News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by ChuckMcM on Saturday February 25, 2017 @09:19PM (#13735259)
"Now Johnny, when you ride your bike you must wear your I-am-a-bike vest and follow these patterns or the cars are likely to kill you." :-)

Summary is that "people riding bikes" (PRB) is a much denser image set than "people in cars" (PIC) and "people walking or jogging" (PWJ), and the PRB objects have a much higher dynamic angular vector capability (they can change direction extremely quickly) combined with a wider dynamic velocity vector to PWJ they strain the ability of the predictive filters to reliably asses the collision threat. As a result you need either faster/better hardware or better algorithms to deal with that particular group.

I'm not particularly surprised by that, I expect the cars to also end up with small animal issues, as they can appear suddenly and aggressive evasive maneuvers to avoid hitting them may injure passengers at the cost of saving a squirrel's life.

And all of that adds up to some of the many things that one has to think about when claiming victory here. It is going to be a long hard engineering slog to get to full autonomy. My question is you can build a computer that can drive a car fully autonomously, what other missions could you create for it? Some of those are kind of scary.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by noobermin on Saturday February 25, 2017 @10:09PM (#13735428)
This is when the humans strike back against the machines.

Every example of a NN I've seen is good at one thing, the thing it is trained for. I haven't yet seen a NN that can beat people at chess, recognize faces, drive, and make coffee, or more importantly, decide when to do one or the other. The closest thing I can think of is Watson from IBM.

People can drive (poorly) but they also recognize the value of life in a biker or a squirrel, and in some cases, override their usual learned behavior, for example, instead of continuing to drive, swerving, basically improvising.

Computers and programs again are good for what they have been input and now, what they already have learned. The synthesis part, I'm not quite sure even NN have reached that part yet. I may be wrong, the answer is probably "learn more" or "learn faster" (which is what you suggest), but it's easier to synthesize like this when you have a mind with general knowledge, at which point the mind is less like a NN and more and more like a person.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by hahajk on Sunday February 26, 2017 @12:41AM (#13735867)
There's a saying that neural networks are the second-best way to do everything. Don't be disappointed when their trajectory flattens out.

And, as for their role in autonomous vehicles, I don't think they play a primary role (although I don't design autonomous cars so I wouldn't know for sure.) You can see in this Tesla video that a lot of the computer vision isn't even reliant on neural networks: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BLlwm5Dq7Is

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by Eridrus on Sunday February 26, 2017 @02:48PM (#13739373)
Why do you think that video shows that Tesla isn't reliant on neural networks? Neural nets outputting bounding boxes is pretty normal.

Despite NVIDIA's papers, end-to-end neural nets for self-driving cars are dumb, but for the initial perception based on sensor data, neural nets are the only game in town.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by hahajk on Sunday March 12, 2017 @01:19AM (#13849380)
I was looking at the optical flow indicators and the road-tracking. Afaik any NN solution to those are immature if they work reliably at all. Your probably right that that the bounding boxes are probably NNs.
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by mathattack on Sunday February 26, 2017 @11:57AM (#13738191)
There's a saying that neural networks are the second-best way to do everything. Don't be disappointed when their trajectory flattens out.

Outstanding quote! I'm going to reapply it.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by gnipgnip on Saturday February 25, 2017 @11:05PM (#13735608)
Frankly you're overstretching. If you've ever driven in India you'd be questioning the very basis of humanity.
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by rspeer on Sunday February 26, 2017 @02:19AM (#13736114)
> The closest thing I can think of is Watson from IBM.

What are you imagining Watson is? Watson is not a singular entity that decides whether to play Jeopardy or analyze medical records or whatever. It's a brand.

The comparison that comes to mind is Colonel Sanders.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by jmspring on Saturday February 25, 2017 @10:47PM (#13735551)
Sometimes with the accidental (and non-accidental) encounters between bikes and cars show that the value of the life of the biker isn't really valued that highly.
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by noobermin on Saturday February 25, 2017 @11:39PM (#13735706)
People often take the minimum as the representative statistic. The article implies the mean event for self-driving cars is much worse than that for human drivers.

