News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by JoeAltmaier on Sunday March 05, 2017 @10:07AM (#13796237)
So, the value of PI is a human invention? That's hogwash.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by GavinMcG on Sunday March 05, 2017 @10:36AM (#13796368)
This is an odd reading of the parent comment, since "apart from that" indicated that mathematical truths being built in isn't what the commenter disagreed with.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by cannonpr on Sunday March 05, 2017 @10:10AM (#13796252)
Don't you feel it's a bit harsh to summarise the entire debate between idealism and realism as hogwash ?
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by JoeAltmaier on Sunday March 05, 2017 @10:32AM (#13796344)
Just echoing the parent post there.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by FabHK on Sunday March 05, 2017 @04:05PM (#13798626)
> Don't you feel it's a bit harsh to summarise the entire debate between idealism and realism as hogwash ?

Granted, a bit harsh :-) There's more to be said about it. But remember how Ford Prefect wrote volumes about earth in the Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, and then it was abridged to "Mostly harmless"? So that was (my) very abridged version of idealism.

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by lacker on Sunday March 05, 2017 @02:27PM (#13797974)
A circle is a human invention. There are no perfect circles in the universe.

Euclidean geometry is a human invention. In the real world, spacetime is curved.

Real numbers are a human invention. The universe does not seem to be built of numbers with infinite precision.

I would go further and say that the number "two" is a human invention. The universe could carry on just fine without any life anywhere having the concept of "two". But the case is certainly stronger for calculus and geometry being human inventions, than it is for number theory.

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by raattgift on Sunday March 05, 2017 @03:46PM (#13798503)
> In the real world, spacetime is curved

Why is curved spacetime (in the sense of an infinitely differentiable pseudo-Riemannian manifold with a Lorentzian metric) not a human invention while Euclidean geometry (a limiting case of such a manifold) is?

> The universe does not seem to be built of numbers with infinite precision

What's your definition of spacetime? It's not that of General Relativity, if you deny infinitesimals.

I think you're stuck either with accepting curvature and infinitesimals and the involvement in pi in the relationships between a set of points at a small fixed spacelike distance from an origin, or you're stuck with denying curvature as anything other than a coarse approximation of some manifold with a non-Lorentzian taxicab-like metric.

Minimum lengths (abolishing infinitesimals) have been proposed theoretically, and we can readily parameterize with a minimum length equations like the Dirac equation or the Klein-Gordon equation or like the Lagrangian of the Standard Model, and in doing so we see pretty plainly that the Lorentz transformations of Special Relativity must be modified. One concrete modification is the theory of Doubly Special Relativity whose length cutoff is the Planck length. It predicts an energy-dependent speed of light, and that is contradicted by evidence (gamma rays do not win races with infrared rays in near vacuum). Other similar deformations of Special Relativity have been advanced, and they also conflict with experiment and observation, unless the minimum length goes to zero, or other physical quantities are (counter-)parameterized pushing the observation-and-experiment conflict elsewhere. (One programme for this sort of research is the Standard Model Extension).

> The universe could carry on just fine without any life anywhere having the concept of "two"

The universe could carry on just fine without any life period. Indeed, it almost certainly did in our distant past. However, there is pretty conclusive evidence that there were quadratic relations among various physical quantities in the earlier universe, notably the inverse square laws for electrostatics and gravitation. It seems extreme to blame that on humans...

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by danbruc on Sunday March 05, 2017 @09:11PM (#13800239)
However, there is pretty conclusive evidence that there were quadratic relations among various physical quantities in the earlier universe, notably the inverse square laws for electrostatics and gravitation. It seems extreme to blame that on humans...

I will repeat one of my comment from yesterday [1] as we argued about the same topic.

I want to argue that whenever you think that there is some math already contained in the universe, it is actually you accidentally introducing it without noticing it. Look, trees! One, two, three, ... See? There are numbers in the universe. And look, I can add the number of trees in this wood and that wood.

It is of course tempting to conclude that the math was already there. But I argue that it was not, that it is you inventing it. It is your concept of object identity that defines what a tree is and when two trees are the same or different trees, you divide the world into different objects. It is your concept of grouping objects into sets. It is your concept of pairing the elements of two different sets to compare their cardinalities. It is your concept of including one more element in a set that defines what counting means. It is your concept of combining two sets that defines what addition is.

That are all things you can do with objects in the universe, but nothing of that is inherent. If you look carefully enough, all the things that look like math already exists in the universe actually require you making use of a lot of abstract man-made concepts. Many of them, like object identity and counting, are just so deeply ingrained in us that you don't notice that you are using them if you don't pay careful attention.

