Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax
by pjc50 on Friday March 10, 2017 @10:34AM
(#13839329)
No, it's very capitalistic: IP is capital on which rent can be charged, so naturally the system coerces transfer of ownership to the rentier class and away from the labour class. :(
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax
by 6stringmerc on Friday March 10, 2017 @10:55AM
(#13839511)
Interesting counter point! I happen to think though that Deals-That-Never-End on the 360 path are more Feudalistic exploitation than a supply-demand-free market kind of thing. I do see where you're coming from and I understand the wrinkle.
Well, this is where people end up having no-true-Scotsman debates about what is really meant by capitalism, which is tremendously dull but sometimes necessary :) Note that most of the free market analysis work has assumptions built into it about market power and the prior distribution of resources. IP is a little weird because it's so non-substitutable; if you don't like the price of fish you can go buy some other fish, but if you don't like the price of a Phish album you may not find a substitute.
One of the main improvements of capitalism over feudalism is that contract terms usually last for at most a lifetime, and where they don't they're at least limited to a piece of real estate.
>No, it's very capitalistic: IP is capital
That's quite wrong. the very basis of IP is a state-imposed monopoly, which is the complete opposite of what capitalism is, what its basic principles are, and how it works.
Re:John Carmack is suing ZeniMax
by Exofunctor on Friday March 10, 2017 @11:44AM
(#13839882)
Many would argue that IP itself is inherently anti-capitalistic, because it imposes artificial scarcity where it would not otherwise exist and, relatedly, because IP "theft" doesn't actually deprive the "victim" of a scarce resource they created or purchased. Ideas have (effectively) zero marginal reproduction cost.
That's not to say there aren't some good arguments for IP, but they sort of inherently have a planned-economy bent.