News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by snackai on Saturday March 25, 2017 @07:18AM (#13955058)
When I see a nice Headline on HN: "Oh cool, I would love to read that", then I look at the domain: "Oh it's on medium. Never mind then." I'd never pay for that shit show.
Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by fhoffa on Saturday March 25, 2017 @08:06AM (#13955207)
Facts: Hacker News gets a ton of articles posted from Medium, but very few of them get to the front page. Last time I measured there had been 4,108 posts from medium.com in 2017 (largest source of news for HN), but less than 3% of them got some upvote traction.

So you seem to be sharing a similar sentiment towards Medium than the rest of the HN readers.

(Even posting tweets to HN gets them double the attention than a random Medium post)

https://medium.com/@hoffa/hacker-news-on-bigquery-now-with-d...

Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by lathiat on Saturday March 25, 2017 @09:08AM (#13955436)
i've noticed people seem to use medium but hosted on their own domain?

i suspect probably quite a few more front pages if you include that.

Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by user5994461 on Saturday March 25, 2017 @08:39AM (#13955326)
Can you compare to the stats for wordpress?
Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by brianwawok on Saturday March 25, 2017 @08:52AM (#13955386)
Can't get that out of the URLs, would need to actually crawl the stories.
Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by user5994461 on Saturday March 25, 2017 @02:24PM (#13956895)
They can both be redirecting to a custom domain.

Actually, I think that if you accounted only for the blog on medium.com you are ignoring all the medium blogs on custom domains, which probably have better content than the average.

Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by eloisant on Saturday March 25, 2017 @07:33AM (#13955104)
It's a blogging platform. Why posts hosted there should be any less interesting than posts hosted on any other platform?
Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by hdra on Saturday March 25, 2017 @07:44AM (#13955139)
While I don't feel as strongly about Medium as the parent comment, I'm also less inclined to read an article when it is posted on Medium. No real reason, really, just a personal bias from myself because I'm finding a lot of "thought-leader-pieces" articles over there, and technical content over there are not as well formatted as the ones on someone's personal blog that are well designed for code snippets and such in the article.

I still read Medium articles when I came across articles written by people whose work I'm somewhat familiar with though.

Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by sverige on Saturday March 25, 2017 @08:15AM (#13955249)
> it has become the go-to site for tech musings written by unpaid people who can't be bothered to set up their own blogs.

This is it for me. If you want to write about tech, or the tech scene, and especially web tech, why can't you just build a site? I've built a few and I don't even do web development for a living so I had to teach myself some stuff.

Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by user5994461 on Saturday March 25, 2017 @08:38AM (#13955321)
Because it is difficult, a lot of work and potentially very expensive (when you have traffic) to build your own.

If you are in tech, you should understand to use the right tool for the job.

Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by hdra on Saturday March 25, 2017 @09:14AM (#13955453)
I agree. I don't think they should write a custom website to host their articles. I'm perfectly happy reading Ghost or WordPress.com articles as long as the site is well designed to fit the content.

While Medium is a very beautiful, well designed site, it doesn't work equally well for every kind of content out there. Technical content with code snippets are one of the least-suitable type of content for Medium.com design.

No matter how much thought is put into the design of the site, Medium's design is still designed to be a one-size-fit-all kind of product, and well, that means no matter how high quality their design is, it is still taking a somewhat "highest-common-denominator" approach to the design.

Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by sverige on Saturday March 25, 2017 @08:48AM (#13955364)
I'm not saying you have to build a server to host your blog. You can host it on AWS or elsewhere if you get a lot of traffic. It's not that hard to get a domain name, host it somewhere, and write some HTML code.

Yes, it could be difficult and a lot of work if you think you need embedded videos that autoplay and follow readers as they scroll down trying to escape that and the pop up pestering them to subscribe.

Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by user5994461 on Saturday March 25, 2017 @08:57AM (#13955405)
Hosting it somewhere on your own will not give you good analytics, a good clean theme, and a CDN. A wordpress does. You're going for a ton of extra work.

AWS is madness for personal projects. You don't seem to realize how bad you're about to be bankrupt when an article hit the front HN page. If you have a high quality picture, a gif or a video, it's game over.

Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by Turing_Machine on Saturday March 25, 2017 @10:43AM (#13955885)
"You don't seem to realize how bad you're about to be bankrupt when an article hit the front HN page."

I've had a couple of AWS-hosted pages make it to the HN front page.

I don't recall my S3 bill going up to any significant degree, much less bankrupting me.

S3 bandwidth is $0.023/GB at the most expensive tier. It's hard to imagine bankruptcy resulting from any text-oriented site, even if it does hit the HN home page. Maybe if you're hosting hours of HD video or something.

Also, I've never had any trouble using CDNs from an S3 page. Details?

Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by user5994461 on Saturday March 25, 2017 @02:54PM (#13956999)
Bandwidth is $0.090 per GB. (You mixed it up with the storage price that is $0.023/GB).

Let's say the site is 1MB to deliver. That's nothing fancy, lots of text, css, logos, headers.

For 100k viewers, that's about 100GB of traffic, or $9 dollars.

How do you bankrupt yourself with your blog from there: By multiplying it.

1) You've got more than this single article => triple it.

2) You've got medias (picture/gif/video) that take 3MB => quadruple it.

3) My traffic stats don't account for bots/crawler => You're at the mercy of them or any dude who "ab -n 1000000 yoursite.com/logo.png"

A bill of hundreds of dollars for a personal blog might not scare a HN silicon valley engineer making $15k a month but that's much more than enough for the rest of the world. Even in western Europe, don't expect the disposable income to be much more than $100 a month.

Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by Turing_Machine on Saturday March 25, 2017 @10:34PM (#13958755)
"Bandwidth is $0.090 per GB. (You mixed it up with the storage price that is $0.023/GB)."

Correct, my fault there. I was somehow looking at the wrong chart.

"Let's say the site is 1MB to deliver"

I think your estimate of the size of a typical blog post is considerably at variance with the norm. 2-3K would be more like it. Maybe 100K with logo.

Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by user5994461 on Saturday March 25, 2017 @11:08PM (#13958878)
The HTTP headers alone to do a couple of requests are more than 4kB.

The text alone of an article can easily be more than 10kB (that's about 1500 words).

3k might have been correct in 1997 for a single standalone HTML page with only text, very little text actually, and very little formatting.

100k is doable for a very minimal site.

Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by Turing_Machine on Sunday March 26, 2017 @08:16PM (#13964196)
1500 words is much longer than the norm for a blog post. The standard length for classic newspaper columns (in the U.S.) was 700-750 words, and most bloggers don't write posts anywhere near the length of a newspaper column.

By the way, are we talking about normal blog posts or are we talking about "sites"? What is a "site"? Wikipedia is a site. So is a page with nothing but "Hello, world" on it.

Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by user5994461 on Saturday April 01, 2017 @09:37AM (#14012040)
Newpapers are short. Blogs articles are longer.

Most articles on the top of Google (outside of news) are much longer than 700 words. See there for some numbers:

https://www.snapagency.com/blog/whatll-be-the-best-length-fo...

Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by watwut on Saturday March 25, 2017 @09:49AM (#13955615)
It is harder to make said html look nice - unless you are graphics designer. But also, it requires additional time to spend which matters.
Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by muraiki on Saturday March 25, 2017 @09:44AM (#13955588)
Hosting a web site for a blog is expensive? A local webhost offers 75GB of transfer for $6 a month, with the highest transfer day per month dropped completely. If you want a CDN on top of that, it's a whopping $1 per month per 10GB.
Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by z3t4 on Saturday March 25, 2017 @08:46AM (#13955357)
you could easy have a web server with thousands of visitors running on a rasbery pi. i would say a week end project to set it up or one hour if you already are familiar with web servers.
Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by user5994461 on Saturday March 25, 2017 @09:01AM (#13955411)
Your raspbeery will be crushed to death when the article will go on the first page of HN.

You seriously overestimate the capabilities of a raspberry and undestimate the traffic you get.

Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by ttd on Saturday March 25, 2017 @09:24AM (#13955493)
I'm curious about this. If you have a purely static site, what would be the major bottleneck for a front-page-reaching site hosted on a raspberry pi? I'm thinking things like compression would eat up a lot of its CPU, but you seem to know more about this than me.
Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by mcbits on Saturday March 25, 2017 @10:05AM (#13955681)
A solid 3,000-word article with enough CSS to make the page look nice will fit comfortably in 20-30KB gzipped. A Raspberry Pi could handle on the order of tens of requests per second (tens of thousands per hour).

A fluffy 500-word Medium-style article with 1-2MB of JavaScript serving no apparent purpose and 5-10MB of animated GIFs would be another story.

Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by user5994461 on Saturday March 25, 2017 @03:14PM (#13957104)
A realistic static site will have multiple css, a logo, potential images in the headers/footers/sides, links to the other top read articles with icons, pictures/schemas/drawing/photos in the content.

That sets any stupid article at a 500kB bar.

I have no doubt that a HN engineer can publish a single .txt file and force gzip-9 compression, however that's not an acceptable blog by any standard.

Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by user5994461 on Saturday March 25, 2017 @03:02PM (#13957054)
> what would be the major bottleneck for a front-page-reaching site hosted on a raspberry pi?

For a fully static fully cachable site, it's the bandwidth.

Your home connection cannot serve Gigabytes of data in a timely fashion.

Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by jessaustin on Saturday March 25, 2017 @09:54AM (#13955638)
Can't compression be done ahead of time? ISTR it worked that way when serving content directly from S3, at one point...
Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by user5994461 on Saturday March 25, 2017 @03:24PM (#13957139)
Last I checked, compression wasn't supported by all browsers all the time. It needs to be done dynamically depending on the settings the browser allows.

nginx or varnish can do that (with more or less correct rules).

In practise, I usually disable compression everywhere and let the CDN handles it.

The CDN is configured to compress on the fly and I am very confident that CloudFlare/Akamai are doing that much better than a broken snippet of nginx settings from stack overflow.

Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by jessaustin on Sunday March 26, 2017 @10:30AM (#13960936)
As one would expect, S3 can certainly support various browsers. It ends up being just like content negotiation, in that you have multiple representations that could be served from a particular resource, depending on what headers are sent.

I'm not sure if it's still like that, since I'm not using S3 for that right now.

Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by ttd on Saturday March 25, 2017 @10:33AM (#13955830)
I'm not an expert by any means, but I think you can manually gzip your content and add rewrite rules to Apache (don't know about other servers) to use the .gz versions. I think this is the only way for compressed content to be cached by Apache, but I'd love to learn if I'm wrong here.
Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by z3t4 on Saturday March 25, 2017 @07:48PM (#13958126)
You could also reuse an old laptop, buy a proper server, rent a VPS, or buy web hosting space for a few bucks per month.
Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by z3t4 on Saturday March 25, 2017 @08:41AM (#13955338)
even worse i have seen web devs using png tables instead of html tables or svg. have publishing web content become too hard ?
Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by snackai on Saturday March 25, 2017 @07:40AM (#13955129)
For some odd reason medium attracts the worst content. All those super optimistic shallow nonsense. Urgh.
Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by bachmeier on Saturday March 25, 2017 @09:17AM (#13955467)
Yep. Although I've read a few good posts on Medium, most of the content feels like something you'd find in popular business books. The design of the site seems to discourage anything with a technical/academic/deep thinking side. I've been wanting to post there, but I don't have anything to say that would be a good fit.
Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by kowdermeister on Saturday March 25, 2017 @09:08AM (#13955435)
> some odd reason

Let me place my bet: Professional look (design, typography) + Medium brand + very little effort to publish + chance to get featured if it attracts clicks.

Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by artursapek on Saturday March 25, 2017 @10:00AM (#13955661)
It lets a lot of pretentious, self-absorbed people pretend they're being published in some high end magazine.
Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by good_vibes on Saturday March 25, 2017 @08:06AM (#13955209)
Why do you think that is? Is it something about our times, people in general, or having nothing better to say?
Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by sverige on Saturday March 25, 2017 @08:26AM (#13955282)
There's an entire subculture of fake "you can do anything" motivational stuff on the web. The purveyors are direct descendants of Tony Robbins and Dale Carnegie and whoever was selling that stuff before him.
Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by hdra on Saturday March 25, 2017 @09:22AM (#13955487)
I don't think thats necessarily true, but I also think that Medium has that kind of connotation for me.

I think the lack of branding on Medium sites has something to do with it. People ended up lumping everything as "Medium articles", from spammy "growth-hacking" articles to well-researched, well written investigative article.

Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by detaro on Saturday March 25, 2017 @09:45AM (#13955593)
> Why posts hosted there should be any less interesting than posts hosted on any other platform?

Platforms have communities that post about certain things, and less about others, and develop a reputation for doing so (and the average quality). If you post on one, your links share the reputation readers attach to it as a baseline, since readers expect it to fit in the pattern of other content they have seen on there.

Interestingly, for me Medium offering custom domains doesn't really impact this, since "people bothering to set up their own domain name" seems to be a group that's less bad in general (and exceptions get mentally tagged as such).

Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by yoodenvranx on Saturday March 25, 2017 @07:30AM (#13955092)
> then I look at the domain: "Oh it's on medium. Never mind then."

In some cases (like medium.com) HN should not only show the URL behind the link (e.g. 'medium.com') but also the user/author (e.g. 'medium.com/@randomuser').

Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by jitix on Saturday March 25, 2017 @07:25AM (#13955078)
Thats a bit hyperbolic. There are some good articles on Medium. And its just "some".
Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by M_Grey on Saturday March 25, 2017 @07:32AM (#13955097)
There are some good articles, but they exist in a sea of noise. I don't know about you, but I come to places like HN because that noise is undesirable.
Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by good_vibes on Saturday March 25, 2017 @08:05AM (#13955202)
I'm here for the same exact reason. I wonder why Medium attracts that kind of content? Why are people into reading and sharing that kind of stuff? I wonder how much of media metrics are real and meaningful vs. how much of it is forgotten a day later and meaningless after that?
Re:Medium asks $5 a month for nothing by user5994461 on Saturday March 25, 2017 @08:35AM (#13955310)
Agree. I've done the same for a year and a half.