News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to get rich in America by adriand on Thursday February 16, 2017 @06:48AM (#13659150)
Radiolab recently featured (http://www.radiolab.org/story/radiolab-presents-media-busted...) some content from another podcast series called "Busted: America’s Poverty Myths", that examines various myths about the poor - and by extension, the rich - in the US. It was fascinating. One thing that was discussed is the degree of upward economic mobility in the USA. IIRC, they measure this by the likelihood that someone who is born into a family that is in the bottom 20% of earners enters the top 20% of earners in their lifetime.

In other words, what is the statistical basis for the belief that in America, anyone can go from "rags to riches"?

It turns out that in the US, the percentage of people who achieve this feat is, on average, about 7%. In Canada, it's about 13.5%. Another myth busted.

Conclusion: if you want to get rich in the Americas - or at least, well-off in the Americas - come immigrate to Canada. Especially if you're reading this comment, since you likely have the kind of education and experience that makes immigrating here a breeze. Sure, it's cold here in the winter, but you'll make enough cash that you can spend a chunk of the winter in Mexico!

Re:How to get rich in America by flexie on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:29AM (#13659369)
Yes, the social mobility of Americans is almost non existent. One thing I noticed when I lived there is that even people at the bottom and in the middle thought that it was a meritocracy because 1) smart people who 2) studied really hard get into one of the great colleges, get the good jobs and become powerful and wealthy.

The paper that the article is about shows that your chances of going to a great college are 117 times higher if your parents are top 0.1 percent than if your parents are in the bottom quintile. So little Zach who's dad packs parcels for Amazon doesn't even have 1 percent of the chance of getting into Princeton as Matt who's father heads a team working on the Amazon Web Services. Not even 1 percent.

And apart from that I never understood why a genetic advantage like being born smart is less unfair than other birth rights or whether success in life depending on making the right choices when you are a teenager should be much more of a meritocracy. Almost no kid makes those right choices - to study the right things hard, do extracurricular activities etc - without a supporting parent enabling it.

And when there seem to be no fair meritocracy it's so much worse that the wealth distribution is skewed beyond anything.

Re:How to get rich in America by Shivetya on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:38AM (#13659411)
Well there are not many opportunities for the poor in major American cities to get out of their condition and the way welfare and assistance programs are structured it can be detrimental to get beyond a certain means.

To solve a good amount of the city's poor prospects we need to get the War on Drugs back to reality. It not only strikes the city but it hits the poor outside as well. Families that least can withstand the loss of one income are the most affected.

Fix this damn War on Drugs, fix the police preying on the poor with seizure laws, and find a means to reduce the everyday government fees that hit the poor disproportionately will go a long way

Re:How to get rich in America by cmdrfred on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:44AM (#13659448)
I wouldn't claim 7% is non-existent. I think we tell children that college is the only path to wealth and thus many whom never had the opportunity to receive any college believe that they can't achieve anything but a poverty level standard of living. I grew up poor and believed this myself up until a few years ago and even without the benefit of a high school degree I have found that my upward mobility is only limited by my willingness to work hard and make strategic moves.

I wish one of my teachers would have told me that success is possible without education, but then again they went to college and got a government job so they probably had no idea that the path I'm traveling even exists.

Re:How to get rich in America by vixen99 on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:45AM (#13659456)
Reminds me of the quip about the guy who, confronted by a smart friend over his family wealth, retorted "You inherited brains, why shouldn't I inherit money?".
Re:How to get rich in America by tornadoboy55 on Thursday February 16, 2017 @08:07AM (#13659575)
'because if I do nothing with my brain, I'll have nothing. But if you have your 2 million sitting around (in an investment account), it'll earn you 160.000 a year.'
Re:How to get rich in America by owebmaster on Thursday February 16, 2017 @05:07PM (#13664003)
Intelligence is not inherited, it is teached. Smart parents raise smart children, but their same children raised out in the jungle would be dumb just like monkeys.
Re:How to get rich in America by CSMastermind on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:08AM (#13659254)
I'm biased here. I grew up well within the bottom 20% if not the bottom 10% of family incomes. I'm now personally in the top 5%. At no point in my life did it feel like there was anything holding me back. In fact if anything it was frustrating to watch as other people in my situation got handouts while I had to work my way up. I think America is just fine (with maybe a little too much affirmative action).
Re:How to get rich in America by Inconel on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:23AM (#13659341)
I grew up well below the bottom 10% as well, and I'm no where near the top 5% either. I often feel a sense of inadequacy when I compare myself to those with better upbringings, and their subsequently greater accomplishments.

At the same time I saw a lot of kids worse off than myself work much harder and I feel disappointed or even ashamed that I didn't take advantage of the opportunities I did have.

Re:How to get rich in America by oblio on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:11AM (#13659275)
Well, it depends on your environment. What where your parents doing and what was your personal "big break"?
Re:How to get rich in America by CSMastermind on Thursday February 16, 2017 @08:20AM (#13659646)
I grew up in a pretty bad home. My mother was crazy and didn't work and my father was an alcoholic who owned a bar. Got my first job at 13 and I've been working since. After high school I joined the Marine Corps and spent 6 years in the infantry. Got out 6 years ago and went to college on the GI Bill. Worked throughout college (including internships every summer) and got a great job when I got out. Worked my way up as fast as I could.

