News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by lazaroclapp on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @03:10AM (#13642057)
The problem with suggesting that the salary bar be set at the median of the lifetime salary, is that it does mean closing the door to current international students in the U.S., and to recent graduates recruited from universities abroad. The minimum bar for an immigrant should not be that they are better than half the people already employed here in their field, regardless of their stage in life. And, of course, most people immigrate when they are young and without kids.

If you truly believe that H-1B should exist only for truly extraordinary talent, not available in the U.S. at any salary, this might be a reasonable proposal. But the thing is, there is already a program for extraordinary talent, the O-1 and EB-1 categories. If you instead believe that it should be possible for companies to get the best talent, regardless of where they happen to have been born, and for people to work abroad from their nations of birth, then the H-1B program can't be quite that stringent. It is a skilled workers program, and H-1B workers are skilled. It is not a genius engineer only program.

Now, if your proposal is to change green card process so that employers can't hold people hostage over it, or to institute controls that companies can't underpay H1-B workers on average, that's one thing. But in the current political climate the suggestions seems to be "all foreigners must go! exceptions made for super stars". If the U.S. is truly becoming that closed, I genuinely think that, over time, it will find the best technology being developed elsewhere (maybe not at the research lab level if it keeps the O-1/EB-1 programs, but at the industrial/software innovation level for sure). Either in the countries that welcome immigration of skilled professionals (e.g. Canada, Germany, Singapore) or those with large pools of human capital to being with (e.g. China and India).

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by stupidcar on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @03:55AM (#13642224)
You're ignoring the fact the US already produces a surplus of skilled and qualified STEM professionals. Freedom of labor movement is a nice–to–have, but not some ideological priority that must be placed above all other considerations. The size of the pool of human capital is irrelevant if there simply aren't enough jobs on offer.

The government of a country should be first and foremost advocates for, and protectors of, the welfare of its own citizens. If a large number of those citizens are being encouraged to accumulate massive debts gaining an education that them leaves them unable to find a job, then that is a social problem that needs a solution. And if the government can help the situation by putting reasonable restrictions on the number of foreign workers competing for those jobs, then they absolutely should do that.

I really do not understand how so many people came to view these kind of theoretical, free-market niceties as more important than the practical wellbeing of their fellow citizens, but it's an incredibly dangerous attitude. If you support free-markets and globalisation, then you should want them implemented in a way that doesn't cause major social damage that ends up creating hostility to them. Otherwise, you end up with the kinds of populist movements we're seeing now, which feed upon the resentments of people who've watched successive governments refuse to place their own citizen's welfare above that of an ideology that harms them.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by lazaroclapp on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @04:45AM (#13642407)
They are not theoretical, free-market niceties when you have lived abroad for 6 years. Or when your parents are both from different countries. Or when your grandparent immigrated out of the U.S. to live 2/3rds of his life in the country you were born in and never encountered this level of pushback. There is a lot to be said for making welfare systems work together with immigration. But putting "fellow citizens" above everyone else is not an easy question for everyone (and yes, I advocate for immigration and non-discrimination for hiring in my country of origin too).

Also, acting like the STEM jobs in the U.S. exist independent of globalization is disingenuous. They exist because S.V. software is used across global markets, so if protectionism for labor is ok as long as it helps your citizens, then I assume the same is true for trade protectionism or Internet 'great firewalls'? The problem is, that way, we all end up significantly worse for it.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by aaron-lebo on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @06:02AM (#13642663)
But they are theoretical free-market niceties when you are a minority that has a low chance of getting a job in tech because companies would rather import cheap foreigners rather than work on building up a domestic workforce. The same goes for if you are a poor white person in the middle of nowhere. Unfortunately, the same people driving these conditions would also use the results of this to drive the two groups against each other for ideological reasons that are seen as good.

The US is a nation of immigrants. Nobody should deny that. But when workers inside a nation are negatively affected because companies would rather source cheap labor, there's a problem. A country's job first and foremost is to protect the rights of its citizens.

They exist because S.V. software is used across global markets, so if protectionism for labor is ok as long as it helps your citizens, then I assume the same is true for trade protectionism or Internet 'great firewalls'?

No, they exist because software is used across the world. Presumably if we weren't artificially manipulating labor, it'd help the domestic industries of many countries. To your second comment, IP, labor and capital have always been separated. You are directly conflating physical and virtual goods and that would not hold up in an other discussion in this industry.

