Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by 11thEarlOfMar on Monday April 24, 2017 @08:57AM
(#14183912)
RE: electric flying things...
Is battery energy more efficient with air speed lift from a wing, like traditional aircraft, or from air suspension, like a helicopter? Does the mass/energy of a gasoline power train (including fuel & motor) exceed an electric power train?
I guess I'm wondering about the viability of electric power for flight at all. Drones are useful for some applications with light payloads and conducive environments, but when you need to lift a substantial payload, like me, isn't battery just too little power density?
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by FabHK on Monday April 24, 2017 @04:38PM
(#14188080)
A few rules of thumb:
* fixed wing flight is faster, has a longer range, and is "more efficient" than rotorcraft
* gasoline, for now, has roundabout 50x as much energy per mass ("specific energy") as batteries.
* however, electric engines are 4 to 10 times more efficient.
* so basically, with electric power for now you can only fly about 10% to 20% as long/far as with avgas - ok for a few specific applications, but not yet good enough
* on the other hand, electric engines are much simpler, lighter, and more reliable than piston engines (turbine engines are also very reliable, though)
(* note that one needs sufficient specific energy to fly long/far enough, and sufficient specific power e.g. for takeoff)
* lastly, batteries appear to improve at around 4% to 8% per year (some incremental improvements, but mostly switching to new "chemicals", eg lead to NiMH to Li-...), so electric flight could become really interesting in the next two, three decades.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by dingaling on Monday April 24, 2017 @09:25AM
(#14184084)
Air suspension?
Helicopters are aerodynes just like fixed-wing aircraft, deriving lift from aerofoil speed. They are just less efficient because in traditional single-rotor designs only part of the rotor disk is generating lift at any one time ( and part is stalled ) and of that part needs to be directed as propulsive thrust.
Some helicopters have employed short wings to offload the rotor.
A wingless VTOL aircraft such as the Flying Bedstead, or the Lunar Lander testbeds, is a non-aerodyne and is even less efficient because it relies on a small volume of highly-accelerated air for lift versus displacement of a large quantity of slow ( roughly speaking ).
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by Gravityloss on Monday April 24, 2017 @10:24AM
(#14184541)
I guess you could think of a hovering helicopter vs a circling aircraft, both having the same weight and hence same lift. Both have to accelerate some air mass downwards. The lift comes from the velocity x mass = momentum of air, which has to be the same with both.
Since the airplane wings affect a larger air volume than the helicopter blades, the airplane accelerates a larger air mass, but to a lower speed.
The helicopter: smaller air mass, higher speed.
Since energy required is proportional to the second power of speed, the helicopter requires more power for the same lift.
You could create a helicopter that was quite efficient in hover, with really big blades. It would then have some other problems, like limited speed.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by dragonwriter on Monday April 24, 2017 @03:36PM
(#14187362)
> Air suspension?
Could be a reference to ground effect, and a mistaken belief that helicopter lift is driven by ground effect (ground effect does play into helicopter low-altitude behavior, but as you mention they are aerodynes.)
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by mcculley on Monday April 24, 2017 @09:16AM
(#14184019)
My understanding is that electric motors are necessary because they can change speed faster than an internal combustion driven motor in order to maintain balance. What I don't understand is why we don't see more drones or similar flying machines using a small gasoline generator driving electric propellers to get high energy density combined with maneuverability.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by falcolas on Monday April 24, 2017 @09:28AM
(#14184105)
Weight. Multirotors scale up poorly, since the mass of a bigger propeller makes the rapid speed changes required for control harder, or require more energy.
Finding an engine / generator / capacitor combo which is light enough and powerful enough to work well with a multirotor is expensive.
Not to mention that such machines would be looked down on because of their use of fossil fuels.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by Retric on Monday April 24, 2017 @10:38AM
(#14184631)
It's more R&D costs than anything else. Batteries and electric motors are really easy to use and scale up.
Micro/Nano Gas Turbine Engines easily surpass batteries over 1h, but are not cheap or easy to use. And, if you only need 10 minutes at a time for testing then batteries are significantly lower weight.
EX: Wren's MW44i 46 oz (1320g) and produces almost 7 hp or ~5kw.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by falcolas on Monday April 24, 2017 @11:31AM
(#14185085)
Sure, batteries and motors scale up fairly linearly, but the physics don't. The energy required to change the rotational speed of a prop goes up exponentially as as the prop gets bigger.
