http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=4%2F3+pi+*+(radius+of+m...
http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=1.617%C3%9710%5E19+joul...
Assuming you had no losses, so say ideal superconducting coils, that's how much energy you have to dump into magnetic field. You can do this as slow as you like, so with 1/10 the US electrical energy production it would take 10 years to build up that magnetic field. Hypothetically, if you had thin-film plastic PV cells (like cellophane thin to be reasonable to build and get into space) with 100% efficiency covering the footprint of this system (Mars) you could generate enough power to charge up this field in 471 seconds:
http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=1e19+J+%2F+((solar+powe...)
Of course the big story here is that efficient thin film solar in space could generate obscene amounts of power.
I'm not sure on the depth of the field volume required, so that might make it easier, too.
Presumably, though, some of the power generated could be used to accelerate propellant to compensate.
For a deeper cut, see https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/94273/what-force...
https://twitter.com/humansareawesme/status/83696170574585856...
We should be so lucky. Planetary scale can be rather large and slow. For instance the oxygenation of the Earth's atmosphere took hundreds of millions of years
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxygenation_Event#Time_l...
It's extremely unlikely that we can pull it off in a human lifespan but I would bet that planetary oxygenation is possible given a few millennia
The industrial revolution has been going since before 1800 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Industrial_Revolution
So, yes if the magnet dipole were the size of Mars and it needed to be 5mT=500,000nT at 320 Mars diameters, then roughly (ignoring higher order effects) you would need an average 16kT around the surface poles, which isn't possible with current technology.
At 1 Tesla you would want to cover an area 50 times the diameter than Mars? That's pretty fanciful.
OK, either my simple calculations are bunk, or this is a truly crazy idea.
So with the mentioned 1-2 Tesla starting field, we end up and a cube law reducing the strength 200x at 6 times the distance, and a 1.5km moment. That would require at least 2-3km^2 of 1T magnets. Ignoring the support structure that would have a volume of ~10^10 cm^3 and weigh 100ktons, but only cost $100B on Earth at todays Samarium Cobalt pricing, if the market wasn't highly distorted.
Sounds more reasonable...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_artificial_radiation_b...
He said the best plan for a shield for Mars is a 500,000 nanoTesla field at L1 which is 320 Mars radii away from Mars.
Maybe I am misunderstanding what he is saying or pronouncing, nanoTesla i.e. billionths of a Tesla?
I mean, I know that's a stable Lagrange point, but you have to wonder if it could end up moving and or spinning around after enough solar flares hit it and what that would do.
It takes on the order of hundreds of millions of years to lose that much atmosphere.
Or we could at least use this as an indicator that the problem is solvable over a few centuries and start nuking. Better sooner than later!
The first is how big does the structure need to be? I can buy a 1 Tesla magnet online right now but that's probably not what they're thinking of. Would we need a city-sized coil or something like that?
The second is the time scale. They say that the temperature could rise by 4 Celsius and trigger a greenhouse effect, but is that an immediate effect (10 years or so) or century-scale effect? I'm hoping the scientists put out a paper because I'd love to learn more about the specifics of their proposal.