News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Steve Jobs On Android by CitizenKane on Tuesday June 01, 2010 @11:25PM (#1396942)
Steve Jobs says Apple "created" WebKit. That wording makes it sounds like it started from nothing. But it didn't, WebKit was forked from the KHTML project in 2002 and later diverged (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Webkit#Origins). One might say WebKit evolved out of KHTML.
Re:Steve Jobs On Android by jrockway on Tuesday June 01, 2010 @11:45PM (#1396994)
And it was like pulling teeth to get Apple to contribute their changes back. For a while, IIRC, they claimed bug reports were proprietary information, and they refused to provide them back to the KHTML team. And that was before Apple was evil!
Re:Steve Jobs On Android by kragen on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @12:05AM (#1397038)
Wasn't that still after Apple sued Real Networks for making it possible to put RealAudio stuff onto iPods, in 2005, and called hackers unethical?

Real: "Our Harmony technology enables consumers to securely transfer purchased music to digital music devices, including...iPod..."

Apple: "We are stunned that RealNetworks has adopted the tactics and ethics of a hacker to break into the iPod, and we are investigating the implications of their actions under the DMCA and other laws."

To me, that was the day Apple turned evil.

Re:Steve Jobs On Android by benatkin on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @12:21AM (#1397071)
No, Webkit's been around for longer than that.

> The name and project 'WebKit' were created in 2002 when Apple Inc. created a fork of KHTML and KJS.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WebKit#Origins

Re:Steve Jobs On Android by jrockway on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @12:20AM (#1397068)
For me, it was PT_DENY_ATTACH.
Re:Steve Jobs On Android by tumult on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @12:21AM (#1397070)
Maybe you're forgetting some history. When Apple announced Safari, people said it was completely stupid to not choose the Gecko engine. People said that the KHTML engine was totally immature and progressing slowly. Why on earth would you pick KHTML over Gecko?

After a fairly huge amount of work on the part of WebKit contributors, you can see that Apple's move was both not stupid and also generous. WebKit development rapidly outstripped every other engine, and it's still on the leading edge today. It's open source software, with a mostly BSD license.

Re:Steve Jobs On Android by jbellis on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @01:10AM (#1397169)
> people said it was completely stupid to not choose the Gecko engine

That's not how I remember the reaction of the (few) people familiar with both KHTML and Gecko.

Re:Steve Jobs On Android by pablasso on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @01:17AM (#1397181)
it would be more helpful if you tell us how you remember it
Re:Steve Jobs On Android by psadauskas on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @01:42AM (#1397224)
Not the OP, but from what I remember:

* Gecko code was a mess and difficult to separate, integrate. KHTML was cleaner, and already intended to be pluggable, just missing some edge-case features. * KDE/KHTML devs had to fight to get Webkit's source opened, and when they finally did, all they got was code dumps that were impossible to integrate back into KHTML

It's gotten a lot better, and Apple's Webkit devs have become much more open, but from what I understand, it was a huge ordeal to get them to abide by KHTML's GPL.

Re:Steve Jobs On Android by tumult on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @02:01AM (#1397247)
WebCore (the actual rendering fundamentals itself) was open source before WebKit (the bigger chunk of code that makes up more of a browser's features). When code was released back to KHTML, it came in big chunks with large changes because WebKit development was being taken in a different direction and at a much higher speed than KHTML. Therefore backporting was extremely difficult, and it seems like the WebKit people were not too eager to spend time documenting all of their changes back against existing KHTML code, so they just dumped out big patches and diffs without much commenting.

Some features were backported, but you can see today that WebKit is farther ahead than the KHTML fork, and receives a lot more attention.

Re:Steve Jobs On Android by philwelch on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @03:18AM (#1397352)
People criticized Apple for being bad open source contributors, but I don't blame them for choosing to fork over contributing to a project they didn't control. I always thought the "right to fork" was sacred.
Re:Steve Jobs On Android by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @02:06AM (#1397265)
I remember the general consensus being that Gecko, while more functional was convoluted and hard to work with, while KHTML was a cleaner base to work from, but needed work to better deal with the ugly realities of the web.

If it was as crappy as suggested then you'd have to ask why Apple would have picked up a LGPL project rather than start from scratch.

I also remember them being less than great open source collaborators at first.

