News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by ThomPete on Sunday March 05, 2017 @10:17AM (#13796285)
Who else invented it?
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by kordless on Sunday March 05, 2017 @11:27AM (#13796694)
There are some aggregates who hold as a truth that some mathematics constructs, such as a circle, are "prior to knowledge". This is summarized, at length, by Kant in his argument for some truths being a priori, or before knowledge. Kant's stated purpose of his critique of such logic was a proof of god, or a higher state of being.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by ThomPete on Sunday March 05, 2017 @11:58AM (#13796899)
A priori just means assumed to be true which goes to the very heart of the problems with this discussion.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by JoeAltmaier on Sunday March 05, 2017 @10:31AM (#13796342)
That question presupposed it was invented. Its just there. To be discovered. Its not different somewhere else; it wouldn't be different in a different universe.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by ThomPete on Sunday March 05, 2017 @11:00AM (#13796500)
I don't think you are aware of what you are claiming.

If something is "out there" as a specific concept as you claim, then it requires a perspective to isolate it as "a thing" which means you are basically claiming there must have been a creator.

If there is no creator then there is no perspective other than that of observers like us.

Unless you of course claim that the classical physical universe is fundamental not the quantum physical one.

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by wyager on Sunday March 05, 2017 @01:34PM (#13797588)
> then it requires a perspective to isolate it as "a thing" which means you are basically claiming there must have been a creator.

This statement doesn't follow. They're entirely unrelated claims.

> If there is no creator then there is no perspective other than that of observers like us... the quantum physical one.

Stop trying to integrate pseudo-quantum physics into hokey philosophical arguments. You don't know what you're talking about, and it detracts from any value the argument might otherwise have.

Humans are not unique as "observers" in quantum physics. Air molecules appear to work as well. We haven't solved the measurement problem, but we know enough to say that it almost certainly doesn't have any bearing on arguments about platonic realism.

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by mcbits on Sunday March 05, 2017 @02:42PM (#13798075)
Where does one cloud end and the next cloud begin? The boundaries and distinctive traits of clouds only exist in our minds.

We can build mathematical objects that look something like clouds according to the observable characteristics deemed intrinsic to our definition of "cloud". We can't simulate real cloud systems with arbitrary fidelity because the the mathematical foundation we've invented leads rapidly to intractable computation. "But supposing we had infinite computation" is magical thinking.

Still, the universe gives us clouds. It's operating on different foundational principles.

Now, moving from sky clouds to things like electron clouds, we have the added problem of what appears to be "true" non-computable randomness (not just chaos) underlying it all. Many worlds doesn't rid us of the randomness problem but merely shifts it to the problem of deciding which branch we inhabit before/after an event.

We can still hang onto the notion of mathematics as discovery by recognizing it as a process of self-discovery about how our brains perceive the world.

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by ThomPete on Sunday March 05, 2017 @02:15PM (#13797893)
Who claimed we were unique observers? Please stop your strawmen and please stop cutting sentence of a larger discussion into pieces to try and dismiss them.

Air-molecules doesn't change anything with regards to the claim that things exist "out there" non what so ever.

If your only beef is that you don't think I know anything about QM then I will live with that.

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by kordless on Sunday March 05, 2017 @11:30AM (#13796717)
I don't think you are aware of what is claiming this. ;)

Perspective matters in terms of "proving" something outside of observation, by the assumed fact observation can change perspective.

In other words, if all of this is a single entity, it's going to be hard to prove that because bits would exist outside perception due to the cost of it being a recursive operation. One may not know oneself without recursion.

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by ThomPete on Sunday March 05, 2017 @11:45AM (#13796818)
You are also missing the point.

If something exist "out there" as a separate concept then it can only do so because it exist as a discreet entity.

Yet QM shows us that the world isn't fundamentally discreet but rather non-local.

We can observe because there is a discreet universe to observe within, but that does not make the observable universe the foundation of reality.

And so if you want to claim that something exist out there without there being a designer or without our perspective of reality being what turn it into existence then you need to explain how it relates to the entire universe not just the classical one.

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by wyager on Sunday March 05, 2017 @01:37PM (#13797622)
> Yet QM shows us that the world isn't fundamentally discreet but rather non-local

No, it doesn't show us that. A number of collapse theories (notably many worlds) have non-locality baked in, but we don't know if they're correct.

Please stop trying to use QM in philosophy arguments. If you do, you're almost certainly misunderstanding what it entails.

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by danbruc on Sunday March 05, 2017 @01:57PM (#13797767)
No, it doesn't show us that. A number of collapse theories (notably many worlds) have non-locality baked in, but we don't know if they're correct.

Entanglement seems to be fundamentally non-local - unless you posit hidden variables - and does not depend on the interpretation.

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by wyager on Sunday March 05, 2017 @02:49PM (#13798128)
It is not. Theories like einselection explain entanglement with only local effects (via superselection rules).
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by ThomPete on Sunday March 05, 2017 @02:55PM (#13798161)
It's ironic that you go on to use something as an argument against non-locality which I think it's safe to say there is even less actual consensus about.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by wyager on Sunday March 05, 2017 @02:56PM (#13798171)
In what way is it ironic? I'm just pointing out that you don't seem to be aware of the entire solution space.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by ThomPete on Sunday March 05, 2017 @03:00PM (#13798181)
I am well aware of the solution space just as I am aware that the one your are proposing isn't even close to being what one would consider having solid foundation.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by ThomPete on Sunday March 05, 2017 @02:09PM (#13797858)
Non-locality is baked in because the theories are based on that principle. They are not invented to make the theory make sense.

Bells theorem shows that there is actually "spooky action at a distance".

So I am not using some arbitrary collapse theory in QM as a philosophy argument I am using Bells theorem which happens to be one of the most important experiments in the field of QM as I am sure you know better than anyone.

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by wyager on Sunday March 05, 2017 @02:52PM (#13798146)
No, that is not what bell's theorem does. Bell's theorem rules out local hidden variable theories. It leaves open multiple explanations for how entanglement works, including subjective collapse, nonlocal effects, superdeterminism, etc.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by ThomPete on Sunday March 05, 2017 @02:58PM (#13798175)
Sure but to claim that non-locality is an interpretation on the same line as ex Einselection is just absurd to say the least.
Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by kordless on Sunday March 05, 2017 @12:06PM (#13796953)
I would argue it with irrationality, which is the point here. Science can't be used inside a frame of reference to refer to something outside that frame without being irrational. The point the scientific principle becomes irrational is the point people start demanding an explanation.

I would also say that it is possible we are all missing the point.

Re:“When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.” by ThomPete on Sunday March 05, 2017 @12:49PM (#13797241)
What is outside the frame of reference?

QM isn't outside the frame of reference of the scientific method though. It's as proven mathematically and empirically as general relativity is.

So the only irrational thing here would be to claim that the quantum world isn't as real as the classical physical world.

Agree on the last part though. we might (are most likely) all be missing the point