News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by matt_wulfeck on Monday April 17, 2017 @12:35PM (#14132249)
From what I gather online, intel is entering into an exestential crisis as homegrown chips and GPUs are replacing CPUs in the battle for tomorrow's data center. All of the interesting research from Google and others all have one thing in common: a custom asic processor.
Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by eklitzke on Monday April 17, 2017 @01:20PM (#14132691)
The ASIC processors Google use are for inference, not training. Having efficient inference is great, but training is what uses up most of the compute power.

The battle between GPUs and CPUs in the datacenter is real, but I wouldn't count out regular CPUs yet. Even with GPU-ready frameworks like Tensorflow, Theano, and Pytorch, it still requires a fair amount of domain expertise to get good performance out of GPUs. These frameworks can automatically offload compute kernels to the GPU, but actually getting good performance still requires you to understand the memory model, what data to pin in GPU memory, how to use the limited GPU memory effectively, etc.

The new instruction sets that Intel have been adding (e.g. all of the recent vectorized FMA instructions) go a long way to making Intel CPUs competitive for a lot of this ASIC/GPU stuff out of the box for things like neural networks. Nvidia has been off to a really great start in this area, and they have carved out a very respectable lead, but I think it's premature to say that Intel (or AMD) are having an existential crisis.

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by puzzle on Monday April 17, 2017 @01:35PM (#14132815)
Correction: the ASIC processors that Google used in 2015 and just talked about, two years later, were for inference. We don't know what they use now and how. The paper hints that training might happen in a later revision.

You have to wonder why they started with inference and not the other way round. Perhaps it's the case that you train a model once, then use it for predictions many, many, many times, thus using more aggregate compute power. (I used to work at Google, but the above is based on public information and speculation alone.)

The paper does confirm that CPUs are closer to GPUs for smaller or latency-sensitive workloads than most people assumed. At least on 2015-vintage hardware, that is. And they're a lot less trouble to set up and provision.

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by jtmcmc on Monday April 17, 2017 @01:37PM (#14132829)
Training can happen asynchronously and in batch - inference needs to be low latency and have massive parallelism because it's powering millions of android devices voice to text recognition - for instance.
Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by _delirium on Monday April 17, 2017 @03:34PM (#14133745)
> You have to wonder why they started with inference and not the other way round.

At least from what I know of ASICs (which is admittedly pretty high-level), this direction is the natural way I'd expect it to go, because the inference problem is much closer in scale to the kind of problem ASICs are already widely used for and good at. Fast inference can be done with a chip of a size similar to what you see in existing ASICs, like specialized DSP chips. Speeding up training is a lot more speculative. You could try scaling up to massively powerful individual chips that can each replace an NVidia GPU (but with lower cost / lower power budget), or improve distributed training so you can effectively use a much larger number of much weaker customized chips. And there are more significant memory and memory-bandwidth issues with training, so it's less of the pure-compute type of problem that ASICs are more often clear wins for. All of which is probably possible with enough effort, but less straightforward, especially to end up with something that beats GPUs on relevant metrics.

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by Analemma_ on Monday April 17, 2017 @01:41PM (#14132859)
> The ASIC processors Google use are for inference, not training. Having efficient inference is great, but training is what uses up most of the compute power.

I think that was the GP's point? The training is done on GPUs, the execution is done on ASICs, and neither step involves Intel. That's what alarms them. Dedicated hardware might help this, but that seems iffy to me. ML and neural networks are still a fast-evolving field, and instructions that might help today could be useless next year. ASICs can be thrown out and replaced, but instructions that Intel adds to its ISA will be there forever.

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by ganfortran on Monday April 17, 2017 @03:58PM (#14133925)
> for inference

True, but for training, in near future, it is still going to be GPU, probably Nvidia GPU only, not too much Intel could do.

> requires a fair amount of domain expertise to get good performance out of GPUs

Rightfully so, but invisible to end user/programmer, if you ever use those frameworks and understand their abstraction level. This falls into the realm of few experienced engineers in Google/FAIR/Nvidia and other respected institutions, who understand their business well.

