News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by charles-salvia on Thursday March 09, 2017 @11:43AM (#13830439)
I think a lot of the resentment felt by the rural American poor has to do with their perception that they are constantly ignored or overlooked, while similarly impoverished inner-city minorities are at least given some kind of institutional sympathy. It's hard to say how true this really is, or how much of it is simply further fuel for pre-existing racism, but apparently this perception is ubiquitous enough that it can be leveraged to win national elections.

I will say the events of the last year have definitely opened my eyes to the situation. The thing I've noticed is that it actually is harder to sympathize with the white, rural poor than it is with the inner-city minorities, at least for me - even though I want to sympathize and I acknowledge their suffering is probably more or less equal to the inner-city minority poor. I suppose the reason I find it more difficult to feel equivalent sympathy is that it's hard to get over the fact that the white rural poor seem to constantly cling to counter-productive political/world-views that perpetuate their poverty and act against their interests. I mean it's just really hard to allocate significant sympathy towards a large voting-bloc that seems to blame all their problems on terrorism and immigration. But then again, perhaps I am generalizing - I mean I'm just a clueless liberal living in my NYC bubble so what do I know anyway?

Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by noobiemcfoob on Thursday March 09, 2017 @12:01PM (#13830597)
Much of the same can be said of impoverished inner city citizens. It's human nature to find external causes to your pains outside of your control.

There's a double annoyance with inner city residents, though, in that many just expect the government to solve the problems, leaving them without motivation. Almost robbing them of it in some cases. Anyone working hard towards their dreams, no matter how large or small, will naturally resent such mentalities.

Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by infosample on Thursday March 09, 2017 @12:22PM (#13830825)
It's hard to tell if you are making a counterargument to the parent or if you believe inner city residents[0] expect government to solve their problems, lack motivation, and don't work hard.

[0] Do the people you are referring to actually live in the inner city?

Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by noobiemcfoob on Thursday March 09, 2017 @12:48PM (#13831126)
A little of both, but I'm mostly commenting on the "The thing I've noticed is that it actually is harder to sympathize with the white, rural poor" sentiment. Namely to say that the reasons listed for not sympathizing with the rural poor can and often are applied the same to the urban poor. Going further, urban poor have a stigma of being assisted by the government. It's an odd situation because at the same time that there is resentment for the urban poor receiving more government programs, there's more popular will to help the urban poor. I imagine it's largely a visibility problem.

Sweeping generalizations are sweeping. And general. I don't believe all poor people, regardless of residence, lack motivation or are just looking for handouts. If pressed, I'd probably guess no more than 10% of the poor population would fairly deserve those insults. But, you could probably say only 10% of the global population might deserve those insults.

Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by rayiner on Thursday March 09, 2017 @12:33PM (#13830958)
Have you ever lived in the "inner city"?
Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by gamblor956 on Thursday March 09, 2017 @12:59PM (#13831249)
Yes. I've also lived in rural America. While there are significant populations of lazy dolists in both, the population of do-nothings is much higher in rural America. Rural America really does believe that everyone has forgotten about them, and blame all their problems on other people while they happily do meth or get drunk all day in their trailers.

The thing is...they're right. Because they live so far from any place that matters, no one who matters thinks about their situation, so it's much more difficult to leave rural America than it is to leave the inner city.

Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by charles-salvia on Thursday March 09, 2017 @01:48PM (#13831836)
Well, Donald Trump matters. And he thought about them. And this is where we are.
Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by ptaipale on Thursday March 09, 2017 @02:58PM (#13832858)
Indeed. Looking at America from across the Atlantic, it seems that the American inner cities are making themselves heard by drug trade and a fairly large number of homicides, and rural America now made themselves heard through elections.

I kind of find the latter approach more constructive, in fact, even if it resulted in Trump.

Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by charles-salvia on Thursday March 09, 2017 @03:37PM (#13833324)
It's a bit more complicated. Inner-city populations heavily vote Democrat, along with most densely populated areas. In fact, something like ~80% of Americans live in urban areas (which also includes dense suburbs), and therefore we should expect Democrats to win elections most of the time (even in spite of the fact that some dense sub-urban areas heavily lean Republican). However, this doesn't happen in practice because the electoral college system heavily reduces the weight of votes coming from inner-cities and urban areas, and also excludes votes coming from urban areas that lie within a larger, Republican-leaning state. For example, in the last election, probably most people in Philadelphia voted for Clinton, but their votes were nullified because the state over-all went to Trump.

So inner-city populations can't reliably make themselves heard on the national level via Presidential elections.

Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by zeveb on Thursday March 09, 2017 @06:58PM (#13835046)
> However, this doesn't happen in practice because the electoral college system heavily reduces the weight of votes coming from inner-cities and urban areas, and also excludes votes coming from urban areas that lie within a larger, Republican-leaning state.

The Electoral College doesn't 'reduce the weight of votes coming from inner-cities and urban areas'; it allocates votes to states in roughly proportion to population.

