Re:What it was like to be peer reviewed in the 1860s
by BeetleB on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @04:37PM
(#14311463)
>or the scientific community would be flooded with massive amounts of papers that are way below acceptable quality or even entirely false, not the speak of the dangers of pseudo-science and fake scientists or even paid shills.
All problems that exist even with peer review.
>For example, forcing every submitter to anonymously score 5 papers before his/her own submission is accepted
This leads to low quality reviews.
>a karma system, a good meta-moderation system,
On the whole Internet, I have yet to see a system of karma/moderation that lasts. They are always gamed in the end.
And I'm not even sure what you mean here. What will high karma provide to the researcher?
All problems that exist even with peer review.
>For example, forcing every submitter to anonymously score 5 papers before his/her own submission is accepted
This leads to low quality reviews.
>a karma system, a good meta-moderation system,
On the whole Internet, I have yet to see a system of karma/moderation that lasts. They are always gamed in the end.
And I'm not even sure what you mean here. What will high karma provide to the researcher?