News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by simonsarris on Monday February 20, 2017 @09:59PM (#13692897)
So... not very independent.

Holder has advocated for Uber in the past, we know he has a relationship with upper management already, which suggests it may not be a very impartial investigation.

He's been in an advisory position to Uber since at least mid 2016. From July:

> In one of the widest national efforts that Eric Holder Jr. has undertaken for a client since rejoining Covington & Burling last year, the former U.S. attorney general has written to lawmakers in three states on behalf of Uber Technologies Inc., urging them not to mandate fingerprinting for driver background checks. [1]

> Holder's firm advises the company on safety matters and Uber asked him to write the letter, according to company spokesman Craig Ewer. [2]

I hate to be negative and rude but I don't think this is going to generate the best outcome. What if Holder is just their go-to big name to get... political problems solved, and they just consider this to be just another pesky political problem?

The article mentions Holder's firm, and they mention that the firm did an investigation into Airbnb, but they don't mention the previous relationship of that firm to Uber. This seems like relevant info for such a story and makes me wonder if the omission is intentional.

[1] http://www.law.com/sites/almstaff/2016/06/16/eric-holder-adv...

[2] http://bigstory.ap.org/article/01685274cc944196af9016ad0a875...

Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by rayiner on Monday February 20, 2017 @11:14PM (#13693229)
Internal investigations are not government prosecutions. They are an investigation by the company of what its employees did or are doing. "Independent" means independent of the employees, not impartial to the company. Such investigations are typically carried out by a firm familiar with the company and its operations.

Evidence acquired in an internal investigation is sometimes presented to the government to try and convince it not to prosecute. In that role, you generally want someone with credibility. At the same time, the lawyers doing the investigation are intensely protective of their credibility. Unlike any given client, the lawyers are repeat players with the government. And while the government double-checking your work won't uncover a single isolated instance of fraud, those odds change over repeated trials.

Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by tragic on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @02:52AM (#13694054)
That's the theory. It is not always the practice.[0]

[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/News_International_phone_hac...

Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by matt4077 on Monday February 20, 2017 @10:31PM (#13693036)
I'd give him the benefit of the doubt. At that level, corruption, either because of sympathies or financial interests, actually become less common: there is so much outside scrutiny of your work, and any failure will forever be tied to you, that it's in Holder's long-term interest to do a good job. He must be operating under the assumption that the author of that blog post will sue if his investigation appears tainted, and it's unlikely shoddy work by him could survive "the harassment trial of the century" (with dozens of lawyers and investigators using their power of discovery).

But yeah, the optics aren't great. They could've chosen someone like Michael Garcia who has proven his independence. I'm almost inclined to suspect incompetence by now.

Anyway, does it matter? Uber is subsidising each ride at a rate of about 50%, operates in a market with literally no barriers to entry and is saddled with the burden of having investors and lenders expecting some return on the dozens of billions they burned through.

People have finally realised it's a frat house run by red-faced chauvinists and it's only a matter of time until the financial music stops and investors realise this Ford Ponzi only has two seats.

Prediction: Uber will go under within the next 12 months, it will be revealed that they've been most creative in their bookkeeping and there'll be a sudden need of a few extra beds in some federal sweaty-white-collar prison.

Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by Gustomaximus on Monday February 20, 2017 @11:29PM (#13693277)
> Prediction: Uber will go under within the next 12 months, it will be revealed that they've been most creative in their bookkeeping and there'll be a sudden need of a few extra beds in some federal sweaty-white-collar prison.

I suspect it will be more of a Groupon type deal. They'll exist as a large player in an increasingly crowded market via their brand name advantage. Then expect big lay-offs as the valuations/cash injections drop and later some consolidation within the industry etc will shift everything to a significantly more realistic position.

IMO they left their IPO a little past the excitement point.

Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by koolba on Monday February 20, 2017 @10:57PM (#13693173)
I'll take the other side of that bet any day of the week.

I'm not disputing your assessment of the company culture or the VC fueled pricing. They're spot on. I just think there's no viable competitor (at the moment) to truly challenge them.

Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by base698 on Monday February 20, 2017 @11:08PM (#13693214)
Seriously: http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/eric-holder-wall-s...

Here's a man who just spent six years handing out soft-touch settlements to practically every Too Big to Fail bank in the world. Now he returns to a firm that represents many of those same companies: Morgan Stanley, Wells Fargo, Chase, Bank of America and Citigroup, to name a few.

Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by rorykoehler on Monday February 20, 2017 @11:06PM (#13693205)
They don't need one viable competitor. Many smaller/regional ones will do the trick just fine. I travel all over the world without using Uber. This year I used them in Lisbon and now Taipei. Since Taiwan shut them down I just using a taxi booking app. Deleted Uber account yesterday. Never coming back. There is always a convenient alternative.
Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by yeukhon on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @12:22AM (#13693488)
As you noted, Taiwan banned it. HK has a similar policy too. In the U.S. I am not aware of any bans on Uber driving program yet. That's a huge difference.
Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by fragmede on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @12:33AM (#13693526)
Not nationwide, but Uber pulled out of Austin, for one.

https://www.wsj.com/articles/texas-capital-city-votes-to-kee...

Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by yeukhon on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @02:02AM (#13693837)
That's not banning Uber from operating. Uber and Lfyt pulled out because they didn't agree with fingerprint check, so they decided to pressure the Austin government by halting the operation there. But I say yes this does give other local/native taxi apps a chance since they can now compete without Uber and Lyft, to be fair in this debate.
Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by andrewvc on Monday February 20, 2017 @10:56PM (#13693169)
Holder may do a great job but even the appearance of impropriety must be avoided in these cases. Holder should have declined; Uber should have found someone else.
Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by mk77 on Monday February 20, 2017 @11:21PM (#13693253)
You should check out what Microsoft and Intel were upto in the 90s before coming to conclusions.

What has changed though, in a month were we have seen Zuckerberg apologize, an Infosys leaker and now Uber, is employees don't really put up as much as they used to with org culture.

Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by codewithcheese on Monday February 20, 2017 @11:52PM (#13693367)
Profitable Microsoft and Intel?
Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by devoply on Monday February 20, 2017 @11:07PM (#13693211)
Let's play devil's advocate. Companies don't generally want cultures like these. This may be P/R, but at the same time do expect management to do something about the toxic culture. It's not as if it's in the best interest of the big wigs to have a dysfunctional management culture for their own sakes. If they are looking out for their pockets, they will do something about this... the problem is these sorts of cultures once they develop are very difficult to do something about.
Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by LordHumungous on Monday February 20, 2017 @10:39PM (#13693087)
Why does Uber have so many people from the Obama administration? I believe David Plouffe also works for them.
Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by yummyfajitas on Monday February 20, 2017 @11:07PM (#13693208)
Uber is in the complex position of engaging in civil disobedience and direct political action in order to give consumers the freedom to choose new transportation options (which includes, but is not limited to Uber). As such, hiring a bunch of political operatives is necessary.

It also illustrates a big flaw in capitalism. Uber is spending a lot of money fixing government, and after they spend the money their competitors can come in and reap the benefits for free. I truly don't understand why so many investors are giving them money to throw at what is essentially altruism, but I'm glad they are.

Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by jethro_tell on Monday February 20, 2017 @11:28PM (#13693274)
Uh, it's not a sit in for the right to use the same schools as the taxi companies, it's a calculated money grab. It's a bet that they can make enough progress before they go under. Sure, they saw the writing on the wall first, and I don't think anyone thinks this isn't where we will be in a few years, especially with self driving cars, but they're not MLK and co. They're a business that's intentionally breaking rules to make money.

Edit: The rules they are breaking may be silly, but they aren't fighting a moral cause. I guess this is the natural progression of corporations are people too.

Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by yummyfajitas on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @07:25AM (#13694972)
Imagine a person was engaging in civil disobedience and speaking to the public in order to eliminate segregation laws and gain the right to work higher paying jobs, to sell products to white customers, and similar financial reasons. I could equally well characterize that as a "calculated money grab".