You can make this into some kind of indignant us vs them thing but I assure you there are a lot of people who care about the rights of workers everywhere and the current situation clearly has detrimental aspects.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by lazaroclapp on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @06:33AM (#13642779)
But I am not making it an us vs them, that's the whole point. Your argument is that we should all be trying to maximize the benefits to the citizens of our own country, and no one else, literally an us vs them position. For many countries, blocking U.S. Internet services and substituting 80%-of-the-way domestic alternatives does just that in terms of boosting employment. It might not be the same legal framework, but if you are advocating for putting co-national workers first at all costs, then that's very much an option. I consider an open web to be one of those principles that are worth maintaining, though. But it definitely is lower on the list than many other concerns that might count as 'nice to haves' under the nationalistic argument I am seeing made.

Note that I am in favor of better conditions for workers, more progressive taxes, UBI, free higher education, some forms of fair-trade arrangements, you name it. What I am not for is "no foreigners until unemployment is strictly at zero". I think in the long run we should be able to come up with systems at the national and international levels that are fair to both local workers and immigrants. In the context of the current administration, though, I don't see us getting that, I see a lot of scapegoating, a lot of rash policies and an international industry supported by an international workforce, eventually either dying, fragmenting or leaving the U.S.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by aaron-lebo on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @06:41AM (#13642813)
Your argument is that we should all be trying to maximize the benefits to the citizens of our own country, and no one else, literally an us vs them position.

Building up domestic industries is a win for everyone and that goes for any country. Send your best workers to Silicon Valley and your nation is already suffering a drain on talent.

For many countries, blocking U.S. Internet services and substituting 80%-of-the-way domestic alternatives does just that in terms of boosting employment. It might not be the same legal framework, but if you are advocating for putting co-national workers first at all costs, then that's very much an option.

Those countries are welcome to try it and it might even be good for them, but I doubt they want to lose access to US services. That's what leverage is. If those countries have leverage then let them use it.

I think in the long run we should be able to come up with systems at the national and international levels that are fair to both local workers and immigrants.

Ok, so let's deal with the current H-1B program now instead of waiting another 4 or 8 or 16 years or however long some people would like to delay it.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by NetStrikeForce on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @06:46AM (#13642845)
I have always found interesting that people try to chalk out freedom of labour movement as a "nicety, an ideological thing" - while I have to accept that Facebook, Microsoft, Google, Apple, Amazon can become rich selling to my people while the US is protectionist with the well-paid job positions in those companies.

You can sell your shit to me and I can't sell my labour to you. Ok, at least pay taxes locally and fund my universities, roads and infrastructures to pump up the local market.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by shard972 on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @07:11AM (#13642950)
I mean, it's not like your people are being forced to use and buy products from these companies. So why should the US be forced to take in workers from other countries?
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by winter_blue on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @07:24AM (#13643021)
> why should the US be forced

You've got it backwards. Nobody is forcing the US to take anyone. Instead, employers in the US are instead being forced to hire native workers, and are effectively being prohibited from hiring from the rest of the world. It's this prohibition that needs to be defended.

I'm an employer, and I want to hire a French software developer. I'm willing to pay him $160,000 a year. But now, immigration restrictionists are getting in my way and saying that I can't hire him. If I hire him disregarding the laws prohibiting me from doing so, I would get hit by heavy fines and might literally be thrown in jail. Immigration restrictionists effectively advocate for the use of state violence to block me from employing non-Americans.