Voting by states doesn't just 'exclude votes coming from urban areas that lie within a larger, Republican-leaning state,' but also excludes votes from conservatives living in Democratic states, e.g. California.

> probably most people in Philadelphia voted for Clinton, but their votes were nullified because the state over-all went to Trump.

Their votes weren't nullified any more than the votes of those against Brexit were nullified by those who voted for: it's in the nature of a vote that someone will lose (not be nullified).

I didn't vote for President Trump, but I am glad that we are a federal republic with an Electoral College, not a direct democracy or anything like it. I wish we had more federalism, not less, to include state legislatures appointing senators and electors, and the elimination of the popular vote for president altogether.

Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by dctoedt on Friday March 10, 2017 @03:17PM (#13841738)
> The Electoral College doesn't 'reduce the weight of votes coming from inner-cities and urban areas'; it allocates votes to states in roughly proportion to population.

Um, that depends on what you mean by "roughly proportional":

+ Each state, no matter how low the population, gets a minimum of three votes in the Electoral College (one per House member and senator).

+ House representation increases by population, but Senate representation is capped at two, no matter how large the population.

+ As a result: "Each vote cast in Wyoming is worth 3.6 as much as the same vote cast in California. How can that be, you might ask? It’s easy to see, when you do the math. Although Wyoming had a population in the last census of only 563,767, it gets 3 votes in the Electoral College based on its two Senators and one Congressman. California has 55 electoral votes. That sounds like a lot more, but it isn’t when you consider the size of the state. The population of California in the last census was 37,254,503, and that means that the electoral votes per capita in California are a lot less. To put it another way, the three electors in Wyoming represent an average of 187,923 residents each. The 55 electors in California represent an average of 677,355 each, and that’s a disparity of 3.6 to 1." [0].

[0] E.g., http://www.huffingtonpost.com/william-petrocelli/its-time-to...

Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by charles-salvia on Saturday March 11, 2017 @10:49AM (#13845770)
> The Electoral College doesn't 'reduce the weight of votes coming from inner-cities and urban areas'; it allocates votes to states in roughly proportion to population.

It does reduce the weight of votes coming from inner cities, because it does not allocate votes proportionally all the time. The disparity occurs most obviously between the high populated states like New York, California, and Texas, compared with very low-population states like Montana or Wyoming. I live in New York, so my individual vote is worth less than someone living in Wyoming or Montana.

Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by noobiemcfoob on Thursday March 09, 2017 @05:52PM (#13834593)
I'd like to see some data for that 80% urban population statement. Unless the definition of "dense suburbs" is outlandish, I can't see the percentage getting that high. Most studies I've seen put the US at a fair rural to urban split that up until very recently has always favored the rural population. It is only in the past 10 years that we've approached 50% urban to rural.

I know this to be true in North Carolina, and various readings about elsewhere make me believe it to be the case for the greater US.

Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by charles-salvia on Friday March 10, 2017 @02:31PM (#13841339)
You're right - the 80% is exaggerated. I got it from https://www.census.gov/geo/reference/ua/urban-rural-2010.htm.... Their definition of "urban" is actually outlandish, in that it includes "urban clusters", which means towns that have > 2,500 and < 50,000 inhabitants. I assumed the 80% just included all the sprawling, dense suburbs, but I see the definition the census is using here is much looser.
Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by ptaipale on Friday March 10, 2017 @01:15AM (#13836751)
Of course I know it's complicated; I was making a simplification to express a point. The violence in cities wouldn't make me want to give the violent more voice in making decisions, rather to the contrary.

And the votes of those who are second-past-the-post are not "nullified"; they just didn't win. We have a different system (d'Hondt) and it has its drawbacks as well.

Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by InitialLastName on Thursday March 09, 2017 @05:36PM (#13834487)
It doesn't help when voter suppression efforts make access to voting rights prohibitive to people in cities, especially the poor. 4 hour lines to vote (because there are fewer polling places) are painful even when your livelihood isn't on the line.
Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by ptaipale on Friday March 10, 2017 @01:08AM (#13836731)
That's is something I don't understand: how come these cities cannot arrange enough polling stations? After all, if they're Democrat majority, it would be in interests of Democrat-elected local officials to arrange enough polling places.

(Another thing I have a hard time understanding is that Americans allow people to vote even if they have no ID. Over here, it's a basic requirement for democracy that only those vote who have the right to vote, and they each vote only once.)

Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by Decade on Thursday March 09, 2017 @12:33PM (#13830962)
Some of the resentment is because cities are no longer aspirational. In the old days, if you are unhappy with your life, then you move to the city and make a new life. These days, you can’t even imagine moving to the city, because one month of rent will wipe out years of savings.

http://idiosyncraticwhisk.blogspot.com/2015/11/housing-serie...

https://medium.com/@laurafooteclark/how-do-we-avoid-another-...

Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by neltnerb on Thursday March 09, 2017 @01:01PM (#13831270)
I don't think there's anything broken just because you feel both sympathy and resentment for the same people. The real world is complicated, and it's good that you're able to admit that you have this internal conflict.