Various businesses also didn't want to deal with the (costly) hassle of segregation, and opposed segregation for that reason.

Would that mean they "aren't fighting a moral cause"? Were the only people who were fighting for a moral cause the white northerners who had nothing to gain?

Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by dllthomas on Wednesday February 22, 2017 @07:20PM (#13710543)
> Were the only people who were fighting for a moral cause the white northerners who had nothing to gain?

Presumably the logic you are critiquing would also include any white southerners who stood to lose but still supported desegregation.

Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by smokeyj on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @01:50AM (#13693797)
> but they aren't fighting a moral cause

What exactly do you think I want from a car ride?

I encourage everyone to break stupid rules. Let's leave the moralizing to religion.

Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by CaptainZapp on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @02:51AM (#13694050)

  I encourage everyone to break stupid rules
Like, your driver not being intoxicated? Like, the person responsible for your life adhered to her mandatory rest period? Like the person driving you around is properly insured for the case that your face crashes through the windshield, because he was focused on his GPS and didn't note the lorry, which had right of way? Like showing a modicum of sense of place and orientation without being dependent on a GPS?

Yeah! let's fuck all those rules! They are purely for moralists!

Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by yummyfajitas on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @07:34AM (#13695001)
It's completely clear that by encouraging civil disobedience against stupid rules he actually meant breaking all the rules.

Similarly when MLK supported Rosa Parks after she broke the law against sitting in the wrong place, he definitely meant for everyone to break the laws against rape and murder.

Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by smokeyj on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @01:20PM (#13697923)
So if I give someone a ride for free, that's okay. But if I were to offer this ride in exchange for something - then that's bad?

And what about the morality of telling two consenting adults how they can peacefully organize? Do you always like telling people how to live their lives with the threat of violence?

Sounds like the type of religion that would lead to mass starvation. Oh wait..

Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by nb777 on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @08:27AM (#13695231)
There are way more important rules when it comes to passenger safety like e.g. driving according to the speed limit. I had a lot of taxi rides in my life and they definetly didn't feel safer than uber/lyft rides since, at least in my country, taxi drivers drive like lunatics.
Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by te_chris on Monday February 20, 2017 @11:19PM (#13693246)
"fixing government"
Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by r00fus on Monday February 20, 2017 @11:42PM (#13693326)
Is that what they call lobbying these days?
Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by NegativeLatency on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @12:14AM (#13693462)
This reads like someone payed you off, or you aren't looking at the situation holistically.
Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by LordHumungous on Thursday February 23, 2017 @09:46PM (#13720460)
"civil disobedience"

LOL. Give me a fucking break. Don't you dare use a term from the civil rights movement in reference to Uber.

Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by fleitz on Monday February 20, 2017 @10:44PM (#13693109)
Have you seen the politics around what they do?
Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by lowbloodsugar on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @12:01AM (#13693413)
I have finally deleted the app from my phone and installed Lyft. Its honestly not as good, but its good enough after taking this into account. I'll be talking to the five people who have installed Uber because of me too, three of whom are women.
Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by mk77 on Monday February 20, 2017 @11:14PM (#13693226)
Whats the best outcome? Just curious what people think would be a good outcome short term.
Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by obstinate on Monday February 20, 2017 @11:31PM (#13693287)
Good outcome would be:

* Determine what happened, and disclose.

* Offer compensation to Ms. Fowler, if warranted, and a public apology.

* Concrete changes in policy that would prevent this happening in the future.

Longer term, events like these should happen less at Uber.

Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by fragmede on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @12:59AM (#13693629)
Uber undoubtedly previously had a code of conduct that states this behavior is unacceptable but oh, look; here we are.

Changing a couple words in the policy doc? Not good enough.

If Uber actually wants to change, then heads need to roll. By which I mean fire a bunch of people and take away their options. A manager or three for inappropriate behavior; a bunch of people in HR, either for hushing up the problems in the first place ("Oh, this is the first time we're hearing about this." lol, really?) or for being incompetent at their job (specifically, opening them up to a huge lawsuit).

