I wonder if supercooled propellants are really worth it. It seems like a huge risk in exchange for a small performance increase. Hopefully this will be the last vehicle loss they suffer from it.
PS: High launch costs set up a cost escalation as satellites are so expencive they can't fail. Which means launches need a really high success rate. If you could get 10,000kg to LEO for say 1 million but had a 40% failure rate you would see a very different approach with much lower overall costs.
For this particular problem, the risk to the payload will be eliminated by not attaching it for the static fire. Any risk during the actual launch would still affect the payload, though.
To put it in concrete terms, if insurers decide that SpaceX is significantly more dangerous to its payloads, then launch insurance for satellites using SpaceX rockets will become significantly more expensive.
Disclaimer: I don't know shit about the space industry, so don't waste your time.
FT can get 30% more mass to LEO. That is a pretty big performance increase, especially considering that it enables SpaceX to carry the maximum payload of v1.1 in expendable configuration and still land the FT rocket. Even if we assume that half of that performance boost came from the other improvements, 15% is a significant increase.
Shaving just a little weight (especially on the 2nd stage) or squeezing out just a little more performance can have dramatic differences in mass to LEO.
The question is how much this will increase overall operational cost. Up until this year or so, it has seemed that SpaceX has been willing to compromise on performance to get lower overall operational cost and reliability.
I'm a bit worried that they've started to go the other way with some of the improvements they've made this year.
After the Ariane 5 first-launch failure, it was well over a year before it flew again.
Once the redesigned tanks come in, it's likely that they'll go right back, because little holds aren't uncommon.
However even if we did somehow run out of Helium entirely, once SpaceX switches to Methane fuel (as they plan to do for the ITS) they won't need it anymore. Currently it's used to pressurize the tanks, but Methane does that for itself. It would mean speeding up development of 'small' methane launch vehicles presumably, but that's it.
Per the other comment, no other noble gas has a low enough boiling point to remain a gas at LOX temperatures...
And given that the nearest natural source of helium is Jupiter, that is a little concerning.
An estimated 54 billion cubic feet (1.5×109 m3) of helium was detected in Tanzania in 2016
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helium#Modern_extraction_and_d...
We already rely on nuclear reactors to get several elements that are used in radiotherapy. IIRC there was a major shortage of medical isotopes a few years ago when a Canadian reactor that used to supply most of them was shut down.
Of course, it will be expensive, so no more cheap helium balloons for our grandkids. For specialized applications, though, we can afford some artificial helium.
Sun is closer and produces helium all the time, but less practical to harvest it from.
"breaking fibers or friction can ignite the oxygen in the overwrap"
I would like to see at least this ignition source duplicated.
The worst kind of bug is the intermittent one that you can't reproduce or see in logs. With only 35-55 milliseconds of metrics leading up to the event and nearly obliterated evidence, it seemed nearly impossible they would be able to nail down the exact cause.
Critics have pointed out risks in SpaceX's method of loading supercooled fuel. Accidentally forming solid oxygen around carbon fibers from a buckling overwrap is an example of this.
There are benefits, but they will need to find and prevent all these possible edge cases exposed by the new method.