If there's one thing libertarians love, it's redistributing money through the government.
For things like transportation I'd much rather see a "miles traveled" tax than a carbon tax (it could even be tiered for electric vehicles). It's far more specific, and thus harder to lead to crazy far reaching taxes in tangential areas.
Why? The harm done is relative to emissions, which is exactly proportional to the volume of fuel going in. A tax on miles traveled would unfairly punish cars with great (or infinite) gas mileage. (Unless you think the relevant externality is cars on the road...)
But they're dwarfed by non-environmental factors like road wear-and-tear, and accidents, which are covered by other taxes and insurance.
The past 40 years of politics shows that this is simply not true in reality, though it is often repeated. There is significant political will to lower taxes, and taxes get lowered frequently. More frequently on the wealthy, but frequently nonetheless.
When it comes to taxing externalities and improving market function, there's often significant room to improve the market. As long as costs can be estimated within ~50% it's going to be a big win to legislate them. However, since the cost of going over is often not linear, it can be difficult to enforce in a fair way in the market without some sort of auction scheme like what goes on in cap & trade.
A miles tax is far worse than a carbon tax; it's far more of a stab in the dark. It doesn't even account for wear & tear in any way, which is dependent on an polynomial of the vehicle weight.
Large fossil fuel companies, like Exxon, are planning on an $80/ton carbon tax. There's zero reason to not phase this in along with the Paris accords. It's silly to ignore the work that those, negatively affected by the tax, have already agreed is going to happen.
Source: http://www.justfacts.com/taxes.asp (tons of footnotes there to bea.gov
I would assume that the tax rate would be based on vehicle class, but that seems too easy.
Some example reading to open your mind: https://mises.org/library/externalities-argument
Argument that "it's hard" is not much of an argument at all. It does make me think that there's considerable flexibility in a "libertarian" position on externalities though.
Fine it's impossible to correctly calculate externalities. I don't see the line from there to: "BigCo dumped a ton of waste in my pond, but it's unfair for the government coerce BigCo to compensate me because there's a chance the I might get more than the true value of that pond."
But I do agree that the best pricing schemes involve settling on price through transaction. Take, for example, cap & trade schemes. This is a widely used mechanism to manage negative externalities.
Externalities exist, whether or not the "Austrian" school has a way to deal with them. Considering the issue, deciding that one's philosophy can't deal with them, and therefore deciding to stick one's head in the sand instead is why mises.org remains fringe. It's an irrational, religious framework.
Read Mises Human Action and you will understand.. Austrian economics is a priori (built from first principles) not a posteriori (empirically derived)
The electricity generation waste I'm willing to take at face value, but only because I am somewhat familiar with the concepts of conversion factor loss and line loss. I find both of these assertions require digging into the footnotes to understand better. Their presentation is a little too hand wavy. I'm really at a loss to understand what the transportation waste means. Sure, you also need to propel the mass of the vehicle. Is it comparing every other vehicle to a bicycle? I don't know.
The presentation isn't "hand wavy", it's just simplified. Most of the confusion in this thread is from users who don't understand relatively simple aspects of how energy is generated and used. Which is fine, but the response to that should be to look something up or ask a question, not attack the graphic.
However, this stuff still very simplified as lighter cars use less fuel even without changing the % of waste energy generated.
Yes, but they reduce the total Joules of energy wasted, and that's the important point.
And that would be reflected in the graph at hand. I know we're all talking percentages, but the graph is actually about total quantity. If everyone were in very light cars, the transportation bar would be narrower, and the total energy going to the Waste node would be smaller.
So it's accurately reflecting any efficiencies of that kind.
Total work done by the vehicle / total energy contained the fuel.
A small combustion engine is a very inefficient converter of energy, so it's no surprise that it's only able to use 1/4 of the available energy. The rest is lose as heat (as well as minor losses such as noise and slippage).
Much of the waste is simply Carnot efficiency of thermal systems: the amount of useful energy you can extract is proportional to the (absolute) temperatures (Kelvin) of the "hot" and "cold" ends of the cycle.
For thermal electrical generation -- coal-fired plants, gas-fired turbines, oil-fired turbines or diesel generators, biomass thermal, solar thermal, or nuclear plants -- this is in the range of 30 - 45% or so. Ironically, high-temperature thermal coal achieves some of the best thermal efficiency. This doesn't mitigate its far more compelling downsides.
Direct kinetic or photovoltaic electrical generation has no thermal losses, but is subject to the efficiency constraints of the input stream: hydroelectric, wind, or solar PV.
There are additional losses in transmission (about 6%), and in electrical conversion and switching equipment ( ~<10%). The net is about a 66% energy loss in what's delivered to the electrical customer.
For transportation, you have the same Carnot efficiency limits, but given the smaller temperature differential start with a lower initial efficiency -- about 30%. There are additional losses through parasitic systems (any powered in-car features: power steering, brakes, A/C, electrical and electronics, etc.), transmission losses, tire and wind drag.
Again, all well understood and modeled, and well-behaved in large-number populations.
The Lawrence Livermore National Lab (LLNL) has done energy modelling for the United States since the 1970s, and has a set of flow diagrams (Sankey diagrams) showing flows dating to the 1950s, through the present.
I would be surprised if carbon tax payments offset some other taxes.
https://www.vox.com/energy-and-environment/2017/5/3/15512258...
* Carbon tax forecast for X billion in revenue.
* Let's knock X billion off of income taxes (or whatever else you want).
This is what Washington State tried, although the measure was sadly opposed by "environmentalist" groups like the Sierra Club.
http://www.sierraclub.org/washington/sierra-club-position-ca...
I personally support offsetting carbon taxes against other taxes, but since it would be regressive, I'd lean towards mitigating that in whatever compensatory tax cuts were introduced.
And if the policy is regressive then you face the danger of it blowing up in your face. For example, see what happened when the rich in America seized most of the benefits of globalisation, now we have Presidents threatening to burn it all down and being popular in doing so. If you actually want carbon reduce toon to be successful you need to factor in the politics, both getting the wealthy and powerful on board and getting the average man in the street to feel that he's not being screwed (which some people will tell him he is, even if he isn't).
Carbon taxes or excise taxes on fuel are the solution. They are endorsed by most economists (often in addition to emissions trading). Taxes must be imposed on emitting greenhouse gasses or at least on purchasing fuels; in addition a cap must be placed on the total amount of emissions.
If you are libertarian and you feel like there are too many taxes already - the carbon tax can either substitute other taxes or the revenue from it can be returned to tax-payers in some form.
Vox itself recently had an article about carbon taxes in California, it includes a part where the collected revenue is then redistributed back to citizens: https://www.vox.com/energy-and-environment/2017/5/3/15512258...