News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by danm07 on Friday March 10, 2017 @12:06AM (#13836528)
These types of things really irritate me. Corporate NDA agreements are total shams.

We couldn't hire a P/T contractor because the engineer signed an NDA agreement with his company that pretty much said everything he developed, verbalized, or put to paper -- during work or after -- was IP of that company, irrespective of whether it had anything to do with its products. Even as an employer, I find this an absolute outrage.

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by libertymcateer on Friday March 10, 2017 @09:52AM (#13838974)
> an NDA agreement with his company that pretty much said everything he developed, verbalized, or put to paper -- during work or after -- was IP of that company

That is not an NDA. It simply isn't. NDA covers non-disclosure of confidential information. It may say NDA at the top, but it is no more an NDA than if I put a Honda hood ornament on an M1A1 Abrams.

What you are describing is a 360 work-for-hire agreement. Which is a totally, totally different beast.

> Even as an employer, I find this an absolute outrage.

Well, it can be overkill. But depending on how much the guy is getting paid, depending on the industry and the larger context, it can be appropriate. This contract is basically saying that no moonlighting is allowable - there are many business arrangements where this is perfectly reasonable (i.e., critical or unique employees, fiduciaries, key executives, etc.). If, however, he is truly just a low level employee, then maybe it is not appropriate. The point is that it is not clear cut.

Some questions arise:

* Is this the only guy who can perform this particular work for you? If so, then you are giving credence to the argument he is a super valuable asset and there is reasonable motivation for his employers to have him in a total lockup agreement. The hope is that he would be properly compensated for this trade-off, however. If he isn't, he should seek legal representation for negotiation of his next job arrangement.

* If he is not the only guy who can perform this particular work, does he not have friends? Are there no other alternatives?

There are really only two choices: 1) he and his skills are unique, in which case his employer has every motivation to have him be subject to these very strong anti-moonlighting provisions (and hopefully he is getting commensurate pay - if he isn't, that is another whole ball of wax) or 2) there are other people that can do this job, in which case, hire one of them. Or are there no reasonable alternatives?

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by 6stringmerc on Friday March 10, 2017 @10:22AM (#13839223)
Yeah 360 deals are really prevalent in big-time music so to see them showing up in, uh, Skilled Labor (?) is really kind of a shock to me. I hate 360 deals. Hate hate hate. So very anti-capitalistic.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by libertymcateer on Friday March 10, 2017 @10:27AM (#13839269)
> So very anti-capitalistic.

Depends. Is this an entry level programmer? If so, is that entry level programmer fresh out of college and making $150k? Or is an executive making $500k? Is there an equity package? Or is this some guy making 55k and working 60 hour weeks? There is a continuum.

Also, 360 deals in music industry typically relate to the fact that all royalty and endorsement deals must go through the label - it used to be that artists could directly license their names for things like cereal endorsements or clothing lines. A 360 deal means that the artist must do that licensing through the label. Whether or not this is a good deal depends on the artist, the label, and the specific percentages involved.

That is not quite the same thing as a work for hire agreement that states that all of an employees inventions, whether or not developed on or off the clock and whether or not developed with company hardware - are company property. Similar, to be sure, but if you talk about a 360 work for hire agreement, people may get what you are talking about, but some may not. I don't think it is 'term of art' in the same way - even though I may use it as one.

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by pjc50 on Friday March 10, 2017 @10:34AM (#13839329)
No, it's very capitalistic: IP is capital on which rent can be charged, so naturally the system coerces transfer of ownership to the rentier class and away from the labour class. :(
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by 6stringmerc on Friday March 10, 2017 @10:55AM (#13839511)
Interesting counter point! I happen to think though that Deals-That-Never-End on the 360 path are more Feudalistic exploitation than a supply-demand-free market kind of thing. I do see where you're coming from and I understand the wrinkle.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by pjc50 on Friday March 10, 2017 @11:13AM (#13839651)
Well, this is where people end up having no-true-Scotsman debates about what is really meant by capitalism, which is tremendously dull but sometimes necessary :) Note that most of the free market analysis work has assumptions built into it about market power and the prior distribution of resources. IP is a little weird because it's so non-substitutable; if you don't like the price of fish you can go buy some other fish, but if you don't like the price of a Phish album you may not find a substitute.

One of the main improvements of capitalism over feudalism is that contract terms usually last for at most a lifetime, and where they don't they're at least limited to a piece of real estate.

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by geezerjay on Saturday March 11, 2017 @03:56AM (#13844837)
>No, it's very capitalistic: IP is capital

That's quite wrong. the very basis of IP is a state-imposed monopoly, which is the complete opposite of what capitalism is, what its basic principles are, and how it works.