I'm not sure there's a "big break" I could point to besides maybe when I decided to join the military? But that's really something anyone could do.

Re:How to get rich in America by klibertp on Thursday February 16, 2017 @09:25AM (#13660048)
> maybe when I decided to join the military? But that's really something anyone could do.

Not if you're handicapped physically in any way, not if you fail psychological screening, not if you're an immigrant, probably not if you're too old and so on (I'm talking about the military in my country, but is it any different in the US?). And of course not if the military as a whole is against your beliefs.

Going into the military is like becoming a priest. Most of the same advantages and disadvantages apply. Yes, it is a way out of poverty, but it's also a way of life you need to buy into.

Re:How to get rich in America by kamaal on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:19AM (#13659315)
>>what was your personal "big break"?

This.

Many times.

Often people luck-out and think that the same would happen to everyone sooner or later. Or worse they think it was their work all along and nothing else.

You can very easily deceive yourself into believing a certain set of things when the times are going good. Unfortunately you might have to fail for reasons beyond your control(for a lot of time, on a lot of things) to convince you otherwise.

Re:How to get rich in America by david38 on Thursday February 16, 2017 @11:13AM (#13661054)
None of the successful people I know had a single "big break". It took a handful, but more importantly it took the willingness to take risk or do without.

1. Did you study in high school while everyone else was having fun? 2. Break - get into good school 3. Did you graduate with a difficult degree? This is pure tenacity. 4. Did you do interesting projects on the side in college? Tenacity. 5. Said degree + projects lead to job. Sort of break. 6. Moving across the country for a better job - tenacity. 7. Switching jobs many times to move up - tenacity 8. Promotion to management/lead/whatever. Tenacity + break because you have a boss that likes you 9. Large jump in salary by jumping to a company on the way up - break. 10. Several years with low medical bills, no divorce, whatever so you can save $50k+ per year. Break with slight tenacity for not splurging on stuff

Re:How to get rich in America by amelius on Thursday February 16, 2017 @10:30AM (#13660623)
And then there are people who reject any "big break" coming to them because they feel they need to accomplish something on their own.
Re:How to get rich in America by thex10 on Friday February 17, 2017 @07:11AM (#13667677)
Of course you think America is just fine - you made it out the bottom. Survivorship bias at work? ;)
Re:How to get rich in America by hackerboos on Thursday February 16, 2017 @08:55AM (#13659855)
Handouts from America's thread-bare welfare system?

You should really listen to the show from RadioLab. NPR's On The Media aired some of it too.

Re:How to get rich in America by oblio on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:10AM (#13659271)
> In other words, what is the statistical basis for the belief that in America, anyone can go from "rags to riches"?

Inertia of perception. If someone's perception of something is relatively solidified, it takes a long time - or major events - to change that perception. More so for massive groups of people.

The whole "rags to riches" mostly comes from the late 19th century, when the US was still expanding geographically and all the new folks could still get a piece of land for nothing.

That perception was solidified after WW1/WW2, from which the US came out unscathed and a lot richer due to becoming the world's supplier of weapons, materiel and a lot of other things that couldn't be reasonably produced in countries that were actually feeling the effects of those wars (occupations, massive bombings, etc.).

Now the US is a plain ol' regular country where almost everything has been divided up but to make things worse the general culture is very individualistic (self-perception changes just as slowly...).

Re:How to get rich in America by antisthenes on Thursday February 16, 2017 @01:08PM (#13662111)
Not to mention, the post-war period leading up to 1973, US saw the highest oil consumption per capita of any country in the world, and higher than today still.

That wealth didn't come from anywhere - it came from extensive exploitation of fossil based fuels.

Re:How to get rich in America by ismail-khan on Thursday February 16, 2017 @09:00AM (#13659882)
This isn't the fairest comparison, because the richest Americans are richer than the richest Canadians. If the Canadian income distribution is tighter, then it's easier for a Canadian to reach the top 20% simply because the gap between bottom 20 and top 20 is smaller.

I think a fairer comparison would be to specify the "yardsticks" on both sides: what % of people in either country below X income manage to achieve an income above Y?

Re:How to get rich in America by auxym on Thursday February 16, 2017 @06:54AM (#13659177)
People reading this on HN are probably already in the top 20% of earners, or close enough. As such, they are likely better off in the US.

Edit: actually, based off a quick Google search, it seems that if you earn 150k, you are in fact in the top 5%

Re:How to get rich in America by icemelt8 on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:03AM (#13659215)
From Pakistan earning $1600 per month :(

Hackernews is not as small as you think

Re:How to get rich in America by ryan_j_naughton on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:31AM (#13659375)
You're right and you're wrong.

The per capita income in Pakistan is $1,600 a year. You are making 12X the average salary.

Your $19,200 salary, when adjusted for purchasing power (about a 3-4X purchasing power multiplier) and you're effective PPP income is $60-80K.

And honestly that puts you in the exact same category as the rest of us with respect of this article: upper middle class engineers who are generally working to make others rich.

