaps these will also decrease. You can see more and more interest in open source, not just in software but also other fields, is this a shift away from wealth accumulation?

From another angle, people are beginning build homes with recycled plastic and by 3D printing this hopefully will reduce build cost. And hopefully that will filter down to the end consumer.

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by goldbeck on Friday May 12, 2017 @03:18PM (#14327019)
[citation needed]
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by atemerev on Friday May 12, 2017 @04:46PM (#14327782)
Some numbers:

Current US population: 324 million people, 250 million adults.

Poverty line income: $22,000 for the family of four (it is hard to estimate individual poverty line income, but it's more than $22,000 / 4. Let's say $12,000, which is $1000 / month).

Total cost of universal basic income of $1,000/month for the US: $3 trillion per year.

Total US income tax revenue: $1.8 trillion for personal income tax, $0.4 trillion for corporate income tax.

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by dllthomas on Friday May 12, 2017 @04:50PM (#14327814)
You are making the case that it's currently impractical. That is very different from "as inevitable as [the] CAP theorem".

For instance, if the cost of "basic life necessities" was somehow $5/yr, but incomes (and tax revenues) similar to today (... presumably people are spending an awful lot on luxury goods?), it could certainly be all three of those things.

It may be the case that that is somehow impossible, but that's a case that you need to make in some way other than listing off what the current numbers happen to be.

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by atemerev on Friday May 12, 2017 @06:12PM (#14328329)
Yes, the luxuries like rent, education and healthcare. And yes, "somehow" is a word that appears very often in every discussion about UBI.
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by dllthomas on Friday May 12, 2017 @06:52PM (#14328577)
I don't believe you're engaging in good faith, so I'm done here.
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by atemerev on Saturday May 13, 2017 @04:21AM (#14330007)
Why I wouldn't be engaging in good faith? I really believe that UBI is impossible.
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by dllthomas on Saturday May 13, 2017 @11:08AM (#14331334)
I expect that you believe that UBI is impossible. I am not interested in continuing to engage with you because you are not interested in engaging intellectually and analyzing why you might be wrong or helping others analyze why they might be wrong, but are focused exclusively on scoring rhetorical points. That's sometimes a fun game to play, but it's not productive and it's not why I come to HN.
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by learc83 on Saturday May 13, 2017 @12:37AM (#14329547)
Every serious UBI proposal includes an progressive income tax increase.

Everyone gets the UBI, but the more money you make, the more you're paying in additional taxes to support the UBI. At some threshold you're paying as much in additional taxes as your making in UBI payments. Past another threshold and you're paying more in additional taxes than you're taking in.

Effectively you only need to provide the full UBI for people making very little per month.

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by chc on Friday May 12, 2017 @06:20PM (#14328384)
This appears to lead to the conclusion "UBI is impossible" only if we include the premises "It's impossible to reduce COL" and "It's impossible to increase tax revenues."
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by atemerev on Friday May 12, 2017 @06:47PM (#14328559)
Increasing tax revenues to 100% (assuming everybody will continue working like that) won't be enough. USSR learned it the hard way.
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by lamby on Friday May 12, 2017 @03:35PM (#14327167)
If only economics was this simple!
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by kmicklas on Friday May 12, 2017 @03:19PM (#14327033)
Why? The CAP theorem has a logical proof which can not be refuted, this seems unlikely to even have a strong informal argument to me.
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by danbruc on Friday May 12, 2017 @03:33PM (#14327151)
Set the income tax rate to 100 %, give an equal share of that money to every citizen. That should check all three boxes, shouldn't it?
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by BenjiWiebe on Friday May 12, 2017 @03:54PM (#14327356)
Personally I wouldn't bother working very hard if income tax was 100%.
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by danbruc on Friday May 12, 2017 @04:19PM (#14327537)
The incentive structure in this example is certainly bad, but that is an issue whenever you are planning to give things away for free, with a universal basic income scheme or otherwise. That my example is exceptionally poor in this regard should not matter too much for the point addressed unless you want to hint at a problem with sustainability.

That might or might not be the case depending on the behavior of the people but given that universal basic income proponents argue that people would not get lazy and exploit the system I am happy to make that assumption. In case that turns out to be false, it is certainly possible to tweak the scheme in such a way that there remains an incentive not to become lazy, for example by lowering the 100 % tax rate but still keeping it high.