Now this isn't some hypothetical story that I came up with. I work for a French company that has an office in New York, and we've tried to bring a Software Developer from our Paris office for two years now. For two years in a row, he lost the H-1B lottery both times. The L-1B visa didn't work out either. My company which is French-owned and French-based and has to deal with this stuff. It's this restrictionism that has got to be justified.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by muninn_ on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @07:46AM (#13643122)
I'll be concise here: you can hire an American. There are plenty of people who can do that job living in New York City.
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by krzyk on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @08:32AM (#13643350)
Why hire someone new and train him when you have a guy that doesn't need training.
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by muninn_ on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @08:58AM (#13643499)
Because that guy lives in a different country, and the business is in the United States.
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by krzyk on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @01:22PM (#13645749)
No, the business is international with HQ outside US. They just have a branch in the US.
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by muninn_ on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @02:25PM (#13646323)
Right so it's a non-American company, so hire somebody in the Us for that branch.
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by wdcgu on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @11:27AM (#13644675)
Ah, don't you miss good old xenophobia and isolationism?
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by cpburns2009 on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @12:51PM (#13645478)
Preferring to hire people from already in your own country would be patriotic rather than isolationist. That's not xenophobia though because there's no irrational or intense fear of foreigners. That is unless "xenophobia" has been perverted to now mean anything that isn't hardcore globalist.
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by NetStrikeForce on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @03:59PM (#13647117)
What's an objective reason to hire someone born locally vs someone born abroad? Apart from saying "patriotism", what other advantages does it offer?
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by shard972 on Saturday February 18, 2017 @11:59AM (#13675487)
Well you have culture first of all, bringing in people from different cultures can lead to animosity and interpersonal conflict at times. Not to mention divise social groups that can occur when you hire alot from one particular country.

That and language, I have worked with devs and testers who just didn't have a great grasp on the english language which lead to a lot of frustration on both sides as we probably used half our jira comments clarifying/confirming what the other person meant.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by cpburns2009 on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @05:17PM (#13647767)
I meant anyone already in the country and legally permitted to work, not the country you were born in.

One objective reason to favor hiring a candidate living locally over one abroad is effective communication. The less local a candidate is, the greater the chance of poor communication due to increasingly diverging dialects and cultures and a lack of knowledge about the local culture.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by NetStrikeForce on Thursday February 16, 2017 @06:23AM (#13659060)
> I meant anyone already in the country and legally permitted to work, not the country you were born in.

Ah, fair enough, I guess the reason is to "avoid the process of bringing someone from abroad". Sounds pragmatic enough to me.

> One objective reason to favor hiring a candidate living locally over one abroad is effective communication. The less local a candidate is, the greater the chance of poor communication due to increasingly diverging dialects and cultures and a lack of knowledge about the local culture.

You have just contradicted yourself; but let's bite: Even if this looks reasonable to you, it's nowhere near the problem you think it is and most of the times far outweighed by the other reasons you had to choose a non-locally-born-or-raised candidate.

It also decreases diversity, which studies show is an advantage and not just a nicety.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by cpburns2009 on Thursday February 16, 2017 @09:50AM (#13660212)
> You have just contradicted yourself; but let's bite: Even if this looks reasonable to you, it's nowhere near the problem you think it is and most of the times far outweighed by the other reasons you had to choose a non-locally-born-or-raised candidate.

I listed that was a reason, not the only reason. Skill sets being equal, the candidate with a knowledge of the local culture will likely be the better candidate. That's not saying choose the local candidate solely because he is local. I fail to see how it's contradictory. I think we're talking about two subtlety different things. I'm talking about where someone currently resides, not where that person was born or raised.

> It also decreases diversity, which studies show is an advantage and not just a nicety.

I'm pretty sure you meant "increases diversity" because that's the popular trend. I've never comprehended why the "diversity" attribute magically makes a candidate superior. Typically, "diversity" superficially targets ethnic diversity rather than diversity in expertise, experience, or thought. Granted, those aren't mutually exclusive but they're not mutually inclusive either.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by NetStrikeForce on Thursday February 16, 2017 @04:42PM (#13663796)
> I listed that was a reason, not the only reason. Skill sets being equal, the candidate with a knowledge of the local culture will likely be the better candidate.

Why is it better to know the local culture? E.g. would a local 65 year old be a better or worse culture fit than a 25 year from Canada?

> That's not saying choose the local candidate solely because he is local. I fail to see how it's contradictory. I think we're talking about two subtlety different things. I'm talking about where someone currently resides, not where that person was born or raised.

The problem is you haven't given a pragmatic reason why it's better to hire a local person. Well, in fall fairness that's not fully true, you might have implied less hassle during the hiring process (the remote person has to move locally, find a place, might need more time to settle due to that).

> I'm pretty sure you meant "increases diversity" because that's the popular trend.

I meant decreases, then I've meant that diversity is an advantage as per several studies. I'm sorry it was not clear.

I am the one referencing objective reasons, not sure why would you precisely call me out as a trend follower though.

