Re:A list of movies about hacking
by CobrastanJorji on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:29PM
(#13769708)
This doesn't appear to be so much a curated list of much-watch movies so much as a list of all movies about hacking ever.
Here is my curated list of movies ever hacker and cyberpunk enthusiast must watch:
* Sneakers
* Ghost in the Shell
* Tron
Why is Tron there? Because the screenwriter loosely based the character around her husband. Who was her husband? Alan Kay. Tron's protagonist is Alan Kay.
Re:A list of movies about hacking
by sbuttgereit on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:47PM
(#13769886)
I think WarGames really should be on the list. It's old, yes, but it did influence a lot of us that were in that first generation of kids growing up with computers at home (though not many homes). It definitely captures a moment of time worth thinking about.
Re:A list of movies about hacking
by nickpsecurity on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:53PM
(#13769930)
Blackhat should probably be on there for being about only one to get hacking right in recent times.
"Because the screenwriter loosely based the character around her husband. Who was her husband? Alan Kay. Tron's protagonist is Alan Kay."
Had no clue his wife wrote it or portrayed him. That's neat! Brings in some irony given Tron character is fighting the slavery of MCP but Kay told me here on HN he loved Burroughs B5000. Also implied its lead creator, Bob Barton, was a genius and revolutionary overturning all the bad software, hardware, and engineering that came before it in one fell swoop. As in, the movie could've just as easily had MCP as the hero. ;)
Re:A list of movies about hacking
by CobrastanJorji on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:27PM
(#13770189)
I've never seen Patlabor. Sounds like I should.
And Sneakers, asides from the magic, encryption-breaking MacGuffin, is some of the most realistic hacking in movies. What's the preferred tactic of these tech geniuses? Basic social engineering. Sure, they know a lot of other tricks, but why figure out a clever way through the badge system if a cake and some birthday balloons will work just as well?
Re:A list of movies about hacking
by twic on Friday March 03, 2017 @02:41PM
(#13785628)
Patlabor is fun, and has some cool hacker-relevant stuff, but isn't a great and serious movie like Ghost in the Shell. I do recommend watching it, but with suitable expectations!
Re:A list of movies about hacking
by mcphage on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @10:06PM
(#13771080)
It has "Enemy of the State", its spiritual sequel (with Gene Hackman playing an almost identical character). But I agree, The Conversation should be on there, too; I have to admit it's a better movie, even though I love Will Smith.
Re:A list of movies about hacking
by prions on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:24PM
(#13769659)
Seeing this list inspired me to write about the list I keep for the books I read, many of them cyberpunk/scifi. After reading so many of these types of books, you can't help notice their elements in other media.
It's interesting in seeing the print inspirations for many of these movies. The term "The Matrix" was first coined in William Gibson's Neuromancer and considered to be the seminal Cyberpunk novel, even predating Ghost in the Shell.
Re:A list of movies about hacking
by virtualwhys on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:37PM
(#13769783)
Just read Neuromancer this summer. One of the benefits of renting random people's places are the libraries you run across; that was a great read (though somehow disturbing, mystical/mind blowing, and hollow inducing all at the same time).
Re:A list of movies about hacking
by lakkal on Friday March 03, 2017 @02:23PM
(#13785458)
You might like Vernor Vinge's 'True Names', too. There was a PDF of the story on the web a while back; I'm not sure of its legality so I won't link to it.
Re:A list of movies about hacking
by MichaelGG on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:44PM
(#13769861)
And for newer stuff, Richard K Morgan's Altered Carbon (2003) and 2 sequels really hit the spot. It's hard to find good gritty cyberpunk these days.
And it's not that old works are bad, just that some of the tech misses distract and take you out of the atmosphere sometimes. Like on Star Trek, when they have to physically deliver email to people on holodiscs.
I'd also note that Asimov's Robot series are great if you like hardboiled type stuff - not cyberpunk, but has a slightly similar ambiance.
Re:A list of movies about hacking
by Eric_WVGG on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:53PM
(#13769934)
I was very pleased to see The Italian Job make the list.
Hacking is about understanding, optimizing, and manipulating systems. One real-world analogue of a system is a Rube Goldberg machine; the dramatic analogue of a Rube Goldberg machine is a heist flick.
I'd add the Ocean's Eleven remake as an approachable introduction to the genre, and Kubrick's The Killing for vintage noir awesomeness. And maybe The Last Seduction as a curveball.
Black Mirror is missing here too, unfortunately. Several episodes revolve quite intelligently around AI, dystopian technological future, cognitive science.