Yes, I bike, so I know the worst of the worst. I also remember a few courteous encounters, but probably many fewer due to negativity bias.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by blakejennings on Monday February 27, 2017 @05:44AM (#13743297)
I think NNs would work well to solve the bicycle problem with some more data -- maybe a lightweight sensor of some sort on bikes, or a device that could communicate on a public VANET - That would be a safe long term solution, but obviously many years out.
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by TheSpiceIsLife on Saturday February 25, 2017 @10:57PM (#13735585)
I haven't yet seen a NN that can beat people at chess, recognize faces, drive, and make coffee, or more importantly, decide when to do one or the other.

These are the sorts of things humans struggle with too. It could be argued that we, also, don't have one neural net that does all these things but rather a variety of specialised brain regions. It would then make sense that a computer might run specialised programs to deal with different tasks.

Anyway, self driving cars and bicycling can be fixed with a simple engineering solution: separate the two with barriers. This is what we should do anyway.

As someone who had their bike destroyed in a high speed car vs. bicycle collision, and was lucky to walk away with a broken thumb and sprained ankle: cycling on roads is insane.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by stouset on Sunday February 26, 2017 @12:17AM (#13735793)
> cycling on roads is insane.

How is it that people in developed countries across the world have learned to do this, and we haven't?

That said, the relative health benefits of cycling outweigh any risks 7-to-1 for an average human. Cycling for an hour, even with American road infrastructure, actually results in a net increase in the average person's lifespan of over an hour. Seems like maybe it isn't so insane after all.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by dukeluke on Sunday February 26, 2017 @07:14AM (#13736864)
Do you have a source for your claims in the last paragraph? It would be an interesting read.
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by emj on Sunday February 26, 2017 @02:30PM (#13739228)
There I googled it for you, so spend at least 10 minutes reading it now. Please.

But it is common sense, we know that excerise prolong your life, doing it regularly in modest proportions is best. Using a bicycle for transport to work means you are exercising twice daily, maybe 10-20 minutes for lunch as well. It is obvious that this kind of exercise will do you good.

For me it's one to two hours of exercise per day, it's hard to beat those health benefits.

http://ajph.aphapublications.org/doi/abs/10.2105/AJPH.2015.3... https://www.uu.nl/en/news/dutch-bikers-live-six-months-longe...

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by noobermin on Saturday February 25, 2017 @11:42PM (#13735713)
I haven't yet to be hit may be out of luck, but in my city, I don't have the option to be separated if I want to get everywhere. Instead, there are a plethora of "share the road" signs everywhere.

I'm okay with the separation if I get the same access as everyone else...and I am not blocked by slow bikers. Of course, I don't need to ride on highways/freeways (nor do I want to).

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by saulrh on Saturday February 25, 2017 @10:23PM (#13735468)
> Summary is that "people riding bikes" (PRB) is a much denser image set than "people in cars" (PIC) and "people walking or jogging" (PWJ), and the PRB objects have a much higher dynamic angular vector capability (they can change direction extremely quickly) combined with a wider dynamic velocity vector to PWJ they strain the ability of the predictive filters to reliably asses the collision threat. As a result you need either faster/better hardware or better algorithms to deal with that particular group.

Nice analysis of why bicycles are so dangerous even now - computational issues like these are just as much an issue for brains as for computers. Not surprising that, in many cities in the US, biking is insane. Nearly everybody I know that bikes to work has a close call or two in their history.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by stouset on Sunday February 26, 2017 @12:21AM (#13735802)
> Nearly everybody I know that bikes to work has a close call or two in their history.

Nearly everybody you know has had a close call or two with driving, I'm sure. And not just an "almost a minor fender-bender where everyone would have been okay" close call either. Cars are one of the leading causes of death for people of all ages. I've had close calls with cars as a pedestrian, as a cyclist, as a motorcyclist, and as an occupant in cars. I've been hit by a car while on a bicycle.

Cars as an entire category are dangerous, as are the humans who operate them.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by dvtv75 on Sunday February 26, 2017 @06:02AM (#13736671)
It's rather funny that the cyclist who rides downhill at 40mph outside my home every day classifies cars as the hazard and not himself, since he must ride on the road and not the footpath. He's no different to the guy who was riding at a similar speed on the footpath outside of my work. Apparently that was OK, you see, because if he was on the road he would have been riding the wrong way on a one way street and there was no way he was going to ride around the block to get on the southbound road. He nearly hit me every day after work for a month, because he was cutting blind corners at speed.

