Point of order here. HR acts in management's best interests, not necessarily the company's. It's pretty clear that HR's actions here are not in the company's best interests given how much of a shitfest this has been for Uber. They gave cover for people who were not acting in Uber's best interests and, as a result, Uber lost all their goodwill, they're bleeding talent, and you'd have to be delusional to think toxic norms like this haven't been affecting their morale and productivity.
Management's interests are separate from the best interests of the company. Shareholder interests are separate from the best interests of the company. A company is made up of employees, management, shareholders, AND clients all together. All of them are stakeholders and its best interests are the things that properly balance the needs of everyone to fulfill its mission or goal. It's neoliberal bullshit to claim that only management and shareholders matter, and the sooner we accept that the sooner we can make our corporate governance tack into a sane direction.
You're right, and here's the thing. It seems both women who've come forward would have open-and-shut cases against Uber for multi-millions in damages. It's surprising to me that neither have pursued Uber in this regard. Similarly, it's surprising to me that Uber HR hasn't done the mental calculus to figure out that these women have a solid case, and just fix the problem. Or, most disturbingly, Uber HR DID do the mental calculus, determined neither woman would sue; and, therefore, made the correct choices as "best for the company."
Either way, I'm taking Lyft.
Reasons to pursue sexual harassment litigation:
* You may make some money.
Reasons to not pursue sexual harassment litigation:
* You will have to devote an enormous amount of money, time, energy, health, and your emotional well-being.
* Your lawyers will take half the settlement, either in up front fees, or as a portion of the bounty.
* You will get to share, and then be brutally cross-examined about all the worst bullshit you had to endure in a courtroom.
* With so much money on the line, you will trigger a smear campaign against you, whose impact will persist long after the trial concludes.
* You want to program, instead of dealing with legal bullshit.
* You just want this nightmare to be over, instead of it being brought up over, and over again.
* You don't want to have your name permanently associated with "Sues your employers for millions of dollars". Good luck getting a job after that.
* If for whatever reason you lose, you will get to enjoy all the damage to your reputation, all the trauma and indignities that you had to re-live, the black mark on your employment record (Who would hire a liar who sues her employers?), and you'll probably be counter-sued by Uber. I hope you're independently wealthy.
It's easy to suggest the nuclear option when you have no skin in the game.
And then if she spoke with a lawyer, that lawyer would point to all the problems listed above plus many more (the difficulty of proving damages, for one) and would almost certainly try to dissuade her from suing no matter how grievous her treatment, and if she did sue, she would likely lose. The legal remedies are so weak as to be non-existent, but their existence is beneficial to wrong-doers, who can hide behind them and pretend they are effective and powerful.
Oh, you neither, huh?
See?
* It gives other survivors a statement of solidarity and validates their experiences. It says that other survivors really weren't crazy; that others had this experience too. For someone who's left doubting their sanity after an incident like this happened, this kind of support is immensely powerful.
* It forces these incidents to be drawn into the eyes of the public.
Uber's rotten culture is only getting attention because someone spoke up.
I see all the negatives you mentioned as failures of our litigation-after-sexual-harassment model that we should seek to address. There's nothing that says we should make barriers to litigation and cost of failure so high.
Who said anything about "should"? The fact is that the barriers are that high.
We can't improve things until we allow ourselves to imagine better realities. There's nothing wrong with that.
I'd never know about it, except, a while ago, US Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas worked there. During his confirmation hearings there was a real political shitstorm about what might nor might not have transpired there: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clarence_Thomas#Anita_Hill_all...
* You will have to devote an enormous amount of money, time, energy, health, and your emotional well-being. -- You would not have to pay an enormous amount for this. Though it would take a lot of time you are right
* Your lawyers will take half the settlement, either in up front fees, or as a portion of the bounty. -- This is almost always true but cases cost a whole lot to run and manage.
* You will get to share, and then be brutally cross-examined about all the worst bullshit you had to endure in a courtroom. -- With a class action you have far more people to fight on your side, making cross X a lot less scary, if it ever gets to the trial stage.
* With so much money on the line, you will trigger a smear campaign against you, whose impact will persist long after the trial concludes. -- It is much harder to smear a group.
* You want to program, instead of dealing with legal bullshit. -- You want to program in peace for the rest of your life. A class action sends a message to all companies that they cannot act like this.
* You just want this nightmare to be over, instead of it being brought up over, and over again. -- True and a class action will help to end the nightmare.
* You don't want to have your name permanently associated with "Sues your employers for millions of dollars". Good luck getting a job after that. -- As a class action member you are less likely to be singled out
* If for whatever reason you lose, you will get to enjoy all the damage to your reputation, all the trauma and indignities that you had to re-live, the black mark on your employment record (Who would hire a liar who sues her employers?), and you'll probably be counter-sued by Uber. I hope you're independently wealthy. --This is FUD. Nevertheless, by being associated with a class action you are far less likely to be singled out for issues. It's even quite hard for them to counter-sue in a class action.
While the legal option is hard and can be scary, it is not a bad option to pursue.
That's not how class action lawsuits work. It's highly unlikely that 'women and LGBT persons of all genders who were abused by shitty bosses at Uber' will be found, by a court, to be a class. The class-action will be dismissed before it even gets to determining wrong-doing.
You can have a class action lawsuit over your employer, say, stealing wages from 10,000 employees.