Re:A list of movies about hacking
by oblio on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:45PM
(#13769865)
I'm going to go against the grain and say: don't watch these.
Or rather, don't prioritize watching these. Try to balance out movies and books related to your profession or hobby with those outside of it.
The world already has enough stereotypical geeks loving Ghost in the Shell, Star Wars and Star Trek, it needs more geeks having an interest in what "regular people" do and like.
Re:A list of movies about hacking
by duskwuff on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:52PM
(#13769922)
Not to mention, a lot of these movies are awful. For instance, the first movie on the list is, inexplicably, "WarGames: The Dead Code". Not the classic "WarGames", but a horrible direct-to-video sequel released in 2008.
Re:A list of movies about hacking
by GalacticCmdr on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:47PM
(#13769889)
That is rather offensively narrow-minded to think that "regular people" don't also enjoy those those movies. That simply having a job or hobby related to STEM somehow does not make you a regular person.
Re:A list of movies about hacking
by oblio on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:25PM
(#13770171)
I'm not saying regular people don't enjoy these. I'm saying that people in our field have a rather unhealthy fascination with a rather narrow set of topics.
Instead of having a laser focus even for our hobbies I'd advocate a wider range of hobbies.
Re:A list of movies about hacking
by taneq on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:05PM
(#13770452)
You don't know any actual "regular people", do you? (Edit: I don't mean to put your friends down, I just mean that the people you know are probably smart, interesting people, sadly unlike a large portion of humanity.) I don't mean 'person working outside of tech'. I mean the kind of people who think Big Bang Theory is 'a show for smart people'.
Re:A list of movies about hacking
by Nexxxeh on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:57PM
(#13770386)
If you're adding (the excellent) Equilibrium, I'd say V for Vendetta too due to its influence on "Anonymous". And Fight Club because of what their end goal is.
That said, I can still remember seeing eXistenZ in the cinema:
Re:A list of movies about hacking
by blacksmith_tb on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:37PM
(#13769791)
The plot doesn't really have much to do with computers? It was perhaps the first anime to make a splash in the US, and it is worth seeing, but I don't think I'd use "hacker" or "cyberpunk" to describe it.
Re:A list of movies about hacking
by gordon_freeman on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:40PM
(#13769819)
Not for the hacker or cyberpunk genre but I do think that 'Primer' needs to be in this list. Haven't seen more realistic time travel movie than this yet.
Re:A list of movies about hacking
by ringshall on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @08:32PM
(#13770613)
The forward-only time machine in Futurama is probably the only paradox-free time travel premise that's possible. Even that had a giant plot hole re: the motion of the planet, solar system, etc.
Re:A list of movies about hacking
by dezzeus on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:59PM
(#13769991)
This list should have been posted weeks ago, when the StackOverflow's 2017 survey asked us about fictional characters and I wasn't able to recall any particular title...
Re:A list of movies about hacking
by ekianjo on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @06:37PM
(#13769787)
The social network is nothIng for hackers. Most of the facts and characters are in reality not as portrayed. And itS one of the weakest movies of Fincher.
Re:A list of movies about hacking
by extra88 on Friday March 03, 2017 @11:43AM
(#13784069)
Are you talking about the book? My wife read it and said it wasn't very good. The movie was great but I wouldn't call its gritty, near-future dystopian setting very cyberpunk either. Cyberpunk is generally "high tech, low life" but 'Children of Men' doesn't really have high tech. 'Minority Report' is more cyberpunk than 'Children of Men' (but still not that cyberpunk).
"An internet posts a 'movies for hackers' list on Git instead of using other reasonable publishing services as any human being. Hackernews spend hours complaining about how their favorite obscure movie that nobody knows or cares about wasn't included in the list"
Here is my curated list of movies ever hacker and cyberpunk enthusiast must watch:
* Sneakers
* Ghost in the Shell
* Tron
Why is Tron there? Because the screenwriter loosely based the character around her husband. Who was her husband? Alan Kay. Tron's protagonist is Alan Kay.
My two bits. (I very much agree with Tron.)
Obviously watch the whole movie, but the clip gives the gist of the high quality of the script.
"Because the screenwriter loosely based the character around her husband. Who was her husband? Alan Kay. Tron's protagonist is Alan Kay."
Had no clue his wife wrote it or portrayed him. That's neat! Brings in some irony given Tron character is fighting the slavery of MCP but Kay told me here on HN he loved Burroughs B5000. Also implied its lead creator, Bob Barton, was a genius and revolutionary overturning all the bad software, hardware, and engineering that came before it in one fell swoop. As in, the movie could've just as easily had MCP as the hero. ;)
Ghost in the Shell rather than Patlabor?