Whether Uber is willing to go that far is entirely up to them, just like it's up to me to determine if I'd even bother reinstalling the app.

Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by mdip on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @01:50AM (#13693796)
I'll second that HR comment. Honestly, I'd be considering expunging the entire team at this point. Assuming the allegations are correct, they violated the law directly in some cases and where they didn't, they ensured that ethical lapses went unpunished, reporters of ethical lapses were punished/threatened and that this was basically effective policy of the organization.

Staff within the company will never be comfortable with reporting incidents to that team unless all of management, anyone directly involved in these allegations and (probably) most of the HR staff is replaced. Hiring a good, well known, HR manager to rebuild the organization would be the next, good, step.

Policies and codes of conduct are like laws. If they're unenforced, they don't exist.

Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by obstinate on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @02:05AM (#13693853)
Oh, yeah. I would have said that was a given. The "policy" change would be a change in the strenuousness of enforcement of a no doubt preexisting policy.
Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by arjie on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @03:30AM (#13694205)
Is it legal to take away their options? Sounds like a bad precedent to set.
Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by runamok on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @11:29AM (#13696728)
Getting fired for cause usually means you lose them.
Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by grandalf on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @12:02AM (#13693418)
Excellent points. The whole thing wreaks of grossly incompetent HR staff, as well as a management team that was unaware of the very real legal risks that allowing this sort of culture creates.

The guy who did it may be eccentric and totally harmless to everyone who knows him, but none of that matters if there is evidence that a persistent harassment problem was not dealt with.

No matter what the circumstances, it's risky for a company to keep someone employed who has not completely rectified any problematic harassment behavior after receiving a single warning.

Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by adw on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @02:05AM (#13693851)
Ms. Fowler and all others similarly situated, I would suggest.
Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by obstinate on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @02:08AM (#13693866)
Yes, sorry, I didn't mean my list to be exhaustive. Just the first few things that popped into mind. As you say, the investigation should start with the exemplar, like all bug investigations. But the general case should be addressed too, possibly in parallel.
Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by flootch on Monday February 20, 2017 @10:19PM (#13692986)
Eric couldn't find a single bankster guilty of anything in the 2008 meltdown, and he wasn't able to find anything wrong with Fast & Furious, so I have to disagree with you, his appointment will certainly provide the best outcome for Uber.
Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by CalChris on Monday February 20, 2017 @10:55PM (#13693165)
One was found guilty, but point taken.

https://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/04/magazine/only-one-top-ban...

None were found guilty in Britain as well. Nor did Congress enact any meaningful reform. Hell, Arizona has re-elected John McCain and he was a bag man for Charles Keating.

Seems like no one, Justice, Congress or the American people want to hold people accountable.

Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by bboreham on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @04:27AM (#13694402)
> None were found guilty in Britain as well.

Interested to know why you exclude Jay Merchant, Alex Pabon, Peter Johnson et al from your count.

Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by CalChris on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @08:08AM (#13695133)
Thanks. The article I read was from before those convictions. And given the relative sizes of our countries, y'all did a much better job of holding people accountable. We clearly didn't.

After Enron, many people (not enough) went to prison. Arthur Anderson was shut down with huge job losses. White collar jobs. Politicians and the Justice Department have no stomach for that.

Maybe they have a point. In the 30s, a lot of good banks went down as a contagion spread. In 2008, it was already bad and no one but no one wanted that. Lehman was more of a hit job favor for Goldman Sachs, but also a visible sacrifice. But no one wanted the 30s again.

Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by flootch on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @07:18PM (#13701617)
Thanks, very interesting article on how we got there.
Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by brobinson on Monday February 20, 2017 @11:48PM (#13693351)
His refusal to provide documentation related to Fast & Furious also earned him the honor of being the first cabinet member ever to be found in contempt of Congress
Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by grandalf on Monday February 20, 2017 @11:56PM (#13693391)
> the best outcome for Uber

It's OK if it's the best outcome, so long as those who broke the law are fairly punished. At this point, I'm not aware that Susan has initiated a lawsuit, so I'm guessing she'll be contacted with a settlement offer.