This article mentions the vast majority of 1% individuals are bc of working in finance.

This extends into the tech world where the vast majority of equity goes to investors. Thus, even our efforts are primarily enriching individuals in the finance 1% instead of enabling us to move into the 1% ourselves.

This is not too say we don't move up (Obviously the biggest centralization of wealth has been to individuals who founded tech companies), but engineering incomes in silicon valley are far lower on average than Wall Street incomes.

Re:How to get rich in America by yread on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:11AM (#13659276)
You probably live like a king for 1600 in Pakistan though
Re:How to get rich in America by icemelt8 on Thursday February 16, 2017 @08:13AM (#13659609)
I have my good days thanks :)
Re:How to get rich in America by Kurtz79 on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:15AM (#13659298)
... and it doesn't put you in the top 20% in Pakistan ?

http://www.averagesalarysurvey.com/pakistan

It would be a decent salary for many countries in Europe.

Re:How to get rich in America by oblio on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:12AM (#13659279)
Are you earning $1600 in Pakistan on in the US? I'm pretty sure you're top 10% if not 5% with that income, in Pakistan.
Re:How to get rich in America by aclsid on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:37AM (#13659403)
$1000 bucks can get you decent living standards in developing countries. But I would not say by a long shot he is in the top 5% by any standard.

Developing countries main characteristic is the huge disparity between the haves and have-nots, which of course, leads to emigration and crime among other issues. Countries with a large middle class therefore are relatively better off.

In any case, making $4000 per month or more is what'll get you royalty style living in those countries.

Re:How to get rich in America by oblio on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:42AM (#13659437)
According to Wikipedia, the GDP per capita in Pakistan is $1400. He's making > $19000 per year, so he's making 14x what the average Pakistani citizen is producing, not earning.

I'm pretty sure he's in the top 5% :)

Re:How to get rich in America by imaginenore on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:01AM (#13659204)
Which I wouldn't consider rich. Moderately wealthy, but not enough to even buy a 2br in SF or Manhattan.
Re:How to get rich in America by tluyben2 on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:07AM (#13659245)
You are right but why is that something to strive for though? Most people here say they want to become 'rich' to achieve freedom. Why would your artificially make achieving that freedom harder by wanting to buy a 2br in Manhattan or SF? In many other, cheaper places, you have the freedom and thus achieved 'rich'. I am incredibly puzzled by the need to live in the most expensive places on earth; how does that benefit your quality of life? This is my lack of imagination maybe, I am not trying to judge here.
Re:How to get rich in America by ryan_j_naughton on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:54AM (#13659513)
>>>I am incredibly puzzled by the need to live in the most expensive places on earth; how does that benefit your quality of life?

You have the causality in the wrong order. They are the most expensive places on earth because they improve your quality of life, not the other way around. The price is derived from demand which is derived from a desire to have access to many goods, services, and experiences not available in many other places.

I can speak personally to two other cities I've lived in where housing costs are quite high (though lower than SF and Manhattan): DC and Santa Monica / West LA.

My fiancée and I lived in DC for 5 years in a wonderful expat bubble. While I'm am American, the vast majority of our friends were from all around the world and worked at international development organizations. The extra money we paid for housing was worth all the interesting experiences.

Los Angeles is no different. It's easy to find interesting experiences and food through its diverse populations. There is a fundamental aspect to the nature of cities, viz. that there is a good to density itself. It enables humans to get value out of the shear existence of interacting with other humans in interesting ways. You need enough demand for an experience to support the existence of many experiences (e.g. You can't have a live punk music scene in a town of 100 people. Or even if somehow you do bc the entire town loves punk, it will be at the expense of those people being into other interests. Having enough people with enough wealth and distributed across enough interests/cultures/foods/music tastes, etc facilitates access to way more possible experiences. That, at least, I why I love large American cities.

Re:How to get rich in America by tluyben2 on Thursday February 16, 2017 @09:02AM (#13659893)
That is a good point, but those experiences can be had in other, much cheaper cities around the world. Why pick exactly the most expensive ones. The experiences can be had in most big cities I have been, the goods + services are getting there but i'm not personally not too driven by that but can see others might be. For all these things I can see your point, just not why pick the most expensive ones?

And I guess it also has to do with the phase in your life; I value freedom above goods & services handy. The satisfying experiences I have in cities all over, also cheap as chips cities in Asia and cities & villages in Asia & Europe. For people making so much money it seems that freedom is within reach if only compromise on the place of living is made. But you make a good points; I made/make decisions based on those points as well at some times; just now I value freedom more than other things.

Re:How to get rich in America by jblok on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:06AM (#13659241)
Those areas cover probably max 0.1% of total land area in the USA.

Since these are some of the most sought after real estate areas, it seems these areas would be the preserve of the top 0.1%, or 1%. Back of the napkin maths here I'll admit.

The good news is there's still a huge chunk of the country where you would be considered wealthy by land value prices.

Re:How to get rich in America by croon on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:47AM (#13659465)
> Those areas cover probably max 0.1% of total land area in the USA.

Much less than that. I did a quick calculation and Manhattan + SF is 0.0018% of total US land area. Might be 0.1% if it's only developed land.