And Sneakers, asides from the magic, encryption-breaking MacGuffin, is some of the most realistic hacking in movies. What's the preferred tactic of these tech geniuses? Basic social engineering. Sure, they know a lot of other tricks, but why figure out a clever way through the badge system if a cake and some birthday balloons will work just as well?
http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0531381/bio
It's interesting in seeing the print inspirations for many of these movies. The term "The Matrix" was first coined in William Gibson's Neuromancer and considered to be the seminal Cyberpunk novel, even predating Ghost in the Shell.
Definitely a must read for any Cyberpunk fan!
In the same vein, Snow Crash by Neal Stephenson is great as well. Its essentially a parody of cyberpunk but hilariously well written.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/True_Names
And it's not that old works are bad, just that some of the tech misses distract and take you out of the atmosphere sometimes. Like on Star Trek, when they have to physically deliver email to people on holodiscs.
I'd also note that Asimov's Robot series are great if you like hardboiled type stuff - not cyberpunk, but has a slightly similar ambiance.
Hacking is about understanding, optimizing, and manipulating systems. One real-world analogue of a system is a Rube Goldberg machine; the dramatic analogue of a Rube Goldberg machine is a heist flick.
I'd add the Ocean's Eleven remake as an approachable introduction to the genre, and Kubrick's The Killing for vintage noir awesomeness. And maybe The Last Seduction as a curveball.
1954 - Gog (robots that look like robots and not people in metal suits)
1957 - Desk Set (non-stupid treadment of an early computer)
1970 - Colossus : The Forbin Project (how is this not in there)
1971 - How to Frame a Figg (silly, but it's got a computer hacker)
1975 - Three Days of the Condor
1990 - The KGB, the Computer, and Me (PBS doc about "The Cuckoo's Egg")
https://www.indiana.edu/~cogfilms/index.php
Black Mirror is missing here too, unfortunately. Several episodes revolve quite intelligently around AI, dystopian technological future, cognitive science.
Not a movie but definitely required viewing.
Or rather, don't prioritize watching these. Try to balance out movies and books related to your profession or hobby with those outside of it.
The world already has enough stereotypical geeks loving Ghost in the Shell, Star Wars and Star Trek, it needs more geeks having an interest in what "regular people" do and like.
Instead of having a laser focus even for our hobbies I'd advocate a wider range of hobbies.
Most of the world is like this. It's terrifying.
1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Conversation
1. Directors Guild of America's The 80 Best-Directed Films: http://www.dga.org/Craft/DGAQ/All-Articles/1602-Spring-2016/...
2. TSPDT's The 1,000 Greatest Films: http://www.theyshootpictures.com/gf1000_all1000films_table.p...
They aren't about hackers, for sure. But these two lists are more diverse than IMDb 250.
Try movies from the 60s and 70s on these lists. Lots of gems among them.
Also Existenz which has a female programmer and predates the Matrix and Inception.
That said, I can still remember seeing eXistenZ in the cinema:
>Death to the demoness, Allegra Geller.
I know it's just an expression, but it bugs me...
Curation indicates that there is a selectivity involved. That is not evident with this list, that or they're using a pretty un-obvious criteria.
(note the original title of the story indicated that this was a "curated list", and the actual repo still contains that language).
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0256408/
I'd also recommend 2001, Repo Man, Dark Star and They Live on general principles.
Two criteria come to my mind:
- The movie is likely to teach you something that will make you a better “hacker” or “cyberpunk”.
- The movie depicts what it's actually like to be a “hacker” or “cyberpunk”.
Now, which of the movies on this list are going to do either of those? Probably some of the documentaries, and probably almost none of the fictions.
cypherpunk: hacking, computing cryptography and related culture.
cyberpunk: subgenre of science fiction and related subculture.
And not a movie, but Halt and Catch Fire should be on there somewhere...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KEkrWRHCDQU
"Hackers - Wizards of the Electronics Age" Starring a bunch of old school programmers/hackers!
Magnificently produced by Fabrice Florin -http://fabriceflorin.com/
Watch it here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zOP1LNr70aU
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0088979/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_Genius
It's on Vimeo: https://vimeo.com/8919323
(list)
- Tetsuo: The Iron Man
- Videodrome
http://m.imdb.com/title/tt0084978/
Can i get an amen please?!
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
http://n-gate.com/hackernews/
"An internet posts a 'movies for hackers' list on Git instead of using other reasonable publishing services as any human being. Hackernews spend hours complaining about how their favorite obscure movie that nobody knows or cares about wasn't included in the list"