You cannot have a class action lawsuit if 12 people have been harassed and abused by their managers. (The fact that the practice is widespread will impact judgements, but it does not mean that 12 people form a 'class action'.) [1]
Even more importantly, sexual harassment cases by their nature, require each case to be evaluated on its merits. Just because Claire, Adam, and Barbara have been abused by their bosses, doesn't mean that Donna can piggyback onto the lawsuit, and claim damages, without having her case examined as thoroughly as theirs.
> This is FUD.
No, it's not - not if you lose. If they win the case, Uber can, and almost certainly will countersue. (For PR reasons, they would prefer to avoid suing you if you just complain on your blog.) The first Google hit for your name will be about how you sued your employer, and lost.
Yes, there is the social benefit of these cases going to trial (Preventing future abuse in other companies), but not everyone wants to be a martyr.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Class_action#Class_certificati...
>It seems both women who've come forward would have open-and-shut cases against Uber for multi-millions in damages.
These cases are tough to win, even in a liberal jurisdiction like SF. For example, does "Amy" have any witnesses that are willing to testify about what they saw? Sure, a subpoena can compel them to testify, but if the men who were present are still working there, how likely is it that they are going to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth under questioning?
The calculus becomes "keep my current job that is paying my bills, and maybe get a raise/promotion soon" vs. "stick my neck out for someone who no longer works here."
Sure, there are good lawyers who could maybe trip them up, but now you're treating what should be friendly or neutral witnesses as hostile witnesses. And Uber has some good lawyers too, obviously.
Further, even if some of these guys have moved on to other companies, they have to calculate how testifying in Amy's favor might come back to bite them later. With a guy like Travis who lacks good character (according to all the accounts I've read, anyway), it will come back to bite them sooner than later.
So "open-and-shut" is usually not really at all, but rather a less than 50% chance of recovering damages after years of difficult litigation. Unless, of course, you have lots of really good documentary evidence that's admissible.
> to me that neither have pursued Uber in this regard.
I also find this surprising to the point of puzzling. Yes, HR (+legal) works for the company, ALWAYS. However, protecting the company from multi-million dollar lawsuits and potential negative publicity certainly falls within the remit, and removing offenders and mollifying victims would be the way to go.
So something doesn't quite add up, and I have a hard time believing "oh, we know that they won't sue" would be sufficient. Then again...hubris.
Is it possible that their contracts are written in such a way as to preclude this? Which if so is gross and shouldn't be allowed by contract law IMO, but it certainly wouldn't surprise me.
So: yes. I'd definitely talk to a lawyer in that case.
Through inaction and malpractice they have increased the legal liability Uber faces and encouraged irreparable reputational damage for Uber.
Except their actions here are not in the best interest of the company...why do people keep posting this in the context of discussing Uber? These are casebook examples of what HR should not do.
Yes, normally, HR acts in the company's interests.
But for many companies, its in their best interests to identify and fire creeps who work there and abuse women (or others generally).
What HR will do for you depends on what type of company you work in.
If you work in a company that cares about its culture, that values diversity and respects its employees, then HR is very likely to help you if you experience problems like these.
If you work for Uber - well I guess that's what all the heat and light is about. Is Uber such a shithole that these kinds of behaviour are actually condoned by the CEO?
Maybe we'll find out.
Wikipedia: “Human resources are the people who make up the workforce of an organization, business sector, or economy. [...] A human-resources department (HR department) of an organization performs human resource management, overseeing various aspects of employment, such as compliance with labour law and employment standards, administration of employee benefits, and some aspects of recruitment and dismissal.”
Where'd you ever get that crazy idea?
>But its true meaning, to execs/stakeholders/corporate persons, is "[the department which manages the] human resources".
Not exactly. The true meaning is "the department which works to exploit the human resources as much as possible".
(Your first meaning never occurred to me.)
Going to HR is the right move for something like this. In any sane company, HR will take such a claim seriously because the potential legal downside if they don't is an unacceptable risk. In an insane company - aside from the fact that you can't measure the insanity level until you have in fact made such reports to HR and seen them dismissed - you still need to be able to show that you brought the problem to HR's attention and they did nothing about it.
That is, don't interact with them expecting to be "understood" as a person.
You may not just get a "no, we can't do that". You may well also get an unmentioned strike against you, for even raising the point or concern.
There are some good people in HR. Although, upon reflection, I realize that those I've met tended to have moved on or exited HR.
Anyway, my point is, don't just expect "in the employer's interest", be also aware of and prepared for a lack of basic human connection.
Yes but the company's best interest is to support Amy and fire Mike#2.
The reason is that if there is credible evidence of this behavior, she has easy settlement on par with Mike's value to the company (unless that is measured in 8 figures which is unlikely since at the end of the day, if they paid him $500k...they could replace him for $500k).
A competent CEO would take action here.
Hopefully the recently-revealed experiences at Uber will be taken as a wake-up call by HR folks whose calculus tells them that the best option is to cover up problems.
It should now be apparent that buried issues will eventually come to light, so the short-term gain of coverups won't be worth the long-term risk.
Say it over and over, say it loud, and say it to every single person entering the US workforce from day one:
H/R ACTS AND WILL ALWAYS ACT IN THE COMPANY'S BEST INTERESTS. NOT YOURS.
Amy's situation was grave, and kudos to her for getting out. But everyone should read these stories and burn this line into their heads permanently.