News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by kodfodrasz on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @03:13AM (#13528699)
Having coffee made by a barista is about service, serving, that is a premium compared to coffee made by a machine.

Why would I pay premium price for getting stuff from a will-less machine, that I can get cheaper from other such machines. Having coffee made for me by a human with free will, by free will, being made as well as it possible for a human is what is worth a premium price over the simple cost of ingredients and maintenance. For me, and I thing the future of economy the quality human labour with heart and soul put into the product is worth more than automation ( for the sake of automation)

Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by blazespin on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @03:18AM (#13528722)
Yeah, no kidding. What's the point of having money if someone can't make us a nice submissive cup of coffee.
Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by ehnto on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @03:53AM (#13528871)
Forgive me if I have read you wrong, but only from a place of ignorance could a statement like that be said without humor.

You are suggesting that being a Barista is such a low peg on society and such a suffering to endure that it is akin to subservience.

Many baristas are incredibly talented and proud of what they do and make coffee an artisan pursuit. Not only that, but it is perfectly alright to enjoy serving coffee and enjoying customers company even if it isn't an artisan task for you and is just a job.

Regardless of all that, just because you replace a barista with a robot does not mean they will suddenly be interested in STEM fields or art or music or furthering a corporate career. I know you didn't suggest that, but the implication from others seems to be that if someone isn't doing an engineering job then they just aren't living correctly and they sure would if only they didn't have to do their blue collar job. That's clearly not the case nor will it ever be, no matter the will of progress and innovation.

Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by kwhitefoot on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @06:35AM (#13529685)
> replace a barista with a robot does not mean they will suddenly be interested in STEM fields

Any coffee shop that does it will do it just for the money. They won't shed a tear for the barista who is now out of work.

If it doesn't save money, if people remain cheaper than machines, then the barista will keep the job.

Anyway most people who serve coffee are just _serving_ coffee, giving the trade a name doesn't automatically mean that the product is better. In my limited experience of coffee shops (I like coffee but it disagrees with me) the killer features of the good ones are good quality ingredients and repeatability. Whether it's made by machine, barista, or druid incantations it's all the same to me as long as the product is good.

Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by ehnto on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @06:48AM (#13529746)
I hear you and that's likely the attitude most people have toward coffee and coffee places. Coffee can be a product like a bottle of water, and you can buy it from most places like you would a chocolate bar. For those circumstances which I imagine is the majority, automated coffee would be perfect. But there is definitely a coffee culture beneath that, and it's a lot more like a cocktail bar than a drive through bottle shop for example.

The coffee shops I prefer are usually because the coffee is good, but the people serving and the venue itself were also a great experience. An example is the coffee store next door which has a fireplace, great music, sofas and the people behind the counter are all about getting to know the regulars and making everyone welcome. They take huge pride in what they do, which I guess is what my little rant was about. To call them servants undermines a job that is their passion and that's a bummer.

Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by lmm on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @07:15AM (#13529871)
> all about getting to know the regulars and making everyone welcome. They take huge pride in what they do, which I guess is what my little rant was about. To call them servants undermines a job that is their passion and that's a bummer.

Couldn't one say exactly the same about a good butler?

Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by ehnto on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @05:21PM (#13535862)
You could and again many buttlers are well paid and passionate about their work. You could argue that even a high paid engineer is a servant to someone. It was more about the idea that someone would only do it if they were forced to by their economic situation, rather than because they want to.
Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by jpgvm on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @04:29AM (#13529075)
It's clearly sarcasm.
Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by ehnto on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @04:32AM (#13529092)
Right. Clearly sarcasm, but what isn't clear is how they actually feel about the issue.
Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by kodfodrasz on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @03:25AM (#13528750)
Actually kind of. But I think it is not about being submissive, but creating something for another person, with the will to create joy for the other. Slaves cannot put this premium into things, nor can machines. Paying for mass produced stuff is worth only so much, but hand made stuff is worth more because of this in my eyes.

But sure, you can always bash others for being dominant/submissive and enjoy the company of robots instead, and clap for another step in the direction of a uniformized dull mass produced world, where there is no submission, just freedom within will-less machines. I prefer a different freedom, based on free will.

*edit: phone autocompletion corrected.

Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by heeen on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @06:12AM (#13529595)
What you wrote resonates with me. I have an espresso machine and grinder at home and I enjoy making coffee for guests and myself. I wish I could pull off even simple latte art.

In a post scarcity world, I imagine human work with its imperfections will have its own wabi sabi value. People already pay a hefty premium for artisan handmade products like pottery, furniture, even jeans.

“I could try composing wonderful musical works, or day-long entertainment epics, but what would that do? Give people pleasure? My wiping this table gives me pleasure. And people come to a clean table, which gives them pleasure. And anyway" - the man laughed - "people die; stars die; universes die. What is any achievement, however great it was, once time itself is dead? Of course, if all I did was wipe tables, then of course it would seem a mean and despicable waste of my huge intellectual potential. But because I choose to do it, it gives me pleasure. And," the man said with a smile, "it's a good way of meeting people. So where are you from, anyway?” ― Iain M. Banks, Use of Weapons

Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by Chris2048 on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @06:03AM (#13529537)
If someone puts heart and soul into something, I'd sooner they keep it for themselves. I really just want a good coffee, nothing more.
Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by hvidgaard on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @07:07AM (#13529843)
The issue is, for now, a machine can make good coffee, but it cannot make great coffee. There is a lot of science behind the perfect cup that we still don't understand, thus making a machine understand it is impossible. It is still a craft.

If I go down to one of my local roasters, I know I get servered the near perfect cup. A machine would have to be calibrated multiple times a day to achieve the same level of consistency. And the barista would need to hone his/her skill to keep doing this.

Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by razzimatazz on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @09:58AM (#13531013)
Fully agreeing with your points here. The perspective I think that hasn't been mentioned is present here in Switzerland - where they make 'Jura' brand superautomatic coffee machines, and culture is such that in any establishment that is not specialty-coffee focused, you will be served your coffee by a robot. You will still pay top dollar for the middle-aged woman to walk over and press the button for Cafe or Cappuccino, but it will probably taste like burnt rubbish.

To me in particular, any hope of a quality standard of the milk aspect of the coffee is lost completely.

But returning to your points - The 'Jura' standard of coffee is 'good enough', and only not good enough recently to hip-swiss or expats living here. The standard of coffee expected from a barista is significantly higher - I imagine the theoretical Jura coffee machine that can do this would cost an insane amount to build, and to maintain and calibrate.

That is, until we get a real AI powered robot that can optimize and adjust its technique to what is happening in the cup and in the milk jug.

Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by Chris2048 on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @12:22PM (#13532775)
Caffeine grows a like towards the experience of the medium. It's possible some will prefer Jura? Point is, the 'perfect' coffee depends on brain chemistry, which is influenced by coffee...
Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by Chris2048 on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @08:16AM (#13530236)
> There is a lot of science behind the perfect cup that we still don't understand

Are you sure?

> making a machine understand it is impossible. It is still a craft.

Why? What is a 'craft'?

> A machine would have to be calibrated multiple times a day to achieve the same level of consistency

Don't you mean a simple machine?

There's a lot of science suggesting the perfect cup isn't so objective.

Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by hvidgaard on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @08:47AM (#13530434)
Things like humidity, water chemistry, and others affect coffee. We don't understand this process in a scientific manner yet, and the art of calibrating rely on our tastebuds to fine tune every method from an espresso machine to a simple turkish coffee. It is still a long way from doable with a machine if you want that perfect cup.

That is not even touching the different parameters such as preinfusion, variable pressure, grind, and changes in temperature during the brewing. To my knowledge we do not know how to process coffee in a way such that a machine can model and understand the human taste buds. And it certainly haven't been applied successfully to coffee brewing yet.

Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by leoedin on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @09:38AM (#13530854)
We don't really need to have a machine which models human tastebuds. Coffee brewing is ultimately a chemical process, and so it's naive to suggest that a machine couldn't do it in a better and more repeatable manner than a human can.

What I think you're suggesting is that the settings of that chemical process are configured by the barista based on taste, and that they vary based on a number of environmental conditions.

Surely then all we need to do is to correlate environmental conditions with brewing settings. Assuming there is a relationship to be found, it sounds like the perfect application of either statistics or machine learning.

Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by hvidgaard on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @02:41AM (#13539090)
> Surely then all we need to do is to correlate environmental conditions with brewing settings. Assuming there is a relationship to be found, it sounds like the perfect application of either statistics or machine learning.

