Yeah arresting people for crimes they have yet to commit doesn't sound more just to me.
> Crime thrives in dark corners. A surveillance society is a searing searchlight to expose and eradicate the the rot.
Crime thrives when people have no other options. Providing economic opportunities for everyone reduces crime far more than mass surveillance ever will.
The reason they didn't do that was simply because it's a movie, and movies work better if instead of picking a compromise point between our society and some future ideal---you just pick the future ideal that will seem crazy to people.
It's like Logan's Run (movie) where the issue isn't just that you kill everyone over 30 to save resources, but that you lie and pretend no one can physically live past 30 and everyone gets reincarnated. They inserted the moral quandary to make the story interesting.
Beyond that, if we really did want to make wide spread data collection a part of society it should be a constitutional change in the US at least. The 4th amendment protects against unreasonable searches. Proposing that everyone gets searched all the time is just a way for the government to weasel their way around that restriction. Doing so just degrades the rule of law which has a host of problems.
The only way I could possibly see being ok with everyones information being available all the time is if warrants were for specific information, for example looking for people who bought pressure cookers before the boston bombing, and any evidence found in this dragnet that pointed to other crimes could _never_ be used in any other case. That would at least prevent fishing expeditions from the government
Which authorities? Just because you are comfortable with the authorities there where you are or the authorities you have today, doesn't mean you should be comfortable with the authorities here or the authorities you may have tomorrow
> we can end anti-social behaviour as we know it and achieve the kind of peace and harmony that only come from full accountability
Who is we? Who is going to read, interpret and correctly act on this information? Only a total boot heal would write something like this. Your faith in authority is misplaced.
> Crime thrives in dark corners. A surveillance society is a searing searchlight to expose and eradicate the the rot.
You know what else thrives in dark corners? Dissent. A searchlight can wilt a flower just as much as it can expose rot
> Legitimate buyers have nothing to fear and terrorists get caught
There are exactly two people that want to blow up a marathon with a pressure cooker bomb. Two. The planet was only able to produce 22 people who want to fly planes into buildings in over 80 years of commercial aviation. Even then, that was only possible because of an anomaly of state sponsorship. Terrorism is such a tiny problem as to not even deserve mention.
- Edward Snowden
"I can't wait to be judged by a panel with a single, global understanding of correctness, morality, and justice which can account for everyone's beliefs and completely understand what is right and wrong. There is right, and there is wrong. And we must seek to eradicate wrong, for we know what is right. And if you disagree with us, you are wrong."
Resist. Do not let the shills tell you what to believe in.
Big data is such an incredible tool for crime prevention. Minority Report is not a dystopian vision: it's a blueprint for a more just society.
If every "private" email, video conference and search is available for inspection and cross reference, we can end anti-social behaviour as we know it and achieve the kind of peace and harmony that only come from full accountability.
Crime thrives in dark corners. A surveillance society is a searing searchlight to expose and eradicate the the rot.
The question is: what comes next? If you bought a pressure cooker on Amazon a month before the Boston bombing, do police get to know about it?"
Absolutely. That is valuable information for an investigate. That doesn't mean everyone who bought a pressure cooked should be locked up, but that information can be used in conjunction with other information to narrow down a list of suspects. Legitimate buyers have nothing to fear and terrorists get caught.