News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by chollida1 on Friday February 10, 2017 @10:36AM (#13616053)
This guy isn't the first person to make money in one arena and extrapolate that he could do it in others only to get his ass handed to him.

I'm Canadian so the wealthy people AI know are either in finance or hockey players, and those that have lost money in areas outside their wheel house have all followed the same path.

1) Give money to a person they don't know very well to invest in a business idea they aren't an expert in.

There is no step two.

As a side note, i found this interesting....

> It wasn’t until Sarao left Futex in 2008 and struck out on his own that he started to make serious money. Public filings show his assets popped to 14.9 million pounds from 461,000 pounds in the 12 months ending in June 2009, long before he enlisted a programmer to build a system that authorities say was designed to cheat the market.

Not sure what helped more in his rise:

The 6 years he spent learning at another trading firm or the fact that on his own he probably had alot less risk oversight that allowed him to lever up more than he would have in side of an investment house.

> That near-obsessive drive to hold on to as much of his wealth as possible can also be seen in the way he conducted his business affairs. Looking to minimize his tax bill, he was introduced by his accountant to John Dupont, a director at the London arm of an Isle of Man-based financial advisory firm called Montpelier Tax Consultants

The best investment adivce I ever got was from my father. and I quote.... "Don't fuck around with your taxes any more than an H&R block adviser would let you. Getting a million dollar tax bills 7 years after you earned the money isn't worth it."

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by ptero on Friday February 10, 2017 @03:50PM (#13618776)
It seems to me the guy is a scapegoat. What he did is likely illegal market manipulation (placing orders and canceling them before they are executed to give a false impression of a price / volume / something else); I am not defending that; but 300+ years?

I really doubt though that the amount he presumably won (much less than $50M) can be responsible for a significant financial event such as a flash crash at a world's major stock exchange. I suspect high frequency traders regularly affect markets in a much more significant ways (e.g., I think generating large volume via zero-sum trades than withdrawing from trading could cause significant pricing swings).

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by hermitdev on Friday February 10, 2017 @09:59PM (#13620690)
I agree with you on this. I work in finance, and one of the many hats I wear at a small shop is regulatory analyst (basically, I run/create the specialized reports when FINRA, SEC, etc come knocking). +300 years seems excessive, but the financial penalties seem apt: forfeit your ill-gotten gains plus a topper.

An aside: I've always found sentences such as 300 years to be absurd (unless they run concurrent). Why not just call it life and be done with it? Or, is the judge trying to make a statement like the judge in Texas that recently set bail at $4 billion for an accused murder (who turned his self in)?

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by qwrusz on Friday February 10, 2017 @11:48AM (#13616759)
> The 6 years he spent learning at another trading firm or the fact that on his own he probably had alot less risk oversight that allowed him to lever up more than he would have in side of an investment house.

Maybe neither? As good as this kid might be, hard to believe he did a 30x year! Even with more risk and there was some crazy volaility back then, a 30x year going from half a million pounds to 15 million in 12 months is very high.

Never know of course. He might have done it. theoretically possible with the exotics CDS in that year. But also hard to trust journalists aren't just twisting facts these days.

Another explanation for the rise: He already had several million while working at the firm, but they weren't in his name, not in a public filing anyway until went out on his own and took out the funds.

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by MR4D on Friday February 10, 2017 @12:30PM (#13617133)
A 30x return is easy - rare, but easy. Repeating it, however, is damn near impossible.

Options trading, which he was good at, went haywire on that day. Anybody in a decent position with options made crazy returns. But their timing had to be good. If you bought a short-dated, just out of the money SPY put the day before, and sold it that afternoon, you made a killing as far as percentage return.

The number of people who had that or similar trade probably numbers in the thousands. But the reason you don't hear about them is it was either to hedge a larger position, or a small speculative position, and making $50,000 doesn't make headlines.

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by jboggan on Friday February 10, 2017 @02:24PM (#13618090)
I agree with this. I made a 32x return on a front-month WAY out of the money options trade in March of 2008. I tried to pull it off again and lost all of it. Good tuition money.
Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by r00fus on Friday February 10, 2017 @02:35PM (#13618184)
I always wonder why to invest it all... at the very least, if I gained 10x or 32x, I'd save away the original amount or a small fraction of the total, and NOT gamble with that.
Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by simplyluke on Friday February 10, 2017 @03:04PM (#13618421)
>I always wonder why to invest it all

Greed and ego.

