News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by colanderman on Thursday January 19, 2017 @01:44PM (#13438305)
The article (and some comments here) seem to conflate luck and what I will call lot. "Luck" I define as random happenstance during one's life. You can manage luck. Doing so is the central theme of many board games. You can increase your luck "surface area" by taking more chances. Entire industries (e.g. insurance) exist to manage luck.

Your "lot", on the other hand, I define as what you were born with. How you were raised, where you grew up, what kind of education you got -- everything you can't control that does have a significant impact on your life's outcomes. You can work to improve your lot, or minimize its impact on your life, but it's very difficult.

Of course there's some correlation: those with a good lot often learn early how to manage luck, and those who manage luck well can negate a poor lot.

Hence I begrudge no-one with seemingly good "luck": often (possibly more than not), their fortune is simply a byproduct of how they managed their luck. Good for them!

But those born into a good lot? They're the true "lucky" ones.

Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by greggman on Friday January 20, 2017 @02:05AM (#13442150)
I've seen lots of examples of luck. This is not to suggest that tenacious people wouldn't succeed in some way or another but only that their current positions would be different.

Some good examples: Ed Catmull in his own book mentioned all the luck he had becoming Pixar. Pixar was a computer hardware division at ILM. ILM wanted to get rid if them. They almost got sold to a computer company (lucky they didnt). They got bought by Steve Jobs who bought them to make computers. He spent $70 million dollars on them for them to make computers which they failed at. They then pivoted to animation. It's pretty lucky to find some person willing to blow $70 million on you and you don't have to earn a dime.

Bill Gates is a smart guy but being president of Microsoft that makes the OS for the majority of PCs seems like lots of luck. Luck that he was in the right place at the right time to sell MS-DOS. Lucky that none of his competitors shipped something more popular. From that piece of luck the rest follows. Without that luck he could just have easily been like the president of Lotus or the president of Borland.

IIRC Howard Lincoln, the first President of Nintendo of America got the job because he met the president of Nintendo at a layover in Chicago O'Hare Airport. The president of Nintendo said effectively, "Hey, I need someone to head up my USA division, how about you?" Without that luck Howard Lincoln would probably have just been a successful lawyer we'd never heard of.

In my own life I know a guy that was just a game designer. The founders of the company he was working for sold out and he was made president. He's done very well but jees that's some serious luck. There was no struggle it was just handed to him.

The head of the Chamber of Commerce in HK had the 3 guys above him leave. He was like 28 and inherited the job.

Google, tried to sell to Yahoo. Where would they be if that had happened?

Where would Facebook be if Friendster hadn't failed?

I'm not in any way suggesting you shouldn't work hard to increase your chances of success. But there is also tons of luck in most big success.

Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by brutos on Friday January 20, 2017 @04:05AM (#13442508)
Bill Gates is a good example for OP's lot and luck point:

"In 1980, [Mary Maxwell Gates] discussed her son's company with John Opel, a fellow committee member and the chairman of International Business Machines Corporation (IBM). Opel, by some accounts, mentioned Mrs. Gates to other IBM executives. A few weeks later, IBM took a chance by hiring Microsoft, then a small software firm, to develop an operating system for its first personal computer." [1]

Just an anecdote, but I like OP's point with lot and luck.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mary_Maxwell_Gates

Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by zouhair on Friday January 20, 2017 @04:45AM (#13442626)
I would have liked to see what would Gate would have managed to do if he was born in the slums of India not in Seattle, a lawyer as a father and a person in the board of directors of a bank holding as a mother.
Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by luckystartup on Friday January 20, 2017 @10:40AM (#13444550)
The chance that he would accomplish anything is vanishingly small. But I found this story on Google: http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/kolkata/18-year-old-...
Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by saiya-jin on Friday January 20, 2017 @07:21AM (#13443264)
easy, nothing to write about
Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by csomar on Friday January 20, 2017 @06:00AM (#13442884)
Interestingly, most of your examples are about exposure rather than luck. These guys weren't picked at random. If he wasn't flying (not everyone gets to fly and layover at O'Hare, and probably the executive lounge), he would not get the chance to make the connection.

I always assumed that Startups at Silicon Valley are neither lucky nor skilled people (or the most skilled/fit people for the job to be correct). They just happen to be in a place with strong exposure to Capital.

If you are smart, have lots of experience, and hard-working; but lack the ability to fly to SV then your odds of getting funded by a VC are slim to none.

Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by charlesdm on Friday January 20, 2017 @09:20AM (#13443888)
It's more probability than luck. Anyone with moderate intelligence and who is willing to make a commitment to building wealth can say, make 5 or 10 million in life. It might not be easy nor quick, but from what I've seen, it's definitely achievable (i'm not there yet). You do however need to build up a specific skillset.

At least 90% of the population is either 1) not interested in acquiring wealth, or 2) not willing to put in the effort. Becoming a billionaire, on the other hand, is obviously something completely different.

Half the trick is making sure your money works for you. Once you have, say, $5m, it's not all that hard to turn it into $10m. All you need is time.

I've seen guys make hundreds of millions (and lose it all) through great and bad investing. But a commitment to making money is probably the most important thing you need.

Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by sanderjd on Friday January 20, 2017 @11:00AM (#13444687)
> Anyone with moderate intelligence and who is willing to make a commitment to building wealth can say, make 5 or 10 million in life.

This definitely isn't true for "anyone born in the world", and doesn't ring true to me for "anyone born in the US" either. Maybe it's true for "anyone born into the middle class in the US". (But that middle class is rapidly shrinking.)

Unfortunately, starting conditions still matter a lot.

Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by majani on Friday January 20, 2017 @05:09PM (#13447370)
Man, some people here just cannot picture life outside their bubble. It's amazing to me that someone flippantly dismisses making 5 million dollars as an average thing. I'm from a country where only 68,000 people out of 45 million make at least $1,000 per month[1]. That's 0.15% of the population. Where you were born is probably the biggest single factor in success

[1] http://www.businessdailyafrica.com/Number-of-Kenyans-earning...

Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by charlesdm on Friday January 20, 2017 @05:49PM (#13447597)
Did I say it's an average thing? I said, if you want to dedicate 20 years of your life to it, not focusing on other things, living in a Western country, you can do it. Nowhere did I say it's a common thing.

Second, there are plenty of people who manage to make $10,000+ a month online, regardless of where they live. Probably millions.

Also, even in impoverished countries there must be opportunities to make money and do deals. If you keep looking at what others are making, then you will never make any money. Different setting, different opportunities. The average person, regardless of the country he or she lives in, will never be wealthy. €100 in Europe might get you less than $10 in South Africa. Location matters as well in terms of purchasing power.

Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by sanderjd on Saturday January 21, 2017 @01:45AM (#13449179)
> I said, if you want to dedicate 20 years of your life to it, not focusing on other things, living in a Western country, you can do it.

I'm really sorry to quibble, but you didn't say any of those things in the comment I replied to. I mean, there just literally isn't anything about "20 years" or "Western country" in there.

> Second, there are plenty of people who manage to make $10,000+ a month online, regardless of where they live. Probably millions.

Citation needed!

> Also, even in impoverished countries there must be opportunities to make money and do deals.

Why "must" there be? This just sounds like wishful thinking. There is no natural law stating that opportunity is shared globally, and in fact this is mostly not the case in practice.

Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by vitaminbandit on Saturday January 21, 2017 @06:41AM (#13449698)
ctrl + F: "20 years", "Western country", "not focusing on other things"
Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by swedishdaddy on Tuesday January 24, 2017 @02:03AM (#13469390)
The words were not there in the first message.
Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by Swizec on Thursday January 19, 2017 @01:54PM (#13438420)
I would add a third category: fortune.

Lot is what you were born with.

Luck is when random things do or don't happen regardless of skill. You can manage it to an extent. Bad luck through being careful and various types of insurance, good luck mostly through participating. Buying bitcoin 3 years ago and selling at great profit now is pure luck. Maybe you influenced the market to grow, probably it was pure luck.

Fortune is the result of stochastic processes. You can do a thing, invest your skill and knowledge, and it can work out or not. Sometimes it works better, sometimes less. For instance, you launch a product that can do between $2k/month and $5k/month and it hits $4.5k/month instead of $2k. That's fortune. Your input affects your chances, but nothing is ever certain.

With time, fortunate events compound and the more often fortune works out for you, the higher your chance that it will continue to do so.

Or as Peter Dinklage says: "I hate that word—’lucky.’ It cheapens a lot of hard work. Living in Brooklyn in an apartment without any heat and paying for dinner at the bodega with dimes—I don’t think I felt myself lucky back then. Doing plays for 50 bucks and trying to be true to myself as an artist and turning down commercials where they wanted a leprechaun. Saying I was lucky negates the hard work I put in and spits on that guy who’s freezing his ass off back in Brooklyn. So I won’t say I’m lucky. I’m fortunate enough to find or attract very talented people. For some reason I found them, and they found me."

Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by stillsut on Thursday January 19, 2017 @05:34PM (#13440098)
I'd separate hard work into two components:

A. The rewarding part of your craft, e.g. the flow you get into when deeply programming all night. B. The sacrifices your craft requires, e.g. the living in the unheated apartment.

One thing the hard work people forget is that it isn't very impressive to just do type-A enjoyable work for sustained and or even super human periods. Other people would pay for that experience.

I think this separation opens up a few interesting ways of viewing those who are "too lazy" to do the hard work. First, different people flow in different tasks and so even if you gave Peter Dinklage a chance to work for openAI on any project he wanted, he might find it tiring and burn out. This is obvious, but by induction, there's this whole class of school-type activities that many people seem to mentally resist.

Second, there seem to be different expectations on how much of B-type work one has to do in order to get the A-type work they crave. I think people perceived as lazy are those who doubt that almost any amount B-work they contribute will earn them their goal, only more the same. This is excellent when it discourages the average thirteen year old from pursuing pro sports as a career, but I think it also might be the largest reduction to productivity in our economy we have today, as discouraged people tend to lower output and cause problems for their company. And that's only the economic side, the social side of hopelessness and lack of meaning is way worse!

Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by phil21 on Friday January 20, 2017 @09:42AM (#13444070)
This is a very interesting comment, articulated better than I have been able to explain to others.

I've always been fond of saying showing up to work on time and working your butt off is the low bar to success. All this does is buy you entrance to the ride, and opens up doors of opportunity for you which are worthless unless you take advantage of. Just working hard at some dead-end job 9-5 doesn't get it done, there are millions of people who can successfully do this and get nowhere in life.

Finding someone who understands the 'B' work is by far the most important part of their career is rather rare. I've called the lack of motivation to do this from the vast majority of people "laziness in thought". It's much harder to gain discipline and do well in this part of your career than simply showing up and doing what you're told as well as you can.

It also doesn't help that the school system more or less trains you almost exclusively for the "A" type work, and actively encourages ignoring the "B" and letting someone else handle it for you. This is a very hard attitude to break as taking control of your own path is rather scary.

Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by q-base on Friday January 20, 2017 @02:19AM (#13442200)
"Saying I was lucky negates the hard work I put in and spits on that guy who’s freezing his ass off back in Brooklyn." - of course you can't tell people how they should take your comments. But saying that you/he/she was lucky does not negate the fact that they may have worked hard. Saying it was ONLY luck does.

Working hard of course put you in a position where you could gain from the luck. You won't suddenly end up as a world renowned producer if you work as a fireman. You invest in your future with a lot of hard work and then perhaps you are one of those who make it.

A lot of people work hard on whatever they have put their mind into. A lot of people are talented and great at what they do. But a lot of people from both groups never really gets the recognition/success/financial breakthrough as others of similar and perhaps even objectively less hard-working/talented people. They just had a little extra "luck".

Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by Swizec on Friday January 20, 2017 @03:12PM (#13446627)
That's my whole point. When you position yourself to take advantage of opportunities and it works out, that's fortune. Like building a lottery ticket that wins.

Luck is when it just happens without any hard work. Like buying a lottery ticket that wins.

Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by omurphyevans on Friday January 20, 2017 @05:33AM (#13442785)
The Peter Dinklage bit annoys me, as this is precisely the issue - survivorship bias.

I happen to have a few actor friends. All talented, harder working than me, and dedicated to their craft. And no-one is interviewing them because they haven't made it.The talent and hard work pays off because you also get the lucky break.

Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by circlefavshape on Friday January 20, 2017 @12:40PM (#13445418)
Exactly. Fuck Peter Dinklage. Even Louis CK is at it - he was so humble for so long, and then when he got really big he started with the "I've put in the time" schtick, and feeling like he deserves it (which he does, but he's not successful because he deserves it)
Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by kajecounterhack on Thursday January 19, 2017 @04:17PM (#13439579)
nit: seems like OP's definition of luck is roughly your definition of fortune. s/fortune/luck/rg in your post and I think you say the same thing.

Creating a new bucket to qualify things that happen regardless of skill seems redundant with the definition of lot. "Lot" in the context of OP's post happens despite skill.

Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by Swizec on Thursday January 19, 2017 @05:17PM (#13439969)
I think there's a difference between lot and luck though. Lot is what you have before, luck is what you get during.

To crib from Warren Buffet [1], imagine a coin flipping contest. Everyone bets $1 and calls the flip of a coin. Miss and you're out. Betting pool is distributed among everyone else.

20 rounds in, there are 215 people with a few hundred thousand dollars made from a $1 investment and some time.

It's pure luck. They weren't even the one flipping the coin so couldn't have influenced the 50:50 chance even if they tried. That's luck.

Fortune is when you both bet and flip the coin and find a technique to influence the flip to be 40:60 in your favor and it works out.

Lot is when your dad gives you $100k to start a business.

[1] http://www.fool.com/investing/value/2010/03/19/warren-buffet...

Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by ionwake on Friday January 20, 2017 @03:54AM (#13442481)
I agree with your quote but I have to say...

The growing a fortune with bitcoin should be classed as fortune.

Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by Swizec on Friday January 20, 2017 @03:11PM (#13446620)
If you contributed to the growth of bitcoin, yes. Fortune.

If you were just along for the ride, no. Luck.

Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by nerfhammer on Thursday January 19, 2017 @02:00PM (#13438488)
Richard Wiseman wrote a book on the subject of changing your luck: http://amzn.to/2jDN04M

Shorter overview: http://www.richardwiseman.com/resources/The_Luck_Factor.pdf

Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by rhizome on Thursday January 19, 2017 @06:10PM (#13440335)
You seem to be circling around the crux of the fundamental attribution error (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_attribution_error).
Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by rrrx3 on Thursday January 19, 2017 @04:46PM (#13439766)
This definition of "luck" sounds more like "risk mitigation" to me. Luck has a clear and easily understood definition.
Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by wyager on Friday January 20, 2017 @02:20AM (#13442203)
It's not just risk mitigation; it's expectimax optimization, which sometimes involves absorbing additional risk rather than just mitigating or minimizing it.
Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by mapt on Friday January 20, 2017 @06:30AM (#13443052)
When we examine the path others took to achieve extraordinary success, this isn't even what we're doing.

Instead, we're often looking at companies and people that took outrageous risks that will nearly always fail, and luckily ended up in just the right academic path, met just the right collaborator, entered just the right industry, had nobody else bother to compete with them, had an opponent make a fatal mistake, were noticed by just the right person, avoided the ubiquitous pitfall, et cetera.

Luck has an enormous influence on what actually ends up on top. You can do deliberate optimization, and many of these people/orgs did some, but post-hoc reasoning that everything Amazon or Einstein were doing on their path to greatness must indicate radically greater decisionmaking powers than all others is extremely incorrect, and worse (because we think in narratives) extremely misleading/convincing.

Many times, what got people to the top are high-risk, high-reward options. Buying lottery tickets (or the equivalent).

Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by kornish on Friday January 20, 2017 @02:42AM (#13442290)
Or: pursuing high upside, low-risk situations.
Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by kriro on Friday January 20, 2017 @04:16AM (#13442542)
A slight nitpick but I think the luck you manage in boardgames is risk and there's also the category of uncertainty which you can't manage (because you don't know the probability distribution or the fact that something is possible/could happen at all).

See "Risk, Uncertainty, and Profit" by Frank Knight for a much better explanation of risk vs. uncertainty than what I can muster. I think it's noteworthy that entrepreneurship theory from economics tends to be build around the idea that it is indeed handling uncertainty (and not risk) that yields entrepreneurial profits.

Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by Bombthecat on Thursday January 19, 2017 @03:24PM (#13439176)
There is an old saying in FPS games: when luck becomes skill.

Basically, you move the luck in your favour. Using the situation at hand for you.

Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by user5994461 on Thursday January 19, 2017 @03:55PM (#13439400)
I usually say for FPS: when you've got a lot of luck, that's called skill.
Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by groby_b on Thursday January 19, 2017 @04:20PM (#13439601)
And when anybody else has got a lot of luck, that's called an aimbot ;)
Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by brodsky on Friday January 20, 2017 @01:58AM (#13442127)
and when you lack luck, it's called lag.
Re:Don’t Tell Your Friends They’re Lucky by wc23 on Friday January 20, 2017 @03:18AM (#13442380)
Luck is what happens when preparation meets opportunity. -Seneca