That is why I asked for the empty universe, I wanted to take away all the objects on which you could accidentally impose structure. If math were truly fundamental, if Platonism were true, then seven should still exist in an empty universe. I don't see how this would be true in any meaningful way.

If we added a mathematician to our empty universe, he could invent math. He could come up with the idea of objects and identity and sets of objects and he could think about operations with those objects and consequences of the definitions he made. But it would all have no relation to the otherwise empty universe, it would be a game of formal rules, mostly manipulating strings of symbols. If the mathematician had great imagination, maybe he could imagine actual things existing in the universe, how he could label them with those numbers he invented, and how he could visualize addition by moving things around.

In another comment I argued the same for your example of the inverse-square law. It is you who decided how to measure distance. It is you who decided to look at spherical shells around a charge. Nothing of this is inherent. I could easily make it an inverse-cube law by adopting a different measure of distance. I could decide to look at boxes instead of spheres and ruin the symmetry. It is certainly correct that there are more and less natural choices, but I don't think that is a good enough argument to conclude that some preferred math is intrinsic.

Particles flowing outwards from an isotropic source with constant velocity in straight lines in three-dimensional Euclidean space will generate a density field following an inverse square-law. But that is not intrinsic, it is just a useful description of the situations, by itself there are only particles traveling at constant velocity in straight lines. Systems with simple rules, especially all systems with chaotic behavior, can produce behavior with staggering complexity requiring some serious math to describe, but, by itself, there are just many things following simple rules and interacting with each other according to simple rules.

Give me a large enough pile of sand and I will use it to implement set theory on top of it. And then on top of set theory a huge part of math. Does that mean that grains of sand include most of mathematics? That does not sound reasonable to me. I believe people are confusing the ability of describing things with math or implementing math on top of something with the thing already containing the math. Also note that there often many ways to treat the same thing, are they all equally intrinsic?

That all seems very similar to the general question of existence. Do all books and pictures already exist, including those that will be written or taken in the future? An empty SD card certainly has the ability to contain them, I just have to flip the correct bits. To me it seem to simply stretch the definition of existence way to much to declare that everything I can imagine or everything I could create already exists. So being able to do arbitrary math with grains of sand or being able to describe what is going on in the universe with math does similarly not imply that math already exists.

That became way longer and repetitive than intended. On the other hand I repeatedly failed yesterday to convey my argument, so I will just leave it as it is.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13794255

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by raattgift on Monday March 06, 2017 @12:37AM (#13800897)
> as we argued about the same topic yesterday

I replied to one of your comments in a topic that was not [1] and not even obviously related. Additionally there was no argument as you did not reply. So I'm thoroughly confused by your implied context.

I'm a wishy-washy formalist and know some things about Boltzmann Brains as a theoretical diagnostic on de Sitter universes with slow-rolling inflationary fields, so I'm OK with your last two italicized paragraphs ("This is why I asked..." and "If we added a..."), but completely disagree with your subsequent non-italicized text.

In particular, geometry is a feature of nature. The Earth is round to a close approximation, and that is an observer-independent fact, not a convention.

> Does that mean that grains of sand include most of mathematics?

Of course not, but grains of sand include atoms and subatomic particles and those have features that are the same in non-sand substances in the various parts of the the solar system we have directly explored. We can describe those features in whatever language we want; but names, like sets of coordinates, are not features of nature.

Indeed, in the past century we've gotten much better at distinguishing between features which are observer-dependent (even if not obviously so) and features which are not.

In your sand argument, the pile of sand has some observer-independent features and some which are not. The number of the grains of sand in the pile is an observer-independent quantity, even if nobody actually counts them.

Formal models may be incorrect, but physical (as in not unphysical) ones attempt to describe real observer-independent features of nature. I don't think there are many physicists who, arriving at a novel prediction of a formal mode, would do anything other than "trust (or mistrust) but verify"; even the craziest model-building theoreticians I can think of are hungry for contact with nature via controlled experiment.

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by JoeAltmaier on Sunday March 05, 2017 @07:24PM (#13799813)
That's what mathematics is - not the real world. Thus thee ratio of PI is the same in any universe.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by FabHK on Sunday March 05, 2017 @04:02PM (#13798603)
No, as I meant to say with the "apart from that" - mathematical truths are clearly interpersonally verifiable and arguably "out there" to be discovered, not invented.

