News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by sizzzzlerz on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @04:09PM (#14151305)
I like the one from last year where some idiot decided to have a soak in a hot spring so he and his sister went into a off-limits area of a geyser basin. Attempting to test the waters at one with his fingers, he slipped and fell in. By the time the rangers got there, his body was at the bottom of the pool but, due to a lightning storm, they had to abandon recovery until the next day. When they got there the following morning, the body was mostly gone, having been dissolved by the acidic waters.
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by WkndTriathlete on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @04:15PM (#14151351)
I visited Yellowstone last year for the second time and people there were doing the same stupid things they were doing 20 years ago when I first went.

Some of it is unexpected - for example, caps and water bottles being blown off of people's heads or off of handrails into Mammoth Hot Springs - but some of it is just plain stupid (for example, crowds of people encircling a bear to take photographs or people walking up to the elk to pet them.)

All of this happens despite the presence of park personnel continuously walking through all of the areas that have been turned into exhibits, and despite everyone having at least a cell phone camera to take photographs from a safe, non-polluting distance.

Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by dboreham on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @05:19PM (#14151883)
I live near Yellowstone and visitors doing stupid things is a common source of local amusement and bemusement. A local bar had a sign outside last year that said : "Thinking about throwing a baby Bison in the trunk of your car? Come inside for a drink instead."

There are in addition many more incidents that don't get covered beyond the local paper: Bison gorings, people falling off cliffs, a guy got trampled by a moose. A little outside the park, but a local guy got electrocuted by a bear that had itself been electrocuted by a fallen power pole. A party of school girls were "pinned down" for several hours by a black bear. It's endless. These are just the incidents I recall off the top of my head, besides the nationally reported stuff like Canadians traipsing through Grand Prismatic Spring and various people beinv eaten by bears.

Also check out the videos of park and fish+game staff using explosives to dispose of moose carcases in the field.

Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by jameslk on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @05:40PM (#14152053)
> A local bar had a sign outside last year that said : "Thinking about throwing a baby Bison in the trunk of your car? Come inside for a drink instead."

I was wondering the backstory behind this sign, and apparently someone actually did this.

"What started out as an apparently well-intentioned move by tourists who placed a young bison in the back of their vehicle because they believed it looked cold, has ended in no small sadness.

On Monday, officials at Yellowstone National Park revealed that the calf had to be put down after being rejected by its herd."

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/yellowstone...

Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by dboreham on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @08:39PM (#14153048)
Sorry, I thought that one was widely-known so did't include the details -- it was covered on the late-night comedy shows at the time I seem to remember.

Another one I remembered since posting the list above was the tourists who broke several toilets in the park due to standing on the seats. There are now signs, some in Chinese, in the park's public toilets advising not to stand on them..

Source: http://www.jhnewsandguide.com/news/environmental/when-east-m...

Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by saul_goodman on Thursday April 20, 2017 @08:47AM (#14156145)
Heh, in Asia sit-down toilets are rare in the country-side. They use a squat-style toilet with foot pads, the water trap is just below ground and you "flush" by pouring a small bucket of water in the hole when finished. But usually if you have the means to travel to the US from Asia you're afluent enough to have seen a sit-down shitter before. They do exist in Asia/China.
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by Cerium on Thursday April 20, 2017 @10:39AM (#14157018)
It's not that they have never seen them, its a public/private division. Many Chinese homes have sit down toilets in their bedrooms bit squat toilet in the first floor since that is a public area. Standing on a sit toilet is more about not wanting to let your butt touch a public toilet than not knowing how to use one.
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by B1FF_PSUVM on Thursday April 20, 2017 @04:58AM (#14155048)
> broke several toilets in the park due to standing on the seats

Amusingly, one of my early memories of newspaper reading was that a lady had won a lawsuit for breaking her ankle that way (yes, in the US, why do you ask? ;-)

Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by dmix on Thursday April 20, 2017 @12:20AM (#14153930)
I researched the "Bison goring" bit and found out this happens quite often:

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2015/07/2...