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by Exofunctor on Friday March 10, 2017 @11:44AM (#13839882)
Many would argue that IP itself is inherently anti-capitalistic, because it imposes artificial scarcity where it would not otherwise exist and, relatedly, because IP "theft" doesn't actually deprive the "victim" of a scarce resource they created or purchased. Ideas have (effectively) zero marginal reproduction cost.

That's not to say there aren't some good arguments for IP, but they sort of inherently have a planned-economy bent.

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by AimHere on Friday March 10, 2017 @12:03PM (#13840026)
One argument you missed is that IP laws generally create state-granted monopolies, which is something capitalists usually claim to be against.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by bitexploder on Friday March 10, 2017 @01:15AM (#13836754)
This article is about Zenimax not paying the second half of his earnout for the sale of id Software.

I hear you about reatrictive covenants and NDAs, though.

edit: I get Zenimax said it was about him going to Oculus, but it is really just Zenimax being dicks. They will most likely have to pay.

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by danm07 on Friday March 10, 2017 @01:45AM (#13836843)
I read in a subsequent article that ZeniMax was upset about John Carmack taking five of his best guys with him to Oculus, one of whom violated his NDA agreement.

I presume that's what led to this debacle.

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by Arnt on Friday March 10, 2017 @04:54AM (#13837501)
I don't get it. Wasn't that four years after the sale? Was Zenimax supposed to pay for the sale ≥5 years after it happened?
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by danm07 on Friday March 10, 2017 @05:13AM (#13837560)
Typical acquisition also includes an employment contract, and a significant portion of that settlement is paid upon the contract's completion.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by dogma1138 on Friday March 10, 2017 @05:42AM (#13837657)
Yep, this is especially true when you are buying a company where much of it's worth is derived from it's human capital.

With all respect to "id" software, the majority of their value was JC and the tech leads.

Whilst id is still remembered fondly it's not like they were a major brand and had a large portfolio of technical and franchised intellectual property that was worth anything close to what ZeniMax paid for it.

ZeniMax bought the brains not the doom franchise.

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by flor1s on Friday March 10, 2017 @06:42AM (#13837875)
The human capital of id was valuable, but I think you are underselling their brands and technology. 150 million for the ownership of some of the most iconic brands (Doom, Quake, Wolfenstein) in FPS gaming doesn't seem that expensive, especially considering that it's much easier to sell many copies of a game in a well known franchise than to to sell games in a new franchise. The latest Doom sold over a million copies, Wolfenstein; The New Order sold over a million copies, the latest "Quake" (Enemy Territory: QUAKE Wars) probably sold over a million copies as well.

In terms of human capital, Carmack is one of the most respected technologists in gaming, but I'm sure ZeniMax didn't expect him to stay with them for a very long period. At the time id was bought by ZeniMax it seemed like Carmack was spending a lot of time on Armadillo Aerospace too.

In terms of tech it seems id wasn't the leader it used to be anymore (their early engines were used by Half-Life and CoD), taking into consideration Unreal Engine 3, Crytek Engine (being used for Bethesda's own Prey, the previous installment running on idTech) and Unity.

On the other side, Activision bought Infinity Ward (developer of Call of Duty) for just 5 million [1]...

http://venturebeat.com/2010/03/04/lawsuit-details-activision...

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by thrillgore on Friday March 10, 2017 @08:56AM (#13838566)
I'm inclined to agree, but having played Doom 2016, its clear the creative and technical mindshare is still intact. Especially since the other ZeniMax companies are (more than likely) going to use that same technology.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by fnordfnordfnord on Friday March 10, 2017 @08:52AM (#13838536)
I think you're right, but the Doom name has a lot of marketing value.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by Arnt on Friday March 10, 2017 @06:27AM (#13837819)
Sure. Five years is oddly long, though, especially if the contract allows the employee to leave earlier.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by edem on Friday March 10, 2017 @05:53AM (#13837708)
If Carmack takes their best guys it is not JC's fault. They go because they see more value in their new position. That's all.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by fnordfnordfnord on Friday March 10, 2017 @08:50AM (#13838512)
Engineers are the worst at this part of the game. They'll sign anything you put in front of them. At several of the places I've worked, I've been given crap boilerplate forms like that to sign. HR/hiring people will look at you like you're some kind of weirdo if you balk at any of it. Here are the reactions to my reluctance as I recall them.

