News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by azag0 on Saturday February 11, 2017 @04:40AM (#13621932)
How come this isn't culturally perceived in the same way as not paying for software or movies or music? I've read various reasons why people don't want to pay. That's fine. But then simply don't read it.
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by ctrl_freak on Saturday February 11, 2017 @05:50PM (#13625318)
The reason I posted the workaround is because I feel like the publisher is trying to have their cake and eat it too. In other words, they enjoy the publicity they get from having their articles shared on Google, Facebook, Hacker News, but these sites usually don't want to feature articles that require their users to pay, so WSJ sets up a soft paywall that lets some of these users view the article for free.

But of course that becomes a bit of a blurry moral line. If I start browsing Google News in the hopes of stumbling upon a WSJ article so I can read it for free, is that immoral? What about if I google the headline of an article I'm interested in? Automatically setting my referer to facebook.com whenever I visit wsj.com probably goes too far, but then where do you draw the line?

Anyway, I feel very strongly that either everyone from HN should be able to freely read an article shared here, or no one. If no one can read it, then the link shouldn't be allowed here.

Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by paulddraper on Saturday February 11, 2017 @06:33PM (#13625522)
> everyone from HN should be able to freely read an article shared here, or no one. If no one can read it, then the link shouldn't be allowed here.

Then we'll have the laments: oh the ads, the humanity; or, why does all journalism suck?

Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by tracker1 on Sunday February 12, 2017 @02:34PM (#13630120)
I'm fine with their paywall... however, they should no longer come up on google news... their rules have been quite clear, and why google is letting WSJ skate on the issue is beyond me.
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by rhaps0dy on Saturday February 11, 2017 @04:44AM (#13621944)
> How come this isn't culturally perceived in the same way as not paying for software or movies or music?

Perhaps it is? I've almost never had anyone remark that I was doing something bad when not paying for a software or movie or music.

Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by tonfa on Saturday February 11, 2017 @01:34PM (#13623958)
Also there are still countries where downloading copyrighted materials is not illegal (distributing it usually is, though).
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by hacknat on Saturday February 11, 2017 @09:58AM (#13622857)
Well, hear it now. I'm judging you.
[dead]
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by tracker1 on Sunday February 12, 2017 @02:36PM (#13630143)
I expect that when I click a link via google, that I get the same content that google gets. It took years for google to demote expertSexChange and now that WSJ is fully paywalled, they shouldn't get a pass on this.
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by monochromatic on Saturday February 11, 2017 @08:42AM (#13622556)
Theft != copyright infringement.
[dead]
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by monochromatic on Saturday February 11, 2017 @10:13AM (#13622935)
If I steal your car, I've deprived you of the use of your car. If I copy your program, have I deprived you of the use of your program?

How is that a linguistic argument?

Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by sah2ed on Saturday February 11, 2017 @12:02PM (#13623431)
You are correct. In fact the distinction between your two examples i.e the car (a tangible good) and the program (an intangible good) is what economists refer to as rivalry [0].

A car is a rivalrous good. A program is a non-rivalrous good.

The main distinction is that the marginal cost of producing a non-rivalrous good is zero.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rivalry_(economics)

[dead]
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by icebraining on Saturday February 11, 2017 @11:28AM (#13623258)
Tell that to the SCOTUS:

interference with copyright does not easily equate with theft, conversion, or fraud. The infringer of a copyright does not assume physical control over the copyright nor wholly deprive its owner of its use. Infringement implicates a more complex set of property interests than does run-of-the-mill theft, conversion, or fraud.

By the way, the infringer was acquitted, since the court agreed he hadn't "stolen, converted or taken by fraud", despite even making money from his infringing activities.

[dead]
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by icebraining on Saturday February 11, 2017 @12:03PM (#13623439)
Unconvincing argument. The court's statement, as I reproduced above, is not about the specifics of the statute, otherwise it would have said "it's theft, just not physical removal". The wording is very clear.