Happened at least 5 times in 2015:

http://www.yellowstonepark.com/teen-gored-bison/

Apparently they hit you when you turn your back to them and they will toss you in the air. Sometimes more than once.

> On June 2, an Australian man was taking photos within five feet of a 2,000-pound bison in the same area when the bull suddenly charged him, hooking him with its horns and tossing him into the air several times. Incredibly, the man lived.

Not surprised people ignore the warnings about staying back 25 meters. At Algonquin park in Ontario, Canada we came across a giant male moose and everyone was staying well back. Then a Chinese tourist family walked right up to it within a few feet to take a photo. A man attempted yelling at them to stay back but they ignored the warning. Nothing happened but it really bothered me, mostly because they entirely disrespected the animal.

Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by cmurf on Thursday April 20, 2017 @12:32AM (#14153989)
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by takk309 on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @06:29PM (#14152375)
As another local, I can confirm that the never ending idiocy coming from Yellowstone is a good source of entertainment.
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by dboreham on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @08:55PM (#14153130)
Living here and also on HN : that has to be a low-cardinality intersection!
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by avn2109 on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @09:25PM (#14153250)
(waves)... More Montanans than you'd expect are on here. Though maybe you guys are from the WY side.
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by dboreham on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @09:48PM (#14153331)
Bozeman-ish
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by takk309 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @08:24PM (#14199491)
Dido
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by rabboRubble on Thursday April 20, 2017 @01:23AM (#14154180)
Graduate of Bozeman Senior High checking in :)
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by Baeocystin on Thursday April 20, 2017 @02:34AM (#14154435)
Attendee of Montana State waving hello? I lived a couple years in Missoula, too, I figure I should get partial Montana-credit. :D
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by mattnumbe on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @09:22PM (#14153238)
I highly suggest reading the book Death in Yellowstone: Accidents and Foolhardiness in the First National Park. It goes over a long history of really stupid people (along with some extremely sad stories) who have died in the park.
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by yohui on Thursday April 20, 2017 @06:16AM (#14155401)
I remember picking up that book from the gift store on my first trip through Yellowstone. Made for morbidly engrossing reading.

Links, for those interested:

https://smile.amazon.com/dp/1570984506/

https://play.google.com/store/books/details?id=U5uLAgAAQBAJ

Interview with the author: http://www.yellowstonepark.com/unnatural-deaths-yellowstone-...

Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by sizzzzlerz on Thursday April 20, 2017 @08:43AM (#14156109)
There are similar books documenting deaths in both Yosemite and Grand Canyon. While a number of the deaths are accidents or wrong-place-wrong-time things most are caused by the person doing the dying. Example: those who chose to swim in the pool just above Nevada Falls in Yosemite and getting swept over the falls.
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by anaximander on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @04:15PM (#14151354)
What is there to like about such an event?
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by contingencies on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @05:14PM (#14151844)
If you concentrate hard enough, you can feel a distant, cleansing, tingling sensation... that's Darwinian gene pool improvement, which is powered not by death itself but the collective goosebumps of everyone who heard about the mode of expiry actively discouraging such idiocy in the future.
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by Broken_Hippo on Thursday April 20, 2017 @03:20AM (#14154612)
This comment made my morning. Thanks.
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by anigbrowl on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @05:08PM (#14151785)
One less foolish person to deal with. It's awful when something like this happens to a child but adults who are wilfully stupid about their own safety often seem equally comfortable inflicting their stupidity on everyone else.

It's one thing to take a calculated risk and die because the gamble didn't pay off or you made some error in your risk calculus. It's quite another to just ignore the clearest possible warnings that something is a Bad Idea That Will Kill You. I don't really feel any sympathy in the latter case.

Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by Scirra_Tom on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @06:43PM (#14152452)
I assume you think it'd be awful if it happened to a child because even if they knew they were not meant to, they won't be fully understanding of the potential tragedy & suffering it would cause.

