News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by tyingq on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @01:13AM (#14039845)
I think it's okay to fire B2C customers, but refund them before you fire them. Even if you suspect they won't return the physical part of the product.

And do it with less snark. Just state it seems clear you won't ever see eye to eye, and give the money back.

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by rlpb on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @06:26AM (#14041046)
I don't think a refund is necessarily sufficient legally. A customer has a contract with a supplier. That contract doesn't usually say (whether express or implied) that the supplier can arbitrarily terminate the contract with just a refund. So doing so would still be in breach of contract.

Legally, the remedy for breach of contract is to make the injured party whole, and that includes consequential damages. The customer may suffer consequential damages in excess of the price paid for the product (eg. "After buying your product I bought a new garage door to suit your product and now I have to get a different one to use with your competitor's product since the next best thing requires a different specification").

Offering a full refund is still entirely appropriate of course; I'm just pointing out that the customer doesn't have to accept that as a final settlement.

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by tyingq on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @07:58AM (#14041398)
>Legally, the remedy for breach of contract is to make the injured party whole

I don't see a customer getting a free garage door out of it. Using the refund to buy a competitive product would arguably make them whole. Minus perhaps wasted time. Assuming you parted ways because of their behavior (not a review), they arguably wasted their own time.

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by rlpb on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @08:17AM (#14041491)
> I don't see a customer getting a free garage door out of it.

Nor do I. That would imply that the customer had some extra asset at the end. That is beyond making the customer whole, because such a thing presumably has a market value and can be sold, even if just for scrap.

> Using the refund to buy a competitive product would arguably make them whole.

Not necessarily. If the customer has additional costs that have not been reimbursed, and these costs were incurred as a consequence of the seller's breach of contract despite the customer's reasonable efforts to minimize them, then by definition the customer hasn't been made whole. Search for the meaning of "consequential damages".

It's up to the court to decide how to address the balance. It may decide that it isn't reasonable to reimburse some extra costs anyway. And in the US, legal fees won't be reimbursed so the customer may decide to settle for less. But if it does go to court, then in the case that the seller has "fired" the customer unreasonably the court may look upon the customer's claims for consequential damages more favorably.

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by tyingq on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @08:22AM (#14041533)
I understand "consequential damages", but this is a poor example. It's not the only product in the world that can open a garage door from an app.

I can't get a new car if I buy an alternator and it's faulty. Maybe if it damaged the car, but there's no corollary here.

Edit: This happens all the time. Amazon "fires" sellers. Hosting companies "fire" people that suffered a DDOS, or similar cases to this one...customers that are snarky with tech support. Paypal "fires" customers at will, often with no details as to why. I've read many of these stories and never heard of a case where someone got something more than actual, direct losses back (like existing account balance).

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by rlpb on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @09:10AM (#14041799)
You're right; it's a poor example. I wanted to illustrate the principle in general, and had to go with the situation we already had. My point is that in the general case the seller arbitrarily deciding to refund does not constitute an automatic settlement.

Some sellers may attempt to adjust the contracts to make this true. Depending on your jurisdiction and the nature of the sale, this may or may not actually change the contract. AFAIK, we have yet to see a clause of "I'll sell you this IoT device for a one-off payment of $X and I can arbitrarily decide to stop it working as long as I pay you $X and nothing more" succeed in court.

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by tyingq on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @09:24AM (#14041879)
>AFAIK, we have yet to see a clause of "I'll sell you this IoT device for a one-off payment of $X and I can arbitrarily decide to stop it working as long as I pay you $X and nothing more"

Not court cases, but IoT customers do get abandoned.

Google's Nest bought Revolv and shut it down. As far as I know, they offered nothing at all as compensation. These were $300 devices. No related successful court cases from end users, as far as I know...and that's worse than what I suggested...no refund.

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by mring33621 on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @10:36AM (#14042360)
from revolv.com: "The Revolv app and hub don’t work anymore, but we are offering a refund for your Revolv hub. To get your refund, please email us at [email protected]."

Fair enough?