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by WalterBright on Friday February 10, 2017 @11:44PM (#13621067)
You can't win with investing. If you lose money, you say "I shouldna' done that." If you make money, you say "I shoulda invested more."
Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by MR4D on Monday February 13, 2017 @09:51AM (#13635609)
There is substantial research that suggests taking a moderate asset allocation combined with annual rebalancing will have a fairly predictable return over the long run (a decade or more).

If you're making trades frequently, you're probably (as shown by research) throwing that money away.

There are always things that go up, and others that go down, but a well constructed portfolio will do more of the former and less of the latter. Annual rebalancing then buys the cheaper asset (by definition, on a relative basis, the cheaper asset is bought and the expensive asset sold when rebalancing).

And yes, it is actually that simple. The problem is (as someone else on this thread had posted): fear and greed. If you can ignore that, you can do well.

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by qwrusz on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:01PM (#13617423)
Firstly: this is just overall a ridiculously incorrect comment.

Second: the 30x return discussed was back in 2008-2009. The flash crash you are talking about happened in 2010. Also the SPY moved down like -10% during the crash. Bro, come on.

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by chrisatumd on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:56PM (#13617886)
I just want to jump in and comment that 30x gains in a year are not really that crazy with out of the money close to expiration options. I've had 2 different years in the past with better than 30x gains (and years where my options account went to 0).

If you had bought out of the money puts with a near term expiration for an index like SPY and it dropped 10%, you could be talking 80-1000 times return depending on how far out of the money and how close to expiration.

Disclaimer: I do not recommend out of the money options trading for anything other than pure gambling on money you couldn't care less about losing.

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by qwrusz on Friday February 10, 2017 @02:50PM (#13618308)
Ok Hacker News, I think I am done for the day after this.

Just to be clear, we are talking about a 30x return in someone's entire net worth, in 12 months, from trading.

I didn't say you couldn't construct a perfect hypothetical trade that in hindsight would have earned someone a huge 30x or 100x return or whatever. Not sure how that's even relevant though (unless maybe you trade from home and buy those expensive mega-ultimate-dragon options trading online skype courses and still think such trades are even worth talking about).

I didn't even say a 30x return of his net worth was impossible, I said it's "hard to believe" and "very high'.

But apparently a 30x return "is easy" and this guy has done it twice...

OK. Well it's been fun. HAGW everyone

P.S. I appreciate chrisatumd's disclaimer, nice to see, and a good reminder that investing and trading is gambling and you can lose it all, whether you're an amateur or pro.

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by caminante on Friday February 10, 2017 @03:07PM (#13618437)
Man, I lost it at "A 30x return is easy - rare, but easy."

Re: story, I've casually followed his story. I'm also very dubious of the allegations against him and claims about his performance.

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by MR4D on Monday February 13, 2017 @04:03PM (#13638742)
I agree with your second point. As to my wording on your first point, I should explain a bit more....

"Easy" means that it's not technically hard to do. For instance, anyone who's lucky enough can win 30 times their money in roulette. It's "easy", but rare - only 2-3% of people do it.

For contrast, "hard" to me would be something like trading gamma-delta option spreads.

Technically, just about any investor do the former (although they'd have to be lucky), while few can do the latter.

Final point - I consider being lucky consistently is damn near impossible (although statistically, I guess it happens to a few of the 8 billion people out there).

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by chrisatumd on Friday February 10, 2017 @03:40PM (#13618693)
Not trying to upset you, just trying to help you see that the story is not crazy. I'm not sure if you've tried trading futures or options before.

I've never traded futures, but I've seen with the amount of leverage that options provide makes the story quite believable (easy was probably not what the prior commenter meant).

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by hermitdev on Friday February 10, 2017 @10:10PM (#13620721)
It's possible, but almost inevitably, the "strategy" employed backfires, and the trader loses everything. One that comes to mind is Brian Hunter[1], formerly of the now defunct Amaranth Advisors hedge fund. Hunter was viewed as a sort of wunderkind, but he had a natural gas position (I've heard the initial position was between $1B and $2B, but I don't know specifics) go south, and rather than sell off and accept the losses, he doubled down and sank the firm. Margin calls ensued (of up to $6B) that could not be met and assets ended up being sold off for pennies on the dollar. (I previously worked for a firm that bought a large chunk of Amaranth's assets).