> I've never comprehended why the "diversity" attribute magically makes a candidate superior. Typically, "diversity" superficially targets ethnic diversity rather than diversity in expertise, experience, or thought. Granted, those aren't mutually exclusive but they're not mutually inclusive either.

It's interesting that I keep seeing this "diversity of thought" mantra more and more often. I am seriously asking: Where did you get it from? I mean, it starts to look like a meme, so I wonder if it's on purpose.

Anyway, back to the point: What do you think diversity brings? And what do you think we refer to with "diversity"? For me it is:

- Different age

- Different gender

- Different socioeconomic background

- And any other thing that would've exposed you to different challenges in life: Your skin colour, your country of origin, your native language, where did you study, your level of studies, etc

Bringing e.g. more women or people from a different ethnic background to the team is a sure way to increase your so-called "diversity of thought". These people have probably faced different challenges than you did. Now if you want to hire someone that looks like you, grew in the same part of town, studied at the same place, had a similar socioeconomic background while growing up... Your chances of getting very similar points of view are very high.

And again, please spend some time researching the different studies, there are several by reputable sources. Apparently it is a fact that diversity is an advantage.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by muninn_ on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @11:54AM (#13644910)
When every country on the planet hasn't open borders, the US can too. Until then, we will manage and judge who gets to come here. End of story. Calling it xenophobia is meaningless here, unless you're characterizing every country on the planet that way, in which case your comment has no teeth.
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by wdcgu on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @12:06PM (#13645020)
Btw, I'm calling you xenophobic not "it". Unless you want to be an "it".
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by muninn_ on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @12:41PM (#13645386)
That just makes it even dumber
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by wdcgu on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @12:01PM (#13644983)
Are you going to comment on the isolationism part too? Or do you lack a good argument for it?
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by muninn_ on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @12:07PM (#13645025)
What isolationism part?
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by wdcgu on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @11:25AM (#13644647)
This free market thing isn't really working out. The government should just run everything, make 5 year plans and assign jobs to everyone.

Oh wait, but that's communism, nvm then.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by muninn_ on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @11:53AM (#13644896)
Compared to communism, this "free market" is like a shiny, golden, heavenly angel of salvation.

But, what we are talking about here is government policy. We have a government and it makes rules. There are other governments and they make rules too. Since that's the system we have, we need to analyze and balance what's right, and what works.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by NetStrikeForce on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @07:45AM (#13643115)
I think you understood "free market" backwards mate. No one is forcing me to buy US or local for that matter, but demands are for those US companies to be "forced" to buy local labour.
[dead]
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by sctb on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @03:22PM (#13646767)
I'm sorry, but the bar for civility on Hacker News is higher than this. Please don't call names, and please steer well clear of suggesting genocide (which you've already done and we've already asked you to stop).

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by lazaroclapp on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @05:58AM (#13642640)
Admittedly, I don't think there is anything I could reply that will change such a radicalized worldview. But I am going to state three facts: a) my grandfather immigrated from the U.S. to Mexico, brought the best of his ways with him and adopted the best of ours and was quite successful with that (as are many that make the opposite trip), he ran to Mexico after spending 4 years of so in the U.S. navy at war with people who think much as you do now, b) if you think that the reason Mexico is fucked up is 'backward culture' and not centuries of white colonialism and post-colonial exploitation, I should recommend you read a history book, c) if you carpet nuke China or India, they will nuke right back at you, the U.S. can't conquer the world any more than Nazi Germany could.
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by dukeluke on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @07:48AM (#13643132)
The comment above is flagged so I am unable to understand what they said, but the effect of culture on a society is underrated in my opinion. There is kind of a widespread opinion that all of the advancement of white people is due to racism, yet ignore the fact that Asian Americans have a higher average income and net worth than whites. People of Jewish heritage make up a very small percentage of the population, yet make up a large percentage of the Nobel prize holders. I'm not saying differences are completely because of differences in culture; racism definitely exists. But I wonder what kind of effect that culture truly has on a population.
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by Vinnl on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @06:21AM (#13642738)
Maybe you should actually visit a foreign country. It's quite nice here.
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by danenania on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @04:42AM (#13642396)
Why are people born inside the imaginary lines of my country more important to help than those born outside of it? Someone from Bangladesh or Mexico is not a fellow citizen of my country, but they are a fellow citizen of my world. Why should the smaller and more arbitrary geographical division come first?

