Re:What it was like to be peer reviewed in the 1860s
by sndean on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @11:31AM
(#14308928)
That's a great article you linked to. Pretty eye-opening, to me at least. I feel a little different about peer review now.
> decisions about what to publish and what to reject were usually made by journal editors, often acting largely on their own. These decisions were often made rapidly, with papers appearing days or weeks after submission, after a cursory review by the editor. Rejection rates at most journals were low, with only obviously inappropriate or unsound material being rejected
Maybe this isn't possible today because of extreme specialization, but this sounds like a system with a lot of positives (relative to what we have now). ArXiv-like.
> decisions about what to publish and what to reject were usually made by journal editors, often acting largely on their own. These decisions were often made rapidly, with papers appearing days or weeks after submission, after a cursory review by the editor. Rejection rates at most journals were low, with only obviously inappropriate or unsound material being rejected
Maybe this isn't possible today because of extreme specialization, but this sounds like a system with a lot of positives (relative to what we have now). ArXiv-like.