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by AstralStorm on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @12:43PM (#14043415)
If they didn't warn about service end of life, they are open to a tort, e.g. due to lost business or similar damages.
Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by s_kilk on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @06:41AM (#14041106)
> I think it's okay to fire B2C customers

This "firing customers" terminology shows how deep in the Late Capitalism nightmare we really are.

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by ams6110 on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @09:20AM (#14041853)
Some customers are a net negative, or even deliberately abusive. "Firing customers" simply means chosing to not do business with them any more. It doesn't imply that the customer didn't get what they paid for.

That said, there seems to be this attitude among some tech companies that they can do whatever they want, and treat customers/users like crap, regardless of regulations, or just what is usual and customary. I think it's a side-effect of people who have no prior business background getting a ton of investor money (i.e. not earning it from business with customers).

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by s_kilk on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @09:22AM (#14041869)
> It doesn't imply that the customer didn't get what they paid for.

But in this case we are talking about bricking hardware remotely in retribution for a negative review. And we have people using the "Firing customers" rhetoric to insinuate that the needs of the corporation are more important than the needs of the human.

[I think we're basically in agreement, just expanding on my point]

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by TeMPOraL on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @11:19AM (#14042729)
In this particular case I'd say the company behaved very badly. But in general, about "firing customers" in B2C - when you work for customer service for anything mass-market-facing, you quickly learn that among all your customers, there are some that are just utter idiots, there are some who are entitled assholes, and then there are those who want to defraud you. This is a fact of life. Such "problem people" are a big drain on both the company and (implicitly) on the regular customers. Cutting business off with those people is a win for company and customers alike.
Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by LunaSea on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @09:40AM (#14041986)
> It doesn't imply that the customer didn't get what they paid for.

Euh that's exactly what's happening here. If the company bricks the product you bought it's a net loss. So you're definitely not getting what you paid for. The analogy would work only if you decided to do before anything was bought (impossible of course) or refund them 100%.

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by jerf on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @09:54AM (#14042073)
If you decide to make it impossible to "fire" customers, what does that translate in terms of who has what obligations?

Is that really desirable, once you think about it that way?

And do you really think this is some sort of "Late Capitalism nightmare"? You really think nobody had ever decided not to do business with a specific customer before?

This isn't a "late capitalism" issue; this is a "social media greatly amplifies previously quiet signals, and does so with a certain amount of randomness". But the reality probably hasn't changed... just your ability to detect it.

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by s_kilk on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @10:39AM (#14042381)
> If you decide to make it impossible to "fire" customers, what does that translate in terms of who has what obligations?

Are you actually defending the practice of a company damaging or destroying private property, remotely, in retribution for a bad review?

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by jerf on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @11:08AM (#14042620)
No, I'm not. I'm following the context of this conversation, in which we've moved to the general topic of whether you can "fire" a customer.

Try re-reading in that context and thinking about it again.

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by tyingq on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @08:09AM (#14041450)
Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by salesguy222 on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @07:12AM (#14041211)
Reminds me of the Jerky Boys prank phone call where the guy calls a pizza place and said their pizza gave his family food poisoning

The pizza place offered them free coupons to try to fix the situation! haha

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by M_Grey on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @09:12AM (#14041810)
If you even think in terms of "firing" B2C customers, you will eventually fail. "The customer is always right" isn't some kind of service-minded epithet with goodness and wholesomeness in mind, no; it's a loud warning! The customer can make or break you, can cause you to spend disproportionate resources to undo what they can do to you. The customer can, with a Yelp or Tripadvisor review, a lawsuit or a blog post, undermine your entire carefully marketed existence.

If you seriously put your pride on a pedestal next to all of that, you just shouldn't be dealing with B2C in the first place; you will be a menace to your organization.

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by tyingq on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @09:40AM (#14041983)
This particular case isn't a great example because the customer posted one rude comment in a forum. I'm ignoring the bad review, since that's not good reasoning to part ways. Basically this customer hadn't yet crossed a line that would irk me.

However, to me, there is a line. "The customer is always right" can't be literal.

I have no issue parting ways, with a full refund, for toxic customers that repeatedly use abusive language with my employees. Especially when it's not relative to the situation. These kind of customers do exist. It's not common, but do e-commerce long enough and you'll run into one.