You can talk about culture, but I'm sure I have more in common culturally with a phd student or entrepreneur in Dhaka than a Christian fundamentalist in Kansas.

I understand that there is a lot of complexity in these issues, but it's hard for me to see nationalism as anything more than a form of widely accepted bigotry.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by YooLi on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @05:04AM (#13642463)
Because being born inside those imaginary lines means people pay ($ + other) and therefore expect the group they contribute to to put them ahead of an outsider.
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by kelnos on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @05:47AM (#13642611)
That doesn't follow. My friends who are not US citizens and are here on H-1B visas (and have similar jobs as I do) pay significantly more in taxes than I do. And many of the programs those taxes pay into (like Social Security) are closed to them because they're non-citizens.

Given that many US citizens don't start paying much if anything in the way of taxes until post-education (18-22), a non-citizen coming to the US right after college will be paying roughly the same.

But ok, let's say that's not persuasive. I was born in New Jersey, and grew up in Maryland. I moved to California when I was 23 to start working. My family had of course never paid CA state taxes. Should CA have placed artificial "preferences" on workers who were born in CA, preferences that would have put me at the bottom of the hiring pile? Should I have been excluded from a job because other Californians were unemployed at the time? If that sounds ridiculous, then applying the same reasoning to a non-citizen sounds just about as ridiculous.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by YooLi on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @06:00PM (#13648109)
Re: H1-B friends

They pay taxes because now they are here within the imaginary lines and even if they don't get Social security, etc they are still benefitting from being here where they have all the other niceties of being here.

Re: citizens don't start paying until 18.

Their parents paid for them.

Re: California

Still part of a larger imaginary piece where everyone contribute.

You're stuck thinking in terms of just $. And no one is saying no one should be able to come here. You simply asked why do people think negatively about H1-B and I explained it to you. What company wouldn't hire workers that cost them significantly less and can't easily leave over someone local, and hence the position against. It's not difficult.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by kelnos on Wednesday February 15, 2017 @01:09AM (#13650096)
>> Re: citizens don't start paying until 18.

> Their parents paid for them.

Quite the opposite. Their parents got a tax deduction simply because their children exist.

>> Re: California

> Still part of a larger imaginary piece where everyone contribute.

Exactly! Just as the entire world is part of a still larger imaginary piece! Borders are just squiggly lines drawn on a map. I have more in common with an engineering student in India than with most people in middle America: socially, culturally, etc.

> You're stuck thinking in terms of just $.

I was replying to a post of yours wherein you were making an argument about solely $.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by YooLi on Thursday February 16, 2017 @06:49PM (#13664723)
Negative. You can very easily go back to my posts and see where I explicitly say $ + other and mention the H1-Bs benefiting by being here even if they don't qualify for SS. Trying to frame what I said that way is just disingenuous.

Parents absolutely pay into the system when they have children even if they get a federal tax credit. The extra food they buy is more sales tax, etc. just think about it.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by lazaroclapp on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @05:24AM (#13642535)
So, since California has a significant state tax, it would be a reasonable expectation for Californians to put other Californians first at all times? Also note that people living inside the country contribute to it, not just those born there or those who finished their 15+ years long naturalization process...
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by YooLi on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @06:28PM (#13648310)
No it wouldn't be reasonable for the same reason saying no one should have locks on their doors and anyone should be free to go inside any house and use/live isn't reasonable.
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by danenania on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @05:20AM (#13642523)
Which only leads to the question of why, as a world, we are pooling our resources in such an artificially constrained and divisive way.
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by alextheparrot on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @06:55AM (#13642888)
Why should people born outside the imaginary lines of my country be allowed to come inside it? The power structure resides inside the described imaginary lines, thus the outsiders need to make this argument to the insiders, not the opposite way, realistically. If the outsiders can't convince the insiders, they simply won't be let in.

With that framing, it is easy to see how it isn't (necessarily) bigotry, but just that the outsiders appear to offer little or negative value to many people. By saying "They are taking our jobs", people are expressing that they believe the outsiders being let has a negative effect on them, thus it is quite rational that they want to strengthen those imaginary lines.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by sheepmullet on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @05:52AM (#13642624)
I find it interesting that the "American first" crowd tends to donate more to the overseas needy than the "citizens of the world" crowd.

excluding a few billionaires who really do believe in helping others.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by literallycancer on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @06:39AM (#13642810)
Care to provide a source?
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by kelnos on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @05:56AM (#13642633)
> You're ignoring the fact the US already produces a surplus of skilled and qualified STEM professionals.