Re:Steve Jobs On Android by Legion on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @01:26AM (#1397198)
>> Steve Jobs says Apple "created" WebKit. That wording makes it sounds like it started from nothing.

That wording is also more TechCrunch's than Steve's.

Steve's words:

> Well Chrome is not... you know. And it's based on webkit, work we did at Apple.

> Almost every modern browser is based on webkit... Nokia, Palm, Android, RIM has one... and of course ours.

> We've created a real competitor to IE. In the mobile space it's #1.

(link: http://www.engadget.com/2010/06/01/steve-jobs-live-from-d8/)

While that still takes more credit than I'd care to see, "work we did at Apple" definitely is a softer statement than "Apple 'created' WebKit". Even though the word "created" does come up a couple of sentences later...

Re:Steve Jobs On Android by dieterrams on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @03:41AM (#1397376)
After watching some of the video footage, I noticed that Engadget's transcription is often highly paraphrased. So I transcribed directly from one of the D8 videos:

  Steve: We took a tiny little open source project, and we
  created what's called "WebKit" out there, and we did an
  interesting thing for Apple: we put it in open source.
So it turns out that he did say they "created" WebKit, but he also points out that it was created using an existing open source project.

Turns out this thread was a lot of hubbub over nothing, as I suspected. Unless someone wants to gripe about KHTML being described as "tiny little".

Re:Steve Jobs On Android by nailer on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @05:29AM (#1397495)
> and we created what's called "WebKit" out there, and we did an interesting thing for Apple: we put it in open source.

He's acting like Apple had a choice about the licensing of someone else's work.

Re:Steve Jobs On Android by dieterrams on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @05:40AM (#1397514)
When you choose to build off a LGPLed project, you are choosing to open source the work you put into it. They could have easily chosen not to build off a LGPLed project.

Stop fishing for perceived slights. This is petty, and a waste of the internet.

Re:Steve Jobs On Android by nailer on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @08:24AM (#1397718)
When you chose to use an OSS project, you choose to follow the license, sure.

But what Jobs said - 'we put it in open source' - implies that it KHTML wasn't already OSS.

Re:Steve Jobs On Android by dieterrams on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @09:08AM (#1397788)
Dear god, did you completely fail to read the first part of the quote? How can he imply that KHTML wasn't already open source when he specifically refers to it as open source?

The "interesting thing for Apple" is that they chose to put their efforts into an open source project in the first place. Apple, the company that likes to control its software as much as possible. This is all he's saying. Don't read anything more into it than that.

Re:Steve Jobs On Android by nailer on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @09:29AM (#1397840)
Yes I did. The full quote is:

> Steve: We took a tiny little open source project, and we created what's called "WebKit" out there, and we did an interesting thing for Apple: we put it in open source.

which doesn't serve any value beyond simply saying:

"We took a tiny little open source project, and worked on it."

Steve adding 'we created what's called "WebKit" out there, and we did an interesting thing for Apple: we put it in open source' makes no sense - it's either:

- redundant (KHTML was already LGPLed, so obviously Apple's patches would be)

- implying Webkit was something 'created' by Apple that Apple had choice over their licensing with.

To me it seems the latter, which is somewhat disingenuous. You obviously disagree. Invoking spiritual beings is unnecessary.

Re:Steve Jobs On Android by dieterrams on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @10:24AM (#1397998)
I refer you to my previous comment: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1397514

Let me break it down a bit further. WebKit is an Apple-initiated project. It is the web counterpart to Apple's native UIKit framework. If they wanted to, they could have made WebKit closed source, eschewing the use of KHTML entirely. They were in no way obligated to use KHTML as a starting point. And for a company like Apple, you can be sure the decision to tie themselves to the LGPL was not undertaken lightly.

In choosing to use the LGPLed KHTML project as the basis for WebKit, they chose to put WebKit in open source. They did exactly what Steve Jobs said they did, no disingenuity required.

Sure, maybe he could have ordered his phrases more clearly, but he's speaking off the cuff here.

Re:Steve Jobs On Android by nailer on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @10:49AM (#1398084)
> If they wanted to, they could have made WebKit closed source, eschewing the use of KHTML entirely.

Yes, I understand what you're saying - Apple made a choice about what product to use and was aware of the licensing implications.

