News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by wonderwonder on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @04:49PM (#14092298)
This seems to come off as a means of using peer pressure to ensure everyone comes to work every day, regardless of personal or family illness.

If little Timmy gets the flu or something worse and you take a week or longer off to look after him because he can't go to school, your team is going to feel like your child has cost them money, which he has.

Not a good work way to build an environment based on affection and personal respect. Childless people will hate people with sick kids and if someone has a chronic illness that person is now a drain on the team.

Also a good way to ensure sick people heroically come to work and infect everyone else.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by desdiv on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @04:53PM (#14092331)
"Peer pressure" is the polite way of putting it; I would go as far as to say "collective punishment".
Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by Mithaldu on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @05:34PM (#14092675)
I've been pondering this because on the face of it it sounds stupid and counter-productive. I want to think that the decision makers aren't complete baboons and at least thought they were doing something good. What i think they might be thinking is this:

In germany workers have EXTREMELY strong sick protections and take every chance to get paid-sick-leave as mandated by law they can.

And the main way this happens is the flu, which knocks a person out of work for two weeks over here. And this is unavoidable, people get the flu, people get sick. It happens. Especially in group environments.

But if people are individually on the hook for their flu stuff, have it affect their bonuses, then they have an incentive to show up to work, not get their days counted, but get everyone else sick. Out of those there will be a number of people who do take the sick days.

However if you average the bonus sickday connection out over a group, then suddenly the sick people have an incentive to stay home. If they don't infect coworkers, they don't raise the sick days of the group en masse, thus affect their own bonuses, and everyone else's less than if they went to work sick and got everyone else sick too.

At least that's what i think the managers are thinking.

Whether that works out like this here, i can't even imagine.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by spullara on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @06:19PM (#14093043)
This was my take on it as well. The damage that one sick person coming to work could do with this structure would probably cause the peer pressure to be not to show up and potentially spread it around. Guess we will see.
Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by Scarblac on Sunday April 23, 2017 @05:47AM (#14177398)
That's already the peer pressure in the Netherlands which has similar illness rules as Germany I think. If you're sick, stay home, not least because other people don't want to be infected. And we also have a sort of common punishment -- if too many people are at home sick, we get less done of the stuff we want to get done.
Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by toyg on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @07:58PM (#14093593)
By the time people show symptoms, in many cases one has been infectious for at least a full day, so this reasoning seems fairly useless. Besides, your average manager is not an epidemiologist.

The most likely explanation is simply that they're trying to shave "sickies" through peer pressure rather than managing large-scale infections.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by Mithaldu on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @08:15PM (#14093683)
> your average manager is not an epidemiologist.

Makes it even more likely that they thought like i did, even if those thoughts are not realistically useful.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by pavel_lishin on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @10:26PM (#14094249)
Here's a fun idea: don't have people's sick days affect their bonuses at all.
Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by Mithaldu on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @12:39PM (#14099326)
It is not great and i don't excuse it.

I can however explain why it happens: This is done in Germany because especially in jobs where many people do the same thing and aren't paid very highly, people fake sick to get a day or two off. A relative of mine works as a train attendant, and around days where locally something big happens, or around national holidays (from which they're excempt) her coworkers suddenly send in slips about coughs and throat pains from their doctors at much higher rates than usual.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by mistermann on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @05:42PM (#14092755)
Prediction: the United States will push the limits of everything to the maximum tolerances (for humans, society, etc), "destroying" society in the process (any monetary fruit borne by these efficiencies flow to the top 1% and are moved to offshore accounts, under the watchful eye of the government and three letter agencies mind you).

China will sit back and observe all this, and then at a time of their choosing, implement the majority of these businesses, but in a less insane way, and capture most of everything.

Ok, that is somewhat tongue in cheek, but I honestly do believe that we can't keep running things the way we do. Too much inequality, too much dishonesty, too much theft, too little morality, etc.

Some day, this is all going to come to a head, and something very bad is going to happen.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by spdionis on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @05:49PM (#14092810)
The policy was implemented in Amazon DE. The US has nothing tobdo here.
Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by mistermann on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @06:23PM (#14093071)
Oh, I would have thought amazon.de would be associated with Amazon in the United States, which has a stellar reputation.