> Since these are some of the most sought after real estate areas, it seems these areas would be the preserve of the top 0.1%, or 1%. Back of the napkin maths here I'll admit.

1.6M live in Manhattan, 800k in SF. That's 0.8% of the population.

Re:How to get rich in America by manarth on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:07AM (#13659247)

  Which I wouldn't consider rich
Perhaps this is a sign of the severity of income and wealth inequality: that even having more income than 95% of the country isn't enough to be considered 'rich'.
Re:How to get rich in America by wklauss on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:08AM (#13659252)
Manhattan is a big island. You can buy a 2br (and not in a terrible location) with 150k/yr.
Re:How to get rich in America by jononor on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:06AM (#13659233)
Richer than 95% of people in your country is not rich?
Re:How to get rich in America by dsacco on Thursday February 16, 2017 @08:02AM (#13659546)
I agree with you. But speaking as someone who is in "the 1%", my experience is that most Americans don't define wealth by numbers, they define it by how jetset a lifestyle can be.

Of course being richer than 95% of the country makes you "rich"; that's near tautological. But that's not really the perception. Rather, the perception is that you're rich when you no longer need to work at all and can simply do whatever you want. That's really fuzzy, and I'd agree that it's indicative of wealth disparity in America that this has become the predominant conception of wealth.

My point is that you two are probably talking past each other without meaning to.

Re:How to get rich in America by branchless on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:07AM (#13659250)
Better off because their compatriots are worse off.

And the downvotes begin. Usa high inequality means low pay for many which benefits the wealthy!!

Re:How to get rich in America by svdree on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:11AM (#13659274)
Could it be that the distance between the top and bottom 20% is less in Canada, making it easier to move from one to the other?
Re:How to get rich in America by hackerboos on Thursday February 16, 2017 @09:03AM (#13659897)
That's a fair point.

Average earnings of Canada's 1% - $358,238 USD - http://globalnews.ca/news/3079173/heres-how-much-canadas-top...

Average earnings of US's 1% - $1,153,298 USD - http://www.mlive.com/news/index.ssf/2016/08/see_the_average_...

Couldn't find averages for the poorest but Canada's bottom 20% is 0-13,223 USD - http://www.moneysense.ca/save/financial-planning/the-all-can...

America's bottom 20% 0-18,500 USD (US Census Bureau, 2006; income statistics for the year 2005)

Looking at raw numbers skips over a lot of things such as healthcare and education. You're probably better off being poor in Canada and rich in the US.

Re:How to get rich in America by colefichter on Thursday February 16, 2017 @09:51AM (#13660231)
> Could it be that the distance between the top and bottom 20% is less in Canada

You're just describing the results of inequality: two things are further apart than two other things. It doesn't tell you anything about the cause of inequality, only the magnitude of one symptom.

It's like saying "a mile is longer than a kilometer". Well, yes that's an apt description but it doesn't tell you why that is the case.

Re:How to get rich in America by otalp on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:42AM (#13659440)
I'm thinking of doing my masters in(and eventually moving to)Canada instead of the US.

For the country that I'm from, the waiting time to get permanent residency in the US is much more than a decade, and with the political instability that's present now, it doesn't look to like changing soon. I don't think spending the best years of my life on a temporary worker visa- with all the restrictions and uncertainties that come with it, is worthwhile.

That comes with a compromise of course. The Canadian tech industry is, as far as I'm aware, miniscule compared to the US; but then the tech industry in the US exceeds virtually every other country in both quantity and quality, so it's not a fair comparison.

I wonder if people familiar with the tech scene in Canada can talk about how it compares to say, Europe, or if it really is a big compromise working in Canada instead of the US for a tech job(because of the lower wages and higher taxes).

Re:How to get rich in America by phil21 on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:48AM (#13659472)
> I wonder if people familiar with the tech scene in Canada can talk about how it compares to say, Europe, or if it really is a big compromise working in Canada instead of the US for a tech job(because of the lower wages and higher taxes).

I can't give you much direct experience, but I will say every "rockstar" level talent I know from Canada either immigrated to the US or is working remotely for a US company. Based on those conversation the top level talent seems to be making 2-3x more in the US on average than in Canada.

Re:How to get rich in America by RodericDay on Thursday February 16, 2017 @08:30AM (#13659716)
Doctors also make less in Canada. Lawyers also make less. Movie Stars also make less. CEOs too.

Everyone at the top makes less money in Canada, but the lower bound is quite higher as well. Education is much, much more affordable (e.g.: 4k/yr for university in Quebec), health care is universal (e.g.: as a clueless student I didn't pay anything when I had peritonitis and had to spend weeks in the hospital), etc.

People need to understand this. That extra money you get to pocket when working in the US isn't coming out of nowhere. You're complicit in the horrible state of US welfare, and profiting from it.

Re:How to get rich in America by anovikov on Thursday February 16, 2017 @08:05AM (#13659565)
Well why it has to be more? See, if that was 20%, it meant that wealth distribution is entirely random and parents can't do anything to help their children succeed - that is not the world where many want to live. There should be a balance - getting from poor to rich must be possible, but hard.