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brian_Hunter_(trader)

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by qwrusz on Saturday February 11, 2017 @02:53AM (#13621648)
Ya man I been in the industry a long time I remember Brian Hunter from even before Amaranth. Always interesting reading when his name pops up. Clearly, a brilliant trader on a different level than most guys, but ya that's not always enough on it's own. He should have gotten that DB bonus though, that story was fucked up.
Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by PhantomGremlin on Friday February 10, 2017 @05:07PM (#13619321)
I didn't even say a 30x return of his net worth was impossible, I said it's "hard to believe" and "very high'.

It's simple if you have the talent.

E.g. here's a person who deposited $1000 in cash into a trading account and wound up with $100,000 after just 10 months of trading. That's a 100x return.[1]

Think of how rich that person could have been had she decided to continue her trading!

/s

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hillary_Clinton_cattle_futures...

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by rrrrsss99 on Friday February 10, 2017 @10:10PM (#13620718)
Were you buying these options throughout they year, or just near earnings?
Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by MR4D on Monday February 13, 2017 @10:17AM (#13635835)
Here's an option on DB (DeutscheBank) that moved 10x THIS MORNING.

http://finance.yahoo.com/quote/DB170217P00017000?p=DB170217P...

Here's a PUT option on WMT (Walmart) that moved 35x also this morning:

http://finance.yahoo.com/quote/WMT170217P00062500?p=WMT17021...

Here's an option on CL (Colgate Palmolive) that moved 8 this morning as well.

http://finance.yahoo.com/quote/CL170217C00077500?p=CL170217C...

SOMEBODY made money today on these, and the market hasn't been open for an hour yet.

Before calling my comment "ridiculously incorrect", I would appreciate it if you would show a better understanding of capital markets.

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by ChristianGeek on Friday February 10, 2017 @08:47PM (#13620460)
I thought that any trades made during the crash were reversed after.
Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by charlesdm on Friday February 10, 2017 @11:59AM (#13616853)
If he did 30x a year, he must have been the best investor in the world?
Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by btilly on Friday February 10, 2017 @02:45PM (#13618266)
No, it just means an insane beta and good luck. Anyone can set up the lottery to create an insane beta. And luck, well, you know how that goes.
Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by shoo on Friday February 10, 2017 @03:57PM (#13618822)
you can't judge skill from outcomes in the short run if a large component of the outcome is outside of the control of the operator

see e.g. Taleb "fooled by randomness"

there's also a good "winner's game" vs "loser's game" argument, see Ellis - The Loser's Game: http://www.cfapubs.org/doi/pdf/10.2469/faj.v51.n1.1865 (PDF)

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by charlesdm on Friday February 10, 2017 @11:21AM (#13616468)
> The best investment adivce I ever got was from my father. and I quote.... "Don't fuck around with your taxes any more than an H&R block adviser would let you. Getting a million dollar tax bills 7 years after you earned the money isn't worth it."

This depends on the situation. If you get a bill in Y7 that is not significantly higher than the bill in Y1, it in fact would be worth it, because that capital could have compounded for 7 years.

Focusing on optimising your taxes is actually often worth it. I would dare say not enough people do it. But the more you optimise, the higher the risk becomes you have to pay it back. As with anything, it's risk vs reward.

At the returns this guy was making, it actually makes sense to defer paying taxes as long as possible.

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by tedunangst on Friday February 10, 2017 @11:34AM (#13616622)
Don't forget to include the costs of creating dummy corps, the risk of the off shore owner of the dummy corp running away with your money, the lawyer fees to keep you out of jail, etc.

There are many legal ways to minimize taxes. I might go a step beyond run of the mill tax accountant advice, but if you're getting advice from a guy who changes his phone number every week, that could be a bad sign.

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by charlesdm on Friday February 10, 2017 @11:37AM (#13616647)
Of course. I'm not advocating that. But I do think most people assume there's not much you can do, aside from paying up. Getting a decent understanding of basic tax law pays itself back over the years.