All is well then, nothing to worry about.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by jldugger on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @05:50PM (#14092819)
How do you factor in the fact that this news was from Amazon.de?
Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by sjg007 on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @10:49PM (#14094334)
China implements with brute force and no employee protections. The USA should socialize as Europe has done and it will state by state.
Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by mistermann on Saturday April 15, 2017 @03:34PM (#14122419)
I honestly don't see how you can socialize things with essentially unrestricted free trade.
Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by netsharc on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @05:14PM (#14092508)
It's an incredible way of trying to get the American model into the German system, because in Germany, you don't get a "sick days" budget, if you're sick you're sick, AFAIK the company still has to pay you your full wage for 6 weeks, and after that they're off the hook, your health insurance will pay 80% of your wage.
Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by tradersam on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @05:25PM (#14092599)
This doesn't introduce the American model into the German system at all, in America we don't punish the whole group of workers for individual person's sick time.
Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by logfromblammo on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @06:16PM (#14093022)
Right. In America, I don't get a bonus at all, which means it can't be reduced by the amount of sick leave I or the others in my group take--which is collectively zero, because sick leave and vacation were replaced by "PTO" at least five years ago.

Amazon.DE employees have much further to fall before reaching benefits parity with Americans.

But I do get paid more than a typical European in base salary, so there is that.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by tradersam on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @06:40PM (#14093169)
> But I do get paid more than a typical European in base salary, so there is that.

The typical European get's paid for healthcare and a usable international public transit system.

So, there's that.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by redler on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @07:31PM (#14093455)
Don't forget the $200K+ they don't have to spend (or borrow) for each child they want to put through college.
Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by devoply on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @05:21PM (#14092571)
The idea behind the American hands-off sort of system is that certain businesses can only work with horrible rules and it's better that a job be created even with shitty working conditions and that business be done than no business be done. This however has led to super competitive companies exploiting workers that can easily afford to pay properly, but choose not to for the supposed sake of efficiency. Wal-mart was doing this already but it seems like Amazon takes it to the next level. It all cries out for unionization. Only way to remedy this bad creeping problem.
Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by dvtv75 on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @06:28PM (#14093102)
> Also a good way to ensure sick people heroically come to work and infect everyone else.

There will always be people who'll do that, some out of sheer disregard for others and feelings of being a superhero by not letting a "little" thing like a 'flu stop them, but there are some really bad employers out there who discourage sick days through bad planning and poor decisions.

I just worked two days with someone who has a 'flu bad enough that he has a fever. He shouldn't have been there because he's infectious, and something of a hazard to himself. The only reason he came in is because the employer refuses to train backup staff, and holds each of us responsible for our jobs to the point of stupidity. (What do I mean by that? Old equipment fails, it's marked on the sheet as "operator error." Last week, a script generated incorrect job numbers and we had to restart production well into the run as a result of it - that wasn't accepted by management as an error, because it would never happen. Stupidity on the order of "that printout attached isn't proof of it, it comes from a printer and anybody can do that.")

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by kafkaesq on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @06:05PM (#14092943)
Also a good way to ensure sick people heroically come to work and infect everyone else.

No problem -- we can count on Amazon to just put few ambulances + paramedics outside for when people start collapsing at their stations. Just like they do during major heat waves:

http://www.seattletimes.com/business/workers-complain-about-...

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by aanm1988 on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @06:21PM (#14093057)
No, they put in AC.

Because it became a PR nightmare once their disgusting policy decisions became known.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by kafkaesq on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @06:25PM (#14093089)
No, they put in AC.

What do you mean, "No"? Are you saying the reports of Amazon hiring "Cetronia Ambulance Corps to have ambulances and paramedics stationed at its two adjacent warehouses during five days of excessive heat in June and July", as per the article, were just fake news -- and if so, which parts?

You're right about what ultimately drove the longer-term decision to put in better AC, though.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by aanm1988 on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @07:02PM (#14093286)
*now.

