News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by hugh3 on Monday May 24, 2010 @03:36PM (#1375484)
For perspective:

Last night's Lost finale got 13 million viewers, 2.5 hours each, so that's 32.5 million hours wasted there.

The Superbowl gets ~100 million viewers and lasts... what, three hours? So that's 300 million hours wasted there.

The soccer world cup final is rumoured to get something on the order of a billion viewers, so... that's a lot of hours wasted.

And your entire life, if you never do anything in the least bit worthwhile, will be a waste of approximately 700,000 hours.

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by treyp on Monday May 24, 2010 @04:26PM (#1375598)
i don't like the throwing around of the term 'wasted'

even if you mean 'wasted potential work time', who's to say that entertainment in short bursts doesn't increase productivity by preventing burn out?

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by hugh3 on Monday May 24, 2010 @05:09PM (#1375691)
Of course I was being facetious in describing them as wasted, just as the original article was. If you really thought of every moment spent at leisure as "wasted time" you'd go mad.

The vast majority of hours of anyone's life are "wasted" in one sense or another, so it's not my problem how anyone else chooses to waste theirs. I just hope that when I get to the end of my hours that the top few hundred of 'em will be enough to justify the hundreds of thousands I spent doing stuff rapidly forgotten.

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by ugh on Monday May 24, 2010 @06:26PM (#1375849)
Many people would say the hours where you are productive in order to rake in some money are – in some sense – wasted.

Time in which you can do whatever you like is what life is all about. You are truly lucky if you can make money with that but most people cannot.

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by malnourish on Monday May 24, 2010 @04:57PM (#1375662)
I agree. I always here about how people "waste time" by enjoying themselves. Since when is enjoying yourself a waste of time?

This sort of talk is often directed at financially stable people, too. Sure, there may be "better" things to do with one's time, but we only have one life to live (that we can acknowledge, anyway) so I feel some leisure time is well deserved.

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by Sukotto on Monday May 24, 2010 @04:17PM (#1375569)
How many of those things impact productivity during work hours?
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by jorgeortiz85 on Monday May 24, 2010 @04:59PM (#1375666)
Mexico shuts down during Mexican world cup games. People don't work, there are literally no cars on the street.
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by GFischer on Tuesday May 25, 2010 @09:00AM (#1377268)
Heh, replace Mexico with Argentina, Uruguay, Brazil... we're all fanatics "down here" (South America)

Offtopic: the Mexico-Uruguay match will be fun :) (yes, Uruguayan here)

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by jacquesm on Monday May 24, 2010 @06:57PM (#1375885)
In NL that does not happen officially, but if you're looking for some fast service when there is a game on then better forget it and try again in a few days.

The amount of 'sick leave' around those days is also well above average.

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by pyre on Monday May 24, 2010 @06:58PM (#1375887)
I would hate to see what the super/food/farmer's markets are like leading up to a Mexican World Cup game... People must really have to stock up.
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by minouye on Monday May 24, 2010 @04:11PM (#1375560)
IMO watching the Super Bowl is time well spent...
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by Charuru on Monday May 24, 2010 @06:15PM (#1375834)
Wrong audience.
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by davidblair on Monday May 24, 2010 @02:54PM (#1375381)
I hate the nickle and dime approach to productivity. In fact, the happier I am the more I get done.
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by notauser on Monday May 24, 2010 @05:00PM (#1375670)
That's true, but the time-tracking approach encourages me to work hard for a while and then switch off and do something else.

Nothing sucks my motivation more than sitting around for 8 hours thinking I'm working and getting nothing done.

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by joe24pack on Tuesday May 25, 2010 @07:06PM (#1378954)
that's why I do the low-tech paper, pencil and time pomodoro technique, especially when working on drudgery tasks like database conversions.
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by joe_the_user on Monday May 24, 2010 @05:19PM (#1375722)
Further, the "figures" don't take into account the possibility that someone who choses to spend time in this way might be impelled to not spend time in some equally "unproductive" fashion during some other part of the day.
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by brown9-2 on Monday May 24, 2010 @03:01PM (#1375397)
And what percentage of total work produced do those 4.82 million hours represent?

You can't evaluate if it is a "tragic" cost or not without knowing the other half.

