News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by ohstopitu on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:00AM (#13462171)
A few friends of mine did exactly the same. They still have their jobs (btw, both are Software Engineers).

1. He had 0 idea of coding, or why something was done - basically copy paste from github/stackoverflow and call it a day.

2. She has some basic understanding, but basically got into CS because she had heard that SE/CS Majors made "big bucks" and she thought she "knew computers"

Both graduated 4 years later, just as clueless but with degrees. When it came to interviews, both had 0 idea of the questions asked - to the point that I gave up helping them (if you can't do fizzbuzz, linked lists etc in any language or even psudocode, then you should really learn that first).

So they decided to do exactly what "Brian" did - downloaded a few of my public repos, uploaded as their own (btw it's funny because my name and email is on the README, and on almost every file - autogenerated with IntelliJ/Webstorm).

Somehow they land interviews, and both of them gets jobs at this fancy startup (making way more than me). One of them realizes that she's way over and since I was not helping, she decided to outsource it to Fiverr. She's been there 2 months and no one seems to raise any issues.

At times like this I kinda loose a bit of faith in our community - If that was what was needed, Why am I getting paid less to do more honest work? :/

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by csydas on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:11AM (#13462229)
Don't be disheartened - most industries are like this, and it even has an idiom "fake it till you make it".

My current work allows me a pretty decent look at literally thousands of different IT infrastructure set ups by this point only half a year in, and I'm still explaining the basics of IT administration, infrastructure, SQL queries, and so on to people with the title "Senior ______" and a list of certifications that adds a good 4 MB to each of their emails for all the banners.

Try not to worry about it, and don't enable them either. Be professional, but be firm. I won't promise that they will get their comeuppance or that you will be rewarded, but you can at least leave every day not having to look over your shoulder or double checking that you covered all your bases. In the long run, you'll have the knowledge to do what is necessary for future growth in your career, they will have to keep inventing new ways to fake it.

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by wyclif on Monday January 23, 2017 @10:25AM (#13462769)
I get what you're saying here and agree with it, but I just wanted to make a minor point about "fake it till you make it." FITYMI was never supposed to be a synonym for "misrepresent your credentials and lie about your experience." In other words, it's not related to scamming people, but rather avoiding the self-fulfilling prophecy that results in lacking confidence or being a failure.
Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by mrsernine on Monday January 23, 2017 @10:58AM (#13463034)
I agree, FITYMI is one of the most missunderstood mottos of all time. It has to do with changing one's mental state about something in order to achieve that thing rather than framing someone about what you are capable of.
Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by cr0sh on Monday January 23, 2017 @04:10PM (#13466068)
One of the great old stories about "FITYMI" would have to be that of Sierra Online's Ken Williams:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ken_Williams_(game_developer)

Basically, he moved across country with his wife (Roberta), because (somehow, IIRC the story) he got hired as a software developer by a company in California - but he had no programming experience.

So - on the long drive from where they lived, he crammed learning how to code from a book for the language (don't recall - maybe cobol or fortran, given the time period), and was able to show up, day one, and code for his job.

At least, that's what little I recall about the story. I probably have a few details wrong. Regardless, its an even more amazing story when you realize this was at a time when Ken would have had no access to a computer until he got to his new employer's office (at the time, desktop PCs were virtually non-existent, and laptops were but a dream of Alan Kay - at best, you had a green-screen terminal, if you weren't submitting card batches)...

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by antisthenes on Monday January 23, 2017 @11:57AM (#13463591)
> It has to do with changing one's mental state about something in order to achieve that thing rather than framing someone about what you are capable of.

Sounds like there's no misrepresentation at all. Most people treat it as to become delusional of their own abilities or qualities, so functionally they are just tricking themselves in addition to everyone else.

"Changing your mental state" can be just as harmful as outright faking and sometimes there's no difference in outcome at all.

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by AstralStorm on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @03:24AM (#13469685)
Also known as Dunning-Kruger effect taken to an extreme.