Above a certain size, it's simply more realistic to use variable pitch rotors that don't rely on speed changes to maintain stability, at which point the traditional helicopter design becomes more efficient.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by Retric on Monday April 24, 2017 @11:46AM
(#14185233)
You can add more blades which changes things somewhat, but the transition point is around ~10lb with 30m of flight time. So, any man sized flying machine is going to quickly cross that threshold.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by mcculley on Monday April 24, 2017 @01:20PM
(#14186107)
My question wasn't about changing the size of the propellers. I was wondering if one would get more range by substituting a battery pack for a gas tank and a tiny generator.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by falcolas on Monday April 24, 2017 @03:22PM
(#14187239)
It's still a weight problem. Gas engines and generators are heavy. You also have to add a capacitor system to handle spikes in demand for sudden maneuvers or stabilization jumps in electric demands.
Increasing the weight increases the engine & prop size, which increases your energy needs.
EDIT: From the few multirotors with a gas engine that I've seen, the right combination of weight - maneuverability sweet spot appears to be around the 750mm size - around 2 feet in diameter. They also tend to have good flight times, but still in the sub-one hour range. Again due to weight.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by mcculley on Monday April 24, 2017 @05:16PM
(#14188380)
I get that one still needs a capacitor or battery. My intuition is that this is still better energy density in watt hours per pound than a battery. Maybe I'm just too used to old battery tech.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by Shivetya on Monday April 24, 2017 @09:30AM
(#14184125)
I would expect fuel cells as an alternative power source but retain the electric motors at each point. part of a drone's appeal is that they are quiet and for military the combination of that and low thermal signature benefits. figure electric motors are also desired for simplicity in both design and mounting.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by MadManE on Monday April 24, 2017 @09:23AM
(#14184068)
The issue, as I understand it, is all about weight. Putting two different power systems on board takes away all of the benefits of using one or the other exclusively.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by usrusr on Monday April 24, 2017 @12:34PM
(#14185662)
At least for fixed wing aircraft, there is actually a bit of opening where hybrids could make sense: planes need big power reserves relative to their cruise power demand (or relative to moderate climb) for takeoff and landing abort capability. That extra power needs very little endurance and since electric is much heavier than fossil per Wh, but lighter per W, burning fuel for baseline demand augmented with batteries for peak can be a
meaningful optimization.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by RealityVoid on Monday April 24, 2017 @09:46AM
(#14184234)
I would expect to be a scaling point past which choosing gasoline over batteries becomes more efficient. Maybe common electric flying vehicles have not reached that size point yet.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by usrusr on Monday April 24, 2017 @12:40PM
(#14185716)
I think that it is not a size point but an endurance point. A camera drone can be useful even with just five minutes on a single battery pack (your audience might actually be grateful if those overhead takes are less endless ;)). But a big commercial liner that has to be in final approach after only five minutes in the air would be very, very pointless.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by elmar on Monday April 24, 2017 @10:20AM
(#14184504)
if you interested in these type of vehicles register here http://bit.ly/2pdeml5 for the public co-founder program we will be doing a pre-salle soon, the electrical vehicle will cost around $40k.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by elmar on Monday April 24, 2017 @08:27AM
(#14183692)
they call it "flying car" because technically could replace the "car functionality" on this case more a "motorcycle functionality" with an aerial vehicle.
Probably should be called flying motorcycle but on a marketing level doesn't have the same impact.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by JKCalhoun on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @01:26AM
(#14191008)
Are we talking about battery technology leading to that range doubling? Because I was under the impression that energy densities of our current battery technology were already pushing the limits. To double the range I suspect you need to quadruple the energy density. Sounds like the making of a bomb. :/
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by elmar on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @06:17PM
(#14198644)
yes, battery power to weight ratio is the factor that increases range, you are correct current technology is on is limit, the increase on range is based on speculation that new chemistries will evolve in the future.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by scld on Monday April 24, 2017 @08:42AM
(#14183793)
Unless absolutely necessary, putting drive motor mechanisms and flying mechanisms on the same package is a waste of efficiency.
Why have your engine pull the extra weight of your propellers...and why have your propellers lift a drivetrain?
I get your point that "flying car" may be a tad misleading, but my guess is that they made this first iteration a "water vehicle" to get around the majority of regulations while still getting a product into the field to test and (perhaps) make some money while they're at it.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by CamelCaseName on Monday April 24, 2017 @09:31AM
(#14184127)
Regulations could be one reason. Perhaps you can for your car over bodies of water, but not over land. Since it is impractical, and even less efficient, to have three vehicles (car on each side + a plane) then a flying car is better.