I think Intel is indeed having an existential crisis: they are losing the future, the future of computation is shifting, away from their comfort zone, and they yet figured out how to stop or catch up with the new trend. If CPU becomes a stock controller component, just like a WiFi-chip, how is Intel going to justify its hefty marketing valuation? It is about time for Intel to do some hard soul searching.

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by paulsutter on Monday April 17, 2017 @03:20PM (#14133653)
There's nothing about the TPU architecture that prevents use for training. Training is also done as tensor operations, and training can be done at limited precision[1]. Just because the first TPU was memory-limited doesn't mean TPUs can never be used for training.

[1] https://arxiv.org/abs/1606.06160

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by pjscott on Monday April 17, 2017 @07:15PM (#14135249)
The key problem with the TPU architecture for training is that its on-die buffer space is fairly limited and its memory bandwidth is currently nowhere near that of a GPU. This matters if you've got a lot of intermediate buffers that need to be alive at the same time for backpropagation. Also, there's the less fundamental matter of convenience: while there are some clever ways to train with limited precision gradients, it's not yet as easy as not doing that.

One style of training that would be a good fit for the current TPU architecture is some of the recent work on reinforcement learning without gradients:

https://arxiv.org/abs/1703.03864

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by shaklee3 on Monday April 17, 2017 @04:38PM (#14134211)
Sure, but it's a garbage in, garbage out thing. If you're using those in production in something like, say, google images, you wouldn't want to lose accuracy on a one-time pass. Anything can be quantized lower, but you start making the tradeoff of losing information that may affect the quality of your product later.
Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by scottlegrand2 on Monday April 17, 2017 @04:44PM (#14134258)
Those "inference" chips are capable of 16/32 fixed point MADS on par with a current Pascal GPU with better perf/W. So they could be used for training. Just sayin'...

As to whether the TPU can perform efficient training or whether it chokes like current FPGAs due to insufficient memory bandwidth is a different question. That would be my guess but I'd love to be proven wrong.

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by yvdriess on Monday April 17, 2017 @05:54PM (#14134769)
There is quite a gulf between inference and training, it is not just raw FLOPS. Inference is relatively simple data/control-flow, the weights/biases can be stored read-only and the entire network dataflow can be baked into the chip in case of FPGAs. Training adds the backpropagation step, which performs memory read-update-writes all over the place, has kernels with bad arithmetic intensity and requires SP/DP for most models to converge.

I only know of Nervana's ASIC that is promising to be used for training and Google hinted at it for future work. Does anyone know of other processor, ASIC or FPGA's that are built for training?

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by scottlegrand2 on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @08:19AM (#14138191)
So like I said, they didn't sufficiently think over the memory subsystem?

GPUs can transpose matrices in shared memory and register space in several different ways that are all efficient. I'm guessing that you are describing the transposed matrices required for calculating deltas and weight gradients here? If so, then I see, it's more than just the fact it has one-tenth the bandwidth of a consumer GPU it's just a less flexible architecture in the first place. One would hope they fix that for the second generation TPU which I assume they're working on already. That said I've yet to encounter a network that requires double-precision math to converge. Have you?

Half Precision can be tricky, but the same trick Nervana uses (dynamic fixed point) can be emulated in software and it has been used for graphics for decades. I specifically made use of it in an OpenGL engine 20 years ago for high resolution texture sampling.

As for Nervana IP, IMO they need to ship something soon or NVIDIA'S going to ship a GPU on par with it.

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by puzzle on Monday April 17, 2017 @12:47PM (#14132381)
You forgot that Intel bought Nervana Systems last year, right before IDF. They develop custom ASIC processors for machine learning.
Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by mtgx on Monday April 17, 2017 @01:15PM (#14132630)
Which doesn't necessarily mean anything for Intel's future in machine learning. Intel bought an ARM chip maker before, too, and because of internal conflict of interest with the x86 group, it ended-up killing the ARM division.

Will the same happen to other non-x86 groups? Who knows. But we also see that even Intel's previous "accelerator" divisions have moved focus to being "CPU-driven" as well (Xeon Phi), so we have that data point.

