News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by _ph_ on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @04:18AM (#14253914)
Indeed, EVs don't solve congestion. But they solve a lot of problems associated with congestion, as in toxic exhausts and noise. Self-driving electrical vehicles could greatly reduce congestion, as the throughput of roads could be improved (less distance between cars, optimal driving without human errors).

For sure we should strongly look into alternative approaches which would reduce or eliminate congestion, but until they are deployed, people are going to be dependent on cars - we should make those cars as environmental friendly as possible.

Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by nickez on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @04:46AM (#14254018)
> Self-driving electrical vehicles could greatly reduce congestion

They could. But they could also greatly increase congestion because travelling with car will be a lot more convenient. Especially if the car can drop you of at your location and find a parking spot itself.

I think the only way self-driving cars will reduce congestion is if the cars are shared both per ride and over the day.

Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by ben_w on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @06:58AM (#14254588)
Given the phrase "rush hour" exists in the English language, I think they can only reduce congestion by sharing over the whole day if workplaces are successfully encouraged to shift their starting hours away from the usual 9-5 (or 9-5:30 as it seems to be). This will, of course, also work for human-driven cars.
Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by hwillis on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @10:04AM (#14255706)
>workplaces are successfully encouraged to shift their starting hours away from the usual 9-5 (or 9-5:30 as it seems to be).

This could only possibly work for internationally-focused firms, firms that operate around-the-clock, or firms that do not need contact with other firms and contact customers outside business hours. That is a very small subset.

Business hours are excellent for everyone involved in terms of work-life balance and coordinating business. They are not a good thing to sacrifice and it would only be a stopgap measure anyway. If you need to move a ton of people all at once, you need public transportation. BUILD MORE TRAINS

/swiss

Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by ben_w on Thursday May 04, 2017 @05:21AM (#14263597)
Work life balance is an interesting point I had not considered.

Mainly I was trying to make the point that self-driving cars won't make much difference to this specific problem, but I don't seem to have communicated that very well given the replies.

Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by WorldMaker on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @01:55PM (#14258306)
This is why I think a shift to remote work culture is more likely to be a major reduction of congestion than self-driving vehicles ever could. It's just too bad a remote work culture seems less likely, because it isn't a technical problem but a political/social problem.
Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by oblio on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @08:45AM (#14255162)
Almost all the incentives are for the status quo. I don't see anything which will radically change this.
Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by awjr on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @04:58AM (#14254068)
Pollution in the UK is measured using NOx, PPM10, and PPM2.5

Pollution from brake and tyre particles is something that will not be tackled.

I do think the key is lack of choice. People feel, given the design of our roads, that they have no choice but to get into a steel box and drive around.

Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by DamonHD on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @05:28AM (#14254173)
Better (automated) driving could actually reduce wear too, especially with some regenerative braking in the mix.
Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by marssaxman on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @01:21PM (#14257925)
Oh, but we very much do have a choice - you can also get into an aluminum box and drive around.
Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by mkj on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @08:52AM (#14255197)
Do they actually help noise of busy roads much? The impression I got was that the constant white noise living near a busy road was mainly tyre and air, not engines.

Buses would get a lot quieter though.

Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by r00fus on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @08:17PM (#14261433)
Yes. My house has a minimal setback. Noisiest vehicles are motorcycles, heavier trucks, and modded cars.

Normal cars are fairly silent, and HEV/EVs are almost completely silent.

The proposed? Legislation to have noise emitters on EVs might change this.

Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by URSpider94 on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @11:21AM (#14256445)
They probably wouldn't reduce the white noise from highways much, but they'd certainly have an impact on the break-through noise from rapid acceleration, loud exhaust, etc.
Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by Neliquat on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @08:56AM (#14255222)
Most toxic emissions form todays cars are not from the tailpipe. Most of it is brake pad dust. Electric cars dont help that.
Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by joshyeager on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @09:03AM (#14255260)
I'm not sure if that's true, but if it is then electric cars will definitely reduce the problem. They use regenerative braking for a large percentage of their braking power, which means that the brake pads are used much less.
Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by _ph_ on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @09:41AM (#14255522)
NOx completely comes from combustion, fine particles both from combustion and brake pad dust and tires. The fine particle load is greatly reduced by going electric, one has also to take into respect, that the fine particles from combustion are much smaller and consequently more dangerous than brake and tire dust.
Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by acqq on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @04:24AM (#14253938)
Are the cars made to be the same size as the gasoline cars more environmental friendly at all, once we consider all the environmental effects of producing them, providing the energy, and finally handling the waste at the end? Has anybody performed a whole honest evaluation?
Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by lloeki on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @05:04AM (#14254083)
> producing them, providing the energy, and finally handling the waste at the end

All of those produce environmental effects that for EVs are now:

    - local instead of spread out
    - largely decoupled from the vehicle
This is a huge architectural change because we're factoring environmental effects out of the vehicle, which allows for accelerated improvements without changing the car itself as well as economies of scale resulting in better environmental efficiency. Switch from coal to nuke and all currently running EVs stop emitting a lot of CO2 at once. Switch to wind+solar and they're suddenly all nuke-waste-free too. The same car could change to more recyclable battery tech (swappable batteries, battery rental...) over the course of its life and become progressively cleaner. So even if it provides an increase right now (which it doesn't, plus we're just living on a huge carbon credit card anyway) it certainly won't on the medium to long term.
Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by icc97 on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @06:07AM (#14254339)
Electric vehicles has to be the best example of why you should keep your objects loosely coupled :)
Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @06:33AM (#14254470)
If you don't believe this to be true, just state it honestly and people can correct your claims.

Don't "just ask questions" and then when someone wastes their time responding as if you were genuine, claim that you already know that people have done research but you don't believe it.

Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by icc97 on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @06:02AM (#14254317)
Yes - Elon Musk has quoted quite a few times that even if all electricity is generated via Coal then a Tesla still produces less CO2 than a Prius.

Plus things are improving all the time with electric. That's one of the wonderful things - decoupling of energy usage from generation. You can switch the coal to solar, you can't just switch the diesel for something else that doesn't pollute.

Plus with the Gigafactory they can start doing very efficient battery recycling because they built the batteries (there was a quote somewhere in the speeches given at the Gigafactory opening)

Obviously Tesla is biased, this Green Car Report article [0] (probably still biased, but seems pretty acurate) reckons on 292 g/mi of CO2 for a Tesla:

> We've arrived at a number for the real-world effective CO2 emissions of a Model S of 292 g/mi. Admittedly, that's lot higher than Tesla claims on its website.

> But worse than a Grand Cherokee? Hardly.

> The V-6 Grand Cherokee's official EPA CO2 number is 479 g/mi when fitted with the smallest engine offered, a 3.6-liter V-6. The more powerful V-8 model logs in at a whopping 592 g/mi.

You then have a separate wired article raising most of the questions you're asking [1]

As far as I see it though, all of the aspects of electric cars can be improved from mining of the minerals to recycling - but you can't recycle oil and there's very few improvements that you can make.

[0]: http://www.greencarreports.com/news/1084440_does-the-tesla-m...

[1]: https://www.wired.com/2016/03/teslas-electric-cars-might-not...

Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by icc97 on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @10:15AM (#14255818)
I think it's also worth mentioning that the EPA rating of the Tesla is 0.

So the 479 g/mi for the Cherokee is just the emissions.

So

- Model S CO2 = 0 (EPA) + 292 (other factors)

- Cherokee CO2 = 479 (EPA) + ? (other factors)

Those other factors aren't going to be zero for the Cherokee

Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by acqq on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @06:11AM (#14254364)
How are the environmental effects ofthe production of the huge batteries, their disposal or recycling evaluated. I've seen only some very dishonest ones like "once the batteries are not usable in cars we'll sell them" where the worth of the used batteries was immensely overblown. That wasn't honest at all.

I also can't take Musk's claims for even being close to honest.

The environmental effects of producing such small devices as cellphones is known to be significant. With the cars it's completely new orders of magnitude, which can result in non-linear responses, even if we know the good estimates for the smaller batteries. Do we?

Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by hwillis on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @10:39AM (#14256021)
>How are the environmental effects ofthe production of the huge batteries, their disposal or recycling evaluated.

Very easily. Batteries are very simple and have about a dozen input materials, usually from single sources. They are some of the most easily analyzed products in the world. There's a steel jacket with a plastic gasket, a cathode material (in Teslas this comprises lithium, nickel, cobalt and aluminum), an electrolyte mixture (common, safe liquids like ethylene carbonate or dimethyl carbonate), a separator (one of many common plastics), and an anode mixture (around 55%/45% natural and synthetic graphite, possibly with a few percent silicon). Every one of those materials is extremely common, readily available, and highly recycled or recyclable. Almost all steel and aluminum is recycled, and plastic can easily be recycled. The electrolytes are just small carbonates, used in a ton of industries. Nickel is the biggest threat by far- per pound cobalt is slightly worse, but there is 5.3x[1] as much nickel in a battery.

If we switched to 100% electric cars using Tesla sized batteries, they still wouldn't use as much nickel as the stainless steel industry does. There is no comparing the byproduct during manufacture. Lithium battery production is just great.

For recycling the worry is solely that the nickel and cobalt will leech from broken batteries into the water supply. This doesn't happen with stainless steel because well, it's stainless. Luckily nickel and cobalt are also the most valuable part of the battery, and are quite valuable to recover through shredding and incineration. The scrap value of nickel alone in the battery is more than the scrap value of steel in the car, so recycling is virtually guaranteed.

