* Gecko code was a mess and difficult to separate, integrate. KHTML was cleaner, and already intended to be pluggable, just missing some edge-case features. * KDE/KHTML devs had to fight to get Webkit's source opened, and when they finally did, all they got was code dumps that were impossible to integrate back into KHTML
It's gotten a lot better, and Apple's Webkit devs have become much more open, but from what I understand, it was a huge ordeal to get them to abide by KHTML's GPL.
Some features were backported, but you can see today that WebKit is farther ahead than the KHTML fork, and receives a lot more attention.
If it was as crappy as suggested then you'd have to ask why Apple would have picked up a LGPL project rather than start from scratch.
I also remember them being less than great open source collaborators at first.