I've met self employed people who don't even understand the difference between salary, corporate tax and dividends.

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by Retric on Friday February 10, 2017 @12:05PM (#13616906)
> who don't even understand

That's below the competence of an H&R block adviser. Having basic minimal competence is of course a good idea. But, the risk vs. reward from messing with your taxes is capped at a fraction of your income so there are generally far better risks to take.

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by noir_lord on Friday February 10, 2017 @11:27AM (#13616549)
> Focusing on optimising your taxes is actually often worth it. I would dare say not enough people do it.

I'd largely agree, people don't optimise their tax enough but large companies/corporations get away with it far too much.

It's a pretty big issue in the UK, the last figures I saw where Tax Evasion costs us 67bn a year (HMRC figures iirc) vs 1.8bn for all benefit errors (not fraud, that figure is errors and fraud).

We cracked down on benefit fraud massively... If I where a cynic.

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by loeg on Friday February 10, 2017 @11:54AM (#13616806)
It's important to draw a distinction between tax minimization (within the bounds of the law) and tax evasion (illegal minimization). I don't think anyone here is promoting illegal evasion.
Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by charlesdm on Friday February 10, 2017 @11:35AM (#13616636)
Yeah, large companies don't pay enough.

That said: the more money you have, the more of a game it is. The rules get blurry when dealing with multiple countries.

If you were (or owned) a large company, you'd do the same. Or well, at least I would. Can't blame the game. Fix the rules.

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by rrrrsss99 on Friday February 10, 2017 @10:18PM (#13620756)
Are there ways to optimize personal income taxes the same way corporations do? Can I create a shell person in the cayman islands and pay them the exact amount of my income and deduct my US income to $0?
Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by FatAmericanDev on Friday February 10, 2017 @11:41AM (#13616696)
He violated Buffett's first rule, never invest in businesses you don't understand...
Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by qwrusz on Friday February 10, 2017 @12:25PM (#13617085)
That's not his first rule. It's way better than that:

"Rule No.1 is never lose money. Rule No.2 is never forget Rule No. 1." -Warren "Buff Daddy" Buffett

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by waqf on Friday February 10, 2017 @01:19PM (#13617561)
Can you expand on what he meant by that? I've always taken it to mean "don't ever make an investment that you know deep down is suboptimal".
Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by qwrusz on Friday February 10, 2017 @02:02PM (#13617928)
I can try. Firstly, worth mentioning the quote is a bit facetious, witty, jocose...Jolly old Warren Buffett can often be a bit playful and sort of sarcastic when talking about investing in public but it seems few people pick up on it.

Also maybe worth mentioning the quote is based on a well known "2 Rules" phrase format. For example:

“There are 2 rules of life. Rule number 1 is ‘Never quit.’ And rule number 2 is ‘Don’t forget rule number 1.’” - Duke Ellington

and

"There are 2 rules for success. Rule 1: Never tell everything you know. Rule 2:.. ;)"

OK with that said, I wouldn't overthink the quote. Obviously you can't really guarantee you will "never lose money" and so it's not really a rule and even Buffett loses money sometimes.

If I had to guess what he means: I would say use the quote as fun/serious reminder to think about risk ahead of reward and remember concepts like margin of safety that help protect you from loses even if a stock doesn't go up like you expect and hope.

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by nstj on Friday February 10, 2017 @07:23PM (#13620138)
Actually it's not facetious at all. The point comes from his mentor Benjamin Graham, which relates to the difficulty in recouping investment capital following a loss (ie: making your money back after you break the rule).

eg: You have $100k in your investment account. You have a bad year and lose 50% of your money, leaving you with $50k. You now need to have a 100% return in the next year to just make your money back, even though you only had a 50% loss. Seth Klarman, another highly successful value investor like Buffett is also a proponent of this way of thinking.

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by qwrusz on Friday February 10, 2017 @11:14PM (#13620978)
I'm being totally serious here as I'd love to learn where my writing and communication is being unclear:

May I ask, did you read my full comment?

And do you know the definition of facetious?

I'm not trying to be rude, I just don't understand why you wrote what you wrote.