* One company wouldn't budge. Later, I got a better deal, but it was risky the way I went about it. * At another company, I just didn't sign it. They didn't stop me from starting work but when the omission was noticed they had an HR person pester me about it a few times. They eventually gave up. * At yet another place, I crossed out the parts I didn't like. They just kind of shrugged and said okay.

At no time did I ever want anything unreasonable. I just didn't want all the things that I or my descendants designed/built/invented/helped-whatever to be assigned to ['company'] in perpetuity, etc. And I didn't want a contractual responsibility to come and defend patents in courts, or give depositions at my expense.

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by pc86 on Friday March 10, 2017 @09:16AM (#13838682)
> Engineers are the worst at this part of the game. They'll sign anything you put in front of them.

The smart ones absolutely will not. Smart people absolutely will not do this, regardless of their profession.

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by fao_ on Friday March 10, 2017 @09:28AM (#13838783)
But that's the ultimate cop-out. By sheer definition smart people will not do anything stupid. They are utterly incapable of doing stupid things, because then they wouldn't be smart. This is a wonderful tautology and a beautiful way of saying absolutely nothing.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by ReidZB on Friday March 10, 2017 @11:30AM (#13839786)
It's just a way of saying "doing X is stupid" without being blunt.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by jackmott on Friday March 10, 2017 @09:35AM (#13838845)
Once you internalize tautologies you see them eeeeeverywhere. sadly.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by lordCarbonFiber on Friday March 10, 2017 @10:27AM (#13839270)
That's a dangerous and reductive line of thinking. There are plenty of factors that can lead people to believe (correctly or no) that they don't have leverage in an employment negotiation. First job out of school, first job in the tech industry, family causing them to want to stay in an area without many other prospects, etc; NDAs are an employers way of leaning hard on the fact you need them a lot more than they need you.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by fnordfnordfnord on Friday March 10, 2017 @09:56AM (#13839006)
I don't agree. I've worked with some very smart engineers and scientists who simply do not inform themselves about things that are outside their domain.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by libertymcateer on Friday March 10, 2017 @11:26AM (#13839760)
> who simply do not inform themselves about things that are outside their domain.

And hopefully have the self-awareness not to have strongly held opinions in these areas (at least without sufficient evidence). However, I find that all too often, this is not the case.

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by BlackjackCF on Friday March 10, 2017 @12:49PM (#13840483)
Yup. Often times it's not a matter of whether or not they're "smart" or "self-aware", like I see being argued. It's just a matter of not feeling confident enough to demand more. This holds especially true for engineers I've met in the games industry. The games industry treats their engineers so poorly in terms of compensation that often when I encourage my friends in the games industry to demand more, they're often afraid to because they believe they'll have their job offer rescinded for demanding more.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by libertymcateer on Friday March 10, 2017 @10:31AM (#13839307)
There are lawyers who do this type of negotiation.

> HR/hiring people will look at you like you're some kind of weirdo if you balk at any of it. Here are the reactions to my reluctance as I recall them.

Right. Go over them. Your lawyer will talk to their lawyers, above the level of the HR people you would be talking to.

> I didn't want a contractual responsibility to come and defend patents in courts,

Which is a pretty reasonable requirement...

> or give depositions at my expense.

But that is not (or, rather, it can be in certain circumstances).

A good lawyer will negotiate these things for you. You should try to find one who actually understands software a bit. They do exist.

Disclaimer: I am not your lawyer. If you need a lawyer, you should get one.

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by fnordfnordfnord on Friday March 10, 2017 @09:11PM (#13843763)
When I was dropping out of college because I'd run out of money, I didn't have money to hire an attorney to negotiate an entry level tech/engineering job for me.

>Which is a pretty reasonable requirement...

You omitted the last part. I think it's pretty unreasonable to want that kind of service gratis.

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by Trundle on Friday March 10, 2017 @10:57AM (#13839533)
>But that is not (or, rather, it can be in certain circumstances)

If they're 3/3 with dodging it, what makes it unreasonable? Have they just been lucky so far?

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by libertymcateer on Friday March 10, 2017 @11:20AM (#13839705)
Who is dodging what now? (Not trying to be facetious -forgive me, I'm just not really following.)
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by waffle_ss on Friday March 10, 2017 @11:17AM (#13839678)
I crossed out all the non-compete clauses on the contract I signed for my last job and they were fine with it.

It's really no different than negotiating on salary or anything else - you just have to know your own value and the current job market climate. And obviously not being afraid of having a frank discussion about it - perhaps a lot of devs are non-confrontational in that way.

