News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by rainbowcandy on Thursday February 02, 2017 @05:07PM (#13555245)
You're proving his point. "He's just a fascist, so everything he says should be immediately ignored and disregarded." That's not having a conversation. That isn't talking anymore. I know you 100% believe he is a fascist, and history may look back on you and say "man that guy is so right" but the 45.9% of voters disagree with you. Calling them supporters of a fascist regime isn't going to change their mind, hell it seems to strengthen it.

His point was we need to have conversations and real moderate intelligent people surrounding someone like Trump. You push those people away by calling them nazis and the only thing you're doing is leaving a gap for people who don't care if you call them nazis....you know...like actual nazis.

Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by mcphage on Thursday February 02, 2017 @06:41PM (#13556134)
Do you think people voted for Trump because they wanted a conversation? Is there anything in his leadership style which leads you to believe he or his voters are interested in coming to the table for a discussion?
Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by true_religion on Thursday February 02, 2017 @08:15PM (#13556793)
I was a voter---and I wont' say which way---and I'd like to have a conversation but I am afraid that if I express any views then this will happen:

1. I will be called a member of a neo-fascist party

2. People will say that I am a racist, sexist, bigot.

3. I will be fired from my job because I no longer fit the "company culture".

4. People will see me at a public workspace, and move away from me, and refuse to partner with me. Eventually I will be asked to leave because I am making people uncomfortable with my mere presence.

5. My acquaintances will shun me, and speak about me in whispers of "I didn't know he/she was like that..."

This is why I do not speak. I simply cast my vote, and move on.

Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by mcphage on Thursday February 02, 2017 @09:27PM (#13557130)
Voting is a political action, wherein you express your preference for what you want the future of the country to look like.

Why do you think you shouldn't be held accountable for your actions? If you're of voting age, you're not a child anymore. As an adult, you act, and are responsible and accountable for those actions.

Furthermore, if what you want the country to be like is something that others find distasteful, why do you believe that others shouldn't act on that? It's not like like we're talking about the difference between chocolate or vanilla ice cream. You were asked if you wanted a stable government or... whatever it is we have right now. Why don't you believe that would reflect upon who you are, and how others view you?

Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by vorotato on Thursday February 02, 2017 @11:21PM (#13557658)
I had a coworker admit he was a Trump supporter, and most of those things haven't happened. However this coworker doesn't actually HAVE sexist, racist and bigoted opinions. The coworker expressed distaste in Trump's immigrant ban, but still believed that he would help the economy. I think this coworker is wrong, however I don't think they are a racist/sexist/bigot. I do think they are a follower of a neo-facist party, but I do not think they themselves are facist. He does make people uncomfortable sometimes, but not because of his political views, and yeah sometimes people do go, "He's a trump supporter?", but they get over it.
Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by zimpenfish on Friday February 03, 2017 @06:15AM (#13559046)
> People will say that I am a racist, sexist, bigot.

If you voted for Trump, yes, they will because you voted for someone who is all of those things - you were perfectly ok with his behaviour on those axes.

Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by dllthomas on Friday February 03, 2017 @11:14AM (#13560810)
Voting for Trump would indicate that they are sufficiently okay with his behavior. Nothing has established that they were perfectly okay with it.
Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by prodigal_erik on Saturday February 04, 2017 @05:20PM (#13569449)
Clinton strongly favors free trade and mass immigration. You could despise Trump yet vote for him if you think those trends are sufficiently harmful, because the only signals you could add to this election were Clinton, Trump, and Don't Care.
Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by dllthomas on Saturday February 04, 2017 @07:01PM (#13569882)
> the only signals you could add to this election were Clinton, Trump, and Don't Care.

A third party vote isn't quite the same thing as not casting a vote.

Otherwise, I don't think we disagree?

Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by grzm on Thursday February 02, 2017 @06:47PM (#13556187)
I've heard many express that many voted for Trump because they felt they weren't being heard. A large part of the problem in my opinion is that conversations aren't being had. Even if people are reluctant or not willing to have engage right now I think we all need to be willing to and attempt to talk with each other.
Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by vorotato on Thursday February 02, 2017 @11:13PM (#13557612)
It's important to be mindful that 46% of voters is around 28% of eligible voters, and 20% of the overall US population. Obviously the same is true + or - a few percent for Hillary, so really unpopular presidential picks this year. Either way people weren't going to be super happy, but Trump is making absolutely no efforts to appeal to even moderate republicans.
Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by dreaminvm on Thursday February 02, 2017 @05:09PM (#13555272)
I really don't see the value in reiterating this statistic over and over again.

The POTUS is decided by the electoral vote. If the process was by the popular vote, the candidates would have campaigned very differently and the voter turnout could be much higher.

Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by sundaeofshock on Thursday February 02, 2017 @05:14PM (#13555337)
It is valuable becuase it shows that the vast majority wanted someone other then Trump as president. It means he does not have a popular mandate to do the things he wants to do.
Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by dreaminvm on Thursday February 02, 2017 @05:27PM (#13555459)
The only point I am arguing here is that the popular vote for any election is meaningless (except an electoral tie) when the POTUS is decided by the electoral colleges.

