News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by marricks on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:05PM (#13896365)
Honestly a bit disturbing to see people coming out of the wood works to defend palantir.

They've assisted NSA, and now they're using some skills to help agents look up info on undocumented immigrants.

Sure, we should be tackling the source of the problem, but enablers such as palantir should be taken to task too.

It should be considered how active a role Thiel took in getting this to happen as a Trump ally, which this in turn benefits his company.

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by pnathan on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:59PM (#13896897)
> Honestly a bit disturbing to see people coming out of the wood works to defend palantir.

It was a very sexy startup a while back. And success breeds friends.

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by muninn_ on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:09PM (#13896400)
I'm not fan of the current immigration system, but it seems like "looking up info on undocumented immigrants" is no better or worse than any other criminal database use. Being here illegally is, well, ya know, illegal. We can discuss whether or not that should be illegal or not, but it currently is. Let's not act like it isn't.
Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by op00to on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:40PM (#13896693)
Except undocumented immigration(·) is actually not a crime. You don't go to jail when you're caught by ICE. There's no criminal trial. You're sent out of the country. So, it's not really logical to apply the analogy of criminal database use.

(·) Edit: Unlawful entry (border hopping) is a crime, punishable by $250 in civil penalties, but no jail time. Essentially a jaywalking ticket. Unlawful presence is not a crime.

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by dragonwriter on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:56PM (#13896868)
> (·) Edit: Unlawful entry (border hopping) is a crime, punishable by $250 in civil penalties.

No, it's a crime punishable by imprisonment for up to 6 months and/or fine of up to $5,000 (as a class B misdemeanor) for a first offense and 2 years imprisonment and/or fine of up to $500,000 (as a felony) for a subsequent offense.

It is also a civil offense with civil penalties of $50-$250 the first time a civil penalty is imposed, and double that subsequently.

See 8 USC § 1325(a) for the crime, associated imprisonment, and reference to fines under title 18, and § 1325(b) for the civil offense; 18 USC § 3559 for classification of crimes based on maximum imprisonment, and § 3571 for fines based on classification of crimes.

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by muninn_ on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:51PM (#13896807)
Well in order to be present they had to enter unlawfully. So pretty clear that it's illegal.
Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by dragonwriter on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:02PM (#13896930)
> Well in order to be present they had to enter unlawfully

Wrong, you can be present unlawfully after completely lawful entry.

> So pretty clear that it's illegal.

Unlawful presence is obviously illegal, but it is not criminal. The two words do not mean the same thing.

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by poikniok on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:36PM (#13897252)
But you can't be present lawfully after unlawful entry, that is the point.
Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by dragonwriter on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:45PM (#13897327)
No, the claim was "in order to be present they had to enter unlawfully"; that claim is what is under discussion and it is factually untrue.

What you present is the converse of the claim under discussion. And, for that matter, is also false. A lawful permanent resident alien who enters (say, after a vacation abroad) other than at a designated border crossing is not unlawfully present, but has committed the offense of illegal entry.

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by mikeash on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:37PM (#13896662)
They're not criminals until they're found guilty in court. Imagine if the local police were able to use CIA records, including phone and location data, to prosecute you for, say stealing a car.

Entering the country without permission is illegal, but let's not act like it's a crime so heinous that law enforcement should be exempt from due process and warrants and such when prosecuting people for it.

Keep in mind that ICE does sometimes inadvertently deport US citizens, and that there is no central database of who is or is not a US citizen, nor any single canonical way to prove citizenship.

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by muninn_ on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:43PM (#13896722)
Well I mean, it seems pretty much case closed that they are criminals if they are undocumented immigrants. I'm not advocating that law enforcement should be exempt from due process, but if you're not a citizen I'm not sure what rights you're entitled to here? It's a bit messy, but it's very close to the bottom of the list of police actions I'm worried about. I'm way more concerned about things like the disproportionate amount of African Americans locked up than the due process of people who are here illegally.

Every country on the planet has borders that are enforced. Every country has immigration policies that just be followed. Every country that finds immigrants that are there undocumented (illegally) deports them and uses databases with public/private cooperation to do so.

There are ways to prove citizenship. Easily obtainable documents like a social security card, passport, birth certificate, etc... . There is no real issue with ICE deporting Americans. None whatsoever.

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by mikeash on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:59PM (#13896906)
Nothing in the Constitution says that due process only applies to citizens.

Obviously if they're undocumented immigrants then they're criminals. My point is that ICE can't consider them to be definitely criminals until that's actually proven in court. You can't just say, well, ICE is totally sure that José over there is undocumented, so it's OK if ICE treats him like a criminal even though they haven't gone to court.

I'm not saying we shouldn't guard the borders or enforce immigration law. I'm saying that it's still law enforcement and the ideas of innocent until proven guilty, and requiring warrants for searches, still applies. Or at least should apply.

Not every US citizen has a social security card, passport, or even a birth certificate. There are quite a few US citizens that get detained by ICE:

http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/12/22/504031635/...