A little knowledge in a bad mental framework is a dangerous thing.

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by WalterSear on Monday January 23, 2017 @10:16AM (#13462686)
"Fake it till you make it" doesn't mean this, any more than "God helps those who help themselves" is an exhortation to stealing.
Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by WalterSear on Monday January 23, 2017 @10:51AM (#13462984)
Ultimately, it's shit like this that is why we are made to do Fizzbuzz puzzles during interviews.
Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by flukus on Monday January 23, 2017 @07:27PM (#13467718)
It's shit like this that make me happy to do Fizzbuzz puzzles in interviews, because when you work somewhere that doesn't...
Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by jstanley on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:08AM (#13462214)
> Why am I getting paid less to do more honest work? :/

You're optimising for doing good work. They're optimising for landing high-paying jobs.

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by disease on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:57AM (#13462549)
I've noticed a rather sad correlation of passionate software developers that are interested in the trade with low pay. At this point, I don't even know if employers are legitimately interested in "hiring the best". In my experience companies that aren't Google or Microsoft generally just want to hire the cheapest possible labor. If they luck out and get a strong engineer that can't effectively negotiate for themselves, that's just the icing on the cake.

Note that I'm currently doing software development in the Midwest, so my view may be biased.

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by Bartweiss on Monday January 23, 2017 @10:53AM (#13463004)
Having worked in the Midwest, I had a lot of terrible experiences I haven't seen replicated on either coast.

There seem to be a lot of midwestern companies full of programmers, selling software products, which don't see themselves as "software companies" (like Yahoo is a "media company"). Without exception, I found that those companies were trying to buy code like it came off an assembly line - paying lots of people low wages to pump out their daily lines. Some of the "smarter" ones had realized that this offer was so unpalatable that they couldn't get existing programmers, and were shipping new hires to bootcamps to create candidates. (Cynically, I assume that they have an incentive to ensure these bootcamps teach bad, cargo-cult programming - if they were good they'd quickly lose trainees to better jobs.)

Job hunting out there, at least half the prospects I turned up had something hideously bad involved. Some mandated novice-bootcamp attendance, starting even experienced devs at "See Spot run, see Spot code". Some wanted 6 month (or 1 year!) trial periods on minimal salary or even sub-minimum stipends. Some just wanted the usual bullshit like "5 years of Java 8 experience". Many had ludicrous location requirements, like cycling through shifts in offices around the country before ending up in rural Montana. Pretty much all of it felt like commodity purchasing - I wasn't an employee, I was an agreement to deliver "six codes per week".

Moving back to the coast, and seeing a lot of self-described software companies, I have a lot more hope that people are at least trying to hire well. There are just a lot of companies which haven't gotten the message.

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by bsg75 on Monday January 23, 2017 @12:21PM (#13463814)
Creating a new sub-industry of well paid experienced developers who repair bad implementations.

Not sure if this is a good or bad thing.

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by crdoconnor on Monday January 23, 2017 @11:32AM (#13463359)
I had a similar experience in Singapore before moving back to the UK.
Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by HeyLaughingBoy on Monday January 23, 2017 @01:25PM (#13464478)
I've noticed a rather sad correlation of passionate software developers that are interested in the trade with low pay

This isn't confined to developers. You find the same dynamic in commercial pilots (making an exception for Airline Transport Pilots with thousands of hours of experience!) and Park Rangers: enough well-qualified people want to do the work so badly that the pay remains very low.