People who get rich are those to work towards distant goals and accept delayed gratification. If they are unable to pass anything at all to their children they'd have a much better time drinking and smoking hash - there isn't so much they can spend in their lifetimes anyway, and if they can't pass anything (even cultural! that helps besides money and would already skew that ratio away from 20% down, even if all money was taken away) to their kids - why bother? To me, 7% of 20% poorest making it to 20% richest sounds already too much.

Re:How to get rich in America by Thimothy on Thursday February 16, 2017 @10:07AM (#13660389)
"since you likely have the kind of education and experience that makes immigrating here a breeze"

I don't think you ever tried immigrating to Canada. I don't mean this snarkily but the world would be a much better place if every citizen was forced at some point to go through his countries immigration process.

I have a friend who has been for the last years going through the Canadian immigration and his lengthy facebook posts describe an awful and demeaning experience. In all disclosure, his partner is from a third world country, and that's probably the biggest problem, but he's a clever, resourceful and valuable person that has been living all around the world, including SV, and it's absolutely incredible how have made everything in their hands short of blocking his entry in the country to stop his immigration.

Re:How to get rich in America by adriand on Thursday February 16, 2017 @08:30PM (#13665202)
This didn't seem snarky to me. I appreciate the comment. I'm sure it's very hard - and my comment about it was unnecessarily flippant. In fact I know my country has some unjust immigration policies, like skimming the cream from developing nations. They invest in educating people to become doctors, then we lure them here. I'm sure there's a lot of other stuff like this that would be easy to criticize.
Re:How to get rich in America by pasbesoin on Friday February 17, 2017 @07:12PM (#13672837)
If this is what I recall hearing recently, it also had a very interesting, long segment with a professor who studied e.g. payday loans by having an in and working for 4 months at a payday loan business. She also did some other work pertaining to low income individuals' finances -- I don't recall exactly what, right now.

Turns out, listening to people and their reasons and how it all works, that these people were not acting "irrationally" at all -- within their contexts. There were very valid reasons they did not have bank accounts nor rely on banks to deposit checks, etc.

It didn't negate the expenses involved. But it provided a lot of information that balanced that not just against the sometimes unavailability of "traditional" alternatives but also against the unreported, undiscussed, perhaps too frequently not known or discussed downsides of those "traditional" alternatives.

As just one example: You have to pay rent, or your workers, or whatever, today or tomorrow or soon. With the payday or check cashing business, you leave with cash in hand. With the bank, you have to wait for e.g. a client's check that you just received today, to clear. Up to three days. And if something doesn't clear or there's some other mistake, suddenly you have $25, or $50, or whatever amount of penalties hit your budget. That continue to accumulate until you can fix your cash flow.

And, with software, banks have taken to deliberately, algorithmically maximizing those penalties. E.g you have $100 in your account, and three checks hit for $25, $50, and $125 on the same day. The bank will prioritize the $125 check first, so that you are hit with three overdraft checks, three sets of fees. Instead of e.g. clearing the $25 and $50 checks and leaving you with one overdraft.

It can be argued, I suppose that the bank is minimizing its exposure in some combinations of amounts and overdrafts it decides to allow. But really, it is racking up the fees.

And if you're on a very tight budget, these fees totally disrupt it.

Say a check you deposited didn't clear or clear in the expected timeframe. Bam, now your budget has a big hole in it due to large, unexpected fees.

People avoid this, instead paying the cut the the check cashing business.

It was very interesting. And a lesson in the risks of just absorbing and parroting some often reported "common sense".

Re:How to get rich in America by aanm1988 on Thursday February 16, 2017 @08:08PM (#13665104)
If you're a software dev, don't move to Canada.
Re:How to get rich in America by yummyfajitas on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:18AM (#13659308)
This number conflates can with will. We cannot rule out the possibility that actual mobility is low because people at the bottom choose not to engage in behaviors that would help them rise.

I.e., imagine if the poor simply refuse work that's available [1], choose to have children outside of wedlock, do lots of drugs and commit lots of crime, they will likely remain poor. That's not evidence that "rags to riches" is impossible or even difficult, it's merely evidence that some people prefer other things more than riches and those people don't move up.

Here's a concrete thought experiment: imagine a poor Gujurati or Bengali moves to the US. Do you think he'll remain poor?

[1] It's a common liberal trope that we need Mexican immigration because they do jobs that "Americans just won't do". Strangely the implications of this are never explored.

Re:How to get rich in America by sdrothrock on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:23AM (#13659340)
> imagine if the poor simply refuse work that's available (i.e. the kind of jobs that Mexicans do), choose to have children outside of wedlock, do lots of drugs and commit lots of crime, they will likely remain poor.

I'm from a relatively poor family (food stamps, free lunches) and have always been a believer in "where there's a will, there's a way," but this comment has a definite bias. You could have put in more "positive" choices that would have been completely realistic.

Perhaps they choose to spend more time with their children instead of 100 hours a week in the office or at two or three jobs, or they choose to live in a small town near family despite limited upward growth opportunities.

