News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by wand3r on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @12:51PM (#14195431)
Someone made a compelling case a few months ago that Mayer executed perfectly for what she was brought in for. Activist investors brought her in after buying the stock super low and then liquidated at the perfect time after the stock rallyied.

Regardless, objectively Yahoo failed and she bears a large share of the responsibility. Absurd reward for botching a lot of the sale, operations and core of that company. I think she tried hard but man I wish I got 9 figures for effort.

Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by VonGuard on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @02:03PM (#14196314)
It's very interesting to see so many people on the Internet complaining about Marissa's golden parachute. Honestly, the only remarkable thing about it is that she's a woman. These types of rewards are handed out all the time to CEO's of failed companies. Failed CEO's get them too, and frankly, I don't think Marissa failed.

Frankly, she did what she was supposed to do: sold the company, satisfied Carl Icahn, and improved internal morale. From what I heard anecdotally, she took an internal culture of rot and at least made it a place where people didn't dread going into work every morning. It's kinda like she pulled the teams out of the swamp, and rested them on a muddy, cold bank of the river. At least they weren't drowning anymore.

The pivot to mobile-first was a big deal, internally. They really lived and breathed that change, as is evidenced by the tremendous amount of engineering they put into simple things like their mobile weather app. It didn't ultimately work, but it was the right direction to be going, honestly.

Was it all misguided and doomed from the start? Sure! Yahoo! was the new AOL, and it was a miracle the company didn't get sold off to a media firm. But then, Verizon is kind of building its own media arm, and it already owns AOL. The fact that anyone bought Yahoo is a testament to Marissa's leadership. Would you have bought it, given the opportunity? I probably wouldn't have either. But she made the sale. If nothing else, that golden parachute is a commission just for ending the damn place as a going concern.

One of the things that really killed Yahoo, that no one talks about, is that they had these security people called Paranoids. They were great, super smart, always available, BUT, they held sway over everything and it was very very easy to just say, "naw, forget that 6 months of work, throw it all away, the Paranoids say we can't put it on production machines."

This was evidently an entirely acceptable thing to happen, internally, and it's why so many things were killed. It's also why you don't hear about constant data breaches at Yahoo! anymore, though.

Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by schwarrrtz on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @02:21PM (#14196519)
> One of the things that really killed Yahoo, that no one talks about, is that they had these security people called Paranoids. They were great, super smart, always available, BUT, they held sway over everything and it was very very easy to just say, "naw, forget that 6 months of work, throw it all away, the Paranoids say we can't put it on production machines."

I'm pretty surprised to hear that Yahoo had a security team with that much influence, given their leak of over 1bn accounts and subsequent failure to disclose that information for 3 years.

https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/dec/14/yahoo-hac...

Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by yuhong on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @02:37AM (#14200935)
It dates back to the 1990s I think.
Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by groby_b on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @03:02PM (#14196922)
Uh... Any company that truly cares about security has a security team with veto powers.

I'm surprised Yahoo cared that deeply, but blaming that team for its failure is completely missing the point.

Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by lawnchair_larry on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @09:00PM (#14199677)
Nope, definitely not the case. Seen the inside of many big companies who have top tier security teams. None that I've seen have veto and none can block shipping. The best they can do is escalate, and the business owner gets to decide if they want to ship or not.
Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by WalterSear on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @12:38AM (#14200462)
Security is a business issue like anything else, and good security people can convincingly state their business case. It sounds a bit like they did security by cargo cult.
Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by otoburb on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @02:20PM (#14196508)
>>One of the things that really killed Yahoo, that no one talks about, is that they had these security people called Paranoids.

Did this group of Paranoids hold product-blocking sway after or before the highly publicized Yahoo! hacks? Lose-lose no matter which branch of the analysis tree we traverse.

Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by lovich on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @04:37PM (#14197732)
Based on the timeline of the higher up link about the leak and the below article, its hard to tell. They appear to have had sway before the leaks were public, but they could have been known privately or people could have just been aware of how many holes they had in their system. Seems like it might have been a case of closing the barn door after the cows are out

https://www.cnet.com/news/lord-of-the-paranoids-new-yahoo-se...

Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by mason55 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @01:40PM (#14196082)
> objectively Yahoo failed and she bears a large share of the responsibility

Curious to hear more on this. Yahoo! was a disaster before she came in, she tried some things to turn it around, it didn't work.

One of the arguments for this kind of compensation in this situation is that you want the CEO to take a risk to try to turn around the company. A high profile "failure" like this also means she won't be able to get a job for awhile so you're compensating her for that.

