News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by AndrewKemendo on Friday May 12, 2017 @02:47PM (#14326706)
The early adopters will be the largest companies with the most to gain from improvements in efficiency.

This pattern is actually the one I'm worried about the most. New tech is giving outsize advantage to the major players across almost every industry, who can afford to invest in creating internal teams for these big new technologies.

I see this in every industry I encounter. The middle class worker lost out over the last few decades. Now the middle tier company is going to get killed cause they can't change fast enough.

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by mabbo on Friday May 12, 2017 @03:41PM (#14327206)
> New tech is giving outsize advantage to the major players across almost every industry, who can afford to invest in creating internal teams for these big new technologies.

Oohh, this very much.

Inside Amazon warehouses, there are tens of thousands of employees called 'Pickers'. They walk around with these handscanners with 300x300 pixel screens that tell them where to go and what item to get next.

For two years, my job was to make the UX of that application a little bit faster. Not the order to pick the items (another team) not the decision of which shipments should be processed next (also different team) or which items should be picked by which picker (you guessed it- a different team). Just the UX for the 0.9MP of screen space in front of the user.

Labour costs for that job are in the hundreds of millions per year, so any team that made a 1% improvement to overall efficiency would be covering its own costs a many times over. And we did.

Amazon can afford to get those small 1% gains multiple times per year, but for smaller companies the gains wouldn't pay for the costs. If they want to beat Amazon, they'll need to find a very big win that Amazon didn't see first. The only company I can think of that did that was Kiva Robotics- wait, it's called Amazon Robotics now.

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by nfriedly on Friday May 12, 2017 @04:13PM (#14327484)
I think the only realistic way for a small player to beat Amazon at selling physical goods is to charge more and convince customers that it's worth it.
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by AndrewKemendo on Friday May 12, 2017 @04:21PM (#14327549)
What would keep Amazon from adjusting to this or Acquiring the company if it got big enough?

Those are tiny tweaks that they could make easily.

Plus Amazon is much more than just a place to buy. They are data services, logistics, analytics, seller services, infrastructure etc...

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by nfriedly on Friday May 12, 2017 @04:31PM (#14327650)
> What would keep Amazon from adjusting to this

Obviously not much. The point I was trying to make was that a small player probably can't compete with Amazon on price, but they may be able to compete some other way.

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by zanny on Friday May 12, 2017 @06:09PM (#14328314)
Is it even a problem if they can't compete with Amazon on price? Generally the reason to fear monopolies is abuse of market capture for profit. If you own all the corn, you can set the price. But Amazon doesn't own all the commerce - it just undercuts everyone. But that is a win for consumers until Amazon tries to exploit its position.

But the moment they do that, right there is where you can undercut Amazon. If they are abusing their competitive advantage by the nature of abusing it they are giving it up.

At worse, they raise prices circumstantially to maximize profit, but that is more the benefits of winning the market than of exploiting a monopoly, because they would still be overall cheaper than any competitor could manage.

As long as Amazon is cheaper (and not exploiting employees) than what a competitor could do, the consumer is winning.

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by MawNicker on Friday May 12, 2017 @08:06PM (#14328894)
As you've described it, the consumer's "win" is determined by Amazon's competitors. Every private advantage Amazon has serves to undercut the profits a competitor would need to develop their own productivity gains. Those are the gains that would actually show up for consumers. How are they winning?
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by stevenwoo on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:52PM (#14329338)
At this point, if one could guarantee that what one is selling is not a counterfeit, one has a leg up on Amazon.
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by akvadrako on Saturday May 13, 2017 @02:50AM (#14329820)
It's a growing problem with Amazon that for whatever reason isn't being addressed.

Issues like this are probably due to Amazon's size and culture, which competitors could take advantage of.

Anther example of Amazon doing an unexpectedly poor job was when my brand new seller account was rejected/disabled by mistake, it took significant effort to get any human to look at my case.