For example: when you mention "his mentor Ben Graham" did you think I had not heard of Ben Graham or that I didn't know he was Buffett's mentor so you added that too?

Granted it's possible I hadn't. Or maybe you wrote it as a courtesy in case other readers hadn't heard of him? I ask because you saw in my first comment I am quoting Buffett. Then in my reply to waqf I write about Buffett again, his mannerisms and his track record...So maybe I know at least a little bit about the guy. Maybe?

But then at the end of my comment I not only write the concept of "margin of safety", I put it in italics to emphasize it. How did you see that and still wrote what you wrote?

How can someone know the concept of Margin Of Safety and not know Graham? Margin of Safety comes from Ben Graham. "Margin of Safety" is the Title of Chapter 20 of his book The Intelligent Investor; where Graham explains what it is in detail. Plus he just talked about MoS all the time and called it the "central concept of investment". MoS is Ben Graham.

Also heads up. Margin of Safety is also the title of Seth Klarman's whole book. Have you heard about Seth Klarman or his book Margin of Safety? After reading your comment in full I am guessing you may have. If you haven't, it's worth looking up and has an interesting story attached (at one point the book was being stolen from libraries and going for thousands of dollars on eBay. Madness!). Also if you are into investing of any kind, not just value investing, I recommend reading the book. Very good.

Anyway sorry if this is weird or rude or has gotten too long. I'd really love to understand where I am not writing clear enough. Thanks.

Also as for "facetious". Seriously look up the word. If this is a real rule how do you follow "never lose money"? I'll wait.

In the meantime a rule is a prescribed guide for conduct or action. Someone can lose money from forces out of their control. It's like telling someone "Rule 1 of driving: Never get into a car accident". That's not a rule. You can't follow that rule. Someone could hit you even when you are driving perfectly. Rule broken. A real rule would say something like "always drive the speed limit" or "Never text and drive". Those are rules you can follow or break. I'll let you figure out the real rule here for Buffett (hint look in to Chapter 20 of Graham).

Lastly, your example about how if you lose 50% you now need to earn 100% on that to get back to where you where you started is something I see brought up often. It is sad and it is fucking stupid how it gets talked about. This is not some investment concept from one of the greatest investment thinkers in history nor his mentee. Ha, if only. What you are describing is just a basic math concept. Most people learn this in elementary school I believe. Kinda shocking sometimes how proud and confident people who are new to investing become of themselves when they realize they understand how percentages work and percentages work normal and as expected when talking about the monetary value of something changing too...

Does "X times 0.95 times 1.05" = X"? Of course not.

Replace X with your $100k portfolio, 0.95 is -5%, then 1.05 is +5%, does mathematics still work? Still not equal? Obviously.

I know people are trying to help others when talking about all this stuff. I am trying too. And Caveat emptor and all that. Don't believe everything you read on the internet. But it's a bit frustrating at times to watch and sucks when people lose their hard earned money when they try investing based on bad or misleading information they received; especially when good information that is written well is out there and free to read online or at a library. On the other hand I'm sure there are more than a few folks who are very happy when idiots try investing without doing their research first so they can take the other sides of their trades...Margin of Safety is so important and this is a real investment concept and it actually needs to be learned, but be warned it will take more than a minute to understand it. Passive ETF much less work.

TGIF :)

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by nstj on Saturday February 11, 2017 @12:41AM (#13621233)
You're all good - I've never actually seen such a long response to a short thread before! And indeed, I have read Klarman's book a number of times - he talks about avoiding capital loss and the difficulty in recovering from bad choices quite a lot in the book. Best of luck with your investing!
Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by qwrusz on Saturday February 11, 2017 @04:57AM (#13621973)
Ya I'm still learning to write in English, sometimes this means to practice writing more when and where one can. Best of luck to you.
Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by hermitdev on Friday February 10, 2017 @10:17PM (#13620753)
> "There are 2 rules for success. Rule 1: Never tell everything you know. Rule 2:.. ;)"

In regards to this quote, this is why hedge funds are so protective of their "secret sauce". At a fund I worked for, I saw an employee sued in federal court for intellectual property theft 4 hours before he was terminated. Criminal charges followed a few months later. (Don't email source of a quantitative trading system to your personal email, lest you want to be jailed & unemployed and untouchable by the rest of the industry).