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by AnimalMuppet on Friday May 12, 2017 @04:53PM (#14327843)
Hint at a problem with sustainability? I'll come right out and say it: Your proposal is not sustainable. The only people who will work in that environment are those who will work for free.

Even if that were enough people, you also remove economic feedback about the effectiveness of peoples' actions. That feedback is critical for an economy to efficiently allocate resources.

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by danbruc on Friday May 12, 2017 @05:38PM (#14328148)
First let me say that I am not trying to defend universal basic income schemes, I think they are not a great idea. With that out of the way, the point you are mentioning is a fundamental problem of universal basic income schemes. You can not promise to provide goods and services for basic needs to everyone unconditionally unless you have some magic black box providing the required goods and services.

You can try to tweak the incentive structure here and there to make it unlikely that you will end up in the worst case scenario but you can not really get rid of it. Unless you advance technology and automation to the point where you can provide for basic needs without any labor at all, a universal basic income scheme is a promise you can not keep unconditionally.

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by orangecat on Friday May 12, 2017 @11:28PM (#14329413)
The point of the UBI is that we are already giving things away for free, and we're doing it inefficiently and creating bad incentives in the process. Right now it's entirely possible for a low-income worker to get a raise and end up worse off, because they cross the threshold for a means-tested program and lose more in benefits than the amount of the rais. The question shouldn't be "would a UBI discourage work", it should be "would a UBI discourage work more than the current system does", and there are strong arguments that it would not.
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by dllthomas on Friday May 12, 2017 @04:53PM (#14327839)
Given just how poor the incentives wind up being, I think with current technology that it would be unlikely to tick the second box.
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by danbruc on Friday May 12, 2017 @05:21PM (#14328035)
That is a general problem with universal basic income schemes. Unless technology and automation is advanced enough to provide goods and services for basics needs without requiring any labor at all, the scheme will fail in the worst case, i.e. everyone decides to stop working. And there is not much you can do against that, at best you can devise an incentive structure that makes it unlikely that you will hit the worst case scenario. But without robots doing all the work, there is no way such a scheme can work unconditionally no matter how the people are deciding to live their lives.
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by dllthomas on Friday May 12, 2017 @07:36PM (#14328761)
> Unless technology and automation is advanced enough to provide goods and services for basics needs without requiring any labor at all, the scheme will fail in the worst case, i.e. everyone decides to stop working.

I mean, of course the scheme will fail if everyone stops working. But if not enough people are working to make enough stuff to satisfy demand, you'll see inflation, the BI will fall below someone's comfort level, and they'll get to work. This assumes you don't peg the BI to actual or expected inflation - don't do that!

(Another way of phrasing this - In theory a scheme can be unconditional in nominal terms while allowed to float in real terms, and ideally the feedback will allow us to keep real value distributed at some optimal level based on what society can bear. Whether that can translate into practice is an open question.)

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by danbruc on Saturday May 13, 2017 @06:33AM (#14330264)
If you understand it this way, then why wouldn't my original example be sufficient? The incentive structure might be really bad, but once you start starving you should certainly consider working again. Actually it seems almost everything would be workable in this way. Unless you structure a system in a way that it is simply unable to produce the required goods and services or makes access to them impossible for at least some, then at some ultimate point life threatening forces will set the incentives.

In reality, I guess, people would just overthrow your shitty system or circumvent it with black markets. So after thinking a bit longer about this, the requirements given in the initial comment seem not to be as straight forward as they may appear at first. What does sustainable mean? Is it sustainable if we make use of hunger to convince people to work? Is it implementable at the current population level if it entails something that the current population would never accept, say for ideological or religious reasons?

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by dllthomas on Saturday May 13, 2017 @11:04AM (#14331312)
> once you start starving you should certainly consider working again

Free-rider problem, and the black (or gray) market.

If all the value I capture from working is one/population of the value I produce, there are probably other things I can do (in an environment with a population bigger than "really small village") that will do substantially more to improve my circumstances, whether legal or not (and some things are bound to be legal - consider a kind of analog of the "man who marries his housekeeper" objection to GDP). And when people are desperate, they are more likely to focus on the things that will most improve their circumstance (especially in the shortest term).