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by OpenDrapery on Monday January 23, 2017 @02:32PM (#13465149)
I'm still looking for a dev job in Columbus, OH where I can be part of the engineering team, and not part of IT. Seems that all of the dev jobs are in the IT cost center around here.
Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by flukus on Monday January 23, 2017 @07:28PM (#13467726)
Ok, but why isn't the industry optimizing for good work?
Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by nhebb on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:14AM (#13462238)
OK, I laughed at the Fiverr bit, but I have no idea how someone can cope with living a lie like that. The stress of deceit would cripple me.
Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by nkrisc on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:36AM (#13462380)
I sometimes get imposter syndrome, I can't imagine being an actual imposter.
Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by jwdunne on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:59AM (#13462567)
Yes. No degree, failed high school (well a levels) and yet I can at least do fizzbuzz. I'd have no chance in a corporate.

I don't think I'm a great programmer but if this is what a "bad programmer" is maybe I can breathe a little.

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by Bartweiss on Monday January 23, 2017 @10:56AM (#13463021)
Someday when you're feeling really down, give this a read: http://thedailywtf.com/articles/The-Fizz-Buzz-from-Outer-Spa...

"Bad programmer" is a big range, but the low end is so much lower than we tend to remember.

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by jwdunne on Monday January 23, 2017 @11:20AM (#13463234)
Not gonna lie that made me chuckle. I should read the daily wtf more when I really feel like an imposter.
Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by nhebb on Monday January 23, 2017 @07:23PM (#13467689)
Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by sriku on Monday January 23, 2017 @12:19PM (#13463791)
While it is dishonest to claim credit for the Fiverr job, isn't it a smart thing to do? I mean if this person was in management instead and said "we can outsource this on Fiverr and save a ton of money instead of hiring these devs fulltime", they'd get a bonus, no?

In an interview, I gave a problem to a candidate and asked him how he'd tackle it. He said he'd google for a solution first. At that moment, I recall having a dilemma of choosing between "smart guy" and "no good as a problem solver". He turned out to be the latter, but it was a conceivable answer from a smart and capable candidate too.

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by cr0sh on Monday January 23, 2017 @04:03PM (#13465995)
> While it is dishonest to claim credit for the Fiverr job, isn't it a smart thing to do?

Not really - if you aren't authorized to do that as a developer, it's likely because of IP issues, etc; IOW, you have access to privileged info (the code and IP) - and you are supplying it to an outside 3rd party without permission from your employer.

If all that happens is you get fired - you are lucky. A very expensive lawsuit would be a more likely outcome, depending on the company and their resources, and whether they want to "make an example". It's not much different than taking their code and handing it to a competitor.

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by Kurtz79 on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:41AM (#13462418)
Agreed completely, I really don't get people that fake their CV or lie at interviews.

It might land you a job, but then you have to keep the lies going indefinitely, living in fear of being found out.

Is it worth it ?

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by randomdata on Monday January 23, 2017 @11:34AM (#13463386)
To ask if it is worth it, one must ask what is the risk?

If the biggest threat is that you lose your job, you don't have much to lose. After all, that is the same place you would be if you didn't try at all. And if you can gain something in the process, which seems quite likely here, you're already well ahead of the game.

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by dragonwriter on Monday January 23, 2017 @11:39AM (#13463437)
If maintaining the illusion requires unauthorized outsourcing of work (and, therefore, exfiltration of proprietary company information to third parties), then the risk extends beyond losing your job.
Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by HeyLaughingBoy on Monday January 23, 2017 @01:31PM (#13464539)
In 99.999% of cases where they find out, the only downside is you'll be fired. Could they sue you? Of course. Will they? Almost certainly not. What would it get them?

So yes, the only reasonably foreseeable risk is losing your job.

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by randomdata on Monday January 23, 2017 @11:44AM (#13463477)
On the other hand, if the agreement allows outsourcing of work, that's good business sense.
Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by laurieg on Monday January 23, 2017 @11:09AM (#13463129)
People do all sorts of crazy things for 100 bucks. If you fraudulently get a job as a programmer you might be making thousands and thousands more than you would otherwise. It's not hard to see the incentive.
Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by GFischer on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:28PM (#13473419)
A surprising amount of people do :( , and there have been a few very high profile cases where they're found out, like Yahoo's CEO and Uruguay's vice president. There are even cases of fake doctors.

http://money.cnn.com/2012/05/13/technology/yahoo-ceo-out/

https://panampost.com/sabrina-martin/2016/02/25/uruguay-vp-a...

http://www.nbcnews.com/id/40630166/ns/health-health_care/t/f...