I also remember some of the articles from a decade ago that were sure Intel's "might" would help it succeed in the mobile market. I'm not entirely sure if it's as bad for Intel in the machine learning market, because right now there's pretty much only one competitor rather than many.

It's usually much easier to be second in a market than the 5th, as some customers would inevitably get some raw deals from the incumbent, and they'll want an alternative. But if the machine learning market starts becoming entrenched around GPUs, that second player may end-up being AMD, which I think will have decent alternatives to Nvidia's training and inference GPUs in a year or two (mainly for 2019 with 7nm Navi, though).

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by trhway on Monday April 17, 2017 @03:42PM (#14133807)
> Intel bought an ARM chip maker before, too, and because of internal conflict of interest with the x86 group, it ended-up killing the ARM division.

reminds Sun in 1998 and the onward years when SPARC was like North Korea border patrol in preventing any x86 penetration into Sun even though it was clear that x86 was the future.

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by gonzo on Monday April 17, 2017 @09:27PM (#14135845)
Sorry?

The Sun 386i "Roadrunner" was launched in 1988.

A release of Solaris for PC compatibles began shipping in 1993.

In 2002, Sun introduced its first general purpose x86 system, the LX50.

In 2003, Sun announced a strategic alliance with AMD to produce x86/x64 servers based on AMD's Opteron processor; this was followed shortly by Sun's acquisition of Kealia, a startup founded by original Sun founder Andy Bechtolsheim, which had been focusing on high-performance AMD-based servers. Hardware began shipping in 2004.

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by trhway on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:42PM (#14136282)
it would be very helpful to understand whether you know what you're talking about if you also stated whether you've been there or not :) I spent there about a decade.
Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by pcwalton on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @03:10AM (#14137009)
> I also remember some of the articles from a decade ago that were sure Intel's "might" would help it succeed in the mobile market.

You don't even have to look that far back. As recently as two years ago, I remember comments here proclaiming with certainty that Intel would crush ARM because they had finally broken through the power wall.

I think a lot of folks, Intel included, have a strong belief in the inevitability of x86 dominance. But ultimately most of the inherent value of x86 is compatibility with Windows software (and DOS before it). Take that away and a lot of the advantages disappear. (Not to downplay the impressive technical and process achievements Intel has made, of course...)

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by jacquesm on Monday April 17, 2017 @03:14PM (#14133614)
Xeon Phi was a nice idea without much in terms of support or distribution. I tried getting one through various sources, they were advertised just about everywhere and even at huge discounts but actually getting one has so far proved to be impossible. And it still remains to be seen how useful it would have been, whereas a $600 GPU can be dropped into your computer and put to work in about half an hour. The hardest part is the driver installation and NVIDIA's dumb 'sign up before you download' strategy.
Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by slizard on Monday April 17, 2017 @05:20PM (#14134511)
> ...but actually getting one has so far proved to be impossible.

Where/when did you try buying? I didn't think it was difficult to get the 1st-gen Phi cards while they were selling them -- especially as it seemed like nobody wanted them. Admittedly I never bought any myself, my employer picked up some 31S1P from a local server OEM for testing when they were massively discounted.

Note that the Knights Landing, the current generation is released socketed only for now, so you'd need to buy a server or the ninja dev platforms Intel sells through Colfax.

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by jacquesm on Monday April 17, 2017 @05:32PM (#14134598)
I tried two online vendors that were actively soliciting customers but when push came to shove they couldn't deliver. Right around the same time I ordered an FPGA dev kit and an NVIDIA board, solved the problem I was dealing with and moved on.

Still, I would have very much liked to play around with the 'phi'.

> Admittedly I never bought any myself, my employer picked up some 31S1P from a local server OEM for testing when they were massively discounted.

That's the kind of deal I was looking at too. Maybe they were massively discounted because they were already EOL'd?

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by slizard on Monday April 17, 2017 @06:58PM (#14135152)
> Still, I would have very much liked to play around with the 'phi'.

Well, if you're still interested, KNL is a significantly better architecture, so you could just try now.

> That's the kind of deal I was looking at too. Maybe they were massively discounted because they were already EOL'd?