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by maxerickson on Friday May 12, 2017 @09:59PM (#14329223)
Plus a meteor might blow up the planet.

The unconditional in unconditional basic income has a softer meaning than you use; it mostly just means that the payments are made regardless of wealth and other income (of course in a large number of cases it would also be completely recovered by taxation).

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by drxzcl on Friday May 12, 2017 @03:21PM (#14327047)
What do you base this on? Is there some theoretical limit to productivity?
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by devrandomguy on Friday May 12, 2017 @03:37PM (#14327182)
There are real limits to everything, because the universe has a finite mass and volume. But, that doesn't mean that it is not possible to engineer a working UBI.
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by drxzcl on Friday May 12, 2017 @03:50PM (#14327312)
Productivity is usually value/worker or value/hour worked. There's no indication, as far as I'm aware, that value (inflation adjusted money) is a conserved quantity.

In fact, most of the productivity increases are in industries where the value produced is not directly coupled to the resourced consumed. The software industry is a great example.

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by devrandomguy on Friday May 12, 2017 @03:57PM (#14327380)
The relationship between value produced and resources consumed may not be linear, but that does not mean that it is possible to have infinite production, or to produce a change in value from zero resources.

If production is not limited, then we can instantly transform our solar system into a Dyson sphere, right now. What am I not understanding, of this theory?

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by drxzcl on Friday May 12, 2017 @04:23PM (#14327573)
You'd be right, if all value production was in utilitarian, physical stuff. Increasingly however we're spending a smaller percentage of our income on stuff, and more on services and immaterial goods.

To produce a two ton truck, you need to use more than two tons of resource, that much is obvious. But how many resources go into the production of my copy of GTAV? Or my blue-ray of The Lord of the Rings? Or my viewing of a show on Netflix? The marginal resource usage is pretty much nil, just some electricity, paper of plastic. The resources expended in producing the work itself can be significant, but they are amortized among the many millions of copies.

Now obviously there are limits. Humans need physical stuff to survive, that's not going to change any time soon. There's a limit on the amount of actual stuff we can make. But there's no clear limit on the value of that stuff. We keep finding new ways to make little pieces of plastic or bunches of electrons in wires valuable all the time.

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by devrandomguy on Friday May 12, 2017 @04:39PM (#14327710)
Even information based value has limits. I feel those limits as heat when I push my hardware to its limits. There is also the space limit of how much information I can store, and the time limit of how much information I can experience or learn through my senses.

Those limits are constantly being pushed outwards, but they are not disappearing. Eventually, we might have cities and data centers covering the entire Earth, à la Coruscant. At that point, we will still be constrained by our ability to cool the system, by our ability to efficiently power it all with minimal waste heat, and by the speed of communications through congested networks.

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by dredmorbius on Friday May 12, 2017 @07:57PM (#14328850)
Not only is value a conserved quantity, but value must decrease on a full accounting, through the process chain.

That's the 2nd law of thermodynamics.

Corollary: accounting of costs, prices, and values is badly flawed.

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by dragonwriter on Friday May 12, 2017 @08:00PM (#14328862)
> That's the 2nd law of thermodynamics.

Thermodynamics does not address value.

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by dredmorbius on Friday May 12, 2017 @09:59PM (#14329225)
I believe it does, though it's somewhat complicated. I'm working on that.

You might also want to consider Georgescu-Roegen.

https://redd.it/48rd02

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by orangecat on Friday May 12, 2017 @11:29PM (#14329415)
Ok, but then the "process chain" needs to include the massive energy input from the sun.
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by dredmorbius on Saturday May 13, 2017 @02:59AM (#14329839)
Correct.[1]

There are two ways you can get that though:

1. You can harvest current-cycle solar, as captured or availed by PV, solar thermal, wind, hydro, (pipe dream / ineffective) wave energy, or biomass.