And yes, sometimes they do get deported:

https://news.vice.com/article/the-us-keeps-mistakenly-deport...

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by muninn_ on Friday March 17, 2017 @06:22PM (#13898505)
Yeah but it's largely a non-issue.

Also while people in the US who are here illegally may be permitted due process, it'll be a pretty easy case. Are you a US citizen? Yes? No? Pretty simple. I guess you could argue that the state has to provide evidence that you're not, but if the evidence doesn't exist you're asking the state to prove something exists that doesn't, which is a non sequitor.

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by mikeash on Friday March 17, 2017 @06:54PM (#13898680)
People getting charged with murders they didn't commit is largely a non-issue, but that doesn't mean we should just bypass the whole trial thing.

I don't understand your last part. If the state can't prove something exists that doesn't, then the state can't prove its case, so the accused should go free, no? We don't change the rules of legal proof just because it's inconvenient to the state.

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by muninn_ on Friday March 17, 2017 @07:06PM (#13898744)
So all I have to do is show up in a country and just say "I'm a citizen" and if they can't disprove that claim then I get to stay?

Because that's essentially what you're saying here.

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by mikeash on Friday March 17, 2017 @07:09PM (#13898752)
Well no, you're the one who said it's impossible to prove lack of citizenship, not me.

I'm guessing that ICE is generally able to demonstrate, beyond a reasonable doubt, that most illegal immigrants are not citizens. Most can be fairly easily proven not to have had US citizenship from birth (due to being born outside the US to non-American parents), and there is a central database of naturalized citizens, so if they are also absent from that, done.

What I'm saying here is simply that if it is indeed impossible to prove, as you say, that is not a good reason to relax standards of proof.

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by op00to on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:46PM (#13896749)
There are issues with CBP personnel harassing Americans. I have a constitutional right to freely travel around the country without fear of search or seizure if I'm not suspected of a crime. CBP personnel camp out in airplane jetways ambushing law-abiding American citizens who have no choice but to submit to an illegal and improper search of their personal papers to prove their citizenship. Any freedom loving citizen of the United States should resist this bullshit.
Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by fav_collector on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:17PM (#13897078)
> improper search of their personal papers to prove their citizenship

this is pretty sensationalized. It's very rational to request proof of citizenship before allowing entry to a country

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by logfromblammo on Friday March 17, 2017 @05:27PM (#13898140)
Rational or not, in the US, we have placed upon our officers the burden of having a reasonable suspicion (one that can be later explained to a court) before requiring anything of a detained person.

As such, if I am a U.S. citizen, and say so, the burden is then upon the officer to identify a reason to suspect that I am not actually a citizen before requiring that I submit to additional questioning or produce documentation. We desire that our cops be required to have an actual reason before hassling us. That form of behavior was what goaded our forebears into shooting at the king's men.

At the risk of inciting an opinionated pissing contest, I'd say that meekly presenting your official papers to a government authority is reason to suspect that you are not an American, and that loudly arguing with the officer (especially when relying on spurious legal grounds) is almost as good as stapling a notarized copy of your birth certificate to your forehead.

I think a simple majority of Americans would probably prefer the government to treat the public more respectfully and courteously--citizens or not--even if it means some dangerous people will find it easier to commit crimes. I may be mistaken in this perception, but I wish for it to be true. It's a crying shame that people are deciding not to visit because our government is acting like a paranoid brute and that I can't find any rational grounds to disagree with their decisions to stay away.

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by mikeash on Friday March 17, 2017 @04:20PM (#13897622)
I doubt that "camp out in airplane jetways" is describing border controls entering the US. Probably something more like this: http://sfist.com/2017/02/24/border_patrol_agents_stop_and_ch...
Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by op00to on Saturday March 18, 2017 @07:47PM (#13904120)
I was referencing domestic travel. Within the US.
Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by ng12 on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:44PM (#13896732)
Is your argument that ICE has data they're not supposed to have? Part of ICE's job is to enforce immigration rules. Let's work on your analogy here:

> Imagine if the local police were able to use CIA records, including phone and location data, to prosecute you for, say stealing a car.

Imagine if the local police were able to use their plate reader software to identify and prosecute people who had stolen cars?

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by mikeash on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:53PM (#13896825)
Right, ICE's job is to enforce immigration rules, so they're getting phone and location records from the CIA without a warrant, and that's OK because...?

Police are allowed to use license plate readers because that's considered to be in public view. Since the CIA is separate from both ICE and the local police, let's just use CIA in the analogy too.

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by ng12 on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:57PM (#13896882)
> ICE's job is to enforce immigration rules, so they're getting phone and location records from the CIA without a warrant

Do you have a source for this? It's not clear to me that this is the case -- and if it is we are totally screwed whether Palantir is involved or not.

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by mikeash on Friday March 17, 2017 @03:08PM (#13896985)
Maybe I'm assuming too much, but given the broad language and complete lack of mention of judicial oversight, it seems like it. This document about how ICE uses ICM, a similar system that works with data from other agencies, only mentions warrants in the context of the database holding information about them, or certain information in the database being obtained using them: https://www.dhs.gov/sites/default/files/publications/privacy...
Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by marricks on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:22PM (#13896539)
The Republican controlled house, Senate, executive branch, and majority of state governments highlights how important it is that people and companies resist, and that we support groups that do.

