News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by noonespecial on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @11:08AM (#13696512)
Its the London Cabbie(1) method. They're not looking to fill any particular role. They're just looking for smart people (for the value of smart that fits their biases).

They just need as many warm bodies as possible to ram through their test so that a few trickle out the bottom of the funnel to keep the ranks from shrinking. If too many started getting hired, they'd add competitive basket weaving to the skillset if that's what it took to balance it.

(1)http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/special-features/201...

Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by ryandrake on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @11:36AM (#13696805)
> They're not looking to fill any particular role. They're just looking for smart people

I've found this to be decidedly not true, from many recruiter contacts. They have a role in mind they're trying to fill and if you point out that it's far more junior than what you're looking for, the conversation's over.

Think about how must companies hire. The hiring manager fights internally and finally gets a req for a very specific role. They have to fill that role. Having a generally smart person would be great but they have this immediate need and they can only hire one person. And once that req is filled, no more hiring until you get another req.

I'd love to see a company literally just looking to snap up smart people and then have them come in and kind of define their own role, one where they can add the most value. Nobody does this!

Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by nolemurs on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @12:17PM (#13697275)
> I'd love to see a company literally just looking to snap up smart people and then have them come in and kind of define their own role, one where they can add the most value. Nobody does this!

I don't know about letting people "define their own role", but a lot of the biggest companies are constantly hiring without a specific role in mind. If you've got thousands of employees then your best strategy is just hire the smartest people you can find, and figure out how to use them effectively - you have enough roles available that you'll find something for anyone to do, and while not every role you need filled is someone's dream job, a combination of internal mobility between teams and great benefits and pay will attract a lot of good candidates.

Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by vonmoltke on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @12:37PM (#13697510)
The problem, from my perspective, is that I (as a candidate) have certain things I want to work on. You might have something I can do, but is it something I want to do? I don't want to be hired into a general pool; I want to be hired for one of the specialties I am interested in.
Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by fixermark on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @02:07PM (#13698526)
The problem is that what interests you now may not be economically valuable next year. They want you there past one project, because the future is too murky to guarantee your current role will continue to be needed.

Google et. al. are hiring generalists because they want people of a mindset such that when the entire special-purpose they hired them for dissolves, they're willing and eager to ramp up on a new project and new challenges instead of saying "Well, the foo project is closing down and foo's pretty much what I wanted to do, so I guess I'm going to quit (and take all the knowledge and skills Google spent time and money to train me up on with me)."

Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by vonmoltke on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @03:27PM (#13699560)
You are taking a much too narrow view of "specialization". If project foo is really the only project at Google that uses the skills I like and know best, I am probably not going to apply there.

I get that there are people who don't care (much) what kind of code they are working on. If those are the people Google exclusively wants, that's fine. I just won't have a place there. I do not think this is a generally-advisable strategy, though, as the GGP I was responding to indicated. In fact, I'd argue that well-crafted teams of specialists are superior to, but harder to staff than, teams of generalists.

Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by marssaxman on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @11:29PM (#13703008)
The funny part is that for all the work Google has done building a hiring process that searches for talented generalists, the actual work they have to offer is really boringly specialized. Most of what's going on in there is just stacks upon stacks of web-service middleware, endlessly slinging RPCs back and forth at each other. If that's your bag, then yay, Google is a great place to work! - but for me it was really discouraging to realize, four months in, that no more than ten per cent of Google was doing anything I was ever likely to care about. I didn't last long, and wouldn't go back (not that they'd be likely to want me).
Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by fixermark on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @03:39PM (#13699684)
Ah, I see what you mean and I think I agree; "well-crafted teams of specialists" are, hypothetically, one of the advantages of attempting to tackle a problem as a startup company as opposed to pulling the resources together within a large corporation to skunkworks the problem (though in terms of eventual success or failure, I don't know where to place that advantage relative to, say, having the luck / foresight to choose a problem that the market needs to solve and doesn't have a good solution already in the pipeline somewhere [and will need to solve long enough for a startup to reach minimum viable product] and the startup's capacity to trade equity for a staff that will work their bloody asses off).
Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by nolemurs on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @06:26PM (#13701221)
I definitely don't think that the generalist hiring practice is the best for all purposes - just that it makes a lot of sense for the bulk of the hiring at a large company, and that most the big tech companies do it.

The big tech companies do also build well-crafted teams of specialists where appropriate (for instance, Google's Deep Mind team is all AI specialists). I don't know what sort of hiring process they use for those roles, but I would wager the process is a little more personalized, and also substantially more selective.

Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by DesiLurker on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @03:46PM (#13699752)
I have seen this 'fungible bricklayer' approach at amazon & have to tell you it cant be any more misguided. It may work for generic web software where learning curve is not as steep but any point you are dealing with vertical technologies like wireless or multimedia it just falls flat on its face. And the byproduct is poorly thought out software full of band-aids. unfortunately this kind of nonsense often becomes pervasive where management itself is very non-technical (google may be an exception though).
Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by btilly on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @12:16PM (#13697260)
I've seen the opposite, from close observation on both sides.