>I've seen only some very dishonest ones like "once the batteries are not usable in cars we'll sell them" where the worth of the used batteries was immensely overblown.

Are you sure you have your facts right? A battery is "used" when it's maximum capacity is 80% of it's original capacity. It continues working long after and can even degrade slower. The only problem is that it's much heavier for it's capacity- 25-50% heavier. For permanent storage that isn't a problem. Their value could easily be 50% of the original price or more, for well kept batteries- recycling wouldn't even be an issue in that case. At that price buying used batteries would be almost as cheap as buying gasoline for generators.

[1]: http://neicorporation.com/specs/NANOMYTE_BE-45_NCA_Spec_Shee...

Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by acqq on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @11:53AM (#14256843)
> A battery is "used" when it's maximum capacity is 80% of it's original capacity. The only problem is that it's much heavier for it's capacity- 25-50% heavier. For permanent storage that isn't a problem. Their value could easily be 50% of the original price or more

The above claim is exactly what made me skeptical: the greater availability of something reduces its price, so 50% of the price of a new one just doesn't sound right, unless there's some identified other immense need for them: the number of "used" batteries available to the market would be huge if the number of the buyers of the electric cars would significantly increase. That can only pull down the price of the used ones and increase the price of the new ones. The real question is where the ultimate prices would be, considering these effects.

Also, Tesla claims that their lithium batteries last extremely long, that is so if the battery's not completely discharged, but every lithium battery in every notebook I have had was the first to die or degrade very fast, even if I surely never "deep" discharged it. And it's so small compared to the ones in the car. So there is some significant difference somewhere between what's claimed and what I've personally experienced.

And what's the market for the used up consumer electronics lithium batteries?

Also in 2013 Musk's company claimed the Model S makes 176g CO2 per mile, controlling their claim gives "346g per mile - more than the 312g per mile the EPA says the Toyota Highlander emits."

https://seekingalpha.com/article/1430161-in-summary-the-tesl...

My main argument stays -- there's no reason to believe Musk, and every for an independent careful control of his claims.

Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by hwillis on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @02:21PM (#14258581)
>Also in 2013 Musk's company claimed the Model S makes 176g CO2 per mile, controlling their claim gives "346g per mile - more than the 312g per mile the EPA says the Toyota Highlander emits."

The EPA mileage calculation is based on a set ratio of city/highway miles (35/65 IIRC). Obviously that does not reflect reality perfectly. It is also a description of ideal driving habits, which of course people do not follow.

That link is wholly ridiculous. Its rejecting the EPA data as over-optimistic and then comparing it to... EPA data. I'm gonna go ahead and say that those ratings are also optimistic.

Your quote appears nowhere in the article, which says that the Model S emits 228g per mile, just shy of two hybrids.

The grid will continue to add renewables. Hybrids will be very quickly left behind. Plus, this is a massive luxury car- the model 3 will have much lower consumption, being a smaller car.

>My main argument stays -- there's no reason to believe Musk, and every for an independent careful control of his claims.

That's not an argument- it's a character attack. That's not a counterpoint to actual information.

Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by acqq on Thursday May 04, 2017 @04:33AM (#14263443)
> Your quote appears nowhere in the article

Oh, yes it does. You obviously haven't read it.

> That's not an argument

Of course it is, because even the value which you quote is not what Musk claimed, the whole text behind the link is exactly about how.

That is: Musk provably cooks what he shows in order to sell it in more ways, some of which I've mentioned too, and the different values were proven by the actual users of the car, even by the author who wanted to defend Musk.

Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by hwillis on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @02:13PM (#14258493)
>The above claim is exactly what made me skeptical: the greater availability of something reduces its price, so 50% of the price of a new one just doesn't sound right, unless there's some identified other immense need for them: the number of "used" batteries available to the market would be huge if the number of the buyers of the electric cars would significantly increase.

On the one hand there is something to your intuition: 50% is a near-maximum price that basically assumes people will be buying batteries for the grid/home. This could be for solar, or people could want stationary batteries at home to keep a quick top-up charge for their car. Alternately companies could buy extra batteries to top up their electric fleet, or to supplement solar, or to take advantage of off-peak demand.

On the other hand the actual resale price is basically irrelevant. The scrap price of a car is a few hundred dollars, so a battery would have to fall to like 5% of it's own value to not be worth recycling. At that price you wouldn't be able to sell the things fast enough.

The volume isn't a real problem. There's a 20+ year lag time before enough cars are being recycled to make this an issue. IF used battery supply ever exceeds demand -very unlikely, given the always falling cost of solar- there is pleeeeeenty of time for recycling to start. The short and long term problems are very different. The absorption mechanisms that seem insufficient at high volume are a bridge to the recycling that seems immature.