Casting it off as, "it's just a job someone has to do it", is a pretty weak defence.

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by 67726e on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:11PM (#13896432)
> Honestly a bit disturbing to see people coming out of the wood works to defend palantir.

> They've assisted NSA, and now they're using some skills to help agents look up info on undocumented immigrants.

I'm supposed to be outraged that a company is supplying software to help a government employee do their job in an efficient manner?

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by vkou on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:16PM (#13896483)
If you believe the job is immoral, yes.

IBM supplied computation systems to Nazi Germany, where they were used to carry out the murder of millions of people.

Had it done so knowingly, its management should have been taken out back and shot, right alongside the other perpetrators.

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by jeff_petersen on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:24PM (#13896560)
As with every Nazi comparison with the current administration, this is neither helpful nor honest.
Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by kbenson on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:38PM (#13896668)
Blanket dismissal of a comparison because it uses include Nazis is not useful. The point of learning from history is to actually be able to compare current events to the past. Putting Nazi Germany on a pedestal as uniquely evil is harmful, in that it prevents us from learning from those mistakes. Using it where unwarranted is also harmful, but we should not got to such lengths to avoid that as to reduce this historical period to uselessness.

Comparisons to the current administration are likely overblown, but are not entirely without merit. Comparisons could also be made to past administrations. The important thing is to consider how well the comparison matches, how problematic the features being compared are in each item, and how that works within context.

If those that cannot remember the past are doomed to repeat it, so too are those that refuse to consider the past.

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by vkou on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:26PM (#13896580)
I have implied nothing of the sort.

I have, however, implied that "Helping the government do its job" has no bearing on the morality of your actions. What the job is does.

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by AckSyn on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:36PM (#13896651)
It's intellectually dishonest to draw a comparison of IBM helping the Nazi's commit a genocidal action to the US government deporting illegal aliens, and then say "well I didn't _imply_ anything"

Either that or you're being deliberately obtuse and are trolling.

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by vkou on Monday March 20, 2017 @01:45PM (#13916129)
It's intellectually dishonest to dismiss any ethical controversy about your behaviour with "Well, I'm making a lot of money by helping a government do what it wants, so surely I'm in the clear."

Palantir assists with quite a number of... Ethically controversial government activities.

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by mikeyouse on Friday March 17, 2017 @05:04PM (#13897993)
There's a fair amount of evidence that IBM knew exactly what their customers were doing with their computing systems. There were IBM engineers on site to operate the counters and they had classifications for why they were in the camps (disabled, gay, Jewish) and the methods in which they died - including 'death by gas chamber'. All of that info was being compiled by employees of IBM.

http://m.huffpost.com/us/entry/1301691

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by 67726e on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:23PM (#13896552)
Deporting immigrants who decided to violate the law is in no way comparable to the systematic murder of millions of people. Get a grip.
Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by mikeash on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:39PM (#13896688)
Well, yes. Not everything the government does is supposed to be about efficiency. The legal system is very deliberately inefficient. We make police and prosecutors jump through all sorts of hoops when investigating and prosecuting crime, because the goal isn't to make their jobs as easy as possible, the goal is to ensure that innocent people don't get convicted.
Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by danso on Friday March 17, 2017 @02:52PM (#13896824)
Reminds me of when I was robbed in NY and had to go to a police station to talk to a detective. After I described the physical features of the suspect, he had me use an antiquated program that brought up hundreds of suspects' mugshots who were known criminals in the area that matched my description. The computer and software was comically slow, and after paging through about a dozen slowly loading pages of (poorly lighted) mugshots, I gave up.

I was initially annoyed at how inefficient that software was, how its slow speed and clunky interface inevitably made it hard to focus on the work of identifying suspects. I could think of a lot of ways to make it easier to filter and interactively rank/pin photos for easier on-the-fly comparison. But then on further reflection, I realized it's probably a good thing that that software is so clunky. Making the software slicker (i.e. as portrayed in CSI shows) could mislead or pressure users (both police and victims) into thinking that their human ability to identify people from mugshots is more accurate than it actually is.

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by semione on Friday March 17, 2017 @07:57PM (#13899019)
>into thinking that their human ability to identify people from mugshots is more accurate than it actually is

Identifying in mugshot does nothing, you have to identify suspect in person and detective will interrogate suspect and you both. There are multitude of checks before anything is done. So still failing to understand how good software which could possible show the suspect is the problem? The main reason possibly could be that they(government) cannot hire good programmers who could build useable systems.

Re:Palantir enables immigration agents to look up informatio... by danso on Friday March 17, 2017 @10:42PM (#13899610)
I know, they ended up catching him and I had to identify him in a lineup. He ended up pleading guilty.

Identifying a mugshot isn't "nothing". It can be used as evidence for probable cause in getting a search warrant or at least paying the suspect a visit.