Many people I went to high school with are "poor" because of the latter choice. When you grow up with a local supportive network and everyone helps everyone else out (say, driving someone to work because their car broke down, watching someone else's kids because their mother is sick, passing on hand-me-downs), it's very hard to leave that network -- not only because of the loss of safety, but because of the social aspect of betrayal; leaving the network represents a loss of resources for everyone in the network and can be seen as a selfish behavior.

There are more reasons to "stay poor" than "looking down on work, too much sex, drugs, and crime."

Re:How to get rich in America by someguydave on Thursday February 16, 2017 @11:51PM (#13666020)
>but this comment has a definite bias.

The fact that a majority of poor people are not criminals does not exclude the possibility that that criminals are more prevalent among the poor than any other wealth group.

Re:How to get rich in America by sdrothrock on Saturday February 18, 2017 @03:34AM (#13674073)
The initial discussion was about "poor people," not "criminals" or even "criminals among the poor." To enter that discussion with a focus on the symptoms of the minority to apply them to the state of the majority is disingenuous.
Re:How to get rich in America by timr on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:22AM (#13659332)
" We cannot rule out the possibility that actual mobility is low because people at the bottom choose not to engage in behaviors that would help them rise."

Actually, your statement is such a common (and cruel) myth that there's a there's a whole episode in the series debunking it. You should listen to it.

http://www.wnyc.org/story/who-deserves-to-be-poor/

Re:How to get rich in America by yummyfajitas on Thursday February 16, 2017 @07:34AM (#13659384)
No, it's you who is spreading myths.

The poor choose not to work: https://www.bls.gov/opub/reports/working-poor/archive/a-prof... http://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/library/publication...

Single motherhood is strongly correlated with poverty: http://www3.uakron.edu/schulze/401/readings/singleparfam.htm

The poor commit lots of crimes, including crimes with no economic motive (wife beating, rape): https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/hpnvv0812.pdf

The poor also disproportionately do drugs: https://www.samhsa.gov/data/sites/default/files/2013MHDetTab...

Re:How to get rich in America by ryan_j_naughton on Thursday February 16, 2017 @08:05AM (#13659567)
From the BLS PDF: >Full-time workers continued to be much less likely to be among the working poor than were part- time workers. Among people in the labor force for 27 weeks or more, 4.1 percent of those usually employed full time were classified as working poor, compared with 15.8 percent of part-time workers.

That doesn't imply choice. Their clearly can and is a positive correlation between working part time and being unable to find full time work.

Re:How to get rich in America by yummyfajitas on Thursday February 16, 2017 @08:17AM (#13659631)
If only the BLS thought of this - then they might have included this data in Table 1. From that table we could then learn that 20% of the working poor (or about 7% of poor adults) are in this situation.

The number which implies choice is actually in paragraph 1, however: only 35% of poor adults worked or looked for work for at least 27 weeks/year. The remainder chose to engage in other non-work activities.

Re:How to get rich in America by Retric on Thursday February 16, 2017 @08:02AM (#13659554)
There is a lot of bias in these numbers. People who have more money are less likely get fought doing drugs, but they are also able to afford to do more drugs. The risks of doing drugs drop when you do one transaction a month, vs trying to feed a daily or even hourly habit.
Re:How to get rich in America by yummyfajitas on Thursday February 16, 2017 @08:08AM (#13659580)
Too bad the study authors didn't think of that. If they did, they might have decided to use a survey rather than arrest data. Then they might even have titled the study "RESULTS FROM THE 2013 NATIONAL SURVEY ON DRUG USE AND HEALTH: MENTAL HEALTH DETAILED TABLES".

Step 1 in making a methodological critique of a study is to actually read the study.

Re:How to get rich in America by Retric on Thursday February 16, 2017 @08:18AM (#13659639)
Yes, because the CEO of IBM is going to say they use drugs.

Survey does not mean what you think it means. If you read this they are going to defend the method as a means to track tends but not the actual numbers involved.

Re:How to get rich in America by yummyfajitas on Thursday February 16, 2017 @08:27AM (#13659696)
Unlike last time when you clearly didn't read it, I think that this time you actually read the study and identified a major methodological flaw (in under 11 minutes!!!) that the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Administration didn't notice at all.
Re:How to get rich in America by Retric on Thursday February 16, 2017 @08:34AM (#13659735)
No, working with heath data on a regular basis I can tell you that it's not a flaw in the study. It's a flaw in your interpretation of the study. Pill speaking behavior for example is common even amount those who don't consider themselves drug addicts.

Surveys are a very useful tool, but because the heath care community and patient don't agree on definitions they don't represent absolute numbers well.

Re:How to get rich in America by gjm11 on Thursday February 16, 2017 @08:38AM (#13659757)
I looked through the 16-page BLS report and 20-page USCB report you linked but didn't see where either said that "the poor choose not to work" or anything close to equivalent to that. The nearest I can find is that people working full-time are less likely to be poor than people working part-time, but if there's anything saying that everyone working part-time does so by choice then I failed to see it.