You may be right technically, but there are practical reasons why flying cars may not travel over land for a very long time. I suspect noise is one of those reasons, it's why planes are limited to certain speeds despite being able to travel faster at higher efficiencies. It would be a great disturbance to the residents living below.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by dTal on Monday April 24, 2017 @04:06PM
(#14187719)
>electric
Hard problem.
>personal aircraft
Much harder problem, if by that they mean "flyable without a pilot's license". You need to tackle reliability, then AI on the order of self-driving cars, then regulators, then infrastructure. Even Tesla is having a hard time making a slightly different kind of car.
Why tackle all the hard problems at once? Why not make a self-landing helicopter, or a "normal" electric aircraft (like Tesla but for planes), or a reliable and cheap (!) experimental VTOL craft? I can't help but think that the only reason to do it this way is because you're selling sizzle, not steak.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by kumarvvr on Monday April 24, 2017 @08:43AM
(#14183803)
What is the range on this thing?
Also, at this point of time, maybe we can engineer good specs and good price into the product, but we cannot overcome human factors.
- Riding in strong winds.
- Loss of control over populous areas.
- Higher risk of crime in a vehicle that has no boundaries like roads and dividers.
The most likely solution is to make a cloud connected one which refuses to fly in or into bad weather, automatically lands during emergencies etc. But then that will necessitate some sort of remote control over the vehicle, leading to a host of other issues related to lack of privacy.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by elmar on Monday April 24, 2017 @07:16PM
(#14189322)
the volocopter is a very cool project the problem is that will need a new legal framework kitty works on current part 103 regulation.
Also I don't belive the volocopter will work for 2 passengers at least in the next 10 years.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by FabHK on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @03:41AM
(#14201203)
> new legal framework
That appears to be underway in Germany (though bureaucracy moves slowly...). USA/FAA, of course, remains to be seen, though the general move to performance-based certification makes me a bit more optimistic.
At any rate, the two major roadblocks are regulation and battery, as ever.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by lazyjones on Monday April 24, 2017 @08:46AM
(#14183837)
Looks like a silly contraption to me, far too slow to replace a car (and earn the misleading article title). I'd find a hybrid quadcopter / https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ground_effect_vehicle project more worthwhile. Take off and land like a quadcopter, then fly fast and efficiently using the ground effect. Compensate for uneven ground with the down facing rotors...
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by falcolas on Monday April 24, 2017 @09:33AM
(#14184142)
There is an interesting correlation between multirotors and 15 minute flying times. It always seems to take an abnormally large battery pack (and correspondingly less payload) to get to 20 or 30 minutes.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by elmar on Monday April 24, 2017 @09:47AM
(#14184238)
you are correct, bleeding edge tech small drones do 25 minutes if you do a large drone capable of people transport you can do 25 minutes empty when you put a passenger inside you get 15 minutes.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by RandyRanderson on Monday April 24, 2017 @09:46AM
(#14184236)
* 15min flight time
* I'd estimate 5 miles range
* if you roll it into the water and any part of the battery is exposed you'll be electrocuted and likely drown.
Fixed wing is the only way to go for efficiency and I can't imagine anything other that a hybrid having more than 45minutes flight time @ <40knots.
It's deffo possible to make a high lift, low speed fixed wing that has a short takeoff/landing requirement. There are elec ultralights that do this today.
This whole obsession with elec/'coter design baffles me - even with the most optimistic math assumptions it is a terrible product.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by lutusp on Monday April 24, 2017 @11:29AM
(#14185060)
Many readers of the linked article won't understand the meaning of "ground effect" and what role it plays in the video. It's possible to create a demonstration flying craft that can't ascend above the ground effect regime, but still create an impressive video.
In short, if the video had shown ascent to an altitude of, say, 100 feet, I would be much more impressed.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by nradov on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @12:30PM
(#14195141)
Regardless of ground effect lift, 100ft altitude is well into the "dead zone" for vehicles like this. Too high to survive a crash and too low to use a parachute.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by coldcode on Monday April 24, 2017 @09:57AM
(#14184328)
Looking forward to seeing flying car crashes. Lookout below! Seriously how do you avoid killing people innocently underneath one of these when it fails? Build "roads" in the sky like in Back To The Future?
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by ithinkinstereo on Monday April 24, 2017 @08:43AM
(#14183804)
So in the next 8 months? Seems like Google has an interesting pipeline of novel new products, but I wonder if any this will ever see the light of day, let alone by the end of the year.
I wonder why Google is doing all this pre-launch marketing hype. Usually this is the playbook that startups use to hype up VCs for funding rounds. Maybe just for PR and branding?