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by z3t4 on Friday March 10, 2017 @01:08AM (#13836735)
creative work is a 24h job. you will get ideas even when you sleep. closing tickets and programming however is not and then such a contract would be outrageous. make sure you are paid for 24h and not 8h. or go home early every day stating that your contract say you can work from home on anything you want.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by LoSboccacc on Friday March 10, 2017 @01:58AM (#13836886)
All authored work like programming gets covered as creative in some states, i.e. Italy.

It is rarely enforced but it's always there, looming.

Anyway, even before the consideration of intellectual properties, it stand to reason that a worker can produce only so much work per day before stressing out, and if an employee hired for 8h does 4h more on the side as contractor the employing company gets 'cheated out' of productive time and this is especially true in a job that require fairly constant concentration, even if being tired at the job is shitty all around universally.

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by kbenson on Friday March 10, 2017 @03:03AM (#13837077)
> if an employee hired for 8h does 4h more on the side as contractor the employing company gets 'cheated out' of productive time

No, if I'm hired as an employee, it's either to perform specific duties during specific times (hourly pay), or it's to provide my expertise to accomplish tasks given me, with a possible expectation I be available or at a location during certain times (salaried pay). If I'm salary, and my employer expects it will take me 8 hours but it takes me 1, I can relax the rest of the time. Doing so may reflect poorly on me if I'm looking to advance, but that's why employment is a negotiation.

Nobody can provide 100% output 100% of the time they are working if they work 40 hours a week. People aren't built to be able to sustain that rate of work, they can try, but very quickly they are no longer putting out 100% output, even if they are there 100% of the time. So it's fairly obvious people do naturally limit the amount of effort they put into work based on the expected return, which is how it should be.

As an example, it's not unheard of for people to switch jobs for positions that pay less but also have far less responsibility. If you can work half as hard but get 75% the pay, some people will take that if that 75% is sufficient and they've determined that the prior amount of stress was too much.

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by mijoharas on Friday March 10, 2017 @05:17AM (#13837577)
That is true, and some companies (e.g. amazon) will not own any of your IP created outside of the office (they don't even mind if you use company equipment (e.g. work laptop)), but the contract states that you cannot be employed by anyone else while you are employed by them. This way they ensure that employees aren't tired from working a second job which as you pointed out is a problem.

Amazon isn't always thought of as the nicest of companies, but in terms of employees I.P. I'd say they are one of the fairest companies.

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by talmand on Friday March 10, 2017 @10:08AM (#13839105)
They are fine with an employee being tired during the day due to their own personal projects but are not fine with being tired due to a second employment? What difference does that make? That's just stupid.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by mijoharas on Friday March 10, 2017 @11:04AM (#13839593)
They're not fine with an employee being tired due to their own side-projects, if you were underperforming you'd get told off by your manager, asked to improve e.t.c. all the way to getting fired.

You being able to own the IP to things you create outside of work does not mean that you suddenly don't have to work during your actual work times.

Also, if an employer gave that as a reason for them keeping my IP created outside of work hours I would very seriously reconsider accepting a job with them (other reasons such as those outlined in Joel's article make a lot of sense).

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by talmand on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @11:21AM (#13868200)
What you are saying is not within the context of what I was replying to. The comment specifically stated that they ensure you are not tired by not allowing you to be employed by a third-party, and yet personal projects are fine in that context.

Unless the comment I was responding to was worded badly, my statement is valid.

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by fnordfnordfnord on Friday March 10, 2017 @09:06AM (#13838624)
> if an employee hired for 8h does 4h more on the side as contractor the employing company gets 'cheated out' of productive time and this is especially true in a job that require fairly constant concentration

No. Just no. Side projects are another way to up your skills. In addition to side projects I've done for pay, I've done them for a charitable organization on a volunteer basis, fundamental science research group (small fee, practically volunteer work). Even if my day-job suffered temporarily, they've still benefited because each of these projects involved learning/practicing something new.

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by pjc50 on Friday March 10, 2017 @10:37AM (#13839350)
> a worker can produce only so much work per day before stressing out

So why are workers allowed to do their own laundry, cooking etc? If I do DIY on my house in my own time, does the company now own the increase in value of my house? That seems to be what you're arguing: that effort outside of the workplace directly zero-sum competes with effort in the workplace.

I mean, a really strict reading of the IP clauses would indicate that if I wrote a letter to my mother the IP would reside with the company.

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by zaptheimpaler on Friday March 10, 2017 @05:58AM (#13837725)
>it stand to reason that a worker can produce only so much work per day before stressing out, and if an employee hired for 8h does 4h more on the side as contractor the employing company gets 'cheated out' of productive time and this is especially true in a job that require fairly constant concentration, even if being tired at the job is shitty all around universally.