... I see from another comment you've made that your actual point lies in the background information the BLS report mentions at the start (FFS, would it have killed you to say that at the outset?): 45.3M poor people, of whom only 10.5M are "working poor", from which you conclude that the others have chosen not to work. Well, let's take a look. About 14% of US senior citizens and 18% of US children are in poverty. That's about 14% of about 45M plus 18% of about 70M, or about 19M people. These are not people who have chosen not to work, but people not in a position to do so. So that leaves about 16M people of working age but not in the labour force. What else? There are about 10M people with disabilities in the US who are of working age but not in the labour force. I don't know what fraction of them are not in the labour force because their disability prevents them working, but let's suppose it's only half of those people. (I bet it's more.) That would leave 11M people in the US who are in poverty, of working age, not unable to work because of disability, and yet not in the labour force. Are all those people poor by choice? Well, no; I bet a lot of them are people who have tried and tried to find employment, failed and failed, and eventually given up in despair. But let's suppose I'm wrong and all those people could realistically get a job if they wanted. (I bet at least half of them couldn't.) And let's suppose, optimistically given those working-poor statistics, that all of them could realistically get a job that would stop them being poor. (I bet at least half of those who could get a job couldn't get one that would actually lift them out of poverty.) That would mean that ~11M out of 45M poor people in the US are poor by choice. Less than a quarter of 'em. (My guess, as per my parenthetical comments above, is that the real figure is more like 2-3M out of 45M, but I'm being generous to you here.)

Yes, poor people commit more crimes than rich people, even crimes with no direct connection to money. May I suggest that you take five minutes and see what other explanations you can think of for that, besides "poor people are naturally bad people who do bad things"? I can think of several. Here are a few to get you started: (1) Poor people can't afford to live in nice places; in the nasty places, there is more violence for them to get caught up in. (2) Poverty causes stress and people under stress are more likely to commit crimes. (3) The laws that determine what things are crimes are generally made by well-off people, whose characteristic ways of screwing other people over tend not to be criminalized. If a rich person and a poor person do equal amounts of harm to others, the poor person is much more likely to go to jail.

Yes, poor people use illegal drugs more than rich people, and (you linked to a 577-page document and gave no indication of exactly what bit of it you had in mind) what may be more to the point is that when poor people use illegal drugs it's more likely to mess up their lives enough that it gets noticed. (Because the worse your situation is, the more likely it is that doing drugs makes it really bad.) Again: I suggest that you spend a few minutes really trying to think of explanations other than "poor people are stupid people who do stupid things"; I can think of several. Rather than suggesting some examples, I'll leave this one up to you completely.

None of this justifies the claim that poor people are generally poor because they choose not to do things that would stop them being poor. (It's evidence against a strawman theory that says poverty strikes completely at random and there's nothing at all anyone can do about it. I don't think anyone believes that, though.)

My guess, FWIW: There's a whole spectrum from "ample opportunity for a comfortable life, voluntarily did things that screwed that up and became poor as a result" through "difficult initial situation made it much harder to avoid poverty, failed to do so" and "became poor by whatever means, and the circumstances of poverty make it harder to make the sort of decisions that might get you out of it" to "terrible situation from the outset, never really had a chance", and there are people all along it; everyone's situation is the result of interaction between their character and their environment, and the two shape one another in any case; most comfortably off people, if suddenly made poor without other changes to their character and social networks and so forth, would get out of poverty; but most comfortably off people, if they had been dropped into a situation of poverty from childhood onward, would not have escaped; in any case, responding to poverty with "eh, it's their choice, no point trying to fix it" is not only callous and inhumane but also unlikely to be an effective way of reducing poverty.

Re:How to get rich in America by yummyfajitas on Thursday February 16, 2017 @08:56AM (#13659860)
I looked through the 16-page BLS report and 20-page USCB report you linked but didn't see where either said that "the poor choose not to work"

I'm glad you could figure out this fact, stated in the first couple of paragraphs of the first study I cited, which I also explained in a comment 23 minutes before yours: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13659631

Well, no; I bet a lot of them are people who have tried and tried to find employment, failed and failed, and eventually given up in despair. But let's suppose I'm wrong and all those people could realistically get a job if they wanted. (I bet at least half of them couldn't.)

I bet they could, even if no hablo ingles y no se permite trabajo.

Here are a few to get you started: (1) Poor people can't afford to live in nice places; in the nasty places, there is more violence for them to get caught up in. (2) Poverty causes stress and people under stress are more likely to commit crimes. (3) The laws that determine what things are crimes are generally made by well-off people, whose characteristic ways of screwing other people over tend not to be criminalized.

Yes, the laws against wife beating are made by people who are rich enough to afford a wife who isn't "asking for it". And I can totally see how I'd "get caught up in" raping people if I lived a stressful life of watching TV in a bad neighborhood while not working.

most comfortably off people, if suddenly made poor without other changes to their character and social networks and so forth, would get out of poverty; but most comfortably off people, if they had been dropped into a situation of poverty from childhood onward, would not have escaped;

I'm a bit confused. On the one hand, the tone of your post suggests you strongly disagree with me. Yet you've just explicitly stated complete agreement with me on my core point.

It's evidence against a strawman theory that says poverty strikes completely at random and there's nothing at all anyone can do about it. I don't think anyone believes that, though.