The example of the other case (which, by the way, was only a District Court decision) also seems weak. AFAIK (IANAL), the fact that copyright law preempted state law doesn't mean the two are equal, it just means that both theft and copyright infringement occurred - which is easily seen to be the case, since physical plans were actually removed from a place.

Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by imtringued on Saturday February 11, 2017 @12:35PM (#13623637)
Imagine there is a technology that could copy tangible goods such as cars. Now somebody makes a copy of your car. Your car was not stolen but you may not be happy with the fact that somebody now also has a copy of your personal belongings like a smartphone that was inside the car.

This is where copyright law comes into play which only allows copying the car only under your rules. If somebody doesn't follow the rules that doesn't mean they stole your car but it still means they should receive some form of punishment to prevent future copyright infringement.

Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by monochromatic on Saturday February 11, 2017 @12:10PM (#13623472)
Let me know when your definition makes it into a legal dictionary.
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by kuschku on Saturday February 11, 2017 @10:09AM (#13622916)
Ah, that tired old PIRATE-COPIER-MURDERER-TERRORIST argument.

You do realize that copyright protection is an invention to prevent artists from being fucked over by commercial publishers, and was originally not intended to limit people from copying content noncommercially?

Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by contras1970 on Saturday February 11, 2017 @09:27AM (#13622744)
if copyright infringement is theft, then theft is surely murder?
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by distances on Saturday February 11, 2017 @09:21AM (#13622712)
That's a bit beside the point parent was making: it's true that music piracy is somehow usually not frowned upon, at least based on my anecdotal experience. People don't see it as a thing to explicitly avoid, any more that they would avoid sharing someone's (copyrighted) photo in Facebook.
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by Fifer82 on Saturday February 11, 2017 @08:40AM (#13622543)
You have to care to be ashamed.
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by kaspiCZ on Saturday February 11, 2017 @08:34AM (#13622519)
Let's pretend you developed a piece of software you want to sell. People download it without paying you. What do you do in that case?
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by chillingeffect on Saturday February 11, 2017 @10:03AM (#13622882)
I recognize that review comes from two sources, direct through sales and indirect, through discovery. So I try to make sure discovery reaches people with the best material and spend the most money to move the most people, persuading them to pay along the path of least resistance....

...which is exactly what the WSJ has been doing.

Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by kofejnik on Saturday February 11, 2017 @09:21AM (#13622711)
it's a logical fallacy to assume that people who downloaded your work would have discovered it and actually paid for it if there was no free option

a lot of artists would PAY to get millions of downloads/views

Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by abiox on Saturday February 11, 2017 @05:58PM (#13625360)
> it's a logical fallacy to assume that people who downloaded your work would have discovered it and actually paid for it if there was no free option

it's a "logical fallacy" to assume they wouldn't

Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by gaius on Saturday February 11, 2017 @11:26AM (#13623246)
Let me know when you can pay rent or buy groceries with retweets.
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by vonklaus on Saturday February 11, 2017 @12:29PM (#13623589)
it's unclear if you do not realize thousands of people make their living full-time as promoters on social media. They literally pay rent with money that was paid to them proportionate to their retweets. Or if this was hyperbole to underscore your disagreement with a freemium business model
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by abiox on Saturday February 11, 2017 @05:59PM (#13625363)
this seems like an equivocation
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by hacknat on Saturday February 11, 2017 @09:59AM (#13622863)
You mean pirated? It's a logical fallacy to assume that your otherwise non-discovery makes your decision moral.
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by beefield on Saturday February 11, 2017 @09:13AM (#13622680)
Rethink my business model?
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by kuschku on Saturday February 11, 2017 @12:17PM (#13623514)
Are you willing to pay each month

    SPIEGEL:  $  9.40
    FAZ:      $ 44.90
    WSJ:      $ 30.85
    Guardian: $  6.99
    KN:       $ 19.99
    
    -----------------
    Total     $112.13
just to read a handful of articles per newspaper?