That may be true, but we're hardly a homogeneous group. There certainly isn't a surplus of skilled and qualified professionals from my subgroup of STEM. And I suspect that's the one where most H-1B visa holders end up in.

Not saying the system isn't abused: oh sweet jesus, it most certainly is. But throwing it out or reducing the caps isn't the answer. Removing all the perverse incentives and the ability of employers to use their employees' visa status as a pair of handcuffs... now that'll help.

> The government of a country should be first and foremost advocates for, and protectors of, the welfare of its own citizens. If a large number of those citizens are being encouraged to accumulate massive debts gaining an education that them leaves them unable to find a job, then that is a social problem that needs a solution.

Why are they unable to find a job?

Are they less skilled and capable than a foreign worker? If so, then the foreign worker should get the job. I care about our country's competitiveness in the science and technology landscape. If we can entice people smarter than us to come here and help make us smarter, that's the right move.

Are foreign workers willing to work for less? Well then perhaps these citizens should suck it up and be willing to work for less as well. Or maybe they shouldn't get into a field with questionable job prospects in the first place. Four years isn't a very long time; the landscape doesn't change that much, and even if it does, changing majors/fields/etc. midway through isn't that hard (and even if it is, we're talking about your job prospects for the rest of your life; that sort of thing is good motivation to take on something hard).

I want the best people here. Period. I don't care where they are from. Protectionism will just make us less competitive globally, and will move cutting-edge research and development to countries with more permissive immigration policies. We're already losing our status as the global superpower, and kicking out qualified immigrants will only hasten that decline.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by unprepare on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @08:26AM (#13643314)
> Why are they unable to find a job?

>Are they less skilled and capable than a foreign worker? If so, then the foreign worker should get the job

Are you under the impression that organizations when hiring are looking to maximize skill and disregard all other factors?

once you reach 'good enough' skill level, its a cost minimization game.

If the American costs twice as much, but the foreign worker is good enough - who should get the job?

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by nikdaheratik on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @06:08PM (#13648159)
From what I can tell, this is more an argument for collective bargaining than an argument against immigrant workers. I don't care which sector you're in, immigrants have the least amount of control over both the business and the politics, and yet they seem to take the most blame.

If there's a race to the bottom, maybe the solution is for workers to force capital to stop pitting them against each other.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by kelnos on Wednesday February 15, 2017 @01:04AM (#13650083)
Of course not. I'm talking about a (slightly) idealized scenario, responding to the original assertion (paraphrased), that the US should always take care of its citizens first. I just don't agree with that.

Obviously the H-1 program is flawed, and it allows for some pretty perverse incentives. But we should be focusing on fixing that, not applying some asinine protectionism policy.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by wdcgu on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @11:35AM (#13644744)
Hire the foreign worker obviously. That's just business and economics 101.
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by hocuspocus on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @05:02AM (#13642456)
> You're ignoring the fact the US already produces a surplus of skilled and qualified STEM professionals.

STEM is a broad category. Saying there's a surplus of STEM graduates is a useless metric. Most of these graduates aren't interchangeable, let alone willing to work as cheap IT workers.

The H-1/L-1 visas are abused to screw American IT workers, I get that. Do you know how most developed countries prevent that despite lenient immigration requirements (compared to the US)? Better labor laws, unions, collective bargaining, ...

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by nikdaheratik on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @06:15PM (#13648217)
I don't know what labor market you're talking about, but this STEM "surplus" is not very believable. Even if the exact match isn't always there, the people graduating with a degree in Biology or Civil Engineering are still more marketable from the skills it takes to get those degrees than many other graduates. The issue with "unemployable" college graduates has more to do with humanities majors who probably should have gone to technical or junior college and got a certificate in something practical than too many "STEM" graduates.

And a much better question: is the problem that we're letting too many immigrants in, or that capital has had control of the laws and culture so much that labor can't fight to get their fair share? Immigrants don't write the laws, they don't make the business decisions, all they do is sign up for a space in the H1B lottery.