What about the two who were occupying a whole traffic lane, weaving back and forward to stop cars overtaking, while riding at under 15mph in a 40mph area? They'd start screaming like lunatics at anybody who legally overtook them - the cops wanted a word with them, but they disappeared when they saw me on my phone.

Five or six times a day, cyclists run a red light at a busy intersection in town. I see many near-accidents in my fleeting times in that intersection, all of which are caused by the cyclists - and I'm not counting the number of times they've nearly hit pedestrians crossing with the red light. I've seen one car run a red light, three years ago, since I started crossing there in 2012.

Years ago, I was overtaken by a cyclist and his three children, just as I had begun my turn. I nearly ran over the father, and they took their sweet time to move through the intersection a car coming the other way (who legally had the right-of-way) had to stop and wait for them. I could have got out of my car and walked, and I would have got to the other side before they did. They bumbled along as if they'd done nothing wrong.

It's not uncommon for cyclists enter intersections on foot, and so legally become pedestrians for the duration of the crossing, and then jump on their bikes and dodge through traffic while hurling obscenities at vehicles who have right-of-way because they didn't enter as pedestrians. The law here doesn't change your status because it's convenient for you.

Back in 2013, one of my ex-workmates told me quite a tale, about the time she pulled up at a set of lights. When she moved off she signaled to change lanes and only noticed by chance that there was a cyclist holding onto her car to get a free ride. He couldn't have seen her signal, the indicator was near his foot, and if she had turned he would have toppled in high speed traffic, perhaps ending up under her wheels.

Back in the early 1990s, a friend of mine was pulling out of his garage and was hit by a cyclist at some speed - the cyclist threatened to call the police, but stopped short he would have been charged, not my friend.

Don't lump it all on drivers, cyclists are dangerous, too.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by stouset on Sunday February 26, 2017 @02:09PM (#13739088)
I'm not sure how throwing out a bunch of anecdotes about people doing stupid things that might injure themselves counters the notion that people doing stupid things in multi-ton vehicles traveling at tens of miles per hour regularly injures and kills an unacceptable number of people per year.
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by brokenmachine on Sunday February 26, 2017 @11:29PM (#13741870)
As a cyclist, I hate seeing cyclists flout the rules like this because it makes the people driving those multi-ton metal weapons lose respect for all cyclists.

However, dangerous on a bike is not even in the same league as dangerous in a car.

While clearly inexcusable, how many of those incidents of bad cyclist behavior do you imagine could have ended with a fatality or catastrophic injury?

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by pvaldes on Monday February 27, 2017 @05:02AM (#13743111)
Is a diferent type of danger.

> how many of those incidents of bad cyclist behavior do you imagine could have ended with a fatality or catastrophic injury?

Several. My neighbour had around 75 y/o when a cyclist guy passed too close and broke her hip. Result: A long post-operatory, big scar in her leg, and she never could walk properly again. Died a few years later.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by brokenmachine on Monday February 27, 2017 @10:14PM (#13750841)
That sucks... Yes I wasn't thinking about the frail aged. I'm assuming she was on the sidewalk. What a horrible person to cause an elderly person to fall.

Of course, a car would have done much more damage to her in the same situation, and there are many more instances of real injuries from cars to cyclists than cyclists to pedestrians.

Did the cyclist actually make contact with her or just pass too close?

I'm not condoning the cyclist's actions in any way, just asking.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by _Wintermute on Sunday February 26, 2017 @03:07PM (#13739494)
Should we all list personal anecdotes of the stupid stuff we have seen motorists do as well?
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by eridius on Sunday February 26, 2017 @01:36AM (#13736011)
The difference is a "close call" on a bike has a far higher chance of being lethal than a "close call" in a car.
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by stouset on Tuesday February 28, 2017 @04:00PM (#13757769)
Not if you're the unfortunate pedestrian or cyclist who finds themselves on the wrong side of the "accident with a car" equation.
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by bsder on Sunday February 26, 2017 @12:55AM (#13735905)
> "Now Johnny, when you ride your bike you must wear your I-am-a-bike vest and follow these patterns or the cars are likely to kill you." :-)

Um, this is true for humans, as well, you know. Every single person I know who decided to start commuting to work on bicycle in the US was in the hospital within a year.