Refreshed my memory and I was wrong; there was some discussion to jump on the $125-$195/card deal Colfax had late 2014 [1] (likely dumping stock due to EOL), but we figured that they are not even worth that much. In comparison, the one card we have was actually bought just 10-11 months before for ~$1500.

[1] http://www.colfax-intl.com/nd/xeonphi/31s1p-promo.aspx

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by gonzo on Monday April 17, 2017 @09:20PM (#14135816)
> Intel bought an ARM chip maker before, too, and because of internal conflict of interest with the x86 group, it ended-up killing the ARM division.

Intel acquired Digital's StrongARM unit as part of a settlement for a patent infringement suit.

https://www.cnet.com/news/intel-digital-settle-suit/

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by chronic940 on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @12:40AM (#14136529)
And since then, has Digital Strong ARM produced anything? You are further proving his point.
Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by orionblastar on Monday April 17, 2017 @06:59PM (#14135157)
If I ran Intel, I'd keep both x86 and ARM chips and make a motherboard using x86 and ARM chips to work together with shared memory. The ARM could be given tasks to do that free up the x86 chip to make the system run faster. Plus ARM operating systems could be run in a virtual machine using the ARM chip to develop or test apps out.
Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by wolfgke on Monday April 17, 2017 @08:01PM (#14135489)
> The ARM could be given tasks to do that free up the x86 chip to make the system run faster.

What advantage does using an ARM core for this have over simply using an x86 core?

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by orionblastar on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @12:18AM (#14145412)
The ARM chip would use less power than the x86 chip. It would be greener computing.
Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by wolfgke on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @06:30AM (#14146750)
Intel also produces x86 cores that use very low power (e.g. Intel Quark). It probably would be much easier (and much more in line with Intel's corporate objectives) to add such a low-power x86 core than an ARM core if there is such a desire.

So I stand by my point:

> What advantage does using an ARM core for this have over simply using an x86 core?

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by orionblastar on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @06:04PM (#14152238)
When I went into UM Rolla in 1986 I wanted to study computer engineering. I had liked the Amiga and its co-processors. It proved to me that if you had processors that took time off the main CPU the OS and apps can run faster.

But if you used 68000, Z80, 6502 chips as a co-processor to an 8088 CPU or Intel X86 you could assign tasks to them to free up the main CPU and even doing parallel processing.

Sure Intel can make low power CPUs but if you have an X86 and ARM chip working together, like an Apple Macintosh that wants to go to ARM eventually but needs X86 code to run as well, if they make Macs with an Intel X86 and ARM chips they can run iOS apps on the ARM and MacOS apps on the Intel to run more apps than a Mac normally has.

Edit:

I like to also add if Apple put am ARM chip on their Macs with an Intel chip and required the ARM for newer MacOS versions they can lock out the Hackintosh users from pirating their OS.

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by wolfgke on Thursday April 20, 2017 @07:04AM (#14155632)
> But if you used 68000, Z80, 6502 chips as a co-processor to an 8088 CPU or Intel X86 you could assign tasks to them to free up the main CPU and even doing parallel processing.

Parallel programming is already possible using a CPU with multiple cores, which I think Intel would love to add more of if developers found usages for them that end users love. No necessity for a CPU using a different instruction set, which just makes programming this more complicated.

EDIT: And if there are active threads that require much less CPU power on some core(s), for modern CPUs the respective core will already enter energy saving states aggressively (giving lots of the advantages that adding low power cores has).

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by orionblastar on Thursday April 20, 2017 @12:45PM (#14158319)
The thing is ARM chips are cheaper than Intel chips.

You got the Raspberry PI Zero series that only costs $5, a system with an ARM CPU on one card. What could Intel chip do that and still cost $5?

The more cores added to an Intel chip, the more electricity it uses and the higher price it becomes.

Sure it would be complex, the Commodore Amiga was complex but people figured out how to program the co-processors, etc.

Right now for Bitcoin mining, they use GPUs or ASIC chips to solve SHA hashes.