The problem is that we don't know what the alternate universe holds, where a different CEO was brought in. It might be that that most likely scenario was that Yahoo! drops to $0 and Marissa actually made $5B for investors that an average CEO would not have made (in baseball terms her VORC [value over replacement CEO] was $5B).

Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by evilduck on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @01:57PM (#14196269)

  A high profile "failure" like this also means she won't be able to get a job for awhile so you're compensating her for that.
Ok, but when is that compensation enough? At 10x your lifetime spending needs, or 20x? She just got paid enough for generations of her descendants to be on easy street for life. It's absurd.

Edit: I'm not angry at Mayer at all, I just don't understand why companies agree to golden parachute deals like this for failure. She took a career-ending risk, that's worth some compensation, but the scale seems disproportionate.

Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by coldtea on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @02:17PM (#14196462)
>I'm not angry at Mayer at all, I just don't understand why companies agree to golden parachute deals like this for failure.

Because "the company" that decides is the board -- and these people rub each other's backs...

Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by 1024core on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @02:28PM (#14196585)
I wish this was researched more. The same group of interconnected people serve on board or C-levels of companies. They happily give raises and generous offers to others, because they know that when their turn comes, the others will do the same to them. Meanwhile, small-time shareholders are powerless, because a large chunk of the shares are held by institutions who don't want to rock the boat, and are just happy that things are fine the way they are.
Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by rmchugh on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @02:38PM (#14196683)
Sociology of elites looks at this kind of thing. One fairly easy thing to do is to do a network analysis of board membership. The ones I've seen tend to describe what you already know anecdotally, a small group of elites controlling a large number of central companies.
Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by mcbruiser3 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @02:27PM (#14196572)
That, and also probably because otherwise CEOs would take ZERO risks. Not sure if that's a good thing or a bad thing.
Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by evilduck on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @12:57PM (#14204784)
In the cases where the golden parachutes are absurdly large, I don't really see how they're really incentivized to take risks either. Perform or don't perform, the difference is the CEO's yacht size, or how many mansions they own around the globe?
Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by coldtea on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @07:37AM (#14202156)
If a CEO doesn't have any negative sequences from their decisions, then any "risky" decisions they take for the company are not actual risks for them either.
Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by xor1 on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @12:46AM (#14200490)
I'm constantly amazed by how many people either don't understand this or simply refuse to acknowledge it.
Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by coldtea on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @02:08PM (#14196369)
>A high profile "failure" like this also means she won't be able to get a job for awhile so you're compensating her for that.

$180 million for "not being able to get a job for a while"?

Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by dnel on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @10:48AM (#14203408)
at least she won't run out of ramen while she's applying for jobs
Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by colmvp on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @01:58PM (#14196278)
> A high profile "failure" like this also means she won't be able to get a job for awhile so you're compensating her for that.

Pure speculation, but I highly doubt that someone as highly touted as Marissa Mayer will be out of job offers for quite some time. A lot of people will attribute the failure to turnaround Yahoo on Yahoo itself rather than on any of the reported shortcomings of the CEO.

Certainly, I think the odds were stacked against her, but if the stories from various reports from inside sources and journalists over the last few years are true, I'd be cautious about absolving her responsibility from the eventual outcome.

Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by wand3r on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @02:33PM (#14196638)
I am a very mediocre programmer and certainly not qualified to run a public company, but I think Yahoo could've been saved. Simply because it had a lot of capital (relative to startups) and with her there, the ability to attract and retain talent for a while. She had a couple years of runway. I would've tried:

- making a personalized/customizable search engine.

- making a browser, in hindsight maybe they could've worked with Brendan Eich on brave.

- structure like Google with subsidiaries (even if not formally) and have technology and entertainment as 2 businesses.

- really tighten up security on the tech side; damn.

Then see what works and iterate. Selling Alibaba and Yahoo Japan at the end of this; Yahoo basically had negative value.

IDK, selling to Verizon and then having your value slashd-- Twice, when multi hundred million accounts are breached and getting raked over the coals on valuation was a sad finish. To her credit; I like to believe the sale was poor because she wanted to keep going and didnt expect to have to firesale the firm, but I don't know. Obv. Yahoo wasn't "just her" but they were in a poor state so she probably had a lot of operational latitude. It's super rare; if it even ever has happened; that a company is so desperate but still so powerful-- that they give up that much control. Being a total outsider and having those resources and a canvas not blank, but so f*Ed that you can really try anything; that's once a decade maybe.

Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by BlackjackCF on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @04:37PM (#14197733)
I honestly think that Yahoo! could have left the search engine alone. That market's moved on. Bing users only use Bing for some kickback rewards/when they're forced to. Everybody else migrates to Google. Maaayyybe if they offered something drastically different (kind of the way that Duck Duck Go did with privacy) to make themselves stand out, but I feel like the search engine ship had already sailed at Yahoo! Honestly, I would have simplified and slimmed down the homepage. The Yahoo! homepage was a fucking design disaster. Just have it focus on the things that really mattered - some news elements, fantasy sports, and maybe email. Everything else can go.

A browser like Brave would have been a good move, particularly in junction with tightening up security on the tech side. It would be like doing community service to try and right the wrongs of the past, or something, ha!

The problem I saw with Yahoo! was that it was a business with no focus. They acquired Tumblr... and then did nothing with it, which was perplexing. Tumblr has a youth market, and if Yahoo! had actually done stuff to improve the Tumblr experience, they really could have put that $1 billion they wasted in acquisition to use via marketing/ads. Hell, maybe they could have somehow capitalized on Vine folding and turning Tumblr into a bigger video platform (the layout loans itself well to it.)

Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by wand3r on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @05:08PM (#14198042)
Interesting. I agree with almost everything. Still think search is huge. A highly customizable, secure private search engine. Your own pagerank.

I also think we agree that there was a lot of verticals to explore and strategies to employ but hers turned out to not be a good one. I think it was possible

Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by yeukhon on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @03:11PM (#14197008)
The biggest problem was she bought too many new startups trying to gain the mobile market, specifically to make Yahoo a place for your daily digest and entertainment. The Summly acquisition was a big noise, but I don't know what happened to Summly. Did it ever integrate into Yahoo? I know they did something to do. Think of it, Yahoo's new direction focusing on mobile was correct and was critical. Many of the Yahoo users go there for news and sport game like the Fantasy sports. Recently I have been taking FourSquare's data-selling focus very seriously. Perhaps Yahoo also could sell some of their data to developers and companies. As I mentioned on another post, Yahoo could build a end-to-end photography service business around Flickr, and even sell NLP and image recognition to various companies. They have Tumblr, they have photos, they could do something with that.

Tumblr acquisition was great theoretically, but the social interaction has changed to more rapid social platform like Instagram and Snapchat by the time the acquisition went through (I used to use Tumblr daily with my ex-girlfriend and it was our preferred social platform).

Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by nemothekid on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @03:42PM (#14197267)
>The Summly acquisition was a big noise, but I don't know what happened to Summly. Did it ever integrate into Yahoo? I know they did something to do.

I believe those series of acquisitions were made just to bring on multiple mobile-experienced teams into Yahoo. The product didn't matter, but hiring teams of proven Mobile-UI/UX/Devs did.

Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by guiomie on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @01:47PM (#14196149)
It would be great to see some data behind this assertion if it exists. I suspect that failing for business reasons as opposed to being caught in some illegal scheme isn't as bad when it comes to finding another job.
Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by coldtea on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @02:07PM (#14196361)
>Curious to hear more on this. Yahoo! was a disaster before she came in, she tried some things to turn it around, it didn't work.

What exactly did she try? Because I haven't seen any effort but BS from Yahoo all this period.

Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by binthere on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @01:00PM (#14195569)
Stocks only went up because of Alibaba, Marissa didn't have anything to do with the price of the stock.
Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by run4yourlives2 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @01:01PM (#14195593)
She's the CEO. You can explain it away but she is as subject to good fortune as much as she is bad.

EDIT: Haters out in force I see. The share price was $16 when she started. It's now $48. It's irrelevant what she did or didn't do to get that. That's the fact, and that's what matters to her employers, the shareholders.

Why shouldn't she be compensated for a 200% increase? The company's long term survival is a goal that may have never been shared by the actual owners.

Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by berberous on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @01:08PM (#14195695)
I don't think you understand how much the Alibaba shares that Yahoo held were worth (~$40 billion) and how little the rest of the business was worth (<$5 billion). This is not a normal situation, where your point would usually be correct. She had zero responsibility for running Alibaba. She ran a business that was worth less than $5 billion, but was compensated based on a stock price that primarily moved based on the run-up in the $40 billion worth of Alibaba stock Yahoo held (and such stock was acquired before she became CEO).

Here's one of many Matt Levine pieces that explained the Yahoo/Alibaba situation, although it's now dated: https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2015-01-28/yahoo-wou...

Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by thisisandyok on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @01:23PM (#14195878)
> Here's one of many Matt Levine pieces that explained the Yahoo/Alibaba situation, although it's now dated

I hadn't been following Yahoo that closely, but was vaguely curious about the whole Alibaba angle, thanks for linking that article

Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by stagbeetle on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @01:21PM (#14195850)
She was brought in to salvage the situation.

By allowing those shares to accrue and not doing anything stupid at the wheel, she did her job. Whether or not it's fair or worth her comp, is irrelevant.

The shareholders valued her work at a set amount and that's what she was paid.

Unless you're taking an economic stance on the issue, wherein you believe shareholders are messing up future incentives and economic prosperity by recognizing and rewarding CEO's that do the bare minimum of "just don't fuck it up," or something similar, this debate is impractical.

Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by run4yourlives2 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @01:12PM (#14195737)
And? Was Meyer not the CEO when this happened? I'm pretty sure she was.

Just because she resorted to something other than organically growing the business to increase the value to her shareholders doesn't mean she's a failure. We're all assuming that her job was to "save" Yahoo. I don't think that was ever really on the table.

Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by derefr on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @01:22PM (#14195857)
Your comment:

> she resorted to something other than organically growing the business to increase the value to her shareholders

Parent comment:

> and such stock was acquired before she became CEO

She didn't do "resort to" anything. Yahoo made that money from an action a previous CEO was ultimately responsible for. If you want to be really generous, you could praise her for not selling the stock—but if we're praising CEOs for every way they choose not to change the companies they come into, then my pet rock would make an awesome CEO indeed.

Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by 1024core on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @02:32PM (#14196626)
> She didn't do "resort to" anything.

You have to give her credit where it's due: she saved the Alibaba partnership from that total fuckup, Carol Bartz. CB was such a fuckup, that she's the sun to Marissa's candle. She insulted Jack Ma in front of his underlings when he came calling to Sunnyvale. She refused/forgot to put someone on BABA's board and totally ignored Ma. As a result, Ma said 'fuck you' and took Alipay out of the group without even telling Bartz.

I wish more people looked at the period preceding Marissa (Bartz, Thompson) and they'd realize that Mayer was a Godsend compared to the cabal of clowns running Yahoo before her.

Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by derefr on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @02:42PM (#14196720)
Even if it's true that her management was better than previous management, I think everyone here is applying a standard where someone shouldn't get compensated for management that was provably worse than no management, because having no management is free. If the board of directors had just told everybody to go on without a CEO, the company would have done better financially than if they had installed Marissa.
Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by 1024core on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @10:09PM (#14199943)
Hindsight is 20/20.
Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by AJ007 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @01:32PM (#14195990)
She was not present when Yahoo invested in Alibaba.

Her job, presumably, as the CEO was to convince all of the enterprise's employees and customers that Yahoo would be sticking around for the long run. At the same time, she had to prepare to wind down the business while returning capital to the shareholders. I would call that a difficult job.

My lesson from this is most companies with excess capital should make investments, not acquisitions. Most certainly a company with a long string of failed acquisitions should. Yahoo has been repeatedly given as an example, but others like Google don't have a particularly great record either. Berkshire Hathaway is a great example of a massive business centrally owned by a very barebones team (in Omaha.)

Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by ethbro on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @01:26PM (#14195925)
I believe berberous' point is that if Yahoo's primary achievement (in terms of share value) had nothing to do with her, they could have appointed a stump as CEO and saved $186M+.
Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by jhall1468 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @03:04PM (#14196942)
Actually a stump would have saved them money on tumblr and their terrible video service.
Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by acchow on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @01:10PM (#14195725)

   Haters out in force I see. The share price was $16 when she started. It's now $48. It's irrelevant what she did or didn't do to get that.
False. More than 100% of that $32 increase in value was due to Yahoo's stake in Alibaba, especially due to its IPO. Yahoo itself ex-BABA lost value.
Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by run4yourlives2 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @01:14PM (#14195775)
I fail to see how this is an issue, but even if I concede the point, she still brought the stock up and created an exit for shareholders.

The goal of a resurgent Yahoo seems to only have been one shared by outside observers.

Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by kesselvon on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @01:39PM (#14196070)
because she didn't do anything to increase the stock price? You could have an empty chair as CEO and it would be rose regardless. She made a lot of objectively bad decisions like Yahoo's stint in video, or the bogglingly expensive acquisition of Tumblr
Re:Yahoo’s Marissa Mayer to Make $186M from Verizon Deal by kesselvon on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @01:38PM (#14196049)
Stock price up: Give CEOs more Business sold for parts: Give CEOs more

When does this ever end