Re:Free Software Foundation statement on WebM and VP8
by _delirium on Friday May 21, 2010 @03:39AM
(#1366704)
Haha, I clicked expecting exactly the same thing. And I actually quite like the FSF; I see them as usually serving a role of idealistic critic, which is useful to have, especially in something like free software. But reality rarely satisfies the idealistic critic, so it's surprising when the critic actually loves something!
Re:Free Software Foundation statement on WebM and VP8
by zokier on Friday May 21, 2010 @12:48AM
(#1366413)
One thing I have been wondering is how will xiph.org guys react? Developing Theora much further seems bit useless now. Will they begin developing VP8 or maybe specialize Theora for something different that web video. Theora has the advantage of being bit lighter on resources.
It's worth bearing in mind that Monty created Vorbis, as used for audio for WebM, but Theora was donated from On2's VP3 so there may be less sense of ownership. Plus their basic mission is royalty-free, open-source friendly media so this is a big thing for them.
They seem to be hinting that they can let Google do the publicity and get back into their core competency of R&D for future formats that will be substantially better than encumbered alternatives.
Re:Free Software Foundation statement on WebM and VP8
by tzs on Thursday May 20, 2010 @08:43PM
(#1365996)
Microsoft will support VP8 in IE9.
Apple's HTML5 implementation uses Quicktime, so supports any format for which you have a Quicktime plug-in. I have no trouble, for instance, watching Ogg Theora video on HTML5 sites in Safari on my Mac.
I'd expect that Perian will add VP8 support for Mac, since they already have a couple other codecs from the VP family. Perian is a third party collection of codecs for Quicktime.
Re:Free Software Foundation statement on WebM and VP8
by jrockway on Thursday May 20, 2010 @09:01PM
(#1366024)
I doubt Apple will cooperate with Google. On the other hand, if YouTube drops support for H.264, then Apple really has no choice. I don't know how much money Google makes from YouTube mobile, but if it's not much, they can really screw Apple over if they want to. Who's going to buy an iPhone if it can't use Youtube or any other online video site?
I, FOR ONE, WELCOME OUR NEW WEBM OVERLORDS:
http://xiphmont.livejournal.com/50239.html
and more officially,
Xiph.Org announces support for the WebM open media project:
http://xiphmont.livejournal.com/2010/05/20/
It's worth bearing in mind that Monty created Vorbis, as used for audio for WebM, but Theora was donated from On2's VP3 so there may be less sense of ownership. Plus their basic mission is royalty-free, open-source friendly media so this is a big thing for them.
They seem to be hinting that they can let Google do the publicity and get back into their core competency of R&D for future formats that will be substantially better than encumbered alternatives.
Apple's HTML5 implementation uses Quicktime, so supports any format for which you have a Quicktime plug-in. I have no trouble, for instance, watching Ogg Theora video on HTML5 sites in Safari on my Mac.
I'd expect that Perian will add VP8 support for Mac, since they already have a couple other codecs from the VP family. Perian is a third party collection of codecs for Quicktime.
http://developer.android.com/guide/appendix/media-formats.ht...