I’m sorry, I’m a student, I don’t even have Netflix because that’s too expensive.

Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by beejiu on Saturday February 11, 2017 @09:28AM (#13622749)
You can often loan out movies, music, books and sometimes software from a local library, free of charge. (At least in the UK.) It was also common to loan a friend a CD back when CDs were a thing. Perhaps it is more pervasive now, but I don't think it is fair to say that everybody who consumes media pays for it.
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by abtinf on Saturday February 11, 2017 @04:45AM (#13621946)
> the Journal also started letting people read for free links that are shared on social media by subscribers and staffers.

Because the publisher explicitly allows it.

Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by azag0 on Saturday February 11, 2017 @07:15AM (#13622283)
No. The publisher wants their subscribers to be able to share the stuff they pay for with other people. If you use that feature to read for free any content they publish, you misuse it. Now, I am very much against any DRM, I don't even really believe that intellectual property should be protected by law, but I believe that content creators have legitimate (but not necessarily legal) right to be paid for their content. (If they want to have legally enforceable income, they need to find different schemes.) If you avoid paying, you're denying them that right. Again, I don't think this should be covered by law, but I also don't think it's fair.
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by Touche on Saturday February 11, 2017 @10:12AM (#13622927)
This argument comes up often but it's not convincing. You can't have your cake and eat it too. You can't distribute your content on a public (free) medium and also control how people consume that content. If you want control of how people use a thing, the internet is the worst possible choice.

It's really simple, if you want to put your content behind a paywall, then put it behind a paywall. Don't leave a backdoor open and then complain when people use that door.

Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by kofejnik on Saturday February 11, 2017 @09:24AM (#13622723)
do you claim to know the exact intent of other people, and are prepared to judge some other people based on sharing your view and adhering to it exactly?
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by dzhiurgis on Saturday February 11, 2017 @09:02AM (#13622635)
The publishers want their subscribers to ADVERTISE the stuff they they pay for.

By definition sharing means giving it away for free.

Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by briandear on Saturday February 11, 2017 @08:10AM (#13622440)
Don't believe IP should be protected? So every single author out there should not get paid? If their content isn't protected, they it's illogical to suggest they should also get paid. Anyone could reproduce that content and redistribute it. That's ludicrous. Film crews ought not be paid? Because if they can't sell their work, then what are they supposed to eat while making movies? Without IP protection, you no longer have new medicines. If the answer is "the government," then the question is -- where does the tax money come from to pay for it? If you wiped out IP law, you'd destroy a significant portion of the economy. The only people that would make any money would be those that control land or raw materials. Innovation would disappear.
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by azag0 on Saturday February 11, 2017 @08:42AM (#13622551)
Obviously, this is too complex a problem to discuss here, so I'll make only a few points: (1) It isn't really relevant for my point about paying the publishers. If anything, IP protection makes my point stronger. (2) I'm not suggesting to abolish IP protection, because I'm not sure I'm right. That's why I said I believe IP protection is not needed. I know I cannot argue my opinion sufficiently. (3) My biggest issue with IP protection is that since there is no unambiguous definition of what IP is, all IP laws are necessarily too restrictive. Leading e.g. to the current craziness with patents. (4) Film crews out to be paid. There are different models of financing than copyright. Music industry got pretty far with the transition. (5) As for drugs, the governments should announce which drugs are needed, and when companies deliver such drugs, they should get a one-time payment. In present language, the governments would buy the copyright from the companies and release the recipes to public domain. It would be financed from health insurance.

Etc, etc. But again, I know there are holes in my reasoning.

Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by xapata on Saturday February 11, 2017 @10:23AM (#13622988)
> drugs ... one time payment

That'd have to be an incredibly large one-time payment. And how would we know how much to pay?

Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by MichaelBurge on Saturday February 11, 2017 @11:43AM (#13623341)
> And how would we know how much to pay?