I will point out that there is one big blind spot I'm seeing in stuff like this. I suspect that you're conflating middle class white voters in conservative cities with poor rural white people and lumping them all together as "white rural voters". You shouldn't assume that they're a bloc, even in California lots of people are conservative and vice versa.

Every state has lots of open minded people who just want to find joy in their lives like everyone else. I grew up in Indiana, and if we want to go full anecdote, one example is my Boy Scout leader saying he'd stand by me against the national organization's anti-gay policies if push came to shove. Or NOBCChE letting me in because there was no other way to do the science fair at my high school. They didn't even tell me what NOBCChE stood for, and somehow I literally never noticed that I was the only person there who wasn't black. There are good people everywhere. Everywhere.

I have very little resentment for poor white people. I am very resentful of well off people voting for their own power, comfort, religious authority, and low taxes over the well being and safety of millions of people.

The data is enlightening, and I'll refrain from editorializing it: http://www.cnn.com/election/results/exit-polls

So yeah, I'm very sympathetic to anyone who is having a hard time. Especially those who see no way out. But that doesn't mean I'm okay with things that hurt me and my friends -- especially when that pain inflicted does nothing to actually alleviate anyone else's problems.

Kicking out immigrants or forcing gays into the closet or preventing transgender people from using the bathroom or preventing minorities from voting or making Jews fear for their lives won't help the opioid crisis or provide financial security. Treating these things like they are in any way intrinsically related is a huge problem in framing that results in poor tactics.

Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by throwanem on Thursday March 09, 2017 @12:05PM (#13830647)
Do you need to feel involved at an emotional level with the problems of your fellow citizens - problems which limit their ability to participate positively in our society to the gain of all - in order to consider it worthwhile that our government take those problems seriously? If so, why so?

I ask because this seems a very strange fashion in which to approach such a matter. On the one hand, you seem by your comment here very concerned with the possibility that one effect of these issues going unchecked is the election of a president with whom I presume you gravely disagree on almost every issue. On the other hand, your analysis of the issues themselves, and the value of efforts directed at mitigating or resolving them, seems entirely colored by the degree of emotional involvement you feel with the people who are most directly affected.

I don't understand this perspective at all, and I'm hoping you will take the time to explain what about it you find as sensible as your comment here strongly suggests you do.

Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by rtx on Thursday March 09, 2017 @11:51AM (#13830511)
Would you sympathise with someone who blames his problems on slavery?
Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by charles-salvia on Thursday March 09, 2017 @12:24PM (#13830852)
I would say it's counter-productive - but at least a direct causal line can be drawn between slavery and the current lower average socio-economic status of black people in the US. Whereas, there is absolutely no causal line between the current plight of poor white people and Mexican immigrants/Islamic terrorism.
Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by intopieces on Friday March 10, 2017 @01:01PM (#13840603)
Not trying to derail the topic, but is Islamic terrorism a claimed cause for the plight of poor white people? If anything, Islamic terrorism is a boon to poor white people. US Military will provide a decent cash influx at sign-up, fund education, and provide a steady paycheck for a few years.
Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by exolymph on Thursday March 09, 2017 @12:02PM (#13830609)
The distinction is that slavery is actually bad — a human rights atrocity with centuries of fallout — whereas globalization is (according to the liberal worldview) good.

I mostly share the liberal worldview.

Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by throwanem on Thursday March 09, 2017 @12:07PM (#13830663)
That's an interesting distinction. On its face it suggests that some human rights atrocities are more morally acceptable than others, but I can't imagine how such a reading might be accurate to fact.
Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by exolymph on Friday March 10, 2017 @12:39PM (#13840372)
What part of my comment suggests "that some human rights atrocities are more morally acceptable than others"?
Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by gmarx on Thursday March 09, 2017 @12:02PM (#13830605)
charles-salvia- the following is not directed against you because you seem to have some insight into your own prejudices.

Just about everyone is bigoted against some group or other.

The fascinating thing is that this now has a meta-component, that is, the perceived bigotry of an out group is one of the rationales for the moral acceptability of bigotry against them.

Of course to most people who have such bigotry they would never call it such.

I do hope down voting this comment helps others deal with the cognitive dissonance.

Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by dbcurtis on Thursday March 09, 2017 @11:54AM (#13830539)
Actually you are making some very broad generalizations based on little data.
Re:Is It Better to Be Poor in Bangladesh or the Mississippi ... by InitialLastName on Thursday March 09, 2017 @05:32PM (#13834453)
In one sense, this is a little true: It's easier and more efficient to provide access to the various safety net services in a city. Just like you can support a niche store in a big city that would never see enough customers to survive in a small town. Population density improves the "customer":"provider resource" ratio.

Access to lots of other services is better too... In the core of the large city I live in, there are so many emergency rooms/clinics that it would be difficult to be outside of walking distance of emergency care. That's much harder to do (and a poor allocation of resources) in rural Oklahoma, but it means my access to medical care is dramatically better.