[0] https://mobile.nytimes.com/2017/02/24/technology/anthony-lev...
The NTSB takes a similar view: autopilot failures that result in aircraft crashes are still human error, since the human should have corrected. Still not very encouraging, since the driver in this case would have had seconds at most to identify and fix the error with a panic stop.
It seems like a known problem, cars would not stop at any red light period and the driver just forgot to stop because he wasn't paying attention.
From the article it sort-of seems like that error is actually in the mapping software that didn't mark that intersection as having traffic lights, so the car didn't look for them.
I mean, take a school bus for instance. They don't have permanent red-light fixtures, but if you're behind them they could enable the red light sign at any moment. If the self-driving car isn't always looking wouldn't that be an issue?
The car needs to be able to communicate with people outside of it, or it needs to have a human inside who can drive it.
Self driving cars are probably just going to have to recognize hand signals. That's simply the reality.
And yes, I think they are doomed. At least for city streets - I expect them on specially instrumented freeways though.
Do you work in the field? I'm a bit skeptical about that. Waymo's self-driving car seems to do pretty well with things that aren't encoded in maps like road works and unexpected obstacles. I don't see why red lights would be exceptionally challenging to detect.
There are also pranksters that turn traffic lights by 90° to make them face the wrong direction.
Those are hard to map.
This seems to be a decision on par with "depend on left-pad". reliability wise
In Florida, the rule is that all traffic going in either direction must stop, except when the road is "a divided highway with an unpaved space of at least 5 feet, a raised median, or a physical barrier"[0], in which case the opposing traffic does not have to stop. It's interesting to me to see how little things like this change from place to place, and how these localized rules will be handled by self-driving vehicles.
[0]http://www.leg.state.fl.us/Statutes/index.cfm?App_mode=Displ...
"Who are you going to believe, me or your lying eyes?"
Screw Uber. I hope the CA government comes down hard on them. But we all know Uber will find yet another slimy way to keep going.
For the record, I'm the biggest proponent of autonomous cars and can't wait for that day. But companies that just put people in danger like this are not going to get us there faster. They're going to slow everything down by their carelessness and greed.
Like moving the program to Arizona...
The AI is expected to fail occasionally, so a human driver is onboard ready to intervene the instant that happens. The test driver wasn't paying attention, and the car ran a red light. It was a human error. Uber did not lie, they didn't mince words or twist the definition of things, the human driver just didn't do his job.
Irrespective of all the other bullshit going on with Uber, this is a mistake that any test driver with any other company testing autonomous prototypes on public roads could have made.
Just like with Tesla's Autopilot, any autonomous test vehicle is technically a level 2 vehicle, meaning the human driver is legally responsible for any traffic violation the vehicle makes.
They could have done, but they haven't. At best that means Uber are just unlucky; at worst it means that Uber are far behind every other self-driving car company and Uber's software just doesn't work for really simple, basic traffic laws. That should be very worrying for any investors.
That's from a 2010 NYT article by John Markoff. They ultimately hired Ron Medford, former NHTSA director to lead a big Johnny Appleseed awareness raising campaign with regulators, but initially they just went and started testing.
[1] https://mobile.nytimes.com/2010/10/10/science/10google.html?...
What's not fine is insisting you don't need a permit (the primary purpose of which appears to be transparency regarding safety), having a safety incident, and then implying in a public statement that it wasn't related to a software failure when it was.
- It was "human error" that the programmers who designed the self-driving AI failed to properly implement red-light detection and braking.
- It was also "human error" that the human driver in the front seat failed to notice the red lights and stop the car.
Uber's statement is effectively true, if you hideously twist the meaning of words. I fully believe that's what they did in their statement. There's similar wordplay for the word "natural", i.e. claiming "All pollution is natural", because humans are part of nature and everything we do is natural, so all consequences of our actions are also "natural". Deceiving yet ultimately, effective.
[1] Uber says self-driving car ran red light due to “human error” https://techcrunch.com/2016/12/14/uber-looking-into-incident...