Re:What it was like to be peer reviewed in the 1860s
by nonbel on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @05:03PM
(#14311696)
What do you mean about not having a decent alternative? The perfect alternative is given in the second part of what you quoted.
Also, I see that physics is now starting to rely on statistical significance (eg LIGO), which I guarantee will be to their detriment. They are just behind those other fields in adopting it.
Problems:
1. Not sure we have a decent alternative.
2. While p-values are heavily used in some fields (social sciences, medicine, etc) they are not in others (e.g. physics). Yet those other disciplines still have similar problems.