There are also (not often) customers that engage in return fraud or other activity that is just obvious cause to avoid them in the future.

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by M_Grey on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @10:15AM (#14042220)
I mean... yeah obviously, but your examples of toxic behavior and fraud are about as far from the case in question as possible, except insofar as they apply to the guy who bricked the door opener. I'm not suggesting that businesses tolerate abuse or fraud, but this is far from either.
Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by zobzu on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @10:26AM (#14042278)
"fuck this product" is also not abuse. its not even personal.

people put the slightest emotions they get on a pedestal as a valid reason to do and justify anything.

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by tyingq on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @10:54AM (#14042496)
No it's not abuse. But it is an opening line that might hint the possibility of a customer that's just never going to be happy. And my suggested recourse would be to refund them immediately once you recognize that's the case.
Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by M_Grey on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @11:46AM (#14042948)
"An opening line that might hint the possibility..." I'm sorry, but at some point you're just expecting the worst possible outcome from a relatively banal situation. Your role in that context would be show an interest and defuse the situation, and only after that failed to have an effect should you start to be concerned that this is a toxic case.

If you approach everyone who so much as barks like they're a mad dog, you'll end up meeting a shocking number "mad dogs".

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by tyingq on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @12:13PM (#14043155)
Okay. It's a rude opener. I'll admit to that biasing my view. Starting a conversation with "your product is shit" sets a certain tone.

You're likely to get better service from me if you're polite. I don't feel badly about that.

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by M_Grey on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @12:30PM (#14043305)
You'll never get anything from me except polite interactions in that arena, and at least in part for just that reason. The problem is that in any B2C you'll have a range of people, a Normal Distribution, and that includes a fair number of angry, entitled, rude, dicks. Plenty of them can be safely, and easily defused; and the truth is that a lot of people "come in hot" especially online.

I respect your position, I do, and I wish it were the standard, but realistically it puts you at a potential disadvantage.

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by sobani on Thursday April 06, 2017 @03:32AM (#14048646)
I just got fired. It's raining and close to freezing. The weather caused the worst traffic jam in months. It's 8 PM when I finally arrive home so I'm hungry. And now this app, which is nothing more than a single button, refuses to start.

"Fuck this product."

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by zobzu on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @07:20PM (#14143962)
Correct use of the sentence
Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by tyingq on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @10:25AM (#14042271)
Well, his opening remark on the forum ended in "wondering what kind of piece of shit I just purchased here.."

That appears to be before any contact with anyone at all.

That, alone, doesn't cross a line. But it is a clue that the interaction might quickly lead down a path where you choose to part ways.

I'd have been initially polite, helpful, try to fix the issue, etc. But there would be some line where I'd stop.

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by M_Grey on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @10:36AM (#14042363)
Impolite and "toxic customer"/"Thief" are worlds apart. If you can't deal with a broad selection of the average public, don't sell to them. It's really that simple, and the business world selects heavily against people who think that their product or their fiefdom is excepted form that rule.
Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by tyingq on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @10:51AM (#14042465)
I can see that viewpoint but there are successful businesses that draw the line in a different place than you do.
Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by M_Grey on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @11:03AM (#14042575)
It's not about the lines that I draw or that anyone draws, it's about the fundamental power asymmetry in customer-business relationships. Obviously a bar or a B&B have to consider the whole pool of customers, but if you're in the business of selling someone an IoT garage door opener...
Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by tyingq on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @12:22PM (#14043229)
I admit that others view it differently. But I'm not apologetic about the idea that a business can choose how much rude behavior to tolerate. Especially if I'm willing to refund without return of the product.
Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by trmsw on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @12:59PM (#14043557)
Calling a thing a "piece of shit" and leaving a critical review isn't rude behaviour. This isn't tea time at Buckingham Palace.
Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by tyingq on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @02:07PM (#14044196)
Your call, I suppose it's subjective. But I personally consider it to be rude. Would it be an appropriate support response to suggest that maybe their phone is a piece of shit?
Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by trmsw on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @03:34PM (#14044867)
It's only rude if you believe that the customer has to respect the hard work and good intentions that went into the product, and make allowances if it doesn't "just work". They don't.
Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by tyingq on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @04:25PM (#14045296)
Similarly, I don't have to make allowances for people that can't manage basic civility. I wouldn't send back food with a "this is shit" comment at a restaurant. Even a fast food place. Because I'm interacting with a human being, and see no reason to be a jerk. As a side bonus, "sorry, this tastes bad, could I get something else?" has a higher likelihood of resolving the problem.
Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by TeMPOraL on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @11:23AM (#14042762)
Counterexamples: Telcos. Banks. Grocery stores.