Reminds me of UBeam's "we plan on launching publicly this year!" (said in 2015, 2016, and now 2017)
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by turc1656 on Monday April 24, 2017 @09:09AM
(#14183973)
Yup. The site's FAQ page says that while you don't require a pilot's license, it is designed to be flown over freshwater in non-congested areas. That's pretty limiting.
There goes my dream of commuting to work like a boss in half the time.
"The focus on over-water flights is intentional -- it's meant to reassure Federal Aviation Administration officials worried that unlicensed pilots will be flying over populated areas. The company wants to work with the FAA to enable more ambitious vehicles, but it would rather play it safe in the early stages."
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by turc1656 on Monday April 24, 2017 @03:22PM
(#14187238)
Very interesting. So it seems like a craft/vehicle such as this can get away with flying in congested areas because of it's maneuverability. What's more, we have a helipad on my building at ground level! And we happen to be on the water! I wonder if I could actually pull this off at some point in the future where I fly over the water and land directly on the helipad. Would need a place to keep the craft, though.
Re:Kitty Hawk is accepting waiting-list signups for its elec...
by elmar on Monday April 24, 2017 @04:22PM
(#14187908)
well my startup is bulding an electrical self-flying fixed wing part 103 compliant for $40k, much more versatile than Kitty http://bit.ly/2pdeml5 we will be doing pre-sales soon, maybe you would like to be an early adopter.
Is battery energy more efficient with air speed lift from a wing, like traditional aircraft, or from air suspension, like a helicopter? Does the mass/energy of a gasoline power train (including fuel & motor) exceed an electric power train?
I guess I'm wondering about the viability of electric power for flight at all. Drones are useful for some applications with light payloads and conducive environments, but when you need to lift a substantial payload, like me, isn't battery just too little power density?
* fixed wing flight is faster, has a longer range, and is "more efficient" than rotorcraft
* gasoline, for now, has roundabout 50x as much energy per mass ("specific energy") as batteries.
* however, electric engines are 4 to 10 times more efficient.
* so basically, with electric power for now you can only fly about 10% to 20% as long/far as with avgas - ok for a few specific applications, but not yet good enough
* on the other hand, electric engines are much simpler, lighter, and more reliable than piston engines (turbine engines are also very reliable, though)
(* note that one needs sufficient specific energy to fly long/far enough, and sufficient specific power e.g. for takeoff)
* lastly, batteries appear to improve at around 4% to 8% per year (some incremental improvements, but mostly switching to new "chemicals", eg lead to NiMH to Li-...), so electric flight could become really interesting in the next two, three decades.
Helicopters are aerodynes just like fixed-wing aircraft, deriving lift from aerofoil speed. They are just less efficient because in traditional single-rotor designs only part of the rotor disk is generating lift at any one time ( and part is stalled ) and of that part needs to be directed as propulsive thrust.
Some helicopters have employed short wings to offload the rotor.
A wingless VTOL aircraft such as the Flying Bedstead, or the Lunar Lander testbeds, is a non-aerodyne and is even less efficient because it relies on a small volume of highly-accelerated air for lift versus displacement of a large quantity of slow ( roughly speaking ).
Since the airplane wings affect a larger air volume than the helicopter blades, the airplane accelerates a larger air mass, but to a lower speed. The helicopter: smaller air mass, higher speed.
Since energy required is proportional to the second power of speed, the helicopter requires more power for the same lift.
You could create a helicopter that was quite efficient in hover, with really big blades. It would then have some other problems, like limited speed.
Still wondering if electric powered flight is commercially viable for general purpose human transport.
Could be a reference to ground effect, and a mistaken belief that helicopter lift is driven by ground effect (ground effect does play into helicopter low-altitude behavior, but as you mention they are aerodynes.)
Finding an engine / generator / capacitor combo which is light enough and powerful enough to work well with a multirotor is expensive.
Not to mention that such machines would be looked down on because of their use of fossil fuels.
Micro/Nano Gas Turbine Engines easily surpass batteries over 1h, but are not cheap or easy to use. And, if you only need 10 minutes at a time for testing then batteries are significantly lower weight.
EX: Wren's MW44i 46 oz (1320g) and produces almost 7 hp or ~5kw.
Above a certain size, it's simply more realistic to use variable pitch rotors that don't rely on speed changes to maintain stability, at which point the traditional helicopter design becomes more efficient.
Increasing the weight increases the engine & prop size, which increases your energy needs.
EDIT: From the few multirotors with a gas engine that I've seen, the right combination of weight - maneuverability sweet spot appears to be around the 750mm size - around 2 feet in diameter. They also tend to have good flight times, but still in the sub-one hour range. Again due to weight.