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by wolfgke on Thursday April 20, 2017 @06:01PM (#14161302)
> The more cores added to an Intel chip, the more electricity it uses and the higher price it becomes.

It is much cheaper to produce as few versions of a chip as possible and deactivate cores (e.g. by fuses) for the cheaper versions. Also energy saving functions in processors have become so much better for the last, say, ten years that one has not to care anymore for energy usage of silicon that is not used.

> Sure it would be complex, the Commodore Amiga was complex but people figured out how to program the co-processors, etc.

At that time no less complex design was feasible. With today's technology it is. Why should one prefer to program a convoluted beast over programming a much more clean design?

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by orionblastar on Friday April 21, 2017 @01:30AM (#14163298)
AI and ML are complicated, many write code for it without knowing how it works by just putting libraries and examples together. Then they notice they only got a 20% success rate so they fiddle with the code until the rate goes higher.

We have so many people warning us about AI, and most of them are famous people who don't even know how it works because of how complex it has become. People often fear what they don't understand.

It is also why some people program in Haskell even if it is more complex than Python or Ruby on Rails.

I am talking about having an ARM CPU as a co-processor to an AMD or Intel system. You could even modify the X86 chips to have an ARM core or two because the design of the ARM chip is simpler than the Intel, which is why the Raspberry PI Zero is only $5 and is on a small circuit board powered by a USB cable.

The need for ARM code comes from mobile devices and in the Post-PC, Post-Microsoft, and Post-Windows era we need to look to alternatives to the way the PC used to work which was simple but out of date.

When JFK talked about going to the Moon, he didn't say it because it would be simple, he said we should do it because it is hard or complex. When he said that he had no idea how the rocket would get to the Moon, etc.

I am talking about a PC/Mobile hybrid using X86 and ARM technology that can run code made for both types of chips. One that both chips can work together as a team by assigning tasks to them.

Imagine if you will, Apple makes a new Hybrid Mac, it has an Intel CPU and ARM Co-Processor. It runs a new version of MacOS that has a virtual environment to run an ARM OS like iOS inside of it and has a touch screen. A developer can use XCode to create ARM iOS apps and then test them on the ARM chip which is the same in the latest iPhone/iPad, etc.

Do you think MacOSX was simple or complex to design? It was based on Unix instead of writing from scratch. It is designed to only work on Apple branded PCs aka Macintoshes. If it were simple to design it would have met the same fate as Copeland and other failures like the Apple Lisa or Apple III. Instead, it took Unix which has a higher learning curve and put the Mac GUI on top of it to make it simpler.

Also, Linux do you think to hack the Linux kernel is simple or complex? Do you read all of the cussing Linus does when someone submits unstable code to it that they never tested? Do you know how hard that is, and to the user they know nothing about it and think it a simple thing?

Do you not know that electronics use math and formulas to work? Do you know that Algebra, Trigonometry, Geometry, Calculus I and II, and Differential Equations as well as Linear Algebra are also not simple but complex that students struggle to try and learn? What about Statistics as well as Finacial math? Not simple but complex. There is a lot of complexity done in computers and programs or apps or whatever you want to call it. To the user it appears simple to those of us who went to college and learned data processing aka information systems and computer science we know how complex a computer is. The Amiga was so good because not that it was simple or played video games, but it could emulate the Macintosh with AMax and eve if it has a slower 68000 than a real Mac the co-processors allowed it to run faster than a Mac with a faster chip in it. End users didn't know how complex emulating a Monochrome PC DOS machine, or a Macintosh was, and only saw how easy it was to do so.

We are getting into the Mobile device age and the Internet of Things age and soon Qunatum computers and the Qubits that will change the way computers work and be more complicated than the X86 PCs or ARM based mobile devices are. The future belongs to the complex design that works better than the simple design.

This is the same mistake that most tech companies make, the people who can debug and write programs who are experts that write complex code, design complex computer systems, and make it so there are fewer bugs and fewer design flaws and save the company millions in expenses for better quality control that needs less help desk hand holding support?