From their writeup, sounds like average time spent on Google for that day went from 33.6 million hours to 38.4 million hours - an increase of 14% more time spent per person on google.com for a single day. This doesn't sound tragic to me. If the average RescueTime user spends 4 and a half minutes on Google each day, an extra 36 seconds isn't going to destroy the economy.

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by tjmaxal on Monday May 24, 2010 @03:23PM (#1375453)
I don't think you guys get the joke. They were being sarcastic about the whole "tragedy" they even said so in the first comment.
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by nandemo on Monday May 24, 2010 @09:30PM (#1376169)
This seems fairly common on HN: sarcasm and subtle humour just goes over (many) peoples' heads, and people keep discussing it as if it were serious.

That stumped me for a while because people here are smart in general. I won't go into why I think that happens. My conclusion is that it's better not to post anything humourous -- unless it's obviously humourous.

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by webwright on Monday May 24, 2010 @04:55PM (#1375660)
Thank you! :-) Yeah, more time is "wasted" getting coffee every day. We thought it was a lot more interesting how LITTLE actual time was spent on Google search and how the Pac-Man logo resulted in a 15% bump on average time logged.
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by doki_pen on Monday May 24, 2010 @02:49PM (#1375365)
Oh yeah, I definitely would have been productive for those 15 minutes if it wasn't for pacman. </sarcasm>
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by noonespecial on Monday May 24, 2010 @03:39PM (#1375491)
Won't someone please think of the ghosts!?

How many ghosts were tragically chomped in the pursuit of this so-called diversion?

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by praptak on Monday May 24, 2010 @05:12PM (#1375704)
Dude - chill down, they are dead already. This is what makes them ghosts!
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by malnourish on Monday May 24, 2010 @05:00PM (#1375671)
We would like to see this statistic.

Sincerely, People for the Ethical Treatment of the Super Natural.

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by jasonlotito on Tuesday May 25, 2010 @09:30AM (#1377335)
PETSN doesn't sound right.

People for the Ethical Nurturing of the Insubstantial Supernatural sounds better.

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by jcl on Monday May 24, 2010 @04:26PM (#1375597)
Of course, that's not including the time lost to support calls:

http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9177261/Google_s_Pac_...

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by streblo on Monday May 24, 2010 @03:01PM (#1375396)
I played it for about 15 minutes and really enjoyed it. Tragic.
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by kingsley_20 on Monday May 24, 2010 @06:10PM (#1375820)
Does anyone else thing that this was a massive experiment? I mean, Google MUST have lost some revenue. This is the first time that they've added anything interactive to the home page. They must want to learn something enough to do that.

If so, what? One possibility is to see if increasing engagement time during a visit has any effects like increased ad conversions or increased time spent on consecutive sessions.

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by bobbin on Monday May 24, 2010 @07:21PM (#1375936)
> I mean, Google MUST have lost some revenue.

Maybe an employee developed it in his 20% of time and they put it up because "why not?".

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by megablast on Monday May 24, 2010 @11:05PM (#1376336)
I think he means lost revenue due to people not searching and clicking on ads as much.

Of course, it also drove a lot of people to google to check it out, hard to measure the good feelings towards google due to that. The images they display really does generate a lot of good feeling, for a tiny bit of work for google.

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by jacquesm on Monday May 24, 2010 @06:59PM (#1375890)
This was just googles stealth entry in to the gaming market.

Wait until next week, when you'll see donkey kong on the homepage and no searchbox.

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by timmorgan on Monday May 24, 2010 @03:49PM (#1375513)
I still got everything done on Friday I thought I would, even though I spent about 15 minutes on Pac-Man. But I don't build widgets, so it may be different for people who do tiny, Mechanical Turk type tasks.
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by dobbse on Monday May 24, 2010 @03:20PM (#1375446)
I think the author must have been channelling my mom from 30 years ago. I eventually won the argument with mom about the value of video games by making a profession out of bending computers to my will. The author should "waste" about 20 minutes watching "Jane McGonigal: How Gaming Can Make a Better World" to understand why Google's Pac-Man might have been an epic win rather than a tragic waste.

http://www.ted.com/talks/jane_mcgonigal_gaming_can_make_a_be...

