The consequences of breaking open (not just a tiny crack) a crate of bananas and a container of industrial nuclear material are probably many many multitudes apart.
Yes, there are far more crates of bananas. My point is that we should make these decisions with cost-benefit analysis, not hype.
More nuclear power is the future, at least in the near term, but we should have the humility to admit we don't really understand all the risks and all the costs.
It still makes more sense to spend attention and resources protecting us from falling crates of bananas if those are more harmful in reality.
But fear normally wins these battles, like with terrorism. Automobile accidents kill about 36,000 people[1] per year in the United States. That's 12 times the number[2] of people killed in the 9/11 attacks. Which one of those do you think we're spending hundreds of billions on?
Ahem:
Another thing to think about is that maybe we're hitting the safety cap in automobiles. Maybe the cost of making things more safe nowadays is just way too high. It could be that the cost of going after some terrorists is even higher, but we might not have been so sure at the time.
Also, the problem with ignoring people who set out to murder you is that it shows an unwillingness to do so. It might prompt other would be killers to attack. A car, on the other hand, isn't going to notice all the accidents happening, and choose to crash because of them.
Terrorism is not about murdering people. It's about pushing people like yourself to overreact.
Also, what are people like me? And what is a proper reaction to an organized attempt to kill civilians in your country? I do not suggest that the US took the proper course of action, btw.
No. Terrorism is, by definition, about using fear as a weapon to further your goals. Terrorism can be perfectly successful even if nobody dies -- it's all about playing your opponent's need to react against him. That's why even a fake bomb, or pre-announced bomb attacks IRA style are terrorism -- because there has to be a reaction to a bomb threat, at a relatively small cost a terrorist can force the opponent to do huge evacuations and bomb sweeps.
Completely ignoring the 9/11 would have been a better reaction that what the USA took -- but as usually with well planned terrorism, completely ignoring the attack would have been politically impossible.
> And what is a proper reaction to an organized attempt to kill civilians in your country?
A proportioned response against the attackers, instead of some of their various allies or complete third parties.
I found
http://mitpress.mit.edu/catalog/item/default.asp?ttype=2&...
to be a revelation in this regard. It's about the uses and abuses of the Nevada test site over the 1950s. From the summary:
"In the late 1950s, birth defects and deaths from cancer began to soar among civilian and military test-site workers and their newborn children, and among "downwinders" living in Nevada, Utah and other western states. Gallagher, a professional photographer, spent several years interviewing and photographing these nuclear-test victims and gathering evidence of official indifference, callousness and outright cover-ups. The sheer density of suffering depicted here is awesome; in certain Utah towns, for instance, Gallagher found cases of cancer in every house. The bitter, stoic testimony of the victims (many of whom have since died), accompanied by Gallagher's photographic portraits of them, is deeply disturbing and exposes a major national scandal. "
On the last point:
http://www.seattlepi.com/national/95178_du12.shtml
Over x10 increase in Iraqi birth defects from 1989 - 2001:
As for Chernobyl, it was significantly underengineered and negligently operated, something clearly indicated by the fact no other comparable nuclear accident happened, before or since.
And depleted uranium ammo... well... that's what you get when you use something toxic (depleted uranium is toxic even if it's not that much radioactive) to make your ammunition.
OTOH, in the specific case of the depleted uranium, it could be possible the extra lethality was only a happy accident.
Weapon designers are an interesting breed.
[1] Coal contains some radioactive elements, and they are burning so much coal, that it gets significant.
From now on, all small leaks should be denoted in crates of bananas. 1x1 meters in size.
I wonder at how many bananas my WRT54Gs radiates...
But the important part of assessing danger is knowing the strength of the radiation, and most public accounts simplistically divide objects into "radioactive, run for your lives" or "safe". Since measurements can accurately distinguish levels of radiation that are actually indistinguishable as far as real danger to human beings, you get reports like in the link stating that "the milk is radioactive!" when it's only 1/75th of a banana dose and no threat at all.
It's strange, but it wasn't always this way. If you look back into older literature, there was a sense that radioactive things would bring about a bright, promising future. So much so that people did some pretty crazy things (at least, knowing what we know now) like those foot x-rays that shoe stores once gave (which caused some pretty high radiation exposure), or those "health" drinks that got people to drink Radium water a long time ago[1].
But once the problems came to light along with the fears of nuclear war and the demonstration of the power of atomic weapons, radiation became something to be feared, even irrationally much. I really hope that things even out over time, so that we fear it neither too much nor too little. It certainly can be dangerous. There were even some really scary criticality accidents[2] with people working on the cores to nuclear bombs. But at the same time, people point out that we don't have to fear every bit of radiation. After all, there's plenty of natural background radiation all around us, from bananas to Brazil nuts.
I wish that we could come up with a happy medium, but I think it will require a lot of time and education.
[1] If you want to see the Radium water, read this: http://www.popsci.com/scitech/article/2004-08/healthy-glow-d...
[2] The "walking ghost" phase after massive exposure is especially creepy. More info here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticality_accident
TMI-2 was built on the final approach path to Harrisburg International Airport, a former U.S. Air Force base, and was therefore beefed-up specifically to withstand the impact of a B-52 hitting the structure at 200 knots. A normal containment [vessel] would have been breached.
This caused a lot of media attention and some politicians made statements about how this was unacceptable and that they would look into it.
One reporter interviewed an older physicist that worked with radiation protection for the government and asked him if a substantial amount of radiation had been released. He said something along the lines of:
"Well, yes there was a fairly significant amount of radiation, about the same level as you would be exposed to when standing next to several crates of bananas."
This made the media hype seem somewhat exaggerated...