This is a great example of how allowing a douche to act in a way that everyone knows violates sexual harassment laws can cost a company money and reputation.

If you're someone's boss, don't talk about sex with them unless you are sure they will be happy to have that conversation and won't have second thoughts within the statute of limitations.

Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by davedx on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @02:40AM (#13694000)
If you are someone's boss don't proposition them, period. It is an abuse of power.
Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by grandalf on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @06:12PM (#13701098)
Of course! My point was that even if you acknowledge some possible gray area, it's still a stupid thing to do.
Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by falcolas on Monday February 20, 2017 @10:26PM (#13693016)
I think he is referring to a finding in Uber's favor by a biased party being bad in the public eye.
Re:Uber Taps Eric Holder to Investigate Discrimination Claims by mdip on Tuesday February 21, 2017 @01:41AM (#13693767)
> best outcome for Uber.

Based on your comment, I'm inferring that your view is that the best possible outcome for Uber would be a situation where a sham investigation is performed, valid accusations are suppressed, they can claim everything's OK and continue business as usual (and that this is the outcome Uber desires -- and they may very well desire this, I'm certainly suspicious). If that's an incorrect read, then please accept my apologies for what follows because that's what I'm addressing in this response.

At this point "the genie is out of the bottle". Every major (and many minor) news source has reported on Sarah Fowler's allegations. There's no going back so some sort of response has to be made to what's being alleged. I see two possible, obvious, options: Suppress/obstruct/lie and distract with a sham investigation. Settle quietly with any accusers with strong NDAs. Come back in a few weeks with findings that are as transparent as mud or get in front of it, probably still settle quietly with accusers/NDAs, communicate internally and externally extremely strong policies addressing this sort of behavior and operate with a nearly "zero tolerance", weed out the bad actors and revisit/measure success at regular intervals.

The best possible, long term outcome for Uber would be to get to the truth of what is happening in a way that is as public and transparent as possible. Then "move heaven and earth" to correct it, continuing to operate as publicly as possible about the outcome. This is a "sharing economy" company where riders and drivers alike are being asked to put a great deal of trust in an entity that looks very untrustworthy at this point. Assuming the allegations are true, what's going on over there is all kinds of bad, and not just for the victims of harassment/discrimination. Sarah Fowler's allegations extend far beyond her personal experiences. The biggest red flag that I saw was the ineptitude and powerlessness exhibited by HR. Without a strong HR department with the ability to independently take action on ethical failures like this, the company, itself, cannot be trusted.

I've been lucky to be part of companies that had strong, established guidelines that extended beyond the protections of the law coupled with HR departments that had the authority to act independent of management[0]. I know of specific cases where popular, top performing managers were removed despite the desires of C-level executives. Policies left little room for interpretation, required yearly re-agreement (with really annoying and specific tests) and required reporting even of witnessed harassment (with teeth -- if you were a witness, failed to report and were found out, you were subject to termination with cause).

Companies that do not demand such obvious ethical behavior are almost certainly suffering from many forms of employee ethical lapses. Corporate culture that actively suppresses reporting of unethical/discriminatory and harassing behavior (through the inaction of HR), cause the "good people" to leave (or stay, but in a state of demotivation and without a chance that they'll ever stand up), and leave the company run by people you can't trust.

Again, assuming these are true allegations, this is a far worse place to be than the position of a company having to apologize for bad behavior, settle some lawsuits and take the necessary action to restore confidence in what they're doing. Attacking it head on comes with the immediate risk that the dirty laundry will be aired for all to see, customers will lose confidence in the company and they won't be able to regain trust quickly enough after the bad actors are rooted out and the problem is corrected, but the alternative is like a pot of soup set to boil. At some point, the multiplication of bubbles accelerates until it rapidly boils over and in this case that might not be something that can be recovered from. It's also possible we're witnessing that pot boiling over right now.

[0] I was never in HR, but had near family-level friendships with a higher-up in that department who shared information that they almost certainly should not have with me.