> We're not talking about a dumb mower that is not storing any of your personal information.
Exactly. That's why it's even more important that we be able to repair it ourselves.
> Apple has the absolute right to protect it in order to protect your data, even in the ways that prevents you from repairing your yourself.
There are no absolute rights. There are laws. I trust myself more than Apple and I don't think there's much you can say to convince me otherwise.
> If you want to repair, take it to Apple or if there's no store, mail it in.
Nope. I'd rather not, thanks! That's why we're going to get this law passed.
I don't trust anyone, but I only want Apple to hold the keys, not all random repair stores. It is a FAR worse idea to force Apple to provide security bypasses.
If security bypasses can be provided securely as LONG as you authorize it on the spot, then heck yes, force Apple to do this. But if they cannot, then nope, they shouldn't be forced.
> Exactly. That's why it's even more important that we be able to repair it ourselves.
I don't think we're disagreeing here, I'm totally on your side that we should be able to repair everything ourselves but I cannot agree with forcing companies to provide security bypasses in a manner that may be done without your knowledge.
> There are no absolute rights. There are laws. I trust myself more than Apple and I don't think there's much you can say to convince me otherwise.
You are correct, I phrased it wrong since there is a clear technical definition of what absolute right means.
I didn't say you shouldn't have the right to repair everything yourself. I'm totally on this but I disagree again on the security components, you should be able to replace it as long as it can be securely does and with information that only you know. Forcing Apple to provide this to repair shops without explicit controls over it, is a bad idea.
> Nope. I'd rather not, thanks! That's why we're going to get this law passed.
I've edited my post after that.
Each customer should hold a personalized key to his own hardware. Then the customer can decide whom he trusts, and give the key to whomever he wants (Apple, some other repair store, do it himself, ...)
The problem is that as long as somebody else holds the key to something you bought, you didn't buy it, you leased it. Or borrowed it. Somebody else can still control it to a greater degree than you yourself. And that somebody now has a monopoly he can use to force thing onto you. Like set prices for repair.
That shouldn't happen.
If you give someone a key to the device, how does the device itself enforce a time-limited key, especially if the crypto-based components are about to be replaced?
That's a straw man, you've already trusted Apple. The argument is 'trust no one else' which seems like a good idea.
I want to own those keys. I actually don't want to trust anybody but myself if I can help it.
Which means hackers could advertise cheap repairs, in exchange for placing malware hardware/software on user device.
I like to see the hardware opensource, as it is immensely valuable, but apple does have a point.
A more secure etc way could be if they made it impossible for themselves to read your data.
tl;dw the process includes a blender.
One example that stood out to me was that a sensor that told the machine something was broken was broken. Due to this, the farmer could not use a perfectly operational tractor for two weeks because there was no way to override the sensor. And the John Deere tech would take two weeks to get out there.
This line sounds like it is directly targeting John Deere and how they handle the manufacture and repair of their tractors. Farmers are actually paying more for ~10-20 year old equipment that can be repaired.
I know WIRED isn't the greatest, but these articles fascinated me. I think after looking at them, that line will make a lot more sense to you.
https://www.wired.com/2015/02/new-high-tech-farm-equipment-n...
I mean, even when I do hand my device to the manufacturer I don't necessarily want to grant them access to my data.
Yes of course, screen/battery/radio etc but suppose we're talking about the TouchID+SoC integrated security component that store your authentication data. Should Apple be forced to provide a security bypass to allow the repair shop to randomly replace this with a different part not authorized by Apple?
There has to be clear definition of what they mean by security bypasses.
The San Bernardino case was different because he wasn't going to be unlocking his phone any time soon...
I have a feeling I'm overthinking what the article said. I need to look at the law itself.
Here's an alternate universe: You replace your home button, and now you need to use your PIN to unlock the device and Touch ID is reinitialised.
And in any case, I don't know why we're playing into Apple's security theatre, if there are technically sophisticated adversaries who can invade your personal security trying to hack you, it's game over for you. Nothing Apple does with Touch ID will be relevant.
Well, no, they don't have an absolute right, do they? Apple's rights are tempered by law.
I meant that Apple as a company has obligations to protect you and your data at all costs. State laws should consider the impact of said forced lock bypasses.
A key everybody has a copy of is not much of a key.
User info should be locked away by the entity to whom the information was entrusted in the first place. In this case Apple. Yes, if you buy an iPhone and use it access/generate information then it is by definition already entrusted to Apple. Don't like it? Don't buy an iPhone. Better yet, go use a self-built Linux PC. Forgo smart phones altogether.
> Right to repair bills in each state require manufacturers to provide software tools to bypass locks that prevent repair.
No, sorry. I do agree with companies (not just Apple) with locking down the security components to ensure no one could just take your device, replace a few components and give it back without your knowledge. We live in an increasingly mobile-only world and where such mobile components are getting more complex, powerful and more information-dense.
We're not talking about a dumb mower that is not storing any of your personal information, we're talking about a smart phone with complex security systems in it. Apple has the absolute right to protect it in order to protect your data, even in the ways that prevents you from repairing it yourself. With this law, there's no barrier or visible line between your ex replacing parts to monitor you and you replacing parts to repair it. Apple has a security lock for a very clear reason, to prevent your ex from doing this.
If you want to repair the broken Touch ID sensor and stuff, take it to Apple or if there's no store, mail it in.
If you just want to replace the battery or screen, then yes, Apple should be forced to sell these parts, just not the security related parts. Did the law clarify this distinction?