There are no alternatives until we have an open baseband.
Every objection you state in your comment about android (and iOS) is dwarfed by the objections you would have if you truly understood the two other general purpose computers inside your phone that you have no control over - namely, your baseband processor and your SIM card.
Your carrier owns you. Your carrier owns you more deeply than any spyware author ever dreamed of owning you.
Your carrier can upload and run arbitrary java applets onto your SIM card without you ever knowing. Your carrier, depending on which SOC you have and how it is implemented, can access your CPU and memory directly. As in, read the passphrase of your cutesy encrypted chat app as you key it in.
We cannot begin to speak of a secure mobile platform or any kind of open source mobile platform until we have an open baseband and control our own SIM cards. We are very, very far away from this.
In the meantime, you have two choices:
1. treat your mobile device as fully compromised and behave accordingly. This is what I do.
2. Buy a non-cellular mobile device (for instance, the old "samsung galaxy player" devices that have no mobile chipset or SIM card) and insert a cellular modem into the USB port and segregate that function there, and use VOIP software. This actually sounds sort-of workable except for one interesting problem - in addition to handling cellular communications, the baseband also handles voice quality like noise cancellation and so on that also needs to be done in real-time and not interrupted by userland events ... and so your actual voice quality will drop as a result of using VOIP on a handset.
Like how many people with legitimate concerns about baseband tampering can safely carry a dumb phone?
For Qualcomm at least, they share a lot of code with Android, and nearly all the code is fully closed source, even to Apple engineers building the phone above.
Note that code does everything from camera autofocus to doing NAT for tethering, to audio decoding while the CPU is sleeping, to setting up the GPU, to handling supercomplex GSM protocols, to determining USB charging current and serial debug interfaces. It is probably more complex than the whole of the rest of the OS.
Looking at the quality of open source code from Qualcomm, I have nearly zero confidence in the security of that baseband. I'm confident you could find an "accidentally" open debug interface within a few days of looking.
So Android is "open source" even though most of what makes Android Android to most users -- Google Play Services and all of the Google apps and third party OEM apps are closed.
But iOS is closed source even though parts of it are also open source?
Android will run ( and performs all the expected smartphone functions ) using only open-source.
iOS won't boot using only open-source.
I'm not a fan of Android in general but reluctantly continue using it with that distinction as consolation.
iOS has the high ground between the two, but neither are anywhere close to acceptable.
If CopperheadOS is installed the only attack vector Verizon could use is the SIM Card, but CopperheadOS implements a lot of security features that could help mitigate the risk:
* Full verified boot, covering all firmware and OS partitions.
* Baseline app isolation via unique uid/gid pairs for each app.
* App permission model including the ability to revoke permissions and supply fake data.
Carriers can not install software on phones connected to the network. Assuming they installed a Carrier configuration application or anything else using the SIM Card you could revoke its permissions or supply fake data, or even create firewall rules to disallow the traffic manually.
More security features:
I don't think we will ever solve that problem without more support for projects like CopperheadOS and ReplicantOS. They are struggling to even maintain and improve just a couple devices.
374 points, 441 days ago, 118 comments. Note the discussion about baseband.
https://www.silentcircle.com/products-and-solutions/devices/
Take something like that - but use a RasPi Zero W - add on a better touchscreen (plenty of options there).
The Arduino version used a 3G module - but if you are willing to fork out the money, you can find 4G modules out there (they aren't cheap, though).
Then all you have to do as the code magic, a 3d printed case, etc...
You'll still need a cell service provider, of course - no real way to get around that, unless you wanted to set up some kind of wifi auto-hacking system to scrounge off of insecure (and other free) wifi nodes (coverage would be spotty, of course).
Two problems remaining why this won't happen:
a) Baseband (which in some cases has direct access to the microphone, or worse, DMA link to the CPU, or even worse, integrated into the SoC) firmware
b) Linux kernel. So many manufacturers either blatantly ignore the GPL by not releasing kernel source code, and nearly all of them, instead of cooperating with upstream, fork the kernels and add literal crap on their trees. The horrors I have seen, especially in leaked Mediatek source trees... unimaginable. I can certainly understand why Mediatek does not want to release kernel sources.
Also this is the biggest threat to the Android ecosystem. Either some kernel contributor sues Mediatek and other shoddy OEM/ODMs for enough money that they go down (unlikely), or the kernel forks by manufacturers will go so hard out of sync that new userlands of Android will simply not work with fossilized kernels. Same as in the embedded-Linux world...
I believe a lot of manufacturers operate by "lets either not release code at all or code so shoddy no one else wants to release anything based on it", and thus holding privacy, security and competition hostage. Especially as competition is stuff like cyanogenmod which removes all the nasty tracking/adware whose data sales the OEMs intend to monetize...
Have there been other carriers pushing such spyware out to Android phones in in addition to Verizon?
And please don't say iOS. It's closed source, which means we really don't know what's going on under the hood. We may trust it today, but one secret court order + an overnight update is all we need to lose everything with iOS. Apple execs may not even be made aware of such an update if the order was delivered to the engineers directly.
What are my options such that I'll actually feel comfortable when I sleep at night? My phone knows everything. All my emails (which can typically be used to get into everything else), all my contacts, all my calendar events, where I go every day, and I'm even paranoid that it records all of my conversations. This isn't schizophrenia, we know that devices record people's conversations without their knowledge. A phone doing the same is just one step away.
So what can I do? How can I get some sanity and security around my mobile life?
Would be a great step to have a phone that:
+ Fully open source. (Sorry Android you don't count) + Hardware switch for mic + Hardware switch for location services
Or at least a phone that is beginning to move in that direction? Should I just stop using my phone?