You cannot replace the light with a sign because by law traffic lights have higher precedence that traffic signs. This is for failover reasons (when traffic light is broken, no electricity etc.) So a sign on an intersection can be rendered void/meaningless if the traffic light is operational.
Having traffic lights show the same light is not that unheard of as the article makes it sound. I visited a part of Europe where right turns on intersections always showed blinking yellow light. This is equivalent to "turn right, but yield first"
I understand it can be confusing if you are coming from the US system though. The European system is highly standardized for use in all kinds of driving situations (like places with unreliable electricity), the drawback is that it can get a bit technical at times.
But that's a moot point if the light isn't there in the first place.
I'm sorry, but no matter how you slice it, this light is stupid. What is needed is simply a pair of signs: STOP and RIGHT TURN ONLY.
If there is a power cut, then the other three roads will have no lights, drivers there will treat the intersection with one set of rules. Whereas the driver on this road with a sign will treat the intersection with another, potentially causing an accident.
When I said "traffic light" I meant the entire set of traffic lights of the intersection. You can't have just one lane without traffic light and all the others with. It would be highly confusing, also probably against the road laws.
The point of the traffic light taking precedence over road sign is actually part of the rules of the road. It is also required knowledge for driver exams.
Of course you can.
> It would be highly confusing
Why?
> also probably against the road laws.
Laws can be changed. The fact that "it's the law" is a stupid reason to keep doing something that doesn't otherwise make sense. Germans of all people should understand this. (And BTW, I am German.)
It would be much better to change traffic la nation-wide so we can get rid of this ONE traffic light in Germany. Isn't it?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Road_signs_in_Germany#/media/F...
Combine that with a stop sign to force a stop and yield.
It feels like this would solve the situation without the need for traffic lights. I'm sure I'm missing something though.
It's a great illustration of a point that came up a while ago in that discussion of 'what makes a good programmer vs. a great one'. A good programmer recognizes the value of consistency, and leaves the red light in there even though it's a bit ugly and inefficient, because that keeps the system consistent. A great programmer would change the rules to allow a more efficient solution which solves the real problem (ie. cars need to know what to do.)
Reminds me of catching hell from random old German ladies in Berlin when I crossed a sleepy residential street, without a car on the road in sight for miles, without waiting for the crosswalk light to go green. Or gasp crossing a street without using a crosswalk!
Any jurisdiction in North America would just put a Stop or Yield sign there.
What is it that confuses you about them?
- In Europe a stop sign means that you have to wait until the way is clear. Of course, you normally don't have stops on more than two of the roads crossing. (Theoretically, you can wait forever at a stop, since people on the other roads won't stop and let you through)
- In North America (I've seen it in Canada), you have stop signs on all four roads crossing and you get through in a first in first out turn.
It seems to me that
- the US uses stop signs as a way to slow down the traffic (so, no real meaning), but
- in Europe it does have a clear meaning: "it's dangerous to drive over a crossing without halting". Not only you have to be careful because you have no right of way (the "give way" sign) but you really have to stop and look at the traffic, mostly due to poor visibility (or high difference in speed).
In practice stop signs don't work at all in the US. People roll through them, sometimes not even slowing down and can't understand whoo goes first at 4 way stop. So they either sit at the stop sign frantically waving on all cars that are approaching until no more cars are approaching or they just go at some random time or they just blow through the sign altogether.
Anyways, 4 way stops aren't just for slowing down traffic, though they are sometimes used that way. They are for when you have two roads coming together that both have roughly the same amount of traffic (no 'main' road) but don't want to put in a light.
Compared to the countries of Europe where I have driven, the American traffic I have experienced often seemed excessively polite, to the point where I think that (relative to Europe) it would be more socially acceptable to drive bad because of being dangerously distracted than to drive bad due to being in a hurry.
I have long suspected a causal relation between the politeness and the four way stop, I just can't figure out the direction of causation.
I still have to slow down a lot because I'm not sure how fast the other drivers are going. At that point it's not a big deal if I stop.
> even more so if you can pretty much ignore one of two directions
That sounds like an intersection that would not be a four way stop in the first place.
There exist all sorts of signs that actually tell the driver what to watch out for, and make the right of way situation clearer. But in North America, a stop sign is used in most situations.
Four-way stop signs are another form of silliness. They often happen in residential areas where small streets cross. In Europe you'd have 'right before left' rules that only really matter when cars actually meet; in North America you have to come to a complete halt, constantly.
I'm no driver, and am not a big fan of drivers or driving in general. But I kind of understand why drivers are so aggravated here.
To illustrate how rare they are, I can only think of two within a 100-mile radius[0] - both in places where you are about to enter a road with a 50mph/80kmh speed limit and where visibility is terrible in either direction.
[0] In fairness I should mention that 2/3 of that circle falls in the Norwegian Sea, where stop signs are exceedingly rare...
The same as in Bucharest, Romania. That's why when I see a stop sign I make double-sure when looking for cars who have right of way over me.
This "solution" seems very confusing. In every US/Canadian jurisdiction I've visited has nothing like this German solution. Just indicate with lights, signage and road furniture that the particular route is not allowed. To technically keep the route open, but prohibit by lights seems prone to confusion, especially for individuals not from the area. Also, how do mapping apps deal with this intersection (curious)? Do mapping apps properly route through such an intersection?
(edit: clarity)