The recruiter may start out with a role that they are trying to fill, but they have plenty of other roles that they could be happy to put you in. And furthermore for the right candidate, they don't have to figure out the role up front.

When I was hired by Google, SRE poached me out of a pipeline to a different group. (Accepting that offer was a mistake on both sides, but it was a learning experience.) When I was hired by Amazon, I was contacted for a job in Seattle, then got hired in Orange County.

That said, plenty of candidates start the process by being too arrogant about what they can demand. Recruiters know to look for that and stop wasting their own time taking these people seriously. That's why pointing out that a proposed role is too junior for you is likely to result in being dropped.

Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by ryandrake on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @01:35PM (#13698093)
Interesting, thanks for the insight. Funny how two people can look at the same recruiting environment in the same industry and have two totally different experiences.

> That said, plenty of candidates start the process by being too arrogant about what they can demand. Recruiters know to look for that and stop wasting their own time taking these people seriously.

Maybe, but I think it saves both sides time. If I'm shopping for a new sports car and a salesman approaches me with a great deal on a 10 year old pick-up truck, it's helpful for both of us if I make my expectations clear right away.

Most Recruiters: "I have this role you'll be great for! Let's see if it's a great match!"

Better Recruiter: "What are you looking for? I work with a lot of companies and probably have a great match!"

Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by btilly on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @02:45PM (#13699096)
Yeah, I've seen those recruiters. And they tend to not be honest about who they are actually working for. So, for example, you'll get contacted by someone who is recruiting for a job at a big name company, from someone who isn't from that company and doesn't know what is actually available from there. They only know about the one role that they were told about.

These things are generally a mess if you start out that way. Waste of time and money on both sides.

Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by chris11 on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @02:56PM (#13699220)
I'm interested in your experience with SRE. What did you like and dislike, and why was it a mistake?
Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by btilly on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @04:00PM (#13699903)
SRE is a difficult role because you need someone with the mindset of a sysadmin and the skills of a programmer. So Google (at least used to) will hire one and hope to find the other half. As a result a large fraction of people hired into the position are not a fit. And Google had no mechanism to identify and rectify this common problem.

I am a programmer. I tend to dive into things in depth and context switching is unusually hard for me. A sysadmin needs to be able to operate on relatively limited knowledge and rapid context switching is par for the course. I was therefore a poor fit in that role.

After I left I was shocked at how many people I met who had known someone else whose story matched mine pretty closely. I would hope that Google has solved this organizational problem since. But rumor from those I know that are still there indicate that things have gotten worse over time, not better, so I don't think that it has.

However it was quite educational. I wish things had worked out differently but I definitely learned a lot that has served me well since.

Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by nvarsj on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @04:22PM (#13700146)
I think it's tough hiring for an SRE role. Much tougher than a programming role. Although in Google's SRE book, they say the interview bar is lower than for their software engineers. Odd!

You're looking for the sort of person that could setup a startup from the data center up. On top of that, they need to be good coders so they can automate everything, and also understand the applications running on the things they build. It's generally a much more in-the-trenches job - relying on limited information, and much harder to test things in isolation since there are so many moving parts, and things you can't change or automate easily (network vendor appliances, and so on).

Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by linkregister on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @09:49PM (#13702534)
The coding standard for SRE hiring at Google is lower, but the other requirements are much higher or aren't considered for a generalist SWE role.
Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by rarec on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @11:46AM (#13696905)
Nobody does that because being smart is of no guarantee that this person can be of any use to a business.
Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by the_watcher on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @12:04PM (#13697130)
Are you entirely excluding university recruiting from this? Because consulting firms and investment banks routinely recruit smart people without any demonstrable experience doing what those companies plan to train them to do.
Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by VLM on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @12:45PM (#13697588)
That's almost exclusively ivy. We need a Yale guy, any Yale guy, doesn't matter who, just need it for the list of accomplishments. Then we can use our new "ivy atmosphere" to get that specific guy from Stanford or whatever.

The only place hiring generic warm bodies at random state-U is Starbucks.

Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by the_watcher on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @07:02PM (#13710445)
Consulting firms and investment banks recruit plenty out of my alma mater, UCLA (a public, state university that isn't considered part of the Ivy Plus). They did the same at University of Texas, where I went to graduate school, another public, state university.
Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by Arnt on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @12:05PM (#13697141)
You make it sound as if some other hiring method provides a guarantee.
Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by jowiar on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @12:12PM (#13697209)
Google is a little bit of both. At least from having gone through the process (and ultimately turning down an offer due to the ridiculousness of the process). There's a massive funnel where they're trying to bring in a bunch of smart people, then teams basically say "I have this position available, who has gone through the funnel that is a skills match for our specific teams".

> I'd love to see a company literally just looking to snap up smart people and then have them come in and kind of define their own role, one where they can add the most value. Nobody does this!

At least with hiring out of college, a lot of companies do the "Let's snap up smart people, then train them to do the specific job we need done". In my experience, this has been particularly prevalent among the big consulting firms.

Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by Le_SDT on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @11:41AM (#13696855)
I think Valve works a bit like that from what I've read.
Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by Spooky23 on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @11:48AM (#13696943)
There are a few different processes imo.

I have been through what you describe. A recruiter reaches out and tries to get you in their funnel. For me, it's a no-go because of my college background. (Unsexy school, shitty grades.)

A family member was pursued by them very aggressively after making some presentations at significant conferences and getting praise in a book written by a high level business exec.

This family member was received borderline harassing levels of outreach from recruiters from Google. It's pretty obvious there is some sort of targeted hunting list and KPIs associated with it.

Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by arielweisberg on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @11:38AM (#13696820)
And in theory it should totally be worth it as a candidate unless they are coasting on reputation. Otherwise the supply of candidates would dry up. In practice it wasn't for me, but I refused to tell them how much I made just to see what would happen.

If you interview at Google and they ask how much you make you should probably tell them or you might get a weak non-negotiable offer. Unless what you make is already far less than their "standard offer."

It would be a shame to waste all that effort by sticking to negotiation techniques that maybe don't work on Google for regular candidates.

Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by digler999 on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @12:16PM (#13697257)
why not just lie to them and tell them you make 20-30% more than you really do ?
Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by arielweisberg on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @12:30PM (#13697433)
Habit mostly I guess. I always implicitly assume lying has the risk of getting caught and then becoming known as liar. I don't evaluate on a case by case basis whether I should lie.

Also the experience of being caught lying is emotionally and mentally draining for me so I stopped way way back. Like in childhood. I wouldn't say I'm completely fib free, but if you are even remotely entitled to the truth your going to get it. If I get caught lying I have to be OK with it and not care. That is a high bar.

Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by cmdrfred on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @12:52PM (#13697647)
>but if you are even remotely entitled to the truth your going to get it

This is a negotiation, they aren't entitled to know how much you make nor do they have a good method of checking up on it.

Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by beachstartup on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @11:47AM (#13696925)
refusing to tell your prospective employer how much you want to get paid is a 'negotiation tactic'?
Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by gcp on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @11:51AM (#13696978)
I thought it was pretty well understood that you should never name a number, and if you're forced to, you should say 5 times the number you had in mind.
Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by beachstartup on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @01:45PM (#13698200)
that's absurd. you should name the price you expect, and not go below your minimum.

would you hire a plumber that refuses to name his rate, and then when pushed, tells you a number 5 times higher than normal? why do you think any other employment negotiation is any different?

if you "never name a number", the person on the other end is going to know you're inexperienced and operating on cargo cult mythology, and will simply take advantage of you.

Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by Apocryphon on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @02:51PM (#13699169)
The 5 times part is surely a joke, but not naming a number is like HN-promulgated salary negotiation 101

http://www.kalzumeus.com/2012/01/23/salary-negotiation/ https://www.twilio.com/blog/2016/02/patrick-mckenzie-on-sala...

Definitely would be good if someone wrote a counter-response to this prevailing meme

Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by twic on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @04:41PM (#13700317)
If you have a good idea of the price you expect, based on a clear understanding of what you can command, then this is an excellent idea.

The standard "don't name a number" advice is based on the assumption that most candidates don't have that. They know what they earn right now, but they don't know what they could be earning. In that situation, you want to sweat some information out of the recruiter by getting them to name the number.

There are other ways you can get a bit of edge.

In a previous round of job hunting, i let a recruiter persuade me to apply at Amazon, even though i was 85% sure i didn't want to work there. They made me an offer substantially higher than my salary at the time, because they're desperate to hire, because nobody wants to work there, because they're a shitshow. I could then take that offer to the other companies i applied to, where i actually did want to work, as a starting point in salary discussions.

In my most recent round, one recruiter said to me "Company X want to know how much you currently earn, because they can't offer above 130k for this position and they don't want to waste their time if you're on more than that". 130k may not sound like a lot to you over in the Valley, but it was getting on for twice what i was making at the time here in London. "Well,", i said in the most noncommital voice i could manage, "130k would probably be okay".

Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by astrange on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @12:18AM (#13703219)
What currency is the 130k in? If they made you move here to SV, it may not be a raise.
Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by twic on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @03:16PM (#13708783)
Pounds. It involved moving just over a mile from my old job.
Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by inimino on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @11:55AM (#13697020)
"how much you make" i.e. disclosing current or previous salary, not how much you want to make.
Re:Why I Don’t Talk to Google Recruiters by kefka on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @12:26PM (#13697379)
Yeah, I engaged a recruiter who seemed pretty decent at the onset. Then when I expressed interest in 2 positions, they demanded that I provide detailed salary for the last 3 jobs I have worked in.

I gave express disinterest in doing that, and had no issue with providing salary expectations. But I made it clear that this behavior was completely unprofessional and unbefitting of a recruiter.

I then told them in no uncertain terms that as long as they have this policy on their books, do not call back. If however, they change this, I would consider them again.