2. You can draw down an existing store of solar energy input deposited, with some inefficiency, as hydrocarbon fuels: coal, oil, gas (including methane hydrates, should you choose to go there).[2]

The difference is that in 1) you're deriving value from a continuing series of deposits, of approximately 84 terawatts,[3] or roughly 2,000 TWh (170 billion mtoe, 1 billion barrels of oil equivalent), an allowance shared with all other life-forms, and ecological / biospheric processes on the planet (we might care to consider those requirements before hiving of yet more for ourselves). The practical value derived remains a small fraction of the influx.

In the case of 2), you're spending down what is effectively an inheritance, at the rate of approximately 5 million times its initial rate of accumulation. This suggests that the spending-down is not particularly sustainable, even barring consideration of any other issues presented.

Of which I'm informed there are several.

The point remains that as you process that energy chain, each stage of the process leaves less useful or usable energy going out than came in, the balance being waste energy (entropy).

________________________________

Notes:

1. There's a very small contribution from non-solar sources, principally geothermal energy, a roughly 50-50 mix of gravitational potential energy of formation and radioactive decay, which could be considered sourced from the supernovae which enabled formation of the Solar System.

2. https://dge.carnegiescience.edu/DGE/Dukes/Dukes_ClimChange1....

3. http://zebu.uoregon.edu/disted/ph162/l4.html

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by DonbunEf7 on Friday May 12, 2017 @04:02PM (#14327421)
No, by counterexample of USA.

The 2015 average income per capita was $57,540 [0]. The 2015 poverty guideline for a family of five was $28,410 [1]. Clearly there is more income per capita than required to keep everybody out of poverty.

A second source, the Census, is pretty reputable too: "Median household income in the United States was $56,516 in 2015." [2] Edit: This statement isn't helpful since it is a median, not a mean. A better source from the Census is [3], which lists the mean average as $75,738. As a reply pointed out, the heavy income inequality in the USA is expected to cause this sort of skew in the median.

Either way, I propose that taking everybody's income away and then splitting it evenly would apportion enough money to keep everybody out of poverty, that it would be sustainable (based on trends of past amounts of income per capita and poverty guidelines), and that it would clear the poverty guideline, a well-known bright line for "basic life necessities."

Is this a good solution? Maybe. There's probably better ones. But they do exist.

Edit: Specifically, would this system remain stable? It's hard to say. We can imagine that anybody on the sad side of the Pareto curve, which is a majority of the typical employed people in the USA, would not mind effectively having a big check from Uncle Sam raising their income to healthy levels. At the same time, we could also imagine that the wealthy few who are hit hardest in this scheme would try to find some way to get their income to be non-taxable, whether by lobbying for a proportional tax or inventing new capital transfer techniques. I'm not going to claim that this scheme is in any way socially workable over the long term, though. I personally feel that any UBI scheme is still socially unworkable; we need more small-scale evidence that UBI works.

Still edit: As an example, imagine that the UBI payments were only sufficient to bring the impoverished up out of poverty, and not necessarily any higher. That means that over half of the income marked in my original scheme would not be needed, so the wealthy could keep it. This would effectively be a two-tax-bracket system, with the brackets labeled "below" and "above." Does it still work on paper? Yes. Do I think that people will like it? No. Do I think that people like taxes? Not really.

[0] http://data.worldbank.org/country/United-States

[1] https://aspe.hhs.gov/2015-poverty-guidelines

[2] https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2016/demo/p60-25...

[3] https://www.census.gov/data/tables/2015/demo/cps/hinc-06.htm... (Warning: XLS sheet!)

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by atemerev on Friday May 12, 2017 @04:37PM (#14327696)
Do you assume normal distribution of income? Because income is Pareto distributed, and shifting the median changes other parameters quite unusually.

For your convenience: US Gini index is ~41%, and, correspondingly, the alpha parameter of Lomax (Pareto type II) distribution is ~1.71. If you plug the median in [1], and try to run any income redistribution scenarios, it doesn't work.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lomax_distribution

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by AnimalMuppet on Friday May 12, 2017 @04:57PM (#14327880)
But it would not be sustainable. If you take everyone's income away, how many people are going to bother to continue to work? Far less than "all of them". So what happens to national income? It falls dramatically. So now you have much less income to distribute.

Peoples' behavior is not a constant. When you change the incentives, the behavior changes. This is one aspect of the "Law of Unintended Consequences" that has wrecked so many fine-sounding ideas.