If your field isn't getting its share, maybe it's not the immigrants who should be getting the blame for this.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by wdcgu on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @04:48AM (#13642417)
Not all STEM professionals are equal, which seems to be the assumptions of these arguments.
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by sleepingeights on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @03:39AM (#13642170)
> If you truly believe that H-1B should exist only for truly extraordinary talent

Second to last paragraph:

"Employers claim that they hire H-1Bs for rare skill sets or outstanding talent ― traits that they would need to pay a premium for on the open market. Yet current law requires only that they pay the average wage. Worse, it is the average wage within one of those four experience levels. Instead, we should replace this with a single wage floor set at the 75th percentile of the overall wage distribution for the given occupation and region."

Silicon Valley is actively exploiting H1Bs and antagonizing and attacking US born/educated workers just to justify bringing in a cheaper labour force of lower skilled workers from India and China.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by lazaroclapp on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @03:52AM (#13642214)
Rare skillset or outstanding talent can be interpreted at different levels in so far as how strong an statement that is. As a percentage of the population, software engineers have a rare skillset, and there is no employment crisis in the field that requires protectionist measures to keep people with said skillset from mass unemployment. The system you are proposing would end with companies having to hire significantly over 25% of their workforce locally. That's not "favoring skilled U.S. workers over lower skilled workers from abroad", that is "restricting our talent pool to 5% of the world population for the most part". You might chose to legislate it thus if you wish, but you would be doing so at your peril.

Don't get me wrong, I don't think the system should incentive not hiring Americans because they can resign with more ease, that is absurd. But on the other hand, I don't think the U.S. really benefits over the long run of having a system where the talent market is strongly distorted by citizenship. Let me put it another way, would you think it is a good idea, if it were legal to do so, if California passed a law saying people born out of state should only be able to work here at 75th percentile overall wage for their occupation?

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by walshemj on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @05:15AM (#13642503)
That's not what rare means rare is not the average SE
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by true_religion on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @04:25AM (#13642331)
I am not sure why those people can't be served by normal visas which don't tie you to your employer at risk of deportation for not agreeing to their every demand.
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by lazaroclapp on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @04:49AM (#13642419)
Which normal visas would those be? H-1B is the normal work visa for everyone not coming from Mexico or Canada.
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by true_religion on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @02:50PM (#13646537)
By that I mean non 'work' visa---the regular visa lottery system, L1 and L2 visa holders, and everyone who would fall in the E2, E3, E4 visa category for having <= 5 years of experience.

And added on that temporary work permit that'd be suitable for contractors.

The USA issues over 3 million visas under which work is permitted per year, so I wonder why isn't there room in the existing legislative framework to accommodate skilled workers without having them be given H1-B.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by mavelikara on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @04:49AM (#13642418)
> I am not sure why those people can't be served by normal visas

What are the names of those "normal visas"?

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by wdcgu on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @05:06AM (#13642470)
Do you even know how the system works?
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by jza00425 on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @12:54PM (#13645504)
What the problem? You want the companies to pay more just because the person is American? No wonder a lot of jobs outsourced. If you can even compete with foreign works, maybe you should move to a developing country since you are so incompetent
Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by rodionos on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @08:43AM (#13643412)
One thing to keep in mind is that unlike O-1, EB-1 is an immigrant visa. It's for people who are set on relocating to the US and eventually become US citizens.

The O-1 visas have been growing too, particularly issued to UK nationals: https://apps.axibase.com/chartlab/1bc51064/4/

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by neltnerb on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @03:17AM (#13642084)
Is your concern about the talent/bidding argument, or the "limited number" part? Because it seems to me that if you relax the latter, the prior is much less an issue.

I dunno, I say the more the merrier. There's lots of problems to solve, may as well solve them here.

Re:Silicon Valley Is Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Im... by lazaroclapp on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @03:26AM (#13642112)
The limited number mostly. I think H-1B reform was a good idea under the previous administration, and that better rules for green card processes, salaries, etc. could make it fairer on both foreign-born and U.S.-born employees, and remove the incentives for employers to strongly prefer one over the other all else being equal (which, btw, implicitly favors people already here, but not overwhelmingly so). But I also feel that right now the U.S. political climate is headed towards pretty strong xenophobia as state policy and that re-examining the H-1B program right now will likely lead to it being quite hostile to foreign-born employees and might end up not even benefiting local employees either on the long run.