Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere
by eloff on Sunday March 05, 2017 @03:59PM
(#13798582)
It's not located on/at Mars, it's located at the Lagrange point - which means much like your hand can cover entire mountains at a distance, a smaller magnetic field could shield an entire planet when positioned between mars and the sun.
Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere
by kurthr on Sunday March 05, 2017 @04:25PM
(#13798774)
Based on the drawing that they made the size is at least 1-2 diameters of mars (but there is no field there?). Since the diameter of Mars is ~4000mi that would >10,000km at 5mT.
So with the mentioned 1-2 Tesla starting field, we end up and a cube law reducing the strength 200x at 6 times the distance, and a 1.5km moment. That would require at least 2-3km^2 of 1T magnets. Ignoring the support structure that would have a volume of ~10^10 cm^3 and weigh 100ktons, but only cost $100B on Earth at todays Samarium Cobalt pricing, if the market wasn't highly distorted.
Sounds more reasonable...
Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere
by LeanderK on Sunday March 05, 2017 @04:44PM
(#13798894)
sounds surprisingly realistic if you consider that this is a proposal to create an artificial magnetic shield for an entire planet.
Re:NASA proposes a magnetic shield to protect Mars' atmosphere
by tankenmate on Sunday March 05, 2017 @04:46PM
(#13798911)
Also, isn't there a shockwave effect?
So, yes if the magnet dipole were the size of Mars and it needed to be 5mT=500,000nT at 320 Mars diameters, then roughly (ignoring higher order effects) you would need an average 16kT around the surface poles, which isn't possible with current technology.
At 1 Tesla you would want to cover an area 50 times the diameter than Mars? That's pretty fanciful.
OK, either my simple calculations are bunk, or this is a truly crazy idea.