It doesn't seem like an unsolvable problem. The drug companies themselves must have budgets, and the publicly traded ones have a stock price. So someone somewhere must be able to create estimates for this.

Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by monochromatic on Saturday February 11, 2017 @08:42AM (#13622550)
Everything on the web used to be free. We got used to that.
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by mirimir on Saturday February 11, 2017 @09:10AM (#13622672)
I'd be happy to pay, under these conditions: 1) payment per article, at prices comparable to aggregate ad income; and 2) payments accepted via Bitcoin, or other methods which can be anonymized.
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by sah2ed on Saturday February 11, 2017 @12:07PM (#13623463)
> 1) payment per article, at prices comparable to aggregate ad income;

Unfortunately, this kind of micropayment will not work for most people and perhaps more importantly will lead to less revenue for the publisher.

Clary Shirky has written about why micropayments [0] is the wrong model for consuming content more than a decade ago.

[0] http://shirky.com/writings/fame_vs_fortune.html

Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by mirimir on Saturday February 11, 2017 @12:33PM (#13623619)
Well, ads are currently placed through a micropayment system. And there's no reason that customers would need to make individual decisions, any more than advertisers do.
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by mason55 on Saturday February 11, 2017 @09:26AM (#13622733)
Then just wait 18 hours for you $0.03 transaction to be confirmed so you can read the article.
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by mirimir on Saturday February 11, 2017 @09:37AM (#13622780)
No, not that way. Put 100 USD worth in an account, for instant debit.
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by sneak on Sunday February 12, 2017 @04:41AM (#13627623)
If they don't want people to read for free, the WSJ should simply not serve it.

We're free to send them any Referer headers we wish... in a request. It's up to them to reply however they wish.

Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by maxerickson on Saturday February 11, 2017 @12:24PM (#13623559)
Which culture are you talking about? Lots (lots!) of people view and collect media without paying for it.
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by k_lander on Sunday February 12, 2017 @04:21AM (#13627555)
i would be perfectly fine with this. just give me a way to exclude wsj from my newsfeed and search results without me having to install a trusted browser extension
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by jdavis703 on Saturday February 11, 2017 @10:38AM (#13623052)
This is the equivalent of reading a magazine in the bookstore and not buying it. It would be different if you walked out the store without paying.
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by dopamean on Saturday February 11, 2017 @10:49AM (#13623097)
I don't they're the same at all. In your example if you walk out of the store with the magazine the store has to cover the cost of the magazine. If you stay in the store and read it then the content provider didn't get paid for someone consuming their content however the magazine is still there. The store could still sell it.

The l.php script basically allows someone to read the magazine without paying for it. The only entity that loses something in that situation is the content provider.

Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by clarry on Saturday February 11, 2017 @03:15PM (#13624538)
> The only entity that loses something in that situation is the content provider.

What do they lose?

Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by tedmiston on Saturday February 11, 2017 @11:05AM (#13623155)
Because there is no Spotify or Netflix for written content.
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by tomjen3 on Saturday February 11, 2017 @08:46AM (#13622573)
It is, music, software and movies are pirated illegally too.
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by icebraining on Saturday February 11, 2017 @11:36AM (#13623306)
Can you pirate legally? Sounds like a pleonasm.
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by zeamaize on Saturday February 11, 2017 @10:56AM (#13623120)
Why the hell should I pay for poor journalism that is riddled with ads?

There is a reason I subscribe to Netflix but not Hulu.

Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by todd3834 on Saturday February 11, 2017 @11:00AM (#13623143)
Hulu has an ad free plan
Re:The Wall Street Journal to Close Google Loophole Entirely by mynameisvlad on Saturday February 11, 2017 @12:31PM (#13623598)
They really should have been more vocal in announcing its release. I find that a lot of people still believe the only available options are ad-supported.

I had only discovered it when I wanted to resubscribe for other reasons; I probably would have done it earlier if I had known the option was available.