Big companies have been trying for many years, and after millions of dollars spend in R&D they still don't have it figured out yet. Imagine providing a full automatic machine that can produce a cup better that WBC contenders - it could cost thousands of dollars in service fee every year, and still be cheaper than your run of the mill barista. They really want to do this, but it is far from trivial. Either the blend and roasting profile produce a bland coffee that is less susceptible to variations in brewing parameters, or you need to fine tune it multiple times a day, each being different for every roast you have. Things such as when it was harvested, how much rain the plant got, how it was roasted, how old it is, ect. all influence it, along side things such as current external parameters such as humidity.

Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by Chris2048 on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @05:25AM (#13539660)
But there are coffee machines that produce amazing coffee automatically, they are expensive though. It's possible there is no market for it. It's also possible this is an emerging market.
Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by hvidgaard on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @06:04AM (#13539797)
They produce amazing coffee, once they have been dialed in, and will continue to do so, as long as they are continuesly calibrated. That is my entire point - we still need baristas to do the calibration. Maybe some day we don't, but until then we cannot say we have it figured out at all.
Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by TarpitCarnivore on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @09:26AM (#13530744)
All of these variables can be determined by a human and then programmed into a machine. We're talking about easily programmable things, not brain surgery.
Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by hvidgaard on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @02:32AM (#13539046)
Yes, we can. But every bean is different, even a different roasting profile means it needs to be calibrated and adjusted differently. It's not a simple matrix of input parameters and bean (yet).
Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by Chris2048 on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @05:26AM (#13539664)
It seems to me a machine would be better at keeping track of the difference. How many Baristas lookup a bean/roasting-profile/table to see what temp to extract at?
Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by hvidgaard on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @06:09AM (#13539812)
They don't have to. It's something you taste. Pull a shot, calibrate, rinse and repeat until it is as it should be.
Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by Chris2048 on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @09:44AM (#13530905)
> We don't understand this process in a scientific manner yet

Again, are you sure? There are industry scientists that study this.

Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by hvidgaard on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @02:42AM (#13539094)
I'm sure. Either it's a well guarded secret, or they havn't been able to full map the relationships or it's infeasible to make a truly great cup purely with a machine (yet).
Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by Chris2048 on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @05:36AM (#13539687)
What about "Espresso Coffee: The Science of Quality" book?
Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by hvidgaard on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @06:07AM (#13539809)
If you can translate it directly to a computer that can adjust an espresso machine, then yes. But you cannot. It is an amazing book (I own it myself), it is a encyclopedia learn the craft of growing, roasting, and brewing some of the best coffee in the world.
Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by LunaSea on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @08:15AM (#13530234)
You're most likely right but you seem also much more enthusiastic and passionate about coffee than most. Most people are fine to just get a good (not great) coffee in the morning on their way to work if only it goes fast enough and friction to use this system is low enough.
Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by hvidgaard on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @08:50AM (#13530460)
I certainly am. I'm a coffee nerd to the core. You're completely correct that most people just want a good cup, and they can already get that from McD - it is seriously a good cup. It's not great, but it's fast and the price is reasonable, albeit somewhat expensive for that it is (though, it is cheaper than starbucks and the like).
Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by TarpitCarnivore on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @09:21AM (#13530705)
You would be shocked by the amount of high end coffee bars moving to automatic and PRE dosing for their service. Even barista champions are speaking up the benefits of automated drinks in the favor of good, high quality service.

A machine will make a more consistent cup, day in and day out then any barista.

Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by hvidgaard on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @02:45AM (#13539105)
A machine calibrated multiple times a day by an experienced barista... I have never questioned the value of this. A machine is likely to produce a more consistent result, but it cannot calibrate itself.
Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by Chris2048 on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @12:23PM (#13532782)
A good barista is a machine operator...
Re:Robot Baristas Serve Up the Future of Coffee at Cafe X by TarpitCarnivore on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @09:24AM (#13530730)
I highly suggest you read the interview with G&B owners from Barista magazine. They go into detail about why they choose pre-dosing and automated machines over manual service. Their primary reason? Service. There is a lot more to coffee service than just someone spending 3-4 pouring out water over a bed of coffee grounds or tamping a puck.

You can find it here starting on page 72 http://baristamagazine.epubxp.com/i/659497-apr-may-2016