However, there are many more that aren't (I personally know a few cases, including a CEO, but I'm not going to out them).

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by greenhatman on Monday January 23, 2017 @06:03PM (#13467048)
There is no way this is sustainable.
Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by imron on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:46AM (#13462473)
> Why am I getting paid less to do more honest work?

Why aren't you applying for the jobs that they are applying for?

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by wpietri on Monday January 23, 2017 @10:48AM (#13462954)
I'm not him, but here's one good answer: who wants to work for a company populated with frauds and run by idiots who don't know how to hire or manage?

I like getting things done. I like working with smart, sane, kind people. I like working on good code. As long as I can make a decent living somewhere like that, there's no plausible salary that would make me give up that.

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by imron on Monday January 23, 2017 @11:15AM (#13463183)
And that's a perfectly valid answer!

But if these people with little/no experience are getting paid higher salaries, it strikes me that ohstopitu is probably being paid under market rates at their current position and there will be companies with smart, sane, kind people and good code bases offering similar (or greater) salaries.

There are dozens of other reasons why it might not make sense to apply for those other jobs, but all of those are decisions and tradeoffs for you to make.

If salary is the overriding concern, it's probably an easy fix.

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by wpietri on Monday January 23, 2017 @10:38PM (#13468624)
It could be, but I don't think this is good evidence for ohstopitu being underpaid. One way terrible companies get people to join despite being terrible is by paying more.

As an example, I took a lower salary at a nonprofit because I cared about the mission. Or at the other end of the spectrum, financial trading companies pay a fair bit more because they have no mission but money, and are often unpleasant places to work.

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by imron on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @01:02AM (#13469156)
> but I don't think this is good evidence for ohstopitu being underpaid

That's a fair enough point. My original post was just to point out that the answer to ohstopitu's original question is not some great mystery, and all they need to do is answer the question I posed back, because it's exactly the same answer to both questions.

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by acdha on Monday January 23, 2017 @11:36AM (#13463399)
This was really common during the first Internet bubble – I remember being on the phone a number of times with a whole room full of people worked on a household-name .com and realizing that maybe one of them had more than a superficial understanding of how the web or commerce worked. Several people basically stated that they were just killing time waiting for the IPO.

The thing I remember is that while at the time most of them were worth a lot of money on paper, it was only about a year later that they were all unemployed and the hoped-for riches had vanished along with a huge cloud of VC funding.

I'm not personally cut out to be a complete mercenary but it seems like if you are it's critically important that you pay a lot of attention to timing your exit. Unless you have a high chance of getting so rich that you won't need another job, you really need more than that to take to the next gig.

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by arenaninja on Monday January 23, 2017 @12:11PM (#13463693)
My question is how do you find these jobs, or do these jobs find you?
Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by eoin_murphy on Monday January 23, 2017 @10:30AM (#13462829)
This is probably more possible now given the ease with which a fraud can get someone else to do their work for them (I remember a news story doing the rounds of an experienced developer doing all of this and outsourcing all their work to India).

But of course, this isn't new behavior and because we work in a job which is seen as well paid, so fraudsters will try to get something for nothing.

See: http://thedailywtf.com/articles/The_Brillant_Paula_Bean

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by nkrisc on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:35AM (#13462375)
Either they will eventually learn and become competent while faking it or they'll implode spectacularly. Either one of those outcomes is nearly a given.
Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by wott on Monday January 23, 2017 @11:00AM (#13463058)
It doesn't matter if they implode: they will immediately start mail-bombing a thousand companies (for they don't care about the company purpose, the job content or anything) and will eventually get hired at one of them (and more easily than the first time because they can now put a company name on their CV).
Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by scruple on Monday January 23, 2017 @01:00PM (#13464213)
> she decided to outsource it to Fiverr

This reminds me of a story from 2013 where a developer at Verizon had outsourced his job to a Chinese firm. He was praised as being a top developer but was eventually found out.

http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2013/01/16/169528579/...