After training, I suspect that computers are going to be MUCH better at avoiding bicycles. They're also going to be much better at avoiding the stupid things that bicyclists do, as well.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by luca_ing on Monday February 27, 2017 @09:48AM (#13744575)
Maybe the US is different, but I've been commuting on my bike, on public roads in a major city, for literally two decades.

Admittedly I've had a few accidents over the years, but none that drew blood (as far as I remember), and certainly not yearly.

Either you live in a dangerous place, or you know bad riders :-)

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by nradov on Sunday February 26, 2017 @12:54AM (#13735904)
What do you think about large animal issues? In some rural areas collisions with deer, moose, and elks are a serious problem and aggressive evasive maneuvers may be necessary. Are current autonomous driving systems able to recognize them quickly and accurately?
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by castratikron on Sunday February 26, 2017 @01:06AM (#13735932)
I sometimes wonder how autonomous cars would fare in very rural areas. In the country, there's usually nothing on the road at all. But when there is, it can sometimes be something strange like, as you said, a moose, or a piece of plywood, or a slow driving tractor.

When I was a teenager growing up in the rural Midwest, I drove a small sports car. I always wanted to see if I could fit under one of these things (a crop sprayer) when I came up behind one on the highway:

https://wapellowarbler.files.wordpress.com/2010/06/edge-of-t...

I wonder if this kind of vehicle would even register on some cars' systems, or if autopilot would just charge full speed ahead underneath to my teenage heart's content.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by M_Grey on Saturday February 25, 2017 @09:47PM (#13735351)
Re your last point, this leaped immediately to mind.

http://souvenirsfromaprogramme.tumblr.com/post/44133459703/t...

David: The Robo-Cup Federation hope that by 2050 a team of fully autonomous humanoid robot soccer players will win a soccer game, complying with the official FIFA rules against the winner of the most recent World Cup of human soccer. That terrifies me. If they can run around and kick a ball and beat us at football, what else can they do?

John: Bring us breakfast in bed!

David: Yes, and then strangle us.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by nl on Saturday February 25, 2017 @09:52PM (#13735370)
I don't understand this logic at all.

We are supposed to be terrified by robot soccer players strangling us in bed? Sure it could happen, but there seems to be easier ways to die.

Apparently one of them is riding a bike around self driving cars.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by ChuckMcM on Saturday February 25, 2017 @10:15PM (#13735448)
It is the unintended consequences of things.

One of the better lines in 'Real Genius' (another comedy) is Lazlo's "All you's need is a tracking system and a, a large spinning mirror and you can vaporize a human target from space." where the consequence of the main character building a multi-GW laser is suddenly clear to that character.

I'm all in favor of self driving cars, and I look forward to the day I can use them to commute and work at the same time, but cars are already used as bombs in the middle east, it isn't a large step from self driving taxi to self driving car bomb is it?

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by M_Grey on Saturday February 25, 2017 @10:06PM (#13735411)
I feel I should point out at this juncture, that this was a quote from a BBC Radio 4 comedy, and that it's not to be taken as seriously as you seem to be.

I think his broader point though, as is the point of the person I was replying to originally, that when we design robots for highly adaptable, sophisticated tasks, we design a potentially very dangerous robot.

Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by nradov on Sunday February 26, 2017 @01:04AM (#13735929)
Right. Horses can beat humans in most running races. Gorillas and chimpanzees can beat humans in wrestling. And yet who's in charge?
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by M_Grey on Sunday February 26, 2017 @10:20AM (#13737594)
Because we can outthink them. We're actively trying to build something that can at least think as well as us.
Re:Self-Driving Cars Have a Bicycle Problem by gnipgnip on Saturday February 25, 2017 @11:03PM (#13735601)
There are deep cnn models for doing joint recognition detection at around 60fps (at 300x300) at reasonable accuracy 75%.

This is arguably the most expensIve part of the pipeline, but we sHould have atleast two more architectures out by NVDA/AMD before any product comes out.