Not quite the reason for the fine according to TFA:
> Instead, it ruled that Luckey, who was working as a contractor for Zenimax before starting the Kickstarter for the Oculus Rift headset, violated his non-disclosure agreement,
I don't think you should charge $500 million for a poaching. That's the crux of my anticompetitiveness argument.
Nonetheless, you definitely shouldn't charge $500 million for merely violating an NDA, even if that's what the jury found.
Supporting competition or being pro-consumer / pro-innovation should not come at the cost of individual property rights, which is one of the cornerstones of wealth creation. I can agree with curtailing property rights in some extreme cases (eg. antitrust litigations or eminent domain), but I don't see any reason to do so in the case of Zenimax.
That being said, Facebook doesn't really seem to have its R&D figured out. It's poisoned by bad leadership. Palmer Luckey managed to disgrace himself in public opinion in a way that seems hostile to recruiting the kind of progressive, free-thinking talent that makes up most R&D teams. John Carmack, besides his political leanings, speaks derisively of "Hollywood people" (Oculus users) and came out of this lawsuit looking like a real jerk chasing a huge check at any cost. At the end of the day, he betrayed a video game company.
Mark Zuckerberg has a lot of leadership faults disguised behind an amateurish ownership structure that puts him outside of public accountability. Despite its huge head start, Oculus is seriously threatened by HTC, Sony, Google and Samsung. Paper and Facebook payments didn't really go anywhere. Though Instagram and WhatsApp seem to be good acquisitions, even at their extraordinary prices, a broken clock can still be right twice a day. And it doesn't really take leadership to spend huge amounts of money on acquisitions—that's the easy way out. Outside of Facebook, his New Jersey schools efforts were not well regarded. Will his $3 billion commitment to a SF Biohub be marred by similar issues? I'm just nervous is all.
I think market sentiment will catch up with this ruling. Eventually someone's going to ask if he's the right guy to be in charge of Facebook. The public investor may never actually have the power to do something about it.