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by crispyambulance on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:26AM (#13462317)
> ... basically got into CS because she had heard that SE/CS Majors made "big bucks"

Unfortunately, this is also how many people decide to go into law and medicine.

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by randomdata on Monday January 23, 2017 @11:24AM (#13463279)
Why is that unfortunate? That's the entire purpose of high prices: To alert others that supply is not keeping up with demand and that their help is needed. Choosing a job, or anything else, because of "big bucks" is exactly what "big buck" offers are meant to achieve.

If you are suggesting that we only want doctors and lawyers who are truly passionate about what they do, then artificial price ceilings are necessary to indicate to others that they are not needed. However, in doing that you create a shortage situation.

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by flukus on Monday January 23, 2017 @07:31PM (#13467750)
> That's the entire purpose of high prices: To alert others that supply is not keeping up with demand and that their help is needed.

Well doctors are happy to limit the supply.

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by BeetleB on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:58PM (#13468458)
>Why is that unfortunate?

Because lawyers don't get paid that much any more...

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by MrBuddyCasino on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:14AM (#13462240)
I've seen similar cases, and while they may appear to be successful for astoundingly long periods of time, ultimately most (unfortunately, not all) of those guys will fall on their face.

Realize that your ability to continuously put in the effort required to become really good is a superpower, even though to you its just following your passion. Many people cannot manage this, and its a massive advantage.

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by greenhatman on Monday January 23, 2017 @05:59PM (#13467021)
>Both graduated 4 years later, just as clueless but with degrees.

How?! I don't have a degree. But how? How can you get a degree and still be clueless?

>Somehow they land interviews, and both of them gets jobs at this fancy startup (making way more than me).

Either you are doing something very wrong, like not negotiating right, and should be paid more, or my understanding of the universe has just been flipped on its head.

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by flukus on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @12:56AM (#13469134)
Because they learn a lot of academic stuff about computer science (or maybe not) but very little about coding.
Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by tdb7893 on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @10:29AM (#13472068)
Also in some places you can get through most of the assignments by either being in a group or copying and pasting the relevant algorithm from the Internet
Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by branchless on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:25AM (#13462315)
> One of them realizes that she's way over and since I was not helping, she decided to outsource it to Fiverr

Management material! (office space)

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by alistproducer2 on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:07AM (#13462206)
Does it really work like that in the Valley? I might have to come out there. Where I'm at, it's mostly big established fortune 5's. they hire they're fair share of idiots with degrees but I'm not sure you'd be able to make it by outsourcing the Fiverr.
Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by ohstopitu on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:09AM (#13462220)
This "startup" is based in Vancouver.

And, I've got a feeling they'll figure it out when they have bugs, or ask her to fix bugs instead of adding standalone features.

(Unless she sends over the entire repo to the person she hires - at which point, I'm 100% sure she's breaking their contract).

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by bluedino on Monday January 23, 2017 @09:42AM (#13462436)
>> Why am I getting paid less to do more honest work?

You never count another man's money.

Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by Mouse47 on Monday January 23, 2017 @10:35AM (#13462862)
I don't see what this comment brings to the discussion. I think it's obvious that the salary discrepancy and the skill discrepancy don't match up. Since salary defines 'market value' of a developer it's worth exploring why the market behaves this way. And I say this as a developer and also as someone who's got input on hiring decisions.
Re:A Story of a Fraudulent Coder by JackFr on Monday January 23, 2017 @10:43AM (#13462917)
The higher salary is compensation for taking on more risk -- that is working for a company whose future is shakier.

I'd say a company who hires like that is likely to go under.