I'm disagreeing with the overly poetic language of "touching immortality" etc. (and German idealism... but that's another topic)

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by omalleyt on Sunday March 05, 2017 @10:41AM (#13796400)
The concept of "circle" is a human invention, in that a perfect circle has never been observed in the universe. The value of pi follows immediately as a derivative human invention.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by coldtea on Sunday March 05, 2017 @12:58PM (#13797309)
>The concept of "circle" is a human invention, in that a perfect circle has never been observed in the universe.

It doesn't have to be observed as some material manifestation to be a discovery. Notions can also exist outside human intervention and shape the universe.

Which is also why humans can discover such things (like pi) in parallel, without one discoverer ever having been in contact with the other.

Or why even aliens can discover the same concepts.

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by omalleyt on Monday March 06, 2017 @05:50AM (#13801864)
Ok, but how would you define "human invention" if not as "something that didn't previously have a material manifestation"?
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by justifier on Sunday March 05, 2017 @11:27AM (#13796697)
I would argue the 'perfect circle' is inherent in every circle, similarly to how it is inherent in your dismissal of it

But if you require a more direct understanding I would say there is a perfect circle in every rotation

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by szemet on Sunday March 05, 2017 @12:49PM (#13797240)
Yes, if you take something like "Minimum Description Length principle", there may exists circles in physical world that are best (most economically) described with a perfect circle + some noise.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by kordless on Sunday March 05, 2017 @11:36AM (#13796756)
The possibility of a perfect circle exists in this universe, but the last digit we are aware of is definitely a posteriori. In other words, the description of a circle is prior knowledge given it allows calculating pi, but the actual values are post observational knowledge, given they must be calculated and continue to be irrational forever. (At least as far as we know.)

It would take an infinite amount of power to calculate every digit in pi, given pi itself is irrational, even while describing how to calculate it is rational.

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by justifier on Sunday March 05, 2017 @11:47AM (#13796829)
You are moving someone else's goalposts

I answered where circles are in our universe and you then try to change the original intent of omalleyt's question to mean a symbolic representation of pi

> It would take an infinite amount of power to calculate every digit in pi

Calculating pi is so simple life without nervous systems does it

Now, expressing that value in our limited yet overly verbose base ten symbolic representation would indeed require infinite recursion

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by kordless on Sunday March 05, 2017 @12:02PM (#13796939)
I'm not aware of a means by which goal posts can exist in a philosophical debate around rational vs. irrational thinking. Both types of thinking are valid, but I can see how and why some tend to argue for absolute rationality at all times.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by justifier on Sunday March 05, 2017 @12:33PM (#13797143)
I apologise, I thought you were implying that what omalleyt 'really meant' was a perfect circle is data we can calculate

It seemed to me you were changing the question that was being asked, and a question asked implies an answer, or 'goal post'

But if you were just developing new inquiry stead building off omalleyt then I apologise and would hope to encourage like critical thinking in the future

.. Thinking on it 'goal posts'.. and 'soap box' elsewhere in this thread.. lacks a timeless quality, I really should have left it out ;P

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by kordless on Tuesday March 07, 2017 @01:34AM (#13808672)
I asked my daughters friend why pi was irrational, and she said "because you have to calculate it". The knowledge of those calculations cannot be given, but the way to calculate it, with a bit of suffering, can.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by szemet on Sunday March 05, 2017 @12:55PM (#13797281)
"It would take an infinite amount of power to calculate every digit in pi"

Representation by digits is just one representation. We have plenty of finite representations: http://mathworld.wolfram.com/PiFormulas.html

Base 10 notation also requires a calculation to get the concrete number: You have to sum and multiply and power a lot

(Imagine whole numbers described in base 10, now how you get that number of something?)

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by wyager on Sunday March 05, 2017 @01:19PM (#13797476)
> a perfect circle has never been observed in the universe

Yeah, that's not true. Many things in the universe have perfectly spherical or spheroid shapes, cross sections, or propagation patterns, like black holes or isotropic EM emissions or (more abstractly) light cones.

Pi is baked into the laws of physics in many locations as a consequence of the geometric behavior of our spacetime. It would also be baked into a lot of other plausible spacetimes. It's hard to quantify exactly what causes it to come up so much, but it's probably the fact that our universe is locally Euclidean and therefore uses the L2-norm for distance, which gives rise to circles/spheres as the unit shape and the extrema of a number of optimization problems.