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by adrianN on Saturday May 13, 2017 @01:22AM (#14329642)
Yeah no, if you go into a normal brick and mortar store you can be pretty sure that what you're getting is not counterfeit. Stores are still not competitive with Amazon.
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by stevenwoo on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @01:37PM (#14351545)
Anecdotally, it's enough to nudge me into alternatives. Other people are saying they know people who decline Walmart shopping for similar reasons but on the other hand with about half of US households using Amazon Prime it's a drop in the bucket.
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by AndrewKemendo on Friday May 12, 2017 @03:56PM (#14327370)
This is exactly one of the processes I see happening, and thanks for the real world example.
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by dexterdog on Friday May 12, 2017 @03:59PM (#14327401)
That's actually a .09MP screen. Makes it sound as pathetic as it is.
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by mabbo on Monday May 15, 2017 @09:39AM (#14341442)
Oh God you're right.

300x300 pixel screen, IE 5.5, tiny tiny processor, 128MB of ram (64MB on the old ones).

The only advantage that thing had was that if you dropped it from a fourth story window, the device would be fine. I was told we had tested this to be sure.

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by habitue on Friday May 12, 2017 @03:37PM (#14327185)
There is a counterbalancing force, which is hard to see going away, which is that larger companies have a harder time seeing which way the wind is blowing and getting ahead of the curve. They make decisions slowly, and tend to be wary about investing in risky things that might pull resources away from their existing profit centers. They have something to defend, so they're anchored to past decisions in a way smaller nimbler companies aren't.
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by AndrewKemendo on Friday May 12, 2017 @03:55PM (#14327359)
My critical contention is that those counterbalancing forces are going away because Large companies have the following vectors:

1. Invest in small companies broadly enough so they get key insight so they can acquire before they become a threat. See GV, Intel Ventures etc...

2. Overwhelm small companies through brute force if they can't acquire. See: Facebook vs Snap

3. Invest in internal moonshots that startups can't compete with. See: Google X

In previous times, big monoliths didn't have the foresight to do this or weren't agile enough to restructure internally. I think the way AFGAM operates and has proven they can pivot at scale, using their market dominance to change that whole equation.

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by marcosdumay on Friday May 12, 2017 @04:55PM (#14327864)
Companies have been doing those 3 forever. It works most of the time, it fails once in a while.

All established companies sooner or later face the choice between destroying a huge revenue stream to get a chance on the new thing, or keep the current revenue and limit its lifetime. Nearly all of them choose the second, and the ones that choose the first do not always make it either.

[dead]
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by AndrewKemendo on Friday May 12, 2017 @04:12PM (#14327482)
More accurate to say "Big companies have traditionally been blind sided by new tech..."

I'm not aware of any major example of this since the introduction of the iPhone.

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by adamsea on Friday May 12, 2017 @04:26PM (#14327598)
...which was really not all that long ago. Give it time ;)
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by dredmorbius on Friday May 12, 2017 @08:12PM (#14328916)
Look at what's happening to the desktop/laptop industry.

Print and broadcaast media.

Telcos, especially wired.

Politics. News. Propaganda.

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by AndrewKemendo on Friday May 12, 2017 @08:45PM (#14329024)
I'm talking specifically about AFGAM:

Apple owns consumer

Facebook owns Social

Google owns Search

Amazon owns E-commerce

Microsoft owns enterprise

Nobody is coming even close to taking them out in their categories and they are collectively dominant in pretty much everything else except hard infrastructure - even then they are gaining ground.

Snapchat could have had a close chance against FB before FB targeted them hard, so you can forget about that. But even then, google capital is an Investor and on top of that is getting $2BN in revenue from snapchat using google cloud!

Name any potential serious startup competitor to any of these. Doesn't exist.

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by dredmorbius on Saturday May 13, 2017 @03:02AM (#14329847)
Correction: Google owns advertising.

At this point, I don't even think Search is a particularly significant element of Google's value chain.

Globally, the typical Internet user runs fewer than 1.5 Google searches per day.

https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/63bib1/google_...

That aside, I find your scoping of the situation excessively narrow.

Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by izacus on Friday May 12, 2017 @05:31PM (#14328115)
iPhone was built by one of the richest corporations on Earth do not sure if even counts.
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by AndrewKemendo on Friday May 12, 2017 @08:12PM (#14328912)
This is exactly my point. It wasn't like some small time player came in and reinvented the market - a big player did it themselves.
Re:Guaranteed Minimum What? by WalterBright on Friday May 12, 2017 @04:30PM (#14327630)
The demise of Kodak?