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by dave_sullivan on Friday February 10, 2017 @04:30PM (#13619062)
Besides the obvious of "Don't lose money because that's bad", he's referring to how losses can quickly wipe returns.

If you're shooting for 10% per year and you lose 5%, you need to then get a gain of more than 5% to get even again, pushing you to take worse risks.

Hence, by simply focusing on a strategy of "Not losing money" you can come out ahead.

This was also the original Hedge strategy where you short some stuff and buy some stuff so you can get some of the gains without participating in all the losses. For instance, if you can capture 70% of market ups while only taking 70% of the downs, you'll beat the market.

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by appleiigs on Friday February 10, 2017 @07:52PM (#13620260)
Why on earth is your comment downvoted? Your comment is correct.
Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by qwrusz on Friday February 10, 2017 @08:50PM (#13620470)
> For instance, if you can capture 70% of market ups while only taking 70% of the downs, you'll beat the market.

Is not correct.

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by dave_sullivan on Saturday February 11, 2017 @02:16AM (#13621558)
Except it is correct.

https://blog.thinknewfound.com/2016/05/the-asymmetry-zone/

Literally, plot daily gains vs daily losses of S&P. If you only take 70% of the losses but get 70% of the gains (so multiply each win/loss % element in the series by 0.7, and apply the new sequence to a portfolio balance), you'll end up doing better than the market.

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by qwrusz on Saturday February 11, 2017 @04:38AM (#13621928)
Ah, dave_sullivan welcome back.

How about this, below is the link to the data (S&P 500 daily returns), whoever is right will donate money to an education-related charity at 70% of the dollar amount donated by whoever is wrong. So for example if you are correct, I will donate $100 and you donate $70, and vice versa.

Trader? Risk taker? For charity?

Here's the link: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/SP500/downloaddata

Happy to chat about it more if you want. But just intuitively and quickly everyone should be able to see why one can't say an equal 70% up/down capture ratio will just beat the market...

1. let's agree the market can do whatever the hell it wants. Up, down, whatever.

2. Imagine a market is down -5% and then up 10%. According to your story and capture ratios, when this happens your portfolio is down only -3.5% and then up 7%. Right? 70% of the down and 70% of the up?

I think you will find in just this example the market beats your portfolio by more than 1% here. This is just a simple example and I am being generous. When you look at real data you will not only find a similar pattern, but your portfolio gets absolutely crushed by the market.

Maybe an even quicker intuitive answer: If a 70% up/down capture ratio portfolio will beat the market, why isn't this a huge thing and everyone sells/changes their regular full market S&P 500 ETFs to do that?

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by dave_sullivan on Saturday February 11, 2017 @12:43PM (#13623683)
Your data only goes back 10 years. Mathematically, whether 70% up/down works out to beat the market depends on the period we're talking about.

> I think you will find in just this example the market beats your portfolio by more than 1% here. This is just a simple example and I am being generous. When you look at real data you will not only find a similar pattern, but your portfolio gets absolutely crushed by the market.

Here's a python script that generates random numbers to simulate the stock market. Each time you run it, you'll get a different result: http://pastebin.com/UNtDPjxd This is basically your "simple example" run many times side by side. Sometimes a hedged strategy works better; sometimes not.

The place I got this idea in the first place was a book I read in college about the history of hedging as a strategy. It noted one of the earlier demonstrations of why it's a good strategy was when a fund showed that participating in 70% of the gains/70% of the losses of the S&P beat the S&P. But which years? This matters. Unfortunately, I can't find the book anywhere. IIRC, I think we'd be talking about a stretch covering the 40s, 50s, 60s.

This is similar to how Milken pitched the junk bond -- it was originally based on a paper that showed a balanced portfolio of low rated bonds performs better than a balanced portfolio of high rated bonds (this is explained in Den Of Thieves). This was true back then because low credit ratings were so heavily discounted by market conditions (mainly, nobody wanted to buy them).

> why isn't this a huge thing and everyone sells/changes their regular full market S&P 500 ETFs to do that?

For the same reason that no one is pushing a diversified portfolio of junk bonds anymore; what worked in the past doesn't necessarily work in the future.

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by qwrusz on Sunday February 12, 2017 @03:09PM (#13630404)
Thanks. For a second I thought I was chatting with someone you who knew what they were talking out. I appreciate you confirming you were basing your answer of something you read 10 years ago in a book, a book you can no longer find. The rest of your comment shows you didn't even study the basics of finance and economics either.

Dave, Hacker News has some of the smartest commentary I found on a News site. Questions on here regularly have people answering them where that person has experience, worked in that field professionally and have studied those topics in school and have degrees in them.

I realize this is the internet, expectations are low. People troll. Even if you wanted to help, why not wait a minute before answering to see if someone more informed or more experienced, than a book read 10 years ago will have answer. It's more a courtesy to the person asking as they get a better answer, and it stops you from looking like an idiot. Win-win.

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by dang on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @09:22PM (#13649197)
This comment crosses into personal attack, which is not allowed on HN regardless of how wrong someone is. Please don't post like this.
Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by qwrusz on Monday February 20, 2017 @02:11PM (#13689981)
My apologies. You're totally right, dang. Thanks for keeping this site civil and all the other work done for HN.
Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by FabHK on Wednesday March 01, 2017 @07:32PM (#13770222)
Just wanted to add that Dave's notion is not quite as absurd as you make it out to be.

As you might know, daily rebalancing leveraged ETFs (say, 2x or 3x) are basically a bad idea for long-term investments, because they are (simplistically) short vol. So, they might outperform the (non-leveraged) index/ETF if vol is low and total return over the period is high. But typically, with normal or high vol, or over long periods, they underperform non-leveraged.

By analogy, a less-than fully invested ETF/trading strategy that's basically "0.7x" leveraged will beat the (non-leveraged) index/ETF in certain trading regimes (where total return over a period is negative or modestly positive, while vol relatively high).

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by dave_sullivan on Wednesday February 15, 2017 @08:24PM (#13657158)
Yeah, sorry, I still think you're wrong. And you keep addressing me by name, do we know each other?
Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by appleiigs on Friday February 10, 2017 @10:56PM (#13620919)
I interpret it as if you are only correct half of the time, you can make money by letting your winning positions run and cutting your losses. Many winning traders talk about limiting your losses and risk management as being key.

Anyway, it's a bit too harsh to downvote. He's just answering a question, and correctly says if you lose 5%, you need to make back more than 5% to get back to even.

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by xsmasher on Friday February 10, 2017 @02:44PM (#13618259)
> those that have lost money in areas outside their wheel house have all followed the same path.

I'm pretty sure that's the first story in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Richest_Man_in_Babylon_(bo...

Old, old advice.

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by myotherother on Friday February 10, 2017 @10:50AM (#13616157)
It's really common for people to criticize professional athletes for trusting unscrupulous business managers, but I've always wondered how many of those people fully understand their own investments. Do they trust a CFA's word? Do they have there entire 401k invested in a vanguard target date fund but do they comprehend what its composition is?
Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by bradleyjg on Friday February 10, 2017 @05:16PM (#13619386)
You don't need to fully understand what is in a Vangaurd target date fund to have high confidence that it isn't a ponzi scheme that's going to go to zero. You can't say the same thing about the ultra-exclusive off the market opportunity that some business manager wants to put you in.

For a pro athlete looking at making millions for a few years and then facing a sharp drop-off thereafter, a Vanguard target date fund is probably not close to optimal. But you could do far worse and many do!

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by audleman on Saturday February 11, 2017 @10:16PM (#13626459)
When you make that kind of money suddenly you're an accredited investor. It's supposed to mean you're a sophisticated enough investor to take on riskier investments, but the way it's implemented it only measures if you can take a loss (either you have > $1mil in assets or make $200k+/year). Thus people like athletes are exposed to much riskier investment deals than they really have the ability to comprehend. I don't blame anyone for losing money, let alone athletes.

To answer your question, I personally don't know all the details about my Vanguard fund, though I understand the basics. But that's very different from a slick salesman in a suit selling me an opportunity to invest in Brazil in a high-risk high-return investment scheme.

Re:How the Flash Crash Trader’s $50M Fortune Vanished by WalterBright on Friday February 10, 2017 @11:49PM (#13621088)
It's a heluva lot easier to lose a million than to make a million.