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by nurettin on Sunday March 05, 2017 @11:42AM (#13796796)
The value of pi is apparent in nature. You can experimentally deduce it by measuring the magnetic permeability or coulomb force without knowing of a circle at all.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by cft on Sunday March 05, 2017 @12:07PM (#13796964)
It will still reduce to the length of a circle, otherwise it's just a units convention.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by amelius on Sunday March 05, 2017 @12:18PM (#13797036)
As far as we know, only at certain length scales and to a certain precision.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by tyingq on Sunday March 05, 2017 @11:32AM (#13796725)
How far from a perfect circle is the event horizon of a black hole? Or, closer...Is the slight bulge in our Sun statistically that far off from perfect?
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by komali2 on Sunday March 05, 2017 @12:20PM (#13797052)
Enough to be considered imperfect.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by tyingq on Sunday March 05, 2017 @12:37PM (#13797164)
But with known reasons for why it isn't perfect. And math that works fine if you round to a reasonable degree.

Edit: "Scaled to the size of a beach ball, say scientists, the sun's equatorial bulge would be less than the width of a human hair"[1]

And, I assume the defects in the event horizon of a black hole are even more negligible.

[1]https://www.theguardian.com/science/2012/aug/16/sun-perfect-...

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by platz on Sunday March 05, 2017 @01:46PM (#13797686)
It is still going to be fuzzy at the Planck length.

I'm not sure quantum mechanics and infinite precision are reconcilable

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by tyingq on Sunday March 05, 2017 @01:54PM (#13797742)
Yes...I'm having trouble verbalizing what I'm trying to say.

Basically trying to say that Pi, to me, doesn't appear to be a man-made construct. Any naturally occurring circle that's near perfect seems to illustrate that. Any deviation from a Pi-derived shape has plausible reasons for the defect, like the one you point out.

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by jknoepfler on Sunday March 05, 2017 @12:23PM (#13797073)
The means of systematizing, expressing, reasoning about, computing with, and teaching about pi are human inventions. Does pi amount to more than the sum of its human parts? You can say "hogwash," but that's not contributing much to a question that requires a careful answer
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by ThomPete on Sunday March 05, 2017 @10:17AM (#13796285)
Who else invented it?
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by kordless on Sunday March 05, 2017 @11:27AM (#13796694)
There are some aggregates who hold as a truth that some mathematics constructs, such as a circle, are "prior to knowledge". This is summarized, at length, by Kant in his argument for some truths being a priori, or before knowledge. Kant's stated purpose of his critique of such logic was a proof of god, or a higher state of being.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by ThomPete on Sunday March 05, 2017 @11:58AM (#13796899)
A priori just means assumed to be true which goes to the very heart of the problems with this discussion.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by JoeAltmaier on Sunday March 05, 2017 @10:31AM (#13796342)
That question presupposed it was invented. Its just there. To be discovered. Its not different somewhere else; it wouldn't be different in a different universe.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by ThomPete on Sunday March 05, 2017 @11:00AM (#13796500)
I don't think you are aware of what you are claiming.

If something is "out there" as a specific concept as you claim, then it requires a perspective to isolate it as "a thing" which means you are basically claiming there must have been a creator.

If there is no creator then there is no perspective other than that of observers like us.

Unless you of course claim that the classical physical universe is fundamental not the quantum physical one.

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by wyager on Sunday March 05, 2017 @01:34PM (#13797588)
> then it requires a perspective to isolate it as "a thing" which means you are basically claiming there must have been a creator.

This statement doesn't follow. They're entirely unrelated claims.

> If there is no creator then there is no perspective other than that of observers like us... the quantum physical one.

Stop trying to integrate pseudo-quantum physics into hokey philosophical arguments. You don't know what you're talking about, and it detracts from any value the argument might otherwise have.

Humans are not unique as "observers" in quantum physics. Air molecules appear to work as well. We haven't solved the measurement problem, but we know enough to say that it almost certainly doesn't have any bearing on arguments about platonic realism.

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by mcbits on Sunday March 05, 2017 @02:42PM (#13798075)
Where does one cloud end and the next cloud begin? The boundaries and distinctive traits of clouds only exist in our minds.

We can build mathematical objects that look something like clouds according to the observable characteristics deemed intrinsic to our definition of "cloud". We can't simulate real cloud systems with arbitrary fidelity because the the mathematical foundation we've invented leads rapidly to intractable computation. "But supposing we had infinite computation" is magical thinking.

Still, the universe gives us clouds. It's operating on different foundational principles.