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by crsmith on Monday May 24, 2010 @05:39PM (#1375768)
I spent more time reading this article than playing Google Pac-Man.
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by tjmaxal on Monday May 24, 2010 @04:01PM (#1375542)
Seriously, The whole post is just a sarcastic joke. He even says so in the first comment. How could you guys miss that?
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by revaaron on Monday May 24, 2010 @02:56PM (#1375386)
Am I the only one who didn't see this? I never go straight to http://google.com, but use the search box or vimperator's ":open google search terms." To think, I had to lose productivity in traditional ways...
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by pavs on Monday May 24, 2010 @03:02PM (#1375399)
You can still play it. They made a permanent place for it here: http://www.google.com/pacman/

According to their blog post its staying there: http://googleblog.blogspot.com/2010/05/pac-man-rules.html

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by kmfrk on Monday May 24, 2010 @04:23PM (#1375589)
It's okay; they were waiting for Battle.net to work in StarCraft 2 again anyway.
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by nir on Monday May 24, 2010 @11:12PM (#1376344)
I understand RescueTime wanting the exposure, but it's too bad many people and publications will now take this number seriously, as if it has any meaning, just because they were given a number to hang on to.
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by mtarnovan on Monday May 24, 2010 @05:54PM (#1375790)
Yeah, let's make the workday 16 hours long instead of 8. That would save uncountable billions every year, right ?
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by detcader on Monday May 24, 2010 @05:27PM (#1375737)
There needs to be a tradition in this world. One hour out of the day, everyone stops everything and does something productive. Read a book for an hour. Code for an hour. Do something, or it's a faux pas.
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by ezy on Monday May 24, 2010 @03:10PM (#1375421)
This, of course, is time spent on the computer. If 15mins more time on google replaced 15mins of time masticating a sandwich, rescuetime isn't going to know about it.
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by peteforde on Monday May 24, 2010 @03:41PM (#1375495)
It would be a pretty strange place for Google to be in if folks perceived them us having an ethical responsibility to steer us towards things they see as productive.
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by jodrellblank on Tuesday May 25, 2010 @08:01PM (#1379070)
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by sebastian on Monday May 24, 2010 @03:32PM (#1375478)
I don't really see what's tragic about it. People had a little fun for a day for 1/2 hour or so. Not the end of the world, not tragic at all.
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by tszming on Tuesday May 25, 2010 @02:31AM (#1376706)
Why no one mention how many hours people spent on facebook everyday?

Ans: over 8 billions minutes => 133M hours per day.

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by 10ren on Monday May 24, 2010 @04:59PM (#1375665)
504,703,000

Are there really half a billion people online? (let online visiting google on a particular day)

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by alex_c on Monday May 24, 2010 @06:08PM (#1375814)
A lot more than half a billion.

http://www.internetworldstats.com/stats.htm

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by anemecek on Monday May 24, 2010 @07:27PM (#1375956)
"The time you enjoy wasting is not wasted time."

Bertrand Russell

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by zackola on Monday May 24, 2010 @05:28PM (#1375743)
Time well wasted.
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by msie on Monday May 24, 2010 @05:39PM (#1375766)
I am not a resource, I am a free man.
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by protomyth on Monday May 24, 2010 @04:12PM (#1375561)
what % is that of March Madness?
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by hackermom on Monday May 24, 2010 @05:27PM (#1375736)
People would of course spend their usual "recreational minutes" away from work on whatever else, regardless of that Pac-Man version.
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by jheriko on Monday May 24, 2010 @02:52PM (#1375373)
When productivity or work ethic really matters stuff like this has almost zero impact - if anything this just demonstrates how many people are lazy and unproductive. :)

When I saw this at work I immediately and automatically thought "cool. i'll check if that's really playable at home later"

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by exit on Monday May 24, 2010 @03:23PM (#1375454)
i don't think lazy coincides with unproductive as often as our society would like us to think. i think most unproductive people are just profoundly uninspired by what they find themselves doing, and the demeaning label of laziness is a tool to keep them doing it.

you convince someone that the problem is some vague but essential character flaw - laziness - and it discourages/distracts them from considering the possibility of addressing their external circumstances.