Apple got to make one choice: use KHTML or something else. As soon as they chose KHTML, the choice of licensing was made for them. Saying 'we open sourced it' implies Apple made the choice to open source it. They did not. They were obligated to by the fact the people who made the code licensed it that way.

Linksys got to make one choice: use Linux or something else. As soon as they chose Linux, the choice was made for them.

Job's already mentioned that Apple chose to use an OSS app. Saying they 'chose the licensing for it' is wrong: they didn't, someone in the KDE project made that decision. Apple abided by the rules, they didn't create them.

Re:Steve Jobs On Android by dieterrams on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @11:30AM (#1398200)
Let me try this again.

Let's say we form a company to develop a web layout engine. We haven't made anything yet, and we're wondering if it would be better to make our layout engine closed source or open. We decide to go with open. Why? Because we're fed up with having to support slow, non-standards-compliant browsers for our web apps. If our fast, standards-compliant layout engine is open source, maybe more browsers will use it, and web development will be less sucky for us in the future.

It turns out that there's already some great open source code called KHTML that we can build on to create our engine, and it's licensed with the LGPL. Well, that's no problem, because we decided our layout engine was going to be open source anyway. So why not fork it? We don't have to, but it's good code, so we might as well. Thus, our open source layout engine ends up being based on KHTML. But it was not our decision to use KHTML that made our engine open source. We decided that it was going to be open source, irrespective of whether we decided to use KHTML.

Likewise, Apple chose whether or not WebKit would be open source, irrespective of whether they decided to use KHTML.

You seem to be making the argument that Apple just decided to base WebKit on KHTML without much concern for the licensing implications, and inadvertently ended up "stuck" with a WebKit that must adhere to the LGPL. Hence, Steve Jobs is disingenuously suggesting that WebKit was intentionally open source. And what I'm saying is, given Apple's long history of tight control over its software, not to mention their willingness to rewrite their software from scratch, that assumption just isn't credible. Whereas they have credible, self-interested motives for creating an open source layout engine, just like Google has credible self-interested motives for making Android open source.

Re:Steve Jobs On Android by nailer on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @11:47AM (#1398261)
> You seem to be making the argument that Apple just decided to base WebKit on KHTML without much concern for the licensing implications

No.

I'm saying 'we used something OSS! Then we decided to make it OSS!' is either nonsensical or misleading.

Re:Steve Jobs On Android by dieterrams on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @11:53AM (#1398281)
Well, I tried my best.
Re:Steve Jobs On Android by nailer on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @11:55AM (#1398290)
I didn't think it was that hard to understand. Do you get what I'm saying now?
Re:Steve Jobs On Android by dieterrams on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @12:00PM (#1398305)
I've always gotten what you've been saying. You seem to be completely incapable of getting what I'm saying. And I'm certain you have to ability to get what I'm saying, but I think you just really, really don't want to. Or you're trolling. Not really sure at this point.
Re:Steve Jobs On Android by nailer on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @01:18PM (#1398626)
>>> You seem to be making the argument that Apple just decided to base WebKit on KHTML without much concern for the licensing implications

>I've always gotten what you've been saying.

Clearly you haven't.

OTOH, if you think I've misunderstood or mischaracterized anything you've said, you haven't said so.

Anyway, I give up.

Re:Steve Jobs On Android by gizmomagico on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @03:05PM (#1399002)
You're saying Apple decided to open source WebKit before deciding what to base it on.

He's saying that because KHTML's LGPL was going to force them to open source WebKit in any case, it's either nonsensical or misleading for Steve to say that Apple "put it into open source".

I didn't remember that LGPL wasn't commercially "safe".

Re:Steve Jobs On Android by tel on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @02:02AM (#1397249)
"... created a real competitor..."

Which I'd have to give to them completely. KHTML wasn't going to compete with IE on its own.

Re:Steve Jobs On Android by sireat on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @02:42AM (#1397311)
"work we did at Apple" is the politicians way of saying that they created it. Compare it to the infamous "I took the initiative in creating ..."

To nitpickers like us, they can say that they did not create it, but to a regular reader/listener it sounds like they did.

Re:Steve Jobs On Android by rodh257 on Tuesday June 01, 2010 @11:46PM (#1396995)
I don't know much about the project itself, but wouldn't web-kit have received contributions from outside of Apple aswell? (perhaps only since 2005 when it was open sourced though)