No, they put in AC now.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by thaumasiotes on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @05:20PM (#14092550)
> if someone has a chronic illness that person is now a drain on the team.

I largely agree with your points, but wasn't the person with a chronic illness a drain on the team before?

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by user5994461 on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @05:30PM (#14092650)
It's variable. It's mostly annoying because you never know when the person may show up or not, and how long it may disappear.

On the other hand, as far as the disease is not too bad, the person is still doing regular work like everyone else when it's here and you may really need the hands.

That's up to the environment. Amazon is in the business of cheap warehouse workers. It's very draining physically and it probably hates unpredictable leaves from employees. It's likely very unfriendly to chronic disease.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by matt4077 on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @05:52PM (#14092843)
This is warehouses and maybe customer service hotlines we're talking about. The work is fungible and the teams are large enough for it to average out.

I'd also argue that because of them being a drag in other work environments, there already is enough social pressure to keep "fake" illnesses low. Humans are surprisingly sensitive to the disapproval of their team/tribe.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by Mz on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @05:21PM (#14092561)
Not necessarily. But, now, their self care time eats into your bonus.
Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by jvvw on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @05:13PM (#14092501)
I don't agree with the policy but surely you use vacation time not sick leave when your children are sick? I do at least and assumed everybody else did too. (I'm in the UK though so appreciate sick leave may be a different concept in the US).
Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by daenney on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @05:22PM (#14092584)
No? Why would I use vacation time for that? I'm not on vacation or taking a break. I'm taking care of a sick family member. Thankfully we have a system for that known as VAB[1] in Sweden that covers this case.

[1]: https://www.forsakringskassan.se/privatpers/foralder/!ut/p/z...

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by jessaustin on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @05:57PM (#14092878)
So Sweden has something set up for this, but it still isn't called "sick leave". How is that relevant to GP's specific point?
Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by daenney on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @02:52AM (#14095380)
The GP comment is:

> I don't agree with the policy but surely you use vacation time not sick leave when your children are sick?

My reply to it is "No". I surely don't use vacation time instead of sick leave to care for sick family members. I can't really make this any clearer and as far as relevant to GP's point, it's an answer to their question. Even if we didn't have that system I wouldn't take out vacation days should this problem show up. It's not vacation.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by justifier on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @10:57PM (#14094368)
Where do you live? Your local government might have those same allowances.. know your rights

Here's California Labor Code section 246.5(o):

Diagnosis, care, or treatment of an existing health condition of, or preventive care for, an employee or an employee’s family member.

(o) http://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection...

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by brianwawok on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @05:36PM (#14092696)
Very common in the US to use sick time for either you being sick of staying home for a sick kid.

At one co this causes some friction. Company policy was 20 vacation days and 10 sick days. A young healthy type guy would use maybe 1 sick day and 20 vacation days, for 21 days off a year.

Anyone with kids know they get sick a LOT. So basically anyone with any amount of kids would use all 10 for their kids. So parents go 10 sick + 20 vacation = 30 days off a year.

I guess enough people complained that they just combined the two into a single "PTO" pool of 28 days. That way you can take the 28 days if you have kids or not. I guess the downside is people with kids got less vacation, but it seemed bit more "fair" overall.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by Broken_Hippo on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @06:02PM (#14092915)
I think it is quite fair that parents get more sick time than single folks. I do not have children, and never will.

You see, parents aren't just slacking off. They are doing the responsible thing - not making a bunch of other children sick while taking care of their own sick child, whom they are responsible for and cannot yet take care of themselves. I'd not trust a 7 year old to take the right dose of medicines on time, for example, nor can the 7 year old go off to the doctor on their own. As you can see in your example, the parents are going to be home with their children regardless, even if using vacation, PTO time, or aren't paid at all.

Luckily, I'm now in a country that allows for this sort of thing.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by brianwawok on Thursday April 13, 2017 @10:21AM (#14107138)
> I think it is quite fair that parents get more sick time than single folks. I do not have children, and never will.

That is a very European attitude. The American attitude is more or less "You choose to have kids, why should everyone else help pay for it?"