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by revaaron on Monday May 24, 2010 @02:58PM (#1375390)
I don't see why what the first part (before the hyphen) has to do with the rest. I'd agree with the first bit, but not because anyone who dinks around a bit online at work is "lazy and unproductive."
Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by jheriko on Monday May 24, 2010 @03:31PM (#1375475)
I've probably overstated myself a bit, whilst failing to explain my opinion well because I was writing from an emotional response.

Dinking around online is lunch-time behaviour. If you really have nothing to do, why not take the initiative and do something productive for your employer instead of fooling around on the net? The occasional 5 minutes probably doesn't hurt, but that doesn't make it right either... an hour or two is totally unacceptable.

I'm probably bitter because I spent a fair amount of time in my younger years working low-pay bottom end jobs with lots of manual labour and "physical" engineering type work. There is no dinking around on the internet, and the amount of slacking that is typical in most office roles would result in prompt warnings and a firing, yet somehow easy-peasy office roles are paid more - even if they are similarly low-skill (data-entry, receptionist, office manager etc).

Even so, my "bad" youthful experiences are nothing compared to how, to a very good approximation, the entire human race earns their living.

Hopefully that can explain why my response was so driven by emotion rather than reason, and hence did not make perfect sense?

(I am a programmer now and I work in an office earning £25k - and yes, I do feel guilty about how much I get paid for such an easy job)

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by qw on Monday May 24, 2010 @04:52PM (#1375656)
I guess it depends on what work you do. If I worked a 100% of the day, except for lunch break, my brain would be fried after a few days. 5 minutes an hour doing something else actually makes me more productive.

Sure, when I'm in the zone and are lucky enough not to get interrupted I can program for longer periods of time, but I still need a short break now and then.

I don't know where you worked, and since I'm from a different country, the standards may also be different. But where I live, I can't think of a physical job where you are required to work at 100% capacity for a whole day, except for a lunch break. Short rest periods are required.

Re:The Tragic Cost of Google Pac-Man – 4.82 million hours by jheriko on Monday May 24, 2010 @05:47PM (#1375782)
5 minute breaks are effective for refreshing yourself and I do the very same probably about once an hour but this is a luxury of my workplace and is generally not allowed in manual work - in some situations - e.g. assembly line, it is crucial that no one take breaks for very long - asking to go to the toilet can get you fired (I've had this happen to the guy working right next to me once). I think we've probably tested methods to "perfection" over the last 5k years or so. This is part of why there is an invisible barrier between office and shop floor so often - because office guys get a lot of slack and have easier jobs by many measures. Just being allowed to sit whilst you work can seem like an incredible luxury to some of these guys stuck standing at an assembly line or running around a warehouse filling orders. And I'm sorry, but I'm a programmer - you can train someone to be a programmer, and most office type jobs on the fly just as easily as an assembly line worker - they won't be great but neither is the assembly line worker when he starts out - in both cases it takes years of practice. The difference, to me at least, seems to be artificially imposed by a combination of broken supply/demand models and general misconceptions - programmers are in huge supply, we just pretend they aren't. Most people rely on programming skills in everyday life - they just aren't told it that way.

I live in the UK there are two standard formats for most grunt work - either 2 hrs work 15 mins break 2hrs work 1hr break UNPAID (i suspect not allowed - i think this depends on a legal loophole against the spirit of the law) 2hrs work 15 mins break 2hrs work - or 8 hours with just 30 minutes paid break to be taken in one consecutive lump. i've worked both - its still nothing compared to what most of the world (i.e. China, India and Africa) deal with. I'm one of the very most privileged...

Whilst you work discipline can be illegally strict because it is accepted and nobody questions things if "80% of places I worked were like this - they can't all be illegal" or "its been this way for years" or "big companies know better than to break the law" etc. I'm one of the fortunates with sufficient balls to stand up for myself - even then I don't do it every time that I probably should, but I've seen so many people (the vast majority) treated illegally because it is accepted by their peers, and they just tolerate it. When you explain how they can protect themselves they don't want to because they need the money and don't want to tick anyone off, job security really matters when people tell you you are unskilled and jobs are hard to find - it doesn't matter how many times I tell them I've never been fired for standing up for myself.

Its one of my personal pet peeves - hence the irrationally strong response to, at best, a vaguely related link.