Even if there is truth to what you said, employers already have enough power as it is. Why should we let them own a workers time even outside of the hours they are being compensated? They have no right to that. At the end of the day, if a worker is not productive enough the company can choose to fire them - thats about all the say a company should have over your life. If they want to OWN ALL your productive output, it stands to reason they should pay much more than the 8 hours your salary covers.

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by LoSboccacc on Friday March 10, 2017 @06:06AM (#13837747)
> Why should we let them own a workers time even outside of the hours they are being compensated?

I think it's more "let them have the power to fire a worker that comes on the job tired, warms the seat while recovers for the night shift and leaves the office without producing the value he is paid for."

more to the point: there's already a contract form that empowers the worker to work goals instead of hours, allowing employers that so desire to manage their time, so there's that as well. if one chooses the salaryman life, he get pros and cons.

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by TheCoelacanth on Friday March 10, 2017 @09:54AM (#13838986)
Fire them, sure. Let them sue the employee to capture the value they produced on their own time, no.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by danm07 on Friday March 10, 2017 @01:50AM (#13836861)
I get that and at my company, we restrict IP to the realm of our product line, and products developed using our resources. If our business sold sewing machines, I wouldn't expect the guy to hand over his encryption algorithm if he built it at home using his personal laptop.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by GigabyteCoin on Friday March 10, 2017 @01:30AM (#13836800)
A lot of companies really do own you and your life while you're with them.

That's why I choose not to work for one personally.

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by unixhero on Friday March 10, 2017 @02:40AM (#13837008)
That sounds leisurely.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by HenryBemis on Friday March 10, 2017 @03:14AM (#13837115)
Not really, contracting frees you from these chains. Even with an NDA the IP that MY company creates is the work of MY company, not the clients'. I respect the clients' side and need for anonymity and I make sure that what is mine stays mine and what is theirs stays theirs.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by vinceguidry on Friday March 10, 2017 @05:41AM (#13837656)
Just pick better companies. If you have the flexibility to choose contracting over employment, then you also have the flexibility to get out of market segments where these kinds of practices are commonplace. I have a friend that works for AT&T, when she describes her work environment, it really feels like a night and day difference from the Rails shops I work in and knock beers back with at meetups.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by anonymousDan on Friday March 10, 2017 @06:12AM (#13837764)
Just to be clear, which of the two has worse employment contracts, AT&T or the rails shops?
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by vinceguidry on Friday March 10, 2017 @06:57AM (#13837940)
AT&T. Main thing there is the non-competes. Such a thing is unheard of in my world, but pretty standard amongst the myriad of companies that supply AT&T with chop-shop labor.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by fnordfnordfnord on Friday March 10, 2017 @08:55AM (#13838558)
I was a sole proprietor once for a few years. I made a bit of money, but it wasn't leisurely, not at all.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by joe563323 on Friday March 10, 2017 @04:26AM (#13837382)
Are you a 10x guy. Please answer with honesty not with false humbleness.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by tehlike on Friday March 10, 2017 @12:34AM (#13836622)
What state was this at? I would question its legality/enforcability.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by alextheparrot on Friday March 10, 2017 @01:13AM (#13836748)
For anyone searching for a relevant California clause [0].

[0] https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySectio....

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by edem on Friday March 10, 2017 @05:56AM (#13837722)
The problem is (from what I saw) is that most people don't understand legal texts and it is not clear to them what is happening. I am always an outlier because I ask the questions and I would never sign an NDA like that. The company can't (and mustn't) control what I do outside of work so far as I dont involve its IP/know-how/patent/whatever.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by emn13 on Friday March 10, 2017 @08:33AM (#13838419)
Unfortunately, if convetional habit is for people to sign regardless and trust they'll get lucky or stay friends, then despite your reasonable intentions, you may still be hurting your position by refusing and absurd contract.

See also: EULA's, and really every contract ever between two entities of significantly different clout.

Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax by sspiff on Friday March 10, 2017 @10:53AM (#13839498)
I've worked for a couple of multinationals as a contractor and I have to say it varies wildly from company to company.

My current employer has a very clearly and unambiguously worded one-page NDA with rules that make sense and don't overreach.

My previous job had a document many, many pages long, that asserted I was liable for up to $10 million if I had violated any of the rules in it, which included things like making a copy of source code or debug binaries onto a USB device (which often happened in practice). It also tried to enforce these rules retroactively for 5 years and until 5 years after my employment ended, and was forced upon me 18 months into the job.