Now, moving from sky clouds to things like electron clouds, we have the added problem of what appears to be "true" non-computable randomness (not just chaos) underlying it all. Many worlds doesn't rid us of the randomness problem but merely shifts it to the problem of deciding which branch we inhabit before/after an event.

We can still hang onto the notion of mathematics as discovery by recognizing it as a process of self-discovery about how our brains perceive the world.

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by ThomPete on Sunday March 05, 2017 @02:15PM (#13797893)
Who claimed we were unique observers? Please stop your strawmen and please stop cutting sentence of a larger discussion into pieces to try and dismiss them.

Air-molecules doesn't change anything with regards to the claim that things exist "out there" non what so ever.

If your only beef is that you don't think I know anything about QM then I will live with that.

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by kordless on Sunday March 05, 2017 @11:30AM (#13796717)
I don't think you are aware of what is claiming this. ;)

Perspective matters in terms of "proving" something outside of observation, by the assumed fact observation can change perspective.

In other words, if all of this is a single entity, it's going to be hard to prove that because bits would exist outside perception due to the cost of it being a recursive operation. One may not know oneself without recursion.

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by ThomPete on Sunday March 05, 2017 @11:45AM (#13796818)
You are also missing the point.

If something exist "out there" as a separate concept then it can only do so because it exist as a discreet entity.

Yet QM shows us that the world isn't fundamentally discreet but rather non-local.

We can observe because there is a discreet universe to observe within, but that does not make the observable universe the foundation of reality.

And so if you want to claim that something exist out there without there being a designer or without our perspective of reality being what turn it into existence then you need to explain how it relates to the entire universe not just the classical one.

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by wyager on Sunday March 05, 2017 @01:37PM (#13797622)
> Yet QM shows us that the world isn't fundamentally discreet but rather non-local

No, it doesn't show us that. A number of collapse theories (notably many worlds) have non-locality baked in, but we don't know if they're correct.

Please stop trying to use QM in philosophy arguments. If you do, you're almost certainly misunderstanding what it entails.

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by danbruc on Sunday March 05, 2017 @01:57PM (#13797767)
No, it doesn't show us that. A number of collapse theories (notably many worlds) have non-locality baked in, but we don't know if they're correct.

Entanglement seems to be fundamentally non-local - unless you posit hidden variables - and does not depend on the interpretation.

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by wyager on Sunday March 05, 2017 @02:49PM (#13798128)
It is not. Theories like einselection explain entanglement with only local effects (via superselection rules).
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by ThomPete on Sunday March 05, 2017 @02:55PM (#13798161)
It's ironic that you go on to use something as an argument against non-locality which I think it's safe to say there is even less actual consensus about.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by wyager on Sunday March 05, 2017 @02:56PM (#13798171)
In what way is it ironic? I'm just pointing out that you don't seem to be aware of the entire solution space.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by ThomPete on Sunday March 05, 2017 @03:00PM (#13798181)
I am well aware of the solution space just as I am aware that the one your are proposing isn't even close to being what one would consider having solid foundation.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by ThomPete on Sunday March 05, 2017 @02:09PM (#13797858)
Non-locality is baked in because the theories are based on that principle. They are not invented to make the theory make sense.

Bells theorem shows that there is actually "spooky action at a distance".

So I am not using some arbitrary collapse theory in QM as a philosophy argument I am using Bells theorem which happens to be one of the most important experiments in the field of QM as I am sure you know better than anyone.

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by wyager on Sunday March 05, 2017 @02:52PM (#13798146)
No, that is not what bell's theorem does. Bell's theorem rules out local hidden variable theories. It leaves open multiple explanations for how entanglement works, including subjective collapse, nonlocal effects, superdeterminism, etc.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by ThomPete on Sunday March 05, 2017 @02:58PM (#13798175)
Sure but to claim that non-locality is an interpretation on the same line as ex Einselection is just absurd to say the least.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by kordless on Sunday March 05, 2017 @12:06PM (#13796953)
I would argue it with irrationality, which is the point here. Science can't be used inside a frame of reference to refer to something outside that frame without being irrational. The point the scientific principle becomes irrational is the point people start demanding an explanation.

I would also say that it is possible we are all missing the point.

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by ThomPete on Sunday March 05, 2017 @12:49PM (#13797241)
What is outside the frame of reference?

QM isn't outside the frame of reference of the scientific method though. It's as proven mathematically and empirically as general relativity is.

So the only irrational thing here would be to claim that the quantum world isn't as real as the classical physical world.

Agree on the last part though. we might (are most likely) all be missing the point