Do you ever notice when these people are fired or downsized that quality control suffers? That the OS and apps get bloated and slow, and suffer more bugs and flaws in it, even hackers stealing data like passwords and email addresses because someone didn't sanitize code because management wanted it more simple than complex. That they hired 20something out of college or dropout people to replace the 30+ or 40+ year old experts for less money.

Sure you could say programmers are a dime a dozen, you get 500+ resumes a day for a programmer's job? You go with the person willing to work for less money to cut costs, but the customer suffers.

Did you know why Apple has been more successful than Microsoft? Steve Jobs learned Six Sigma quality control to make Apple hardware and software a better quality than Microsoft's. Microsoft got rid of the experts that made Windows stable or made a good mobile phone and Vista and Windows Powered devices were awful. Microsoft tried to deny it, but buying a Macintosh or iPhone was better than anything Microsoft put out because of quality control. Without Steve Jobs and his experts at Apple, Apple is starting to suffer as Microsoft had when quality was bad.

Google and Amazon had this problem but found a way to fix it by hiring better experts and quality control people.

So tell me did Evolution and Natural Selection makes a simple human brain or a complex one? It made a complex one that we have problems trying to figure it out how it works, while we try to copy it to an AI program as a series of nodes in a grid or matrix. If the human brain was so simple, we couldn't even figure out how to make computers. Yet because it is complex it is a superior design. So if complex is better, why settle for simple?

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by RealityVoid on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @03:23AM (#14137046)
They also bought Movidius.
Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by Gibbon1 on Monday April 17, 2017 @05:04PM (#14134413)
We're at a crossroads.

Fifteen or so years ago I read someone mentioning that the ratio of processor state transitions per bit of program state was growing almost exponentially.

Anecdote: Starting in the early eighties I started using CAD programs. And they were painfully slow. Yet around 1995 suddenly they weren't 'slow'. That was huge. Since then improvements in processor speed and memory hasn't provided nearly as much functional improvement.

What I think is we're in a world were current processor designs are over kill of much of the programming tasks people need done. What people want is not more speed but better efficiency. That points towards using excess silicon to implement task specific coprocessors, not for more unneeded GPU performance gains.

This leaves Intel in a bad spot. Especially since everyone and their dog is loath to design in Intel parts if they can help it.

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by m_mueller on Monday April 17, 2017 @05:26PM (#14134559)
It was a bit of an eye opener when I saw an old NT 4.0 server again. I think it had around 500 Mhz and 128MB, i.e. quite a beast for its time. All clicks had immediate on-screen results, a real pleasure to navigate, felt like a 90FPS game. Same was true even for something like iPhone 3GS and iOS3. Nowadays processors are so fast that software doesn't need to be optimized much anymore, and this is what we got. Upside is we can soon have true cross platform GUI apps that are smooth everywhere - until the next big platform like AR comes.
Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by lima on Monday April 17, 2017 @01:23PM (#14132713)
Most of the workload is still on CPUs - so the main competitor would be ARM server CPUs?
Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by visionscaper on Monday April 17, 2017 @05:03PM (#14134406)
The Von Neumann architecture is dead, IMHO future computing architectures involve many cores, all with local memory (not just a bit of cache), Tensor computing capabilities and very high bandwidth connecting these cores.

Intel has Xeon Phi, but what else are they doing? There is so much opportunity in new computing architectures but it seems like Intel has been taken by surprise. I hope this giant wakes up.

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by LgWoodenBadger on Monday April 17, 2017 @07:27PM (#14135325)
Well, the core with its own memory is still a Von Neumann machine, is it not?
Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by adrianratnapala on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @12:57AM (#14136591)
More likely a Harvard machine, i.e. one where the instruction memory is distinct from the data memory.

It is essentially what modern cores have with a their split caches, except those things are called "caches" because the architecture then has a lot of machinery for pretending to be a von Neumann Machine with a huge memory. This pretending is done because that's the kind of machine that software expects.

But the first unices ran on machines with memories only as big as a modern L1-cache. Moreover, networking and parallelism are everyday issues for software now. It will be interesting to see if software evolves to explicitly recognise that it is really running on a network of small machines + a hierarchy of big external storage devices, of which DRAM is just one.