Check out this section on Electric/Eco friendly Planes from the famous "Sustainable Energy Without the Hot Air": http://withouthotair.com/cC/page_278.shtml
If you like mathematics you'll also enjoy the chapter on Planes: http://withouthotair.com/c5/page_35.shtml
Probably should be called flying motorcycle but on a marketing level doesn't have the same impact.
(At least this is what I understand the range to be.)
Why have your engine pull the extra weight of your propellers...and why have your propellers lift a drivetrain?
I get your point that "flying car" may be a tad misleading, but my guess is that they made this first iteration a "water vehicle" to get around the majority of regulations while still getting a product into the field to test and (perhaps) make some money while they're at it.
You may be right technically, but there are practical reasons why flying cars may not travel over land for a very long time. I suspect noise is one of those reasons, it's why planes are limited to certain speeds despite being able to travel faster at higher efficiencies. It would be a great disturbance to the residents living below.
Hard problem.
>personal aircraft
Much harder problem, if by that they mean "flyable without a pilot's license". You need to tackle reliability, then AI on the order of self-driving cars, then regulators, then infrastructure. Even Tesla is having a hard time making a slightly different kind of car.
Why tackle all the hard problems at once? Why not make a self-landing helicopter, or a "normal" electric aircraft (like Tesla but for planes), or a reliable and cheap (!) experimental VTOL craft? I can't help but think that the only reason to do it this way is because you're selling sizzle, not steak.
Also, at this point of time, maybe we can engineer good specs and good price into the product, but we cannot overcome human factors.
- Riding in strong winds. - Loss of control over populous areas. - Higher risk of crime in a vehicle that has no boundaries like roads and dividers.
The most likely solution is to make a cloud connected one which refuses to fly in or into bad weather, automatically lands during emergencies etc. But then that will necessitate some sort of remote control over the vehicle, leading to a host of other issues related to lack of privacy.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14167870
http://www.volocopter.com/index.php/en/
(Disclaimer: I have crowd-funded invested a modicum in it)
That appears to be underway in Germany (though bureaucracy moves slowly...). USA/FAA, of course, remains to be seen, though the general move to performance-based certification makes me a bit more optimistic.
At any rate, the two major roadblocks are regulation and battery, as ever.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EPC8qElrG-I
Also, not looking forward to the headlines about disputes[0] about airspace over people's property.
Edit: clarification
[0] Dude with a shotgun vs dude on a flying "car".
What does the Kitty Hawk compete with?
- small helicopters cost $XX.XXX and have been available for many years. Proven technology, though unsafe. E.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mosquito_Aviation_XE
- small airplanes for the crazy? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KLgR3Ipo-Ng
- flying cars that can actually drive on the road? https://www.aeromobil.com/flying-car/
It looks like a toy in comparison, to be operated by quadcopter enthusiasts for 5 minutes ... Perhaps they should call it "flying golf cart"?
I speculate the kitty hawk vehicle will have 10-15 minutes airtime and will cost around $100k
Fixed wing is the only way to go for efficiency and I can't imagine anything other that a hybrid having more than 45minutes flight time @ <40knots.
It's deffo possible to make a high lift, low speed fixed wing that has a short takeoff/landing requirement. There are elec ultralights that do this today.
This whole obsession with elec/'coter design baffles me - even with the most optimistic math assumptions it is a terrible product.
In short, if the video had shown ascent to an altitude of, say, 100 feet, I would be much more impressed.
ps: lakehawk
I wonder why Google is doing all this pre-launch marketing hype. Usually this is the playbook that startups use to hype up VCs for funding rounds. Maybe just for PR and branding?
Reminds me of UBeam's "we plan on launching publicly this year!" (said in 2015, 2016, and now 2017)
https://kittyhawk.aero/faq/
I expect it will barely be a product when it launches, certainly not one with wide appeal.
I speculate the kitty hawk vehicle will have 10-15 minutes airtime and will cost around $100k.
It will appeal to a very niche market of deep pocket hobbyists.
There goes my dream of commuting to work like a boss in half the time.
You can try your luck and fly around with this thing as you would with any other ultralight.
a good post on the subject http://eaaforums.org/showthread.php?5261-Part-103-quot-conge...
"The focus on over-water flights is intentional -- it's meant to reassure Federal Aviation Administration officials worried that unlicensed pilots will be flying over populated areas. The company wants to work with the FAA to enable more ambitious vehicles, but it would rather play it safe in the early stages."
It can be adapted with floats if you wish.