>That can only pull down the price of the used ones and increase the price of the new ones. The real question is where the ultimate prices would be, considering these effects.

It would pull down the price of used and other secondary batteries. Normally this would increase the price of a new commodity, but batteries are supply-constrained and their price is set by the number we can make. It would also pull down the price of new batteries, since they would have fewer buyers at the higher price point. More likely the lower demand would have no effect at all.

>Also, Tesla claims that their lithium batteries last extremely long, that is so if the battery's not completely discharged, but every lithium battery in every notebook I have had was the first to die or degrade very fast, even if I surely never "deep" discharged it. And it's so small compared to the ones in the car. So there is some significant difference somewhere between what's claimed and what I've personally experienced.

I dearly love this stuff, and explaining it (I'm an electrical engineer). There are a bunch of reasons for the difference! The biggest one is actually heat- your laptop gets super hot in use and uses the batteries as a heat sink, but an electric car very carefully cools its battery (unless it's a Leaf). A battery at 60C can drop to 60% of its original capacity after just 3 months. This kills laptops dead after just a few years even if you keep them plugged in every second you own them.

The second biggest is depth of charge. The average daily drive is around 30 miles, or 10-20% of an electric car's battery. Most trips are just short errands or commutes, not long drives. You may not deep discharge your laptop, but a battery will do 5,000 cycles if you discharge it to 85%, and 1,000 if you discharge it to 50%. The best results are with normal discharges under 20%, which nobody does with a laptop but almost every single electric car does. A <10% DoD will last for tens of thousands of cycles.

I really can't overstate how dramatic the difference is. Batteries as we currently use them are very badly mistreated, and when they are kept in <90 F conditions they last 2-3 times longer. When used lightly they last 3-4x longer. Both situations happen naturally in a car. Even in very hot climates the hot days never get anywhere near to the temperatures in a laptop or phone.

>And what's the market for the used up consumer electronics lithium batteries?

Currently more lithium is used to make ceramic glazes than batteries. Collecting and reselling the hundreds of different kinds of batteries from junked laptops is a healthy, profitable business in Asian countries. There simply aren't enough batteries to warrant real recycling though.

Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by icc97 on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @09:26AM (#14255428)
Not sure if you mean the CO2 claim or the battery recycling claim.

CO2 claim is open to argument I guess, but the battery recycling is pretty certain. They will definitely have battery recycling at the Gigafactory and it makes perfect sense to be able to recycle their own batteries better. They've got all the schematics of how they were built and so can more easily pull them apart.

Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by bullen on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @08:55AM (#14255209)
Something probably produces a similar amount of CO2 indirectly if the same mass is produced/moved. The only benefit of electric is the 80% efficiency of the motor. Wind and solar is not producing more energy than it requires to be built. If you sum up all the energy required to build and power a tesla, from the fuel of the mining equipment for lithium, aluminium and steel etc, to the person driving the drills cats food, everything is net negative. The only energy added to the planet is sun rays, the only way this energy is stored is through photosynthesis, we have consumed millions of years of sunshine in 200 years. At the current rate we only have 50 years of fission material left. The only viable solution is to lower your standard of living willingly, before you are forced to. In this case that means buying a bike (non-electric if you live in the city) and working from home. Both of these are actually improvements of standards, but you could also live smaller and eat less.
Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by ebbv on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @06:58AM (#14254591)
Yes tremendously. Even if we just burn gasoline at power plants they are still much more efficient. When you start to add in renewables as a source of power for EVs the environmental impact is tremendous. Buy an EV for your next car if you can.
Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by nojvek on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @10:28AM (#14255921)
Definitely thinking of an EV but they are for the rich folks atm. I'll wait for a sub 30k self driving Tesla.
Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by hwillis on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @10:46AM (#14256098)
The average price for a new car is 34k nowadays. A used Model S is at least 40k[1]. Tesla has a pre-owned up for 50k. The cheapest new Model S, with all rebates + estimated gas savings, is 56k.

If Tesla really pulls off the Model 3, it's a game changer. It'll start the clock ticking until everyone can afford a (used) electric car.

[1]: https://www.cargurus.com/Cars/l-Used-Tesla-Model-S-d2039#lis...

[2] 85kWh, no less: https://www.tesla.com/preowned/5YJSA1DN1DFP16592

Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by smaddox on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @01:38PM (#14258121)
Averages can be misleading in highly skewed distributions...
Re:The Electric-Car Boom Is Real by WorldMaker on Wednesday May 03, 2017 @02:00PM (#14258345)
The 2017 Bolt is competitively priced: $37k MSRP. Still qualifies for ~$7k tax refund. Could potentially negotiate the price down a tad at a local dealership.