Some laws still help, for example you get a small tax break for kids. But it is a struggle. In some towns, the schools are literally falling apart due to age and lack of repair. The school has to do a local vote for approval for funds. The towns with > 50% of the people old and without kids living at home? They tend to vote NO over and over, preferring to have more money for cable TV and not fund other people's kids. (Ignore the fact themselves and their own kids went to the same schools years before).

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by Broken_Hippo on Friday April 14, 2017 @04:15AM (#14113244)
Then I had an European attitude long before I moved away from the states. I never really have understood such attitudes, honestly. Today's children are the very folks that will be taking care of me in a doctor's office in the future, driving, raising children of their own, and intertwined with my own life. I'm seriously invested in the folks around me actually making it. It was always frustrating to see such things voted down.
Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by ncallaway on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @05:48PM (#14092807)
I guess it's more fair if you view someone taking a day to care for their sick child as "vacation".

I personally don't view it that way (I say this as someone who doesn't have a child).

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by dsr_ on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @06:22PM (#14093067)
As someone with multiple children, I assure you that you are correct. It's not a vacation.

On the other hand, most of the time I can work from home while tending to a sick kid.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by aanm1988 on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @06:25PM (#14093084)
It's still a day off work. You made the decision to have a child.

I don't actually have a problem with taking time off for family reasons, but it does sound more fair to just give people a bucket of days and let them figure it out.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by SomeStupidPoint on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @06:05PM (#14092938)
Having to meet with a lawyer, accountant, etc isnt a "vacation", but I'm expected to use vacation not sick days for those appointments. Arguably, those are all more essential to life than having children, which is optional.

Now, I'm not saying we shouldn't incentivize having children by making extra allowances for that, but let's not pretend it's anything but unfair.

But if we're talking fair, why should they get a day to take care of their child but I don't get one to take care of necessary legal paperwork?

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by dvtv75 on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @06:16PM (#14093023)
> Having to meet with a lawyer, accountant, etc isnt a "vacation", but I'm expected to use vacation not > sick days for those appointments.

You think you've made a point, but you really haven't. You don't have to take vacation time for that, you can always take unpaid leave - at least, everywhere I've ever worked. If you dispute using sick days for looking after children, perhaps you should examine your employment contract and perhaps consult an employment lawyer? There will be plenty of legal reasons why it's this way.

Feel free to apply to take a sick day while consulting the lawyer, too.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by SomeStupidPoint on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @06:27PM (#14093095)
And those reasons are unfair. They're fundamentally about incentivizing a behavior via the legal system.

There's nothing wrong with that, but it's ridiculous to say it's fair when at a fundamental level, the exact point is that it's not.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @06:14PM (#14093009)
>those are all more essential to life than having children, which is optional. //

If as a species we don't raise children how will we continue to have life? It's not optional if we wish to continue the species; ergo it's "essential to life".

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by SomeStupidPoint on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @06:31PM (#14093117)
Essential to species continuation, not your life.

It's like you and the sibling comment decided to ignore my second paragraph entirely.

It's unfair, not a bad idea or illegal. Sometimes, we want options not to be fair because we're trying to incentivize behavior.

Incentivizing the continuation of the species is generally regarded as a good idea, so we make extra allowances for people who do that, even though it isn't fair.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by mst on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @10:46PM (#14094317)
> But if we're talking fair, why should they get a day to take care of their child but I don't get one to take care of necessary legal paperwork?

Compassion.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by SomeStupidPoint on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @10:50PM (#14094340)
Please read my second paragraph.

Compassion isn't fairness. Fairness isn't the only criterion we should make decisions on. However, I was responding to the comment about it being fair, which to be honest, none of the replies have addressed and instead gone on tangents about why it might be a good idea for other reasons.

But also, what, compassion for their child being sick but not me having to defend myself against, eg, an unfair ticket?

Seems a very narrow kind of compassion. Why doesn't compassion apply to the legal case?

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by mst on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @12:43AM (#14094817)
As a salaried worker, I've been allowed to take a half day to deal with something ridiculous like that too, on the basis the hours get made up.

