* fixed wing flight is faster, has a longer range, and is "more efficient" than rotorcraft
* gasoline, for now, has roundabout 50x as much energy per mass ("specific energy") as batteries.
* however, electric engines are 4 to 10 times more efficient.
* so basically, with electric power for now you can only fly about 10% to 20% as long/far as with avgas - ok for a few specific applications, but not yet good enough
* on the other hand, electric engines are much simpler, lighter, and more reliable than piston engines (turbine engines are also very reliable, though)
(* note that one needs sufficient specific energy to fly long/far enough, and sufficient specific power e.g. for takeoff)
* lastly, batteries appear to improve at around 4% to 8% per year (some incremental improvements, but mostly switching to new "chemicals", eg lead to NiMH to Li-...), so electric flight could become really interesting in the next two, three decades.
Helicopters are aerodynes just like fixed-wing aircraft, deriving lift from aerofoil speed. They are just less efficient because in traditional single-rotor designs only part of the rotor disk is generating lift at any one time ( and part is stalled ) and of that part needs to be directed as propulsive thrust.
Some helicopters have employed short wings to offload the rotor.
A wingless VTOL aircraft such as the Flying Bedstead, or the Lunar Lander testbeds, is a non-aerodyne and is even less efficient because it relies on a small volume of highly-accelerated air for lift versus displacement of a large quantity of slow ( roughly speaking ).
Since the airplane wings affect a larger air volume than the helicopter blades, the airplane accelerates a larger air mass, but to a lower speed. The helicopter: smaller air mass, higher speed.
Since energy required is proportional to the second power of speed, the helicopter requires more power for the same lift.
You could create a helicopter that was quite efficient in hover, with really big blades. It would then have some other problems, like limited speed.
Still wondering if electric powered flight is commercially viable for general purpose human transport.
Could be a reference to ground effect, and a mistaken belief that helicopter lift is driven by ground effect (ground effect does play into helicopter low-altitude behavior, but as you mention they are aerodynes.)
Finding an engine / generator / capacitor combo which is light enough and powerful enough to work well with a multirotor is expensive.
Not to mention that such machines would be looked down on because of their use of fossil fuels.
Micro/Nano Gas Turbine Engines easily surpass batteries over 1h, but are not cheap or easy to use. And, if you only need 10 minutes at a time for testing then batteries are significantly lower weight.
EX: Wren's MW44i 46 oz (1320g) and produces almost 7 hp or ~5kw.
Above a certain size, it's simply more realistic to use variable pitch rotors that don't rely on speed changes to maintain stability, at which point the traditional helicopter design becomes more efficient.
Increasing the weight increases the engine & prop size, which increases your energy needs.
EDIT: From the few multirotors with a gas engine that I've seen, the right combination of weight - maneuverability sweet spot appears to be around the 750mm size - around 2 feet in diameter. They also tend to have good flight times, but still in the sub-one hour range. Again due to weight.
Check out this section on Electric/Eco friendly Planes from the famous "Sustainable Energy Without the Hot Air": http://withouthotair.com/cC/page_278.shtml
If you like mathematics you'll also enjoy the chapter on Planes: http://withouthotair.com/c5/page_35.shtml
Is battery energy more efficient with air speed lift from a wing, like traditional aircraft, or from air suspension, like a helicopter? Does the mass/energy of a gasoline power train (including fuel & motor) exceed an electric power train?
I guess I'm wondering about the viability of electric power for flight at all. Drones are useful for some applications with light payloads and conducive environments, but when you need to lift a substantial payload, like me, isn't battery just too little power density?