There's very little a customer can do to meaningfully impact either of them. Hell, the companies can be (and regularly are) shitty to someone personally, and they still will use their services.

EDIT: more counterexamples - Comodo. Lenovo. Uber. AirBnB. They were all involved in huge Internet shitstorms about anti-customer behaviours, and they don't look like they've lost anything through it. I've seen enough shitstorms - small and big, local and global - to learn that they generally don't mean a thing, and most people forget about them in a week.

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by M_Grey on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @11:40AM (#14042898)
The most notorious monopolies of our time. The things which bring down our economy with their shenanigans every so often because they so thoroughly own the political and legislative process. Huh?

Grocery Stores? I don't see how that applies... they tend to be highly customer-focused, and they certainly don't do the equivalent of bricking a product after selling it to you because they didn't like your tone.

Still I take your point... if you're a Unicorn then you play by different rules, until/unless it all catches up with you (as it is with Uber). If however, you're not a telecom monopoly, a giant bank, or just crazy like Uber (if for example you're trying to sell IoT fricking door openers) then you are in a very very different position don't you think?!

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by TeMPOraL on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @12:04PM (#14043094)
Again, yes and no. I know a few local on-line retailers that handle their own faulty services like so:

- bribe the customers leaving negative reviews into cancelling them, by offering e.g. free products

- use multiple accounts on the marketplace services, kill off an account after it got too many negative reviews and create a new one to continue

The point being, "customer is always right" is not something that works for all B2C; depending on your market type, there may be strategies that let you be pretty much immune from the effects of a wronged customer seeking revenge. For instance, commodity items are bought by people who are mostly price-sensitive; as long as you keep a lower price, even angry reviews won't mean much. This works well for brick-and-mortar grocery stores (and other inherently local stores) and for business that sell through on-line marketplaces like eBay. It's sometimes even beneficial to not have a strong social media presence - Facebook pages and Twitter accounts are a good place for angry customers to vent off and spread the bad word about you.

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by M_Grey on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @12:22PM (#14043218)
...Right, and the opposite of all of the positive ways to deal with it, would be bricking the device you sold to a customer, as in this case. We're not even talking about a bad review, just a forum post. While I grant your point about commodities, you can't be further from such a thing than an IoT garage door remote.

Basically, this is a business in which you need to desperately convince the customer to want an ongoing relationship with you, for a service they could get with a $5 remote, 9volt included.

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by TeMPOraL on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @12:35PM (#14043348)
I'm in no way defending this particular company here; I was responding to the issue of "customer is always right" wrt. B2C business.

The company here behaved wrong and they deserve whatever loss of business comes out of this mess, regardless of how rude the customer was. They handled it badly. That said, I have no particular love for IoT companies - I find the idea of those cloud-connected devices to be dumb from both user and engineering point of view. To be clear - I'm not opposed to smart devices per se - just those which require vendor's cloud, which makes them basically hardware-as-a-service, and which works against privacy and interoperability.

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by gambiting on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @04:04AM (#14040530)
I think the reaction would have been completely different if the reply was along the lines of "We're sorry to hear that your device does not work. We are issuing a refund immediately to your account - please keep in mind that since the refund was issued, your device won't be able to connect to our network any more. Have a pleasant day, and sorry for the inconvenience".

It would have achieved the exact same result, and I am sure the backlash wouldn't be 10% as severe.

Re:IoT garage door opener maker disables customer’s service ... by tyingq on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @08:05AM (#14041436)
Separating the public and private message might have helped out a bit as well.

In this case, I would have tried to help online (in the forum) at least once, despite the rude forum post. If it kept up, I'd have emailed the "we need to part ways, here's a refund" note.