"Defending yourself against an unfair ticket" is a very different case than "I need to see my accountant" though - had you used that example in the first place I suspect you might've got a different set of responses.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by pavel_lishin on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @10:30PM (#14094259)
> 30 days off a year.

Yeah, boy, it sure is an "off" day when I have to stay home with my vomiting kid. Gosh, I sure am sticking it to all those suckers who only get to be away from the office for 21 days.

Sarcasm aside, it seems like explaining that sick time isn't "off" time might help.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by danmaz74 on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @06:27PM (#14093098)
Anyone with kids also knows that being at home with a sick kid is anything but a "vacation"...
Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @06:10PM (#14092982)
No concept of "compassionate leave" at your workplace? Your holiday time is for taking holidays, that's an important thing for your company too - ensures you don't burn out for example. Looking after sick children and getting less holiday is, from a societal point of view at least, quite wrong. I've not worked many places in the UK but the concept of compassionate leave suits here, the boss gives you leave to care for close family members in dire need be they parents, siblings, children or whoever, at their discretion.

https://www.gov.uk/time-off-for-dependants/your-rights

Apparently there is an 18week unpaid parental leave entitlement for the period up to a child's 18th birthday, never knew that.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by abruzzi on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @05:48PM (#14092806)
In my job, sick leave is officially authorized for immediate family members, though the wording is a little vague on who that covers:

> Sick leave may be authorized due to personal illness or injury; to care for an immediate family member who is ill or injured and requires the personal attention of the employee

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by daxelrod on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @06:08PM (#14092962)
Anecdote: In my US workplace, Vacation Days are planned in advance. Unplanned leave comes out of a smaller pool of Personal Days. (There is no separate category for Sick Days, Personal Days can be used for whatever the employee wants, including being sick.)
Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by merraksh on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @04:56PM (#14092353)
Also, a good incentive to hire people that have no kids or chronic conditions.
Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by VLM on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @05:43PM (#14092762)
Or breasts. Women today supposedly have a lifetime odds of 1 in 8 of living long enough to get breast cancer. I mean, sure, we'd love some diversity, but we "Just Have To" stick to only hiring male devs, you know, solely to maintain our group bonus, not because girls have cooties or we're a sexist company or anything like that, nope solely just because of the bonus. And let me tell you a fascinating statistic that prevents hiring a certain skin color because of sickle cell anemia, I mean we'd love to get some diversity in this department, sure, listen to me virtue signal about how great it could be, but that darn group sick day quota means we just can't so we all white males here...
Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @06:24PM (#14093081)
Isn't prostate cancer [UK, 1-in-7 men] more prevalent than breast cancer [UK, 1-in-8 women]?

[Stats from mass media sources eg The Independent; prostate stat is supported by nhs.uk .]

Aside, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3411479/ suggests we've got a mismatch with funding and health/societal costs of different cancers with Breast, Prostate and Leukemia all being relatively richly funded FWIW.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by bloodbeard on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @11:35PM (#14094543)
Don't forget about the Semites. While the diversity would be great, but you have to keep in mind that many of them won't work from sundown on Friday. They'll also skip out on all 12 days of Ramadan.
Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by mynewtb on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @06:32PM (#14093128)
Or prostates. If you are not a sexist.
Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by lsiebert on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @11:04PM (#14094394)
Ah but prostates are an issue more for older men, right?
Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by fictioncircle on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @05:59PM (#14092896)
> Also a good way to ensure sick people heroically come to work and infect everyone else.

The bonus pool is likely finite and can be manipulated by sick people heroically infecting other teams to improve your team's metrics relatively.

This creates a virus spreading mechanism backed by human ingenuity within the company.

I, for one, welcome my new virus overlords in the hopes they spare my health.

Re:Amazon's Sick New Sick Policy by Spooky23 on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @05:11PM (#14092485)
A some of the fire departments around here did this to prevent overtime.

It pretty much eliminated bullshit sick call outs, especially for "illnesses" that hit during indesireable shifts like Thanksgiving and Christmas.