>"In addition to being poor at detecting gross defects and almost useless for detecting fraud it is slow, expensive, profligate of academic time, highly subjective, something of a lottery, prone to bias, and easily abused." https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1420798/
While I've experienced what you've described, I think throwing it all out is merely going to the other extreme.
I think peer review should remain, but may need reform. The larger problem is the attitude of scientists today - some of the problems you yourself mentioned. Removing peer review will not fix those. And "fixing" peer review to handle those problems is merely treating a symptom. Ultimately, the larger problem is the mentality that has spread amongst academics - and the problems will remain no matter how you tweak peer review.
>In addition to being poor at detecting gross defects and almost useless for detecting fraud
This gets mentioned a lot, so I'll repeat what many others have said: Peer review was never meant to detect fraud, and should not be expected to.
Back during the Schon scandal, people kept asking how peer review had failed the system to let him get so far before he was caught. And the answer was always the same: Peer review is not the appropriate method to catch such people. It was never meant for it.
However, I believe open access journals can and should experiment with alternative forms of peer review. For example, forcing every submitter to anonymously score 5 papers before his/her own submission is accepted, a karma system, a good meta-moderation system, and a good document revision system taken together could work for online publications. There is a lot of potential for innovation in online publishing.
The problems are in the end similar to those on online forums and social media. It's hard to keep trolls and people who try to game the system away and equally hard to prevent people from scoring solely according to their personal tastes and with kind of 'political' (as in politics of science) motivations, especially when the process is anonymous. But ordinary peer review has the same problem.
You can't just replace/remove peer review and expect things to improve. It is part of the whole "assembly line" science environment that was created when the US government became the primary source of funding in the 1940s or so.
If we want functioning science, we need to replace at least two things:
1) The search for "significant" p-values with comparing precise predictions to data.
2) Peer review with independent replication.
Both are pretty much just reverting to how things worked earlier.
Problems:
1. Not sure we have a decent alternative.
2. While p-values are heavily used in some fields (social sciences, medicine, etc) they are not in others (e.g. physics). Yet those other disciplines still have similar problems.
Also, I see that physics is now starting to rely on statistical significance (eg LIGO), which I guarantee will be to their detriment. They are just behind those other fields in adopting it.
All problems that exist even with peer review.
>For example, forcing every submitter to anonymously score 5 papers before his/her own submission is accepted
This leads to low quality reviews.
>a karma system, a good meta-moderation system,
On the whole Internet, I have yet to see a system of karma/moderation that lasts. They are always gamed in the end.
And I'm not even sure what you mean here. What will high karma provide to the researcher?
> decisions about what to publish and what to reject were usually made by journal editors, often acting largely on their own. These decisions were often made rapidly, with papers appearing days or weeks after submission, after a cursory review by the editor. Rejection rates at most journals were low, with only obviously inappropriate or unsound material being rejected
Maybe this isn't possible today because of extreme specialization, but this sounds like a system with a lot of positives (relative to what we have now). ArXiv-like.
There's a story where Einstein withdrew a paper of his after he found out the editor had sent it for peer review without his permission. He was offended - it just wasn't the norm back then.
http://michaelnielsen.org/blog/three-myths-about-scientific-...