Re:Verizon announces plans to install a download-tracking ap...
by mschuster91 on Friday March 31, 2017 @12:37PM
(#14005492)
> Would be a great step to have a phone that: Fully open source.
Two problems remaining why this won't happen:
a) Baseband (which in some cases has direct access to the microphone, or worse, DMA link to the CPU, or even worse, integrated into the SoC) firmware
b) Linux kernel. So many manufacturers either blatantly ignore the GPL by not releasing kernel source code, and nearly all of them, instead of cooperating with upstream, fork the kernels and add literal crap on their trees. The horrors I have seen, especially in leaked Mediatek source trees... unimaginable. I can certainly understand why Mediatek does not want to release kernel sources.
Also this is the biggest threat to the Android ecosystem. Either some kernel contributor sues Mediatek and other shoddy OEM/ODMs for enough money that they go down (unlikely), or the kernel forks by manufacturers will go so hard out of sync that new userlands of Android will simply not work with fossilized kernels. Same as in the embedded-Linux world...
I believe a lot of manufacturers operate by "lets either not release code at all or code so shoddy no one else wants to release anything based on it", and thus holding privacy, security and competition hostage. Especially as competition is stuff like cyanogenmod which removes all the nasty tracking/adware whose data sales the OEMs intend to monetize...
Two problems remaining why this won't happen:
a) Baseband (which in some cases has direct access to the microphone, or worse, DMA link to the CPU, or even worse, integrated into the SoC) firmware
b) Linux kernel. So many manufacturers either blatantly ignore the GPL by not releasing kernel source code, and nearly all of them, instead of cooperating with upstream, fork the kernels and add literal crap on their trees. The horrors I have seen, especially in leaked Mediatek source trees... unimaginable. I can certainly understand why Mediatek does not want to release kernel sources.
Also this is the biggest threat to the Android ecosystem. Either some kernel contributor sues Mediatek and other shoddy OEM/ODMs for enough money that they go down (unlikely), or the kernel forks by manufacturers will go so hard out of sync that new userlands of Android will simply not work with fossilized kernels. Same as in the embedded-Linux world...
I believe a lot of manufacturers operate by "lets either not release code at all or code so shoddy no one else wants to release anything based on it", and thus holding privacy, security and competition hostage. Especially as competition is stuff like cyanogenmod which removes all the nasty tracking/adware whose data sales the OEMs intend to monetize...