That's not a straw man at all. Adriand discussed whether "anyone can go from "rags to riches"" and declared this "myth busted" based on the fact that most people don't. The only way the latter could imply the former is if all of them attempted to, but simply were unable to do so.

Re:How to get rich in America by gjm11 on Thursday February 16, 2017 @05:22PM (#13664121)
> Yes, laws against wife beating are made ...

You are (I assume deliberately) missing my point, which is not that the law is too strict about misbehaviours characteristic of the poor but that it is too lenient about misbehaviours characteristic of the rich.

> On the one hand, the tone of your post suggests you strongly disagree with me. Yet you've just explicitly stated complete agreement with me on my core point.

First: you might consider the possibility that I might agree with you about some things and not others. Second: there are at least two possible versions of a point similar to the one I am agreeing with. One (with which I very much do not agree) says: the reason these people are poor is because they are inferior people -- stupid, lazy, etc. -- and they neither deserve nor will profit from sympathy or financial help. The other (with which I agree, with reservations) says: for the most part, these people behave much as anyone else would if put in their circumstances from early in life; some of their troubles are caused in part by their behaviour, but that behaviour is in turn caused in part by their troubles, and by and large the troubles come first.

These two perspectives agree on at least one important point: The most effective ways of dealing with poverty will attack it systemically rather than by playing whack-a-mole with individual cases.

> Adriand discussed ...

You may not have noticed, but there were two people in that thread taking positions different from yours, and the one you were actually replying to was not adriand and wasn't making the exact same claims.

Anyway: when you say "anyone can do X", I suggest it means more than "it is not literally impossible for anyone to do X". If in one country 7% of people who start in the poorest quintile get into the richest quintile, and in another 13% do, then there is a difference between those countries in how true it is that "anyone can get rich".

Perhaps anyone can go from rags to riches, in the sense that it's not literally impossible for them to do so. But that's compatible with there being substantial obstacles in the way, and if the fraction of people who manage it is small that's evidence for (though not proof of) such obstacles.

Is 7% small enough to make it strong evidence? As it happens I'm inclined to think not; your reply to adriand wasn't the one I disagreed with and replied to. That was your reply to timr. And the claim you made there was this: It's a myth to say that it's a myth that social mobility in the US is low because poor Americans choose not to do things that would help them get not-poor.

It doesn't seem to me that you've done a good job of defending that claim, which is more or less equivalent to the claim that social mobility in the US is in fact low because poor Americans choose not to do things that would help them get not-poor.

If at some point you want to discuss this with attention to the actual points at issue rather than just engaging in snark and presupposing all your claims, do let me know.

Re:How to get rich in America by timr on Thursday February 16, 2017 @10:02AM (#13660334)
So, did you listen to the podcast, or did you just decide I'm wrong and start arguing?
Re:How to get rich in America by yummyfajitas on Thursday February 16, 2017 @10:06AM (#13660376)
The transcript is quite long. Can you tell me where they show that the Census, BLS, BJS and other government agencies that I cite are wrong?
Re:How to get rich in America by timr on Thursday February 16, 2017 @10:51PM (#13665776)
so, no, you didn't.
Re:How to get rich in America by RodericDay on Thursday February 16, 2017 @08:26AM (#13659691)
Every single time a post about poverty and inequality comes up, like clockwork, you're defending the status quo, greed, the american system, etc.

Is there any place you expound on your views in more detail? I think I'd like to mount a more formal, less piecemeal rebuttal to your worldview, if I can.

Re:How to get rich in America by yummyfajitas on Thursday February 16, 2017 @08:38AM (#13659756)
I've been considering writing a blog post on the topic. However, I don't think I'm arguing as much as you think I am. I'm not arguing for a status quo, greed or the American system.

I'm merely arguing that certain behaviors seem to be extremely common among the (American) poor and that these behaviors also have a direct causal relationship with being poor. This is my major claim - do you disagree with this?

Re:How to get rich in America by RodericDay on Thursday February 16, 2017 @08:47AM (#13659800)
No, but I find it strange to stop there, and find satisfaction in blaming it on 'poverty'.

Okay, poor people do things that keep them poor. You may call it a "poverty cycle".

Where to go from there? A lot of people reach out for race and genetics pretty quickly. I don't think this holds. What else is there? Economic policy, surely.

Re:How to get rich in America by yummyfajitas on Thursday February 16, 2017 @09:17AM (#13659997)
As I said in my reply to gjm11:

Adriand discussed whether "anyone can go from "rags to riches"" and declared this "myth busted" based on the fact that most people don't. The only way the latter could imply the former is if all of them attempted to, but simply were unable to do so.

That's the sole point being made in the comment you replied to. There are behaviors people can engage in to stop being poor, they simply don't.

I'm not allergic to genetic explanations, but I also believe that economic policy can affect behavior. I favor economic policies that will put the poor back to work and get them to stop engaging in these destructive behaviors.

(For example, I favor replacing welfare/disability fraud/etc with a Basic Job - like a basic income, but only given to people who work for it.)

Re:How to get rich in America by RodericDay on Thursday February 16, 2017 @12:13PM (#13661617)
> I'm not allergic to genetic explanations

I suspect this is an understatement. Looking forward to you expounding on your views in greater detail sometime.