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by visionscaper on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @03:38AM (#14137074)
Yes, true, Von Neumann is dead, long live Von Neuman! ;)

The difference is of course that we should not see the whole cluster of cores as a Von Neumann machine, the memory bandwidth is just too low to drive multiple cores with some external memory, memory must be as close as possible to the cores themselves. Quote from wtallis lower in this sub-thread :

> You can't pretend that memory is all equidistant from the processor cores unless you want everything running equally slow.

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by ww520 on Monday April 17, 2017 @09:42PM (#14135899)
NUMA style architecture has been existed for a long while now. It doesn't seem to take over the world.
Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by dom0 on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @03:05PM (#14141869)
NUMA is used, when it is actually needed, which is not that often. Most other stuff gets by without requiring NUMA enlightenment (if you think competent parallel software developers are hard to come by... finding competent NUMA people will make you reconsider that assessment).
Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by adrianratnapala on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @12:59AM (#14136599)
But the practical case for it should grow as long transistor counts increase while the speed of light doesn't.
Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by wtallis on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @03:00AM (#14136983)
And NUMA-like architectures on a single CPU die have been increasingly common between Intel's multiple ring busses on larger Xeons and AMD's 4-core clusters on Ryzen. Even per-core L2 caches violate the assumption that a given memory address is equally accessible from any processor core. You can't pretend that memory is all equidistant from the processor cores unless you want everything running equally slow.
Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by visionscaper on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @03:30AM (#14137059)
We already have practical use cases: training and evaluation of large neural networks.
Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by MichaelMoser123 on Monday April 17, 2017 @02:57PM (#14133463)
They put up a lot of money for the recent acquisition of mobileye, is a company in problems supposed to do big acquisitions ?
Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by nextweek2 on Monday April 17, 2017 @04:52PM (#14134324)
Yes.

If you are a large multi-national where your product pipeline is shallow due to competitors creation better products than your R&D.

I think the Xeon Phi is an example of something which fell flat.

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by lightedman on Monday April 17, 2017 @07:07PM (#14135201)
I think it goes a bit deeper than that. Intel is losing the power it had as a general-purpose CPU maker. Now that technology and brains are improving, others are figuring out more efficient ways of handling specific tasks that the x86/x64 CPU used to do in an efficient manner.

And intel doesn't have these people. They don't want the embarrassment and are too entrenched in their own processes. The technology as of this year can compete or stomp intel into the ground. We can program ASICs to handle any task, just about as fast as it can handle the electron flow. The only real setback is the fact the instructions are not hard-coded in the actual physical logic. That's literally the only slow-down. Were it not for that translation layer right there, ASICs would come out on top, no problem. Specialization is the future. General purpose was good enough for 30 years, it's time to move on.

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by CalChris on Monday April 17, 2017 @12:54PM (#14132450)
custom asic processor

Is that like La Brea Tarpit? Just say ASIC.

An ASIC is an Application Specific Integrated Circuit. In particular, a GPU is not an ASIC. Saying Custom Application Specific Integrated Circuit Processor is doubly redundant.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Application-specific_integrate...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graphics_processing_unit

Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by jacquesm on Monday April 17, 2017 @03:15PM (#14133626)
A GPU actually also is an ASIC, it just happens to be that that application is a different one.
Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by wyldfire on Monday April 17, 2017 @03:47PM (#14133841)
I wouldn't describe something capable of executing something quite so flexible as shaders/kernels an ASIC. It sounds much closer to a CPU -- designed to execute nearly arbitrary software. And if we're including chips that execute software as ASICs, then it seems to really water down the term to be meaningless.
Re:Intel Discontinues the Intel Developer Forum; IDF17 Cance... by gumby on Monday April 17, 2017 @01:27PM (#14132744)
I don't think so: a GPU is application-specific, (not GPGPU if such a thing really exists), as are other ones. Lisp Machine chips were application-specific. Various application-specific accelerator chips have been designed for FP, video decoding, security etc.

Where you're right is that Nirvana was a chip company founded for this ASIC and I think the term "custom" is misnomer. You could argue that Google isn't a chip company so theirs are custom.