Why can't we extend that sympathy to adults who also might not been fully aware of the consequences as well?

Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by mikestew on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @08:12PM (#14152929)
Adults that are capable of rudimentary reading are made aware of the consequences. There are signs all over that list the consequences of pissing in the town well, a list which ends in "...or death". We collectively told you to not do $STUPID_THING_THAT_COULD_END_IN_DEATH, and you did it anyway because you think you have a special exemption, and don't give a second thought to trashing the commons. I'm not saying that the punishment should be death, but it doesn't sadden me if that's how it turns out. If they weren't killed by the sulphuric pools, a bison, or a bear, it would have been something else that involves someone holding their beer.
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by omginternets on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @06:51PM (#14152496)
The phrase "they ought to have known better" comes to mind.

... as does "play stupid games, win stupid prizes".

Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by Scirra_Tom on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @06:57PM (#14152523)
Breaking the rules/doing something a little risky can lead to some of the most magical moments in your life.

Death for someone attempting to seek escape and joy in their life seems like an excessive punishment - mockery isn't necessary.

I feel terrible for what happened in this instance, but there have been a handful of moments in my life where looking back I suppose they could of also ended similarly. Don't regret them in the slightest though - they enriched my entire life.

It was only a few weeks ago people were celebrating Amazon's philosophy of if a mistake is made, it's never the individuals fault it's the systems fault. Could we not also perhaps apply this philosophy to safety notices/warnings/education in this tragedy?

Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by khedoros1 on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @07:56PM (#14152857)
> Breaking the rules/doing something a little risky can lead to some of the most magical moments in your life.

Sure. But part of the reason for that is that those actions are risks.

> seems like an excessive punishment

I didn't see any kind of punishment in the story. I saw a consequence for an action. He didn't die because he broke the rules. He died because he made a fatal mistake by slipping into a hot, acidic pool.

> I feel terrible for what happened in this instance

I feel sorry for the people that he hurt as an indirect result of his actions, but not for the guy himself.

> it's never the individuals fault it's the systems fault. Could we not also perhaps apply this philosophy to safety notices/warnings/education in this tragedy?

I strongly disagree with Amazon's philosophy, in that case. From what I've heard, there are many, many posted warnings, marked trails, and rangers patrolling to educate people. The park's almost 9,000 km^2. At some point, you've got to consider that a best effort was made to provide guidance for safety, and anything that happens as a result of going against that guidance is on whoever did it. He died because he did something stupid, not because the signs/rangers/trails/his 2nd grade teacher didn't stop him.

Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by lazyasciiart on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @10:22PM (#14153470)
> It was only a few weeks ago people were celebrating Amazon's philosophy of if a mistake is made, it's never the individuals fault it's the systems fault. Could we not also perhaps apply this philosophy to safety notices/warnings/education in this tragedy?

It has been established in court that the National Parks System is not required to make National Parks safe (families of dead tourists suing for more fences and safety rails and so on) because an intrinsic part of the value of the parks is exposure to nature without a glass wall in front of it. A few people dying horribly is a price the rest of us are willing to pay for that value.

[dead]
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by sctb on Thursday April 20, 2017 @07:05PM (#14161683)
Please stop. We've already asked you not to do this and we ban accounts that continue.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by lazyasciiart on Thursday April 20, 2017 @02:03AM (#14154318)
Which group are you addressing here as "you morons"?
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by 0xfeba on Thursday April 20, 2017 @09:08AM (#14156279)
> Breaking the rules/doing something a little risky can lead to some of the most magical moments in your life.

I agree. But some people lack the ability to judge the risk/reward ratio. For those people, we have signs--which unfortunately treats all risky behaviour the same.

> Could we not also perhaps apply this philosophy to safety notices/warnings/education in this tragedy?

There's a whole industry for that. For example, GM/Ford have dashboard cutouts they use for trials against them. They are example dashboards with warnings for every single thing their lawyers could think of. At some point, users just ignore the warnings. Some users never look at any. You can't get everyone to cooperate, accidents are going to happen. The point at which users ignore warnings, or how they respond to them in general are being actively studied.

Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by omginternets on Thursday April 20, 2017 @03:55AM (#14154750)
>Breaking the rules/doing something a little risky can lead to some of the most magical moments in your life.

Wholeheartedly agreed, but getting close to an acidic geyser is way beyond "a little risky".

Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by anigbrowl on Friday April 21, 2017 @06:54PM (#14170086)
That's why I made the distinction from people who take calculated risks. Death in this case is not a punishment, it's just a consequence. When someone is surrounded by warnings saying 'don't get killed in this very obvious and irreversible way' and still goes ahead I feel fine about mocking such poor choices, for the same reason I laugh every time Wile E. Coyote runs out of cliff.
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by prawn on Thursday April 20, 2017 @02:13AM (#14154350)
I think though if you're going to break rules in a national park, you're best off considering your impact on the environment left behind and the others experiencing it with you.
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by vacri on Thursday April 20, 2017 @01:17AM (#14154155)
At some point, you have to expect personal responsibility. If there weren't any safety signage at all, then there'd be more sympathy. But when you actively reject safety signage that is there to help you, then you're the one who is rejecting the care of others. In that case, why waste sympathy on those people who took those risks and rejected the a priori help?

This isn't a complex sociopolitical scene like an underclass of drug-users trying to escape from their hellish reality, where cause and effect are hard to disentangle. It's people on holiday assuming that they're special and the safety signage doesn't apply to them. It's pretty straight-forward.

Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by Baeocystin on Thursday April 20, 2017 @02:42AM (#14154463)
I think there is a reasonable argument to be made that part of the problem is over-encompassing safety rules in general, to the point that so many can be safely ignored (hello, Prop 65 in California) that it leaves people numb to the fact that some are real.

I am not sure how far I would take that line of thought, but I do think there's something to it.

Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by anigbrowl on Friday April 21, 2017 @06:40PM (#14169989)
I agree that wrapping everything in safety warnings is no more effective than doing without them and expecting everyone to rely on some unspecified common sense.
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by diebir on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @05:23PM (#14151925)
Soaking in most springs in the Park is illegal. However, the illegality is not based on the level of danger for a given spring.

Soaking is a great idea if done carefully. There are several places in YNP where it is allowed, officially or semi-officially.

In fact, every time I visit Yellowstone NP (like 5 times a year) it strikes me how silly it is that people are kept and are happy to stay on boardwalks and paved roads. They might just as well watch the BBC documentary and save everyone the trouble. If you are outdoors you should hike, swim, wade and sense the warm thermal waters. YNP is the most regulated and civilized park I know. I think this is sad.

Driving to Yellowstone on an interstate is probably more dangerous anyway.

Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by johndotsun on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @07:45PM (#14152796)
There are millions of people travelling to these areas every year. As this article outlines, even a few thousands of people per year travelling unrestricted in this park in its first few decades of popularity has lead to long-lasting damage of park features that we are still deprived of experiencing in their original states more than a hundred years later. Visitors today continue to pollute the pools with garbage and wander off the marked areas to 'soak' in them despite the pleas, warnings, and boardwalks meant to deter this behavior.

Allowing millions of tourists from around the world, many without any respect or knowledge of how to conduct themselves in the wild in such a way as to leave minimal impact, would lead to a rapid and permanent destruction of the very park features that make the area worthy of preservation and visiting.

Your perspective on things doesn't work in a world with 7+ billion people who are increasingly able to travel to popular destinations. The trail and boardwalk restrictions in the park make it possible for all visitors to enjoy park features in perpetuity rather than all features being destroyed by a single selfish generation.

Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by mirimir on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @05:51PM (#14152132)
Soaking in a hot spring seems unnecessarily risky. There's too much chance of substantial temperature change. Better to soak in a pool that's fed from a hot spring. Rather than mess with park police, find hot springs where it's allowed.
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by dboreham on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @10:09PM (#14153421)
Locals know places where it is relatively safe to soak in the hot water. Heck, you can go to Chico and pay a few bucks there to soak in the same water at no risk and drink a beer..
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by cmurf on Thursday April 20, 2017 @01:16AM (#14154147)
If there's a couple million people on the whole continent, sure. But the park doesn't have the restorative capacity for everyone who goes there to do what you propose which is pretty selfish and ignorant.
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by mythrwy on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @10:20PM (#14153462)
If it's on the way stop by Thermopolis WY. Charming little town and soaks are encouraged. They even have several bathhouses fed by the springs and it's a wonderful experience. I especially enjoy the hot spring fed steam room.
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by scythe on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @07:18PM (#14152646)
For one thing, we enjoy sharing the story, which is a useful cultural trend because it causes us to spread information about dangerous events and prevent people from being injured in the future. This is not quite as accurate as scientific data, but it can take advantage of neural circuitry which is not useful for science.

For another, it promotes a sense of shared identity of rule-followers, by criticizing people who break rules, which promotes pride in following rules and prevents people from breaking them. This is important because when I read a sign telling me to do something it is necessary that I trust the person who wrote the sign if I am to obey.

But like all forms of humorous entertainment it is not as amusing when we deliberate on it for too long. And there is a pernicious feedback effect of callousness which can arise from the sense of collective identity mentioned in the second paragraph. The positive effects of such activities seem to be best utilized when many cultural mores are practiced together to smooth out the "errors".

Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by sizzzzlerz on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @08:49PM (#14153107)
OK. How about "enjoyed and was amused by in a reflective, sad, and melancholy way all the while pondering why we were put on this earth with a functioning brain only to waste it by doing stupid things after having been repeatedly warned not to"?

Better?

Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by guyfawkes303 on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @04:38PM (#14151538)
Darwin at work.
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by aaron695 on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @05:11PM (#14151818)
Humans like to hear about other humans dieing.

It improves their self being because they can imagine in their heads using hindsight and a loaded story they would never be that stupid.

AKA Darwin awards.

Hopefully at some stage culture can wipe out the attitude and replace it with something better then using they deaths of the uneducated poor and mental ill for our betterment.

Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by Arizhel on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @06:04PM (#14152242)
Deaths of uneducated and mentally ill people are sad.

The person in that story was not mentally ill, beyond being stupid and refusing to heed plainly obvious warnings, and there's no evidence he was uneducated.

There's a difference. There's nothing noble or innocent about being selfish and stubborn and refusing to heed warnings meant to keep people safe who aren't familiar with the serious dangers in a place like Yellowstone.

Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by eeZah7Ux on Thursday April 20, 2017 @05:50AM (#14155276)
> nothing noble or innocent about being selfish and stubborn

Are you saying that people deliberately choose to be "selfish and stubborn" to the point of getting killed, and yet this is not a form of mental illness?

Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by Arizhel on Thursday April 20, 2017 @12:14PM (#14158021)
Um, yes? If you think being selfish and stubborn qualifies as a mental illness, I suggest you go talk to a professional psychologist. I'm quite sure they'll disagree. People do stupid and reckless stuff all the time (esp. 16-25yo males as the other commenter pointed out); that doesn't make them mentally ill.
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by InitialLastName on Thursday April 20, 2017 @09:25AM (#14156374)
It's often a special form of mental illness called "16-25 year old maleness"
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by fastball on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @05:56PM (#14152171)
Not all idiots are uneducated, poor or mentally ill.
Re:The Embarrassing History of Crap Thrown into Yellowstone’... by fpgaminer on Thursday April 20, 2017 @02:31AM (#14154425)
Yeah, heard that one too when we were there last winter. I think people are confused by the term "hot spring". Makes it sound like those bubbling pools are jacuzzis. But no, most of them are bubbling pools of _sulfuric_acid_! I guess people don't figure that out from the fart smells...