If the popular vote decided the POTUS, then Trump voters in traditionally Democratic states (think Pacific NorthWest) might have turned out in droves and vice-versa for Hilary.

Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by altern8tif on Thursday February 02, 2017 @08:19PM (#13556808)
I beg to differ. While the presidency is determined by the electoral college, the popular vote is not meaningless.

A hypothetical president who won only 30% of the popular vote, while winning the electoral college, will be enacting policies that 70% of the electorate explicitly voted against.

Even with these numbers, a more moderate (and reasonable) president might still be able to mend the fences put up during the campaign trail. But with such a polarising president, the dissatisfaction amongst the populace will be even more pronounced. This is exactly what we're seeing now.

Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by Lagged2Death on Thursday February 02, 2017 @11:34PM (#13557706)
...the popular vote for any election is meaningless...

Yet the administration itself keeps bringing it up. Making up stories to explain it away. As if it mattered quite a lot.

Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by prodigal_erik on Thursday February 02, 2017 @05:34PM (#13555541)
2% of the popular vote is not a vast majority.

(EDIT: I said "and we aren't even certain about that number because states generally don't keep counting after the state outcome is certain" but I was mistaken).

Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by sundaeofshock on Thursday February 02, 2017 @06:09PM (#13555862)
Trump won 46.1% of the popular vote, which means 53.9% of the electorate wanted someone else as president. 8 points is a pretty big difference.

Can you provide evidence that states stop counting votes after it looks there will be a winner in a specific race? Last time i checked, states take several weeks to provide official results because counting all the votes takes a while.

Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by prodigal_erik on Thursday February 02, 2017 @06:46PM (#13556174)
Snopes says I'm wrong and even absentee votes are eventually counted, sorry for the misinfo: http://www.snopes.com/2016/11/13/who-won-the-popular-vote/

We have a first-past-the-post system in which only the top two candidates are viable, so 5.7% of the voters didn't prioritize keeping Trump out of office. If we set the bar at "I think this is the best qualified person on Earth for this office" every elected official has only had a small minority. If we set the bar at "of these two, this one is better" Hillary only won by 2% along with a lot of "don't care".

Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by sundaeofshock on Thursday February 02, 2017 @09:48PM (#13557247)
That's a lot of handwaving and speculation about what was going on in the voters' minds. I'm going to Occam's Razor this and say that ~54% of voters voted for Not Donald Trump.
Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by robert_foss on Thursday February 02, 2017 @05:06PM (#13555233)
> leader of the free world

Seeing the US referred to in this way really makes you get a sense for how effective nationalistic propaganda is.

  * leader of the free world
  * greatest nation on earth
  * freest nation in the world
None of which is quantifiable or accurate.
Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by mcphage on Thursday February 02, 2017 @06:44PM (#13556161)
::shrug:: it refers to the US having the largest economy, military, and cultural influence. "Greatest", and "Freest", those are somewhere between meaningless and false. But "leader" is a statement of influence, although it is waning.
Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by HillaryBriss on Thursday February 02, 2017 @05:24PM (#13555428)
Not only is it inaccurate, it feeds American exceptionalism. And that seems to justify our self-issued license to undertake all manner of insensible, irresponsible, destructive acts.
Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by brixon on Thursday February 02, 2017 @05:02PM (#13555200)
The real problem complacency. Too many Democrats assumed Hillary could not lose and did not bother to vote.
Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by appleflaxen on Thursday February 02, 2017 @05:06PM (#13555238)
the real problem is that the democratic party rigged the system against a candidate who could have beat trump, and ended up with the only candidate who could have lost to him.
Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by vorotato on Thursday February 02, 2017 @11:26PM (#13557676)
Exactly, this is the thing that many moderate democrats aren't even facing! I voted for Hillary begrudgingly because Trump was so horrible, but I didn't like her at all.
Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by zimpenfish on Friday February 03, 2017 @10:31AM (#13560430)
I've yet to see a cogent political analysis that shows how Sanders could have beaten Trump. Do you have an example?
Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by jokermatt999 on Friday February 03, 2017 @12:56PM (#13561692)
Honestly, even as a former Bernie supporter, I don't know if political analysis that indicated it can still be called reliable. I've heard his team produced data showing Bernie would win versus Trump, but most polls also thought it was a sure victory for Clinton. While 538 pointed out there was just a "normal polling error"[1] between Clinton and Trump (and I haven't dug as much into the post election analysis due to being distracted by more urgent matters) it seems like the polling clearly missed support for Trump.

I think he would have done a good job at picking up votes from the "disaffected" crowd that voted Trump over Clinton as a protest, but there's certainly the possibility that he would be lose votes for being too far left.

At this point, I certainly still wish Bernie won, seeing as Trump is president regardless, but I don't think there's necessarily a solid counterfactual that he would've beaten Trump. Either way, I think some of the blame can certainly be placed on Democrats pushing more of the same when people were clearly calling for a change.

[1] https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/trump-is-just-a-normal-...

Re:Uber C.E.O. To Leave Trump Advisory Council After Criticism by jacquesm on Thursday February 02, 2017 @05:08PM (#13555258)
He's not